Bain v International Capital Markets Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Bain v International Capital Markets Pty Ltd (No 3) [2025] FCA 599

File number: VID 1088 of 2023
Judgment of: O'BRYAN J
Date of judgment: 6 June 2025
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – representative proceedings – application for non-standard orders for discovery – relevant principles – orders made
Legislation:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37M

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 20.11, 20.15

Cases cited:

Adelaide Brighton Cement Ltd v Concrete Supply Pty Ltd (subject to deed of company arrangement) (No 3) [2018] FCA 1058

Bain v International Capital Markets Pty Ltd (No 2) [2024] FCA 847

Clifton (Liquidator) v Kerry J Investment Pty Ltd trading as Clenergy [2020] FCAFC 5

Ford, in the matter of Careers Australia Group Ltd (in liq) v Mansfield (No 2) [2022] FCA 1565

Fuji Xerox Australia Pty Ltd v Whittaker (No 2) [2021] FCA 696

Pleash (Liquidator), in the matter of SFG Relocations Pty Ltd v Fourie [2022] FCA 552

Reiche v Neometals Ltd [2024] FCA 1202

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 84
Date of last submissions: 28 May 2025
Date of hearing: 21 May 2025
Counsel for the Applicants: T Bagley and M Aguinaldo
Solicitors for the Applicants: Echo Law
Counsel for the First Respondent: D Thomas SC, R Zambelli, M Forgacs and M Gvozdenovic
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan
Counsel for Second Respondent: P Annabell
Solicitor for Second Respondent: Arnold Bloch Leibler

ORDERS

VID 1088 of 2023
BETWEEN:

NATHANIEL JAMES BAIN

First Applicant

CHRISTOPHER WYER

Second Applicant

AND:

INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL MARKETS PTY LTD (ACN 123 289 109)

First Respondent

ANDREW LEON BUDZINSKI

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

O'BRYAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

6 JUNE 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.By 9 July 2025, and in accordance with order 4, the first respondent give discovery of documents within category 25 (Board Documents) of the categories of documents specified in Annexure A to these orders.

2.By 6 October 2025, and in accordance with order 4, the first respondent give discovery of documents within a first tranche of documents that fall within the balance of the categories of documents specified in Annexure A to these orders.

3.By 8 December 2025, and in accordance with order 4, the first respondent give discovery of documents within a second (and final) tranche of documents that fall within the balance of the categories of documents specified in Annexure A to these orders.

4.The first respondent is to give discovery of documents:

(a)of which, after a reasonable search, the first respondent is aware; and

(b)that are, or have been, in the first respondent’s control within the meaning of Sch 1 to the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (FCR).

5.By 6 October 2025, the second respondent is to give standard discovery of documents.

6.Each of the first and second…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bain v International Capital Markets Pty Ltd (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 599
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court, Bain and others brought proceedings against International Capital Markets Pty Ltd (ICM) and another, alleging various breaches of statutory duties, false or misleading conduct, unconscionable conduct, and negligent misstatements in connection with the offer and sale of contracts for difference (CFDs) to retail clients. The applicants sought orders for discovery of documents from ICM and another respondent, Mr Budzinski. The court considered the appropriate timeframes and scope of the discovery orders. The discovery task was substantial, but the court determined that ICM’s discovery should not extend beyond six months. The court accepted the timetable proposed by the applicants but set a later deadline for category 26 documents and rejected the deferral of Mr Budzinski’s discovery. The court concluded that each party had partial success on the application, and the costs of the interlocutory application should be costs in the cause. The court made specific orders regarding the discovery of documents, including deadlines and the scope of the discovery, ensuring that the process was balanced and efficient.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. By 9 July 2025, and in accordance with order 4, the first respondent give discovery of documents within category 25 (Board Documents) of the categories of documents specified in Annexure A to these orders.

2. By 6 October 2025, and in accordance with order 4, the first respondent give discovery of documents within a first tranche of documents that fall within the balance of the categories of documents specified in Annexure A to these orders.

3. By 8 December 2025, and in accordance with order 4, the first respondent give discovery of documents within a second (and final) tranche of documents that fall within the balance of the categories of documents specified in Annexure A to these orders.

4. The first respondent is to give discovery of documents:

(a) of which, after a reasonable search, the first respondent is aware; and

(b) that are, or have been, in the first respondent’s control within the meaning of Sch 1 to the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (FCR).

5. By 6 October 2025, the second respondent is to give standard discovery of documents.

6. Each of the first and second respondents is to give discovery of documents by:

(a) serving a list of documents verified in accordance with r 20.17 of the FCR; and

(b) producing the documents, identified in the verified list of documents, in electronic format (excluding the documents subject to a claim of privilege).

7. Costs of the applicants’ interlocutory application dated 4 April 2025 be costs in the cause.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

ANNEXURE A

CATEGORIES OF DOCUMENTS TO BE DISCOVERED BY THE FIRST RESPONDENT

Defined terms used in the discovery categories have the meaning given in the consolidated statement of claim.

For the avoidance of doubt, a reference to ‘documents’ includes emails and their attachments.

Applicants

1.

The Applicants

(1) Documents created during the Relevant Period which refer to the Applicants (either by name or other unique identifier, such as their account number), in connection to:

(a) the Applicants’ accounts (including opening applications and application forms, their Client Suitability Tests, and any account transfers and upgrades);

(b) statements sent to the Applicants in relation to their CFD trading;

(c) documents recording the trades (Trading Orders) placed by the Applicants, including records of any conditional Trading Orders placed (such as Stop Orders), which were or were not then executed;

(d) documents which record the price of the underlying reference asset in relation to the Applicants’ Trading Orders at the time and the date of each trade;

(e) records of assessments and/or annual or periodic reviews of the Applicants;

(f) communications between either of the Applicants and the First Respondent;

(g) internal communications about the Applicants (including emails, Microsoft Teams, Zoom, Skype or any other applications utilised by ICM for internal direct messaging, recordings, transcripts, notes or records of same);

(h) account statements that were not issued or provided to the Applicants (i.e. outside of those included at sub-paragraph 1(b)); and/or

(i) records of use or participation by the Applicants in any non-trading services offered by ICM (including but not limited to education tools).

Client trading

2.

Trading analytics

(1) Any report, summary or analysis of underlying data created during the Relevant Period of:

(a) the number and/or percentage of active, inactive, deactivated and reactivated ICM client accounts, and/or ICM client ‘churn’;

(b) the likelihood and/or quantum of ICM client losses, and the number and/or percentage of ICM retail clients experiencing losses, or predicted or modelled to experience losses (but excluding reports which show daily trading results that are not specific to losses);

(c) the likelihood of ICM client transactions experiencing a close out and/or the interaction between Reference Asset volatility and margin calls;

(d) the likelihood of ICM client transactions experiencing a margin call and/or close out despite the ICM client correctly predicting the trend in the price movement of the Reference Asset;

(e) the extent (if any) to which ICM’s revenue is impacted by the volume of ICM client trades;

(f) the extent (if any) to which ICM’s revenue and/or client trade volume is impacted by ICM’s marketing;

(g) the percentage of ICM client accounts using CFDs to hedge existing investments;

(h) the number and/or percentage of ICM client accounts in negative balance and/or with debt owing to ICM as a result of losses; and/or

(i) the identification of any ICM retail clients with significant or repeated losses.

Client Qualification and Assessment of Suitability

3.

Client demographics

(1) Any report, summary of analysis on the following characteristics, metrics or demographics of ICM’s client base during the Relevant Period:

(a) the number of retail, sophisticated and wholesale clients (as defined in the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth));

(b) age;

(c) income;

(d) assets;

(e) occupation or profession;

(f) level of education;

(g) nationality, location and/or country of residence;

(h) methods used to fund trading, including the number of clients using credit cards, savings accounts or other payment systems; and/or

(i) experience in trading CFDs, derivatives or other financial products.

4.

Client Qualification and Suitability

(1) A copy of any final versions of policies, written processes or any similar types of documents that were in effect during the Relevant Period which record, describe or determine:

(a) ICM’s account application or client qualification process for retail clients;

(b) the monitoring of ongoing suitability of ICM’s clients for continued trading, including any annual or periodic review process; and/or

(c) the deactivation and reactivation of ICM retail client accounts.

(2) Documents concerning the development of, implementation of, and/or decision to change or maintain, the Client Suitability Test, as amended or in force from time to time during the Relevant Period.

(3) Any report, summary or analysis during the Relevant Period of the number and/or percentage of persons who applied to open a CFD trading account with ICM, including specifically the number and/or percentage of persons who:

(a) opened an ICM demo account;

(b) were approved to open a CFD trading account with ICM;

(c) were exempt from taking the Client Suitability Test when opening their CFD trading account with ICM;

(d) took the Client Suitability Test;

(e) took the Client Suitability Test, did not pass and were refused an account as a result of that or repeated failure of the Client Suitability Test; and/or

(f) took the Client Suitability Test, did not pass and thereafter retook the Client Suitability Test:

i. once;

ii. twice; or

iii. three or more times.

(4) Any report, summary or analysis during the Relevant Period regarding the average period of time between:

(a) a retail client commencing an application to open a CFD trading account with ICM;

(b) a retail client completing their application (including their attempt or attempts of the Client Suitability Test); and/or

(c) notification of the approval of a retail client’s application by ICM.

(5) Documents referring to the suitability of:

(a) ICM’s account application or client qualification process;

(b) ICM’s process for monitoring the ongoing suitability of its retail clients for continued trading; and/or

(c) the Client Suitability Test,

as amended or in force from time to time during the Relevant Period.

(6) Any third-party audit or report on ICM’s account application or client qualification process, or client suitability monitoring processes as amended or in force from time to time during the Relevant Period.

5.

Not Used

6.

Target Market Determination

(1) Documents created during the Relevant Period concerning the development of, implementation of, and/or decision to change or maintain each ICM Target Market Determination, as amended or in force from time to time during the Relevant Period, including those issued by ICM on 1 October 2021, in April 2022 and in April 2024.

(2) Documents created during the Relevant Period concerning the occurrence of any review triggers, as described in each ICM Target Market Determination, which did or did not prompt amendment of any ICM Target Market Determination.

(3) Any report, summary or analysis of the number and/or percentage of ICM clients annually and/or periodically reviewed by ICM to address whether the clients remained within the scope of each ICM Target Market Determination, including:

(a) ICM retail clients who passed any review;

(b) ICM retail clients who failed any review; and/or

(c) of the clients falling in sub-category 3(b) above, any action taken by ICM in respect of that review, including but not limited to whether the relevant client accounts were closed by ICM.

(4) A copy of any final versions of policies, written processes or any similar types of documents that were in effect during the Relevant Period, which record, describe or determine the risk that CFDs would be distributed by ICM to retail clients outside the target market set out in each ICM Target Market Determination, including those issued by ICM on 1 October 2021, in April 2022 and in April 2024, and any steps taken for the purpose of addressing that risk.

7.

Disclosure documents

(1) Documents created for the purpose of developing, implementing, and/or making a decision to change or maintain the following documents concerning ICM’s disclosure to clients, as amended or in force from time to time during the Relevant Period:

(a) the 2018 PDS, 2020 PDS, 2021 PDS and the April 2024 PDS;

(b) Financial Services Guide;

(c) Account Terms; and

(d) Target Market Determination.

ICM Products, Trading Platforms and System

8.

Trading Orders

(1) A copy of any final versions of policies, written processes or any similar types of documents that were in effect during the Relevant Period which record, describe or determine the conditions or circumstances in which an investor could apply for the following types of Trading Orders (as defined in the ICM Product Disclosure Statements) and the effect of these Trading Orders (including any variations of the same types of Trading Orders offered by ICM during the Relevant Period):

(a) Market Order;

(b) Limit Order (including a Take Profit Order);

(c) Stop Order (including a Stop Limit Order or Stop Entry Order);

(d) Trailing Stop Order (including a Sell Trailing Stop Order or Buy Trailing Stop Order); and/or

(e) If Done (Contingent) Orders.

9.

Reference asset pricing and spread

(1) A copy of any final versions of policies, written processes or any similar types of documents that were in effect during the Relevant Period which record, describe or determine the manner in which:

(a) the buy and sell prices (and/or spreads) for the CFDs issued by ICM were set;

(b) a manual override of automatic pricing methodologies for the buy and sell prices (and/or spreads) for the CFDs issued by ICM could occur.

(2) Documents created during the Relevant Period concerning the disclosure to clients of the methodologies for the setting of the buy and sell prices (and/or spreads) for the CFDs issued by ICM.

10.

Leverage and margins

(1) A copy of any final versions of policies, written processes or any similar types of documents that were in effect during the Relevant Period which record, describe or determine the manner in which:

(a) the leverage ratio; or

(b) the leverage ratio selected by an investor

was set or changed for the CFDs offered to ICM’s retail clients on the ICM trading platforms (MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 and cTrader) and the ICM demo account.

(2) User guides available to ICM’s retail clients during the Relevant Period, which explained how retail clients could select or change leverage.

11.

Margin and close-out mechanics

(1) A copy of any final versions of policies, written processes or any similar types of documents that were in effect during the Relevant Period which record, describe or determine the manner in which minimum or initial margin requirements, margin calls or variation margin requirements, close out and liquidation processes, negative balances and debt recovery were developed and implemented.

(2) Any report, summary or analysis during the Relevant Period of margin call or variation margin requirements, close outs and liquidation practices in relation to accounts of ICM retail clients.

(3) Any report, summary or analysis during the Relevant Period of negative balance accounts, debts owed to ICM and recovery of such debts, in relation to accounts of ICM retail clients.

12.

Fees and costs

(1) A copy of any final versions of policies, written processes or any similar types of documents that were in effect during the Relevant Period which record, describe or determine how the fees and costs were charged by ICM on its CFDs, including but not limited to:

(a) transaction or commission fees;

(b) finance or interest charges;

(c) bank fees;

(d) conversion fees;

(e) taxes; and

(f) external fees,

as described in the ICM Product Disclosure Statements.

13.

Inducements, rebates and credits to retail clients

(1) Any final versions of policies, written processes or any similar types of documents that were in effect during the Relevant Period which record, describe or determine which inducements, rebates or credits were paid by ICM to retail clients or prospective retail clients on its CFDs.

(2) Documents recording the terms of any inducements, rebates and credits offered to ICM’s retail clients or prospective retail clients during the Relevant Period.

(3) Any report, summary or analysis during the Relevant Period of the effect of paying inducements, rebates and credits to ICM’s retail clients.

(4) Documents concerning the development of, implementation of, and/or decision to change or maintain any trading inducements to retail clients or prospective retail clients, including but not limited to concerning the ‘White Label’ program.

14.

Not Used

15.

Marketing

(1) Documents sent, received or created during the Relevant Period by ICM’s marketing department or other persons outside of the ICM marketing department with relevant authority and control, concerning ICM’s marketing strategy.

16.

Trading using credit card

(1) Documents comprising the development of the policy, practice, direction and/or strategy, operative during the Relevant Period, of allowing retail clients to fund their accounts with a credit card in an unlimited amount.

17.

Hedging policies and practices

(1) A copy of any final versions of policies, written processes or any similar types of documents that were in effect during the Relevant Period which record, describe or determine ICM’s hedging policies or practices.

18.

Websites and platforms

(1) Documents sent, received or created during the Relevant Period by personnel responsible for the design of ICM’s website or by personnel within ICM’s marketing department, or other persons with relevant authority and control with respect to the design of ICM’s website, concerning ICM’s strategy with respect to the design of the webpages on the ICM website relevant to CFDs or the design of the ICM trading platforms.

(2) The final user guides or similar types of instructional documents in effect during the Relevant Period regarding the ICM trading platforms and ICM demo account, and demonstrating their functionality.

Client communications

19.

Client communications

(1) Documents concerning the development and distribution of client communications during the Relevant Period, including but not limited to being in connection with:

(a) the ‘The Week Ahead’ newsletter;

(b) the ‘The Month Ahead’ newsletter;

(c) the ‘Weekly Technical Outlook and Review’ newsletter;

(d) the ‘Upcoming Weekly Webinars’ announcements;

(e) the ‘Live Analysis Session’ or ‘Live Trading Analysis Session’ announcements;

(f) the ‘Global Markets Webinar Series’ announcements;

(g) the ‘IC Your Trade’ podcast; and/or

(h) the ‘Information Hub for Series Traders’ blog.

(2) Policies, written processes or any similar types of documents that were in effect during the Relevant Period which record, describe or determine communications with or marketing to prospective retail clients, ICM demo account holders, inactive or dormant retail clients and retail clients who requested account closure.

(3) Documents concerning the development of, implementation of, and/or decision to change or maintain template or pro forma automated communications with retail clients during the Relevant Period.

(4) Documents concerning the development of, implementation of, and/or decision to change or maintain call scripts, live chat scripts, and instructions or guidance to ICM employees or agents in connection with communication with retail clients or prospective retail clients, including but not limited to client or account managers, help desk employees, sales employees and ‘Live Chat’ employees, during the Relevant Period.

(5) A copy of any final versions of policies, written processes or any similar types of documents that were in effect during the Relevant Period which record, describe or determine the Key Performance Indicators or any remuneration or incentive schemes for client or account managers, help desk employees, sales employees and ‘Live Chat’ employees.

(6) A copy of any final versions of policies, written processes or any similar types of documents that were in effect during the Relevant Period which record, describe or determine the ability of retail clients to opt out of marketing and/or other communications from ICM.

20.

Client complaints

(1) Any report, summary or analysis sent, received or created by ICM’s Complaints and Compliance teams or other persons outside of these teams with authority and control of the ICM’s Complaints and Compliance team, during the Relevant Period, of complaints by retail clients in connection with:

(a) the accuracy of representations made by ICM to retail clients regarding CFD trading;

(b) the adequacy of disclosures made by ICM to retail clients regarding CFD trading;

(c) the adequacy of ICM’s application and account qualification processes, the Client Suitability Test, and ongoing client review and monitoring processes; and/or

(d) the retail client’s understanding of the nature of, and risks associated with, CFD trading.

(2) A copy of any final versions of policies, written processes or any similar types of documents that were in effect during the Relevant Period concerning complaint resolution and/or standardised guidance and instructions distributed to ICM employees or agents.

Regulatory materials and communications

21.

Regulatory materials

(1) Documents concerning the below content of the regulatory materials as set out in the CSOC, its application to or potential implications for, ICM’s business, and any policies, practices, directions or strategies arising from those matters:

(a) the Australian regulatory materials referred to at paragraphs [143] to [162] and [176] to [205];

(b) the international regulatory materials referred to at paragraphs [206] to [217];

(c) the Product Intervention Orders referred to at paragraphs [169] to [175]; and/or

(d) the ARODA Standards referred to at paragraphs [163] to [168],

but excluding documents concerning day to day operational matters related to implementing the Product Intervention Orders.

22.

Communications with regulators

(1) Documents concerning communications between ICM or its agents and, ASIC, the ACCC, the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) or the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) in connection with:

(a) the Australian regulatory materials referred to at paragraphs [143] to [162] and [176] to [205], the Product Intervention Orders referred to at paragraphs [169] to [175], and/or the investigations underlying those materials;

(b) any notices or requests about ICM in relation to the CFD trading undertaken by clients; and/or

(c) ICM’s responses to those notices or requests.

ICM’s business

23.

Risks of CFDs

(1) Any report, summary or analysis sent, received, or created during the Relevant Period by persons holding a senior executive title at ICM, or other persons with relevant authority and control in ICM, during the Relevant Period concerning:

(a) the risks of CFDs (and/or ICM’s CFDs specifically) for retail investors, including as a result of:

i. their leveraged nature;

ii. the volatility of the price of the reference assets;

iii. the impact of the automated margin calls or variation margin requirements, close out and liquidation processes;

iv. the ability of retail clients to go into negative balance;

v. the possibility of retail clients suffering financial losses as a result of CFD trading; and/or

vi. trading on credit;

(b) the complexity of CFDs;

(c) the addictive or gambling or gaming-like quality of CFDs on ICM trading platforms;

(d) the ability of retail clients to understand CFDs and/or their risks and/or the disclosures made by ICM concerning those risks;

(e) the suitability or lack of suitability of CFDs retail clients; and/or

(f) disclosure of any of the matters referred to in (a)-(e) to ICM retail clients and prospective retail clients.

24.

Compliance reports, audits and external professional advice

(1) Any internal compliance reviews and other reports, external compliance reviews and other reports, audits and other documents, recording advice from external professional advisers (not including lawyers but including external risk and compliance experts) in connection with the topics described at categories 4, 6, 7, 10, 11, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21 and 23 above, but excluding documents recording advice that pertains to any document including policies, processes, disclosure documents and materials that were not operative during the Relevant Period.

(2) Documents recording business wide risk assessments and risk registers created or received by the ICM during the Relevant Period, in connection with:

(a) risks to ICM’s retail clients in relation to trading CFDs;

(b) risks associated with the adequacy or inadequacy of ICM account application or client qualification process, or client suitability monitoring processes;

(c) risks associated with the monitoring and supervision of compliance with policies and practices in relation to the distribution and issuing of CFDs;

(d) statutory and regulatory risks associated with distributing and issuing CFDs;

(e) risks specifically directed to each ICM Target Market Determination; and/or

(f) financial risks to ICM associated with the distribution, issuing and hedging of CFDs.

25.

Board packs and related documents

(1) Agendas, board packs or minutes during the Relevant Period, which are directly relevant to any issue raised by the pleadings, including for any meeting of the:

(a) Board or directors of ICM; or

(b) any committee of ICM convened for risk identification or risk management purposes.

(2) Organisational level charts for ICM which applied during the Relevant Period.

26.

Financial statements

(1) Final versions of ICM’s annual and periodic financial statements or accounts reporting on:

(a) revenue generated by ICM as a result of fees, spreads and costs charged to ICM’s clients on trades during the Relevant Period; and/or

(b) revenue earnt by ICM from its hedging practices in relation to ICM’s clients during the Relevant Period.

27.

Role, knowledge and involvement of Mr Budzinski

(1) Documents recording communications between ICM and Mr Budzinski evidencing:

(a) the assertion or exercise of management and/or control over ICM’s operations and business by Mr Budzinski;

(b) Mr Budzinski’s knowledge of the regulatory obligations and regulatory materials which applied to ICM’s operations in Australia which are alleged in Parts D and E of the consolidated statement of claim;

(c) Mr Budzinski’s knowledge of the matters referred to in paragraph (2);

(d) Mr Budzinski authorising the implementation of the matters referred to in paragraph (2).

(2) The matters referred to in paragraph (1)(c) and (d) are:

(a) the matters alleged at paragraphs 70 to 142 of the consolidated statement of claim;

(b) the offer and sale of CFDs by ICM to retail investors in the circumstances alleged in paragraph 254 of the consolidated statement of claim;

(c) the matters alleged in section G and paragraphs 255 to 257 of the consolidated statement of claim;

(d) the representations alleged in paragraph 251 of the consolidated statement of claim;

(e) the non-disclosures alleged in paragraph 258 of the consolidated statement of claim;

(f) the dissemination of information alleged in paragraph 266 of the consolidated statement of claim;

(g) that ICM had significant bargaining strength relative to the retail investors to whom it offered and sold CFDs;

(h) that the retail investors to whom ICM offered and sold CFDs were in a position of vulnerability;

(i) that any one or more of the conduct and behaviours of ICM alleged at paragraphs 70 to 142 of the consolidated statement of claim caused ICM to profit at the expense of its clients;

(j) the matters alleged in section L of the consolidated statement of claim.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The discovery task is likely to be very substantial. Nevertheless, it is not acceptable to have ICM’s discovery extend for more than 6 months. I will therefore make orders in accordance with the timetable proposed by the applicants, save that I will not require category 26 to be discovered by 9 July 2025. Contrary to the applicants’ submission, category 26 is not equivalent to category 25 because it extends beyond annual financial statements to include periodic statements or accounts reporting upon specific items. I also consider that Mr Budzinski should be able to complete his discovery by 6 October 2025. His discovery is not tied to ICM’s discovery and there is no reason for his discovery to be deferred pending the completion of ICM’s discovery.Conclusion In conclusion, I will make orders as set out in these reasons. Each party has had a measure of success on the discovery application. It is appropriate that the costs of the application be costs in the cause.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In respect of the primary claim period, it is alleged that, in connection with offering and issuing CFDs, ICM:(a)contravened the prohibitions against false, misleading or deceptive conduct in ss 1041E and 1041H of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act) and ss 12DA and 12DF of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) (ASIC Act);(b)contravened the prohibitions against unconscionable conduct in s 12CB of the ASIC Act and s 991A of the Corporations Act;(c)breached its duty of care to investor clients to warn them of the material risks inherent in the highly leveraged CFDs issued by ICM; and(d)made negligent misstatements on which investors relied,in each case causing investors to suffer loss.PIO (product intervention order) claims The second time period is from not later than 29 March 2021 until 23 August 2024 (inclusive) (PIO claim period). The claims in respect of the PIO claim period relate to conduct allegedly engaged in by ICM in connection with the issue of Product Intervention Order 2020/986 by ASIC on or about 22 October 2020 (the PIO). The PIO had been preceded by Consultation Paper CP 322 released by ASIC on or about 22 August 2019 proposing the issue of a Product Intervention Order restricting the supply of CFDs to retail clients. The PIO had the following effects from 29 March 2021 in respect of retail clients: (a)limiting the maximum leverage that could be offered on CFDs;(b)implementing standard margin close-out arrangements;(c)limiting a platform operator’s recourse to money held in the client’s account; and(d)prohibiting the giving of gifts, discounts and other benefits to open a CFD account or acquire CFDs. It is alleged that, with an awareness of the forthcoming PIO and in order to avoid the restrictions that would be imposed by the PIO, from on or around July 2020, ICM recommended that existing retail clients:(a)apply for a professional trading account which offered higher leverage than a standard account and, where a client was approved, re-categorized the client as a wholesale investor; (b)apply for a trading account with ICM Seychelles which offered higher leverage than a standard account. It is alleged that, in doing so, ICM took no or no adequate steps to assess the client’s suitability for the higher leverage. It is also alleged that ICM made false or misleading statements to clients in connection with that process. In respect of the PIO claim period, it is alleged that, in connection with offering and issuing CFDs, ICM:(a)contravened the prohibitions against false, misleading or deceptive conduct in ss 1041E and 1041H of the Corporations Act and ss 12DA and 12DF of the ASIC Act; and(b)contravened the prohibitions against unconscionable conduct in s 12CB of the ASIC Act and s 991A of the Corporations Act.TMD (target market determination) claims The third period is from 5 October 2021 until 23 August 2024 (TMD claim period). It is alleged that, during the TMD claim period, ICM was obliged to publish a “Target Market Determination” (TMD) pursuant to s 994B of the Corporations Act, and ICM complied with that obligation. It is further alleged that ICM contravened s 994E of the Corporations Act because it failed to take reasonable steps that would result in retail product distribution conduct in relation to CFDs that was consistent with its TMD.Conflicted remuneration