Reiche v Neometals Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Reiche v Neometals Ltd [2024] FCA 1202

File number: NSD 1273 of 2024
Judgment of: FEUTRILL J
Date of judgment: 16 October 2024
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Redfern Schedule – rulings on objections to requested documents  
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 1317AE, 1317AE(2B); Pt 9.4AAA

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37M

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 20.11, 20.12, 20.14, 20.14(2), 20.14(3), 20.15

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 14
Date of hearing: Determined on the papers
Date of last written submission: 14 October 2024
Solicitor for the Applicant: Gillis Delaney Lawyers
Solicitor for the Respondent: Herbert Smith Freehills

ORDERS

NSD 1273 of 2024
BETWEEN:

CHRISTIAN GERHARD REICHE

Applicant

AND:

NEOMETALS LTD (ACN 009 116 631)

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

FEUTRILL J

DATE OF ORDER:

16 OCTOBER 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The respondent give discovery of documents described in the rulings in the Redfern Schedule attached to these orders of which, after reasonable search, the respondent is aware and that are, or have been, in the respondent’s control (where the expression ‘reasonable search’ is used as described in r 20.14(3) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) and having regard to the expedited nature of the proceeding) and, otherwise, in accordance with paragraphs 8 and 9 of the orders of 30 September 2024.

2.Where the ruling in the Redfern Schedule refers to giving discovery of documents directly relevant to an issue raised in the applicant’s concise statement, the documents must meet at least one of the criteria in r 20.14(2) of the Rules.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


Redfern Schedule

No.

Document(s) / Specific Category of Documents Sought

Basis of Request

Response

Ruling

Reason why Documents are relevant and material to the outcome of the case

Reason why Documents are assumed to be in possession, custody and control of Respondent

1.

All emails, memos, minutes of meetings. letters or other documentation or correspondence relating to:

(i)  the respondent's employees (including the applicant) made redundant due to the respondent's restructure including each employee's notification of redundancy letter, minutes of any consultation and/or meeting with the affected employee,

(ii)  the decision to terminate the position, including but not limited to meetings, resolutions determinations or other

documents touching or

The documents are material and relevant as the applicant alleges that he was the only employee (apart from his former personal assistant who requested and immediate separation) who was made redundant and who was not permitted to work out his notice period where other employees were permitted to work out their notice period.

The respondent should have possession, custody or control of these documents as they were created by representatives of the respondent.

Such documents are not in the applicant's possession, custody or control.

In satisfaction of the applicant's request at 1(i)-1(iv), the respondent agrees…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Reiche v Neometals Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 1202
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case of Reiche v Neometals Ltd involves the applicant, Reiche, pursuing discovery of specific documents from the respondent, Neometals Ltd. The central legal issues revolve around the relevance and materiality of the requested documents to the ongoing dispute, as well as the proportionality and reasonableness of the document requests given the expedited nature of the proceeding. The applicant sought various categories of documents, including those relating to redundancy, whistleblower disclosures, bullying allegations, forgery of signatures, re-engineering, and claims for Time in Lieu (TIL).

The court meticulously evaluated each request, considering whether the documents met the criteria for relevance and materiality under the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth). The court found that many of the requested documents were either irrelevant to the issues at hand or were overly broad, imposing an unreasonable burden on the respondent. In particular, the court emphasised that requests which did not pertain directly to the decision-making process regarding the applicant's redundancy or the alleged detriment suffered by the applicant were not relevant. Similarly, documents concerning other employees' redundancies or unrelated allegations were deemed irrelevant and burdensome.

The court ordered that the respondent provide specific documents directly relevant to the decision to make the applicant’s role redundant, terminate his employment, and pay him in lieu of notice. Furthermore, documents directly relevant to the applicant’s whistleblower disclosures and the subsequent investigation were to be provided, as well as those directly relevant to the bullying allegations and TIL claims. The court also noted that while the respondent would admit certain facts, such as the applicant's role being made redundant and the termination of his employment, other requests for documents were deemed unnecessary and disproportionate.

The final orders mandate that the respondent provide the specified documents within the stipulated timelines, ensuring compliance with the expedited nature of the proceedings and the Federal Court Rules. The respondent is directed to give discovery of documents meeting the relevance criteria and to avoid imposing an unreasonable burden through overly broad requests.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The respondent give discovery of documents described in the rulings in the Redfern Schedule attached to these orders of which, after reasonable search, the respondent is aware and that are, or have been, in the respondent’s control (where the expression ‘reasonable search’ is used as described in r 20.14(3) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) and having regard to the expedited nature of the proceeding) and, otherwise, in accordance with paragraphs 8 and 9 of the orders of 30 September 2024.

2. Where the ruling in the Redfern Schedule refers to giving discovery of documents directly relevant to an issue raised in the applicant’s concise statement, the documents must meet at least one of the criteria in r 20.14(2) of the Rules.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Redfern Schedule

No.

Document(s) / Specific Category of Documents Sought

Basis of Request

Response

Ruling

Reason why Documents are relevant and material to the outcome of the case

Reason why Documents are assumed to be in possession, custody and control of Respondent

1.

All emails, memos, minutes of meetings. letters or other documentation or correspondence relating to:

(i) the respondent's employees (including the applicant) made redundant due to the respondent's restructure including each employee's notification of redundancy letter, minutes of any consultation and/or meeting with the affected employee,

(ii) the decision to terminate the position, including but not limited to meetings, resolutions determinations or other

documents touching or

The documents are material and relevant as the applicant alleges that he was the only employee (apart from his former personal assistant who requested and immediate separation) who was made redundant and who was not permitted to work out his notice period where other employees were permitted to work out their notice period.

The respondent should have possession, custody or control of these documents as they were created by representatives of the respondent.

Such documents are not in the applicant's possession, custody or control.

In satisfaction of the applicant's request at 1(i)-1(iv), the respondent agrees to give discovery of:

· board papers;

· board meeting minutes; and

· determinations / resolutions,

relating to the respondent's restructure announced on 22 August 2024, the decision to make the applicant's role redundant and the decision to terminate the applicant's employment immediately and pay him in lieu of providing notice.

The respondent otherwise objects to this request on the basis that:

1. it is not a request for a narrow and specific

In addition to the documents the respondent has agreed to provide, the respondent is to give discovery of documents directly relevant to the decision and reasons for the decision to make the applicant’s position redundant, terminate the applicant’s employment and pay the applicant in lieu of working out the notice period under his contract of employment.

No.

Document(s) / Specific Category of Documents Sought

Basis of Request

Response

Ruling

Reason why Documents are relevant and material to the outcome of the case

Reason why Documents are assumed to be in possession, custody and control of Respondent

concerning the redundancy,

(iii) the decision to terminate the applicant's employment with immediate effect,

(iv) the actual redundancy letter and any other documentation of discussions or decision making concerning the roles were determined to be made redundant.

category of documents (see Orders, para. 4);

2. the documents requested are not sufficiently relevant to the case or material to its outcome (see Orders, para. 5(b)(i)); and

3. the request is disproportionate to the expedited nature of the case management directions and would impose an unreasonable burden on the respondent (see Orders, para. 5(b)(iii)).

In relation to the applicant's request at 1(i), the respondent submits that employees are not made redundant; rather the role/position that an employee occupies is made redundant when it is no longer required by the respondent. It is assumed this request relates to the respondent's decision to make certain roles, other than the applicant's role, redundant. As drafted, the

applicant's request at 1(i)

No.

Document(s) / Specific Category of Documents Sought

Basis of Request

Response

Ruling

Reason why Documents are relevant and material to the outcome of the case

Reason why Documents are assumed to be in possession, custody and control of Respondent

seeks the production of all documents (including emails, memos, minutes of meetings, letters and other documentation or correspondence) relating to the other around 11 employees of the respondent who were made redundant due to the recent restructure. This is an extraordinarily broad request and would require the respondent to carry out an unduly burdensome search through its records for documents which are irrelevant and therefore of no probative value to the case. The respondent objects to this request on the basis that it is unduly burdensome. The respondent will admit that the applicant was the only employee whose employment was terminated by the respondent with immediate effect and did not work out his notice period, except that one other employee did not work out her notice period at her request. Documents in relation to the decision to make the applicant's role

No.

Document(s) / Specific Category of Documents Sought

Basis of Request

Response

Ruling

Reason why Documents are relevant and material to the outcome of the case

Reason why Documents are assumed to be in possession, custody and control of Respondent

redundant are dealt with under request 1(ii) below.

In relation to the applicant's request at 1(ii), the respondent submits that a position is not terminated, and rather, a position is made redundant or an employee's employment is terminated.

This request is therefore unclear. Further and in any event, to the extent the request at 1(ii) relates to the decision to make the applicant's role redundant, it can be answered by providing the specific documents that the respondent has agreed to provide.

With respect to the applicant's request at 1(iii), the respondent will admit that

(i) of the employees whose employment was terminated for reasons of redundancy, the applicant was the only employee who was paid in lieu of receiving notice of his termination (other than his former personal assistant who requested that she not

work out her notice period);

No.

Document(s) / Specific Category of Documents Sought

Basis of Request

Response

Ruling

Reason why Documents are relevant and material to the outcome of the case

Reason why Documents are assumed to be in possession, custody and control of Respondent

and (ii) by reason of his immediate termination, the applicant has suffered a detriment within the meaning of section 1317ADA of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Further and in any event, the request at 1(iii) can be answered by providing the specific documents that the respondent has agreed to provide.

With respect to the applicant's request at 1(iv), the applicant requests the production of documented discussions or decision- making concerning each of the roles which were made redundant as part of the respondent's restructure. These documents are irrelevant to any issues in dispute between the parties in this trial. Any redundancy letters, documentation or correspondences relating to the other around 11 redundancies will have no bearing whatsoever on the substantive issues of the trial. The respondent's request

amounts to nothing more than a fishing expedition and

No.

Document(s) / Specific Category of Documents Sought

Basis of Request

Response

Ruling

Reason why Documents are relevant and material to the outcome of the case

Reason why Documents are assumed to be in possession, custody and control of Respondent

is an improper use of the document production process. Further and in any event, it is unduly burdensome given the admissions the respondent will make as noted above, and the documents the respondent has agreed to provide.

2.

All emails, memoranda, minutes of meetings, letters, or investigations undertaken in accordance with the respondent's whistleblowing policy or other correspondence relating to the applicant's formal whistleblower disclosures made in writing on 9 July 2024.

The documents are material and relevant as the applicant alleges that he was not provided whistleblower protections pursuant to Part 9.4AAA of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) after making the whistleblower disclosures.

The respondent should have possession, custody or control of these documents as there should be records of the whistleblower disclosure and the subsequent investigation/s created by representatives of the respondent to comply with the whistleblower investigation requirements of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

Such documents are not in the applicant's possession, custody or control.

The respondent objects to the request on the basis that:

1. the documents requested are not sufficiently relevant to the case or material to its outcome (see Orders, para. 5(b)(i)); and

2. the request is disproportionate to the expedited nature of the case management directions and would impose an unreasonable burden on the respondent (see Orders, para. 5(b)(iii)).

The applicant does not allege that he was "not provided whistleblower protections pursuant to Part 9.4AAA of

The requested documents are not relevant to the applicant’s contentions set out para 74 of his concise statement.

No.

Document(s) / Specific Category of Documents Sought

Basis of Request

Response

Ruling

Reason why Documents are relevant and material to the outcome of the case

Reason why Documents are assumed to be in possession, custody and control of Respondent

the Corporations Act". The applicant alleges that the respondent caused him detriment by reason of a belief or suspicion that he had made, may have made, proposed to make or could make a disclosure that qualifies for protection under Part 9.4AAA.

The respondent will admit that the applicant's disclosure made on 9 July 2024 was a disclosure that qualified for protection under Part 9.4AAA, and that the respondent caused detriment to the applicant by making his role redundant and terminating his employment and paying him in lieu of providing him notice.

The relevant issue is whether a belief or suspicion that the applicant had made such a disclosure formed any part of the reasons for the respondent causing detriment to the applicant. The respondent has the burden of proof with respect to this issue. The documents requested are not relevant to

No.

Document(s) / Specific Category of Documents Sought

Basis of Request

Response

Ruling

Reason why Documents are relevant and material to the outcome of the case

Reason why Documents are assumed to be in possession, custody and control of Respondent

that issue. In any event, even if they were relevant, the request is so broad as to be disproportionate to the case, having regard to the expedited program, and would impose an unreasonable burden on the respondent.

3.

All emails, memoranda, correspondence, records of investigations or other documentation relating to the applicant's allegations of bullying.

The documents are material and relevant in that the applicant alleges that he was bullied, and pursuant to its obligations under its own bullying policy, the respondent was obliged to conduct an investigation into the bullying allegations.

The respondent should have possession, custody or control of these documents as there should be records of the bullying allegations and the subsequent investigation/s created by representatives of the respondent to comply with the respondent's bullying policy.

Such documents are not in the applicant's possession, custody or control.

The respondent objects to this request on the basis that it does not concern documents which are relevant to the case and its outcome (see Orders, para. 5(b)(i)).

The respondent will admit that the applicant, in his disclosure dated 9 July 2024, raised allegations of bullying and harassment by Ms Purdie, but will deny that any conduct amounted to bullying or harassment. This will be a question of fact to be determined based on the evidence at trial in relation to the alleged conduct.

However, whether or not the respondent conducted an investigation into the

applicant's bullying

The respondent is to give discovery of documents directly relevant to the issues raised in paras 44-47 and 50-53 of his concise statement.

No.

Document(s) / Specific Category of Documents Sought

Basis of Request

Response

Ruling

Reason why Documents are relevant and material to the outcome of the case

Reason why Documents are assumed to be in possession, custody and control of Respondent

allegations and acted consistently with its bullying policy in doing so, is not a material fact in issue, nor a matter relevant to the trial and its outcome.

Accordingly, the documents sought in this request are wholly irrelevant to the trial.

4.

All emails, memoranda, correspondence, investigations undertaken or other documentation relating to the applicant's allegations of the forgery of signatures made as part of the applicant's formal whistleblower disclosure on 9 July 2024.

The documents are material and relevant to the question of whether the respondent's affairs were being properly and honestly managed. .

Moreover, as a publicly listed company, such allegations are sufficiently serious to warrant a formal investigation by the respondent. The issue goes directly to the question of whether the applicant reasonably suspected misconduct or an improper state of affairs in relation to the respondent, as a regulated entity and as a publicly listed company.

The respondent should have possession, custody or control of these documents as there should be records of the subsequent investigation/s created by representatives of the respondent.

Such documents are not in the applicant's possession, custody or control

The respondent objects to this request on the basis that the documents sought are wholly irrelevant to the issues in dispute between the parties (see Orders, para. 5(b)(i)).

Whether 'the respondent's affairs were being properly and honestly managed' or the applicant's allegations were 'sufficiently serious to warrant a formal investigation' are not issues in this case.

As outlined in response to request 1 and 2, the applicant alleges that the respondent caused him detriment by reason of a belief or suspicion that he had made, may have made, proposed to make or could make a disclosure that qualifies for

The requested documents are not relevant to the applicant’s contentions set out in para 74 of his concise statement.

No.

Document(s) / Specific Category of Documents Sought

Basis of Request

Response

Ruling

Reason why Documents are relevant and material to the outcome of the case

Reason why Documents are assumed to be in possession, custody and control of Respondent

protection under Part 9.4AAA.

The respondent will admit that the applicant's disclosure made on 9 July 2024 was a disclosure that qualified for protection under Part 9.4AAA, and that the respondent caused detriment to the applicant by making his role redundant and terminating his employment and paying him in lieu of providing him notice. The relevant issue is whether a belief or suspicion that the applicant had made such a disclosure formed any part of the reasons for the respondent causing detriment to the applicant. The respondent has the burden of proof with respect to this issue.

The documents requested, which relate to the steps taken in response to one of the allegations in the applicant's disclosure of 9 July 2024, are not relevant to that issue.

In any event, even if they were relevant, the request is

No.

Document(s) / Specific Category of Documents Sought

Basis of Request

Response

Ruling

Reason why Documents are relevant and material to the outcome of the case

Reason why Documents are assumed to be in possession, custody and control of Respondent

so broad as to be disproportionate to the case, having regard to the expedited program, and would impose an unreasonable burden on the respondent.

5.

All emails, memoranda, correspondence, investigations undertaken or other documentation relating to the applicant's allegations of re- engineering made as part of the applicant's formal whistleblower disclosure on 9 July 2024.

The documents are material and relevant to the reasonably held belief of the applicant about misconduct or an improper state of affairs in relation to the respondent as a regulated entity and as a publicly listed company. The potential legal ramifications to the respondent if the re- engineering allegation was accurate were significant.

The respondent should have possession, custody or control of these documents as there should be records of the subsequent investigation/s created by representatives of the respondent.

Such documents are not in the applicant's possession, custody or control

The respondent objects to this request on the basis that the documents sought are wholly irrelevant to the issues in dispute between the parties (see Orders, para. 5(b)(i)).

As outlined in response to request 1, 2 and 3, the applicant alleges that the respondent caused him detriment by reason of a belief or suspicion that he had made, may have made, proposed to make or could make a disclosure that qualifies for protection under Part 9.4AAA.

The respondent will admit that the applicant's disclosure made on 9 July 2024 was a disclosure that qualified for protection under Part

9.4AAA, and that the respondent caused detriment

The requested documents are not relevant to the applicant’s contentions set out in para 74 of his concise statement.

No.

Document(s) / Specific Category of Documents Sought

Basis of Request

Response

Ruling

Reason why Documents are relevant and material to the outcome of the case

Reason why Documents are assumed to be in possession, custody and control of Respondent

to the applicant by making his role redundant and terminating his employment and paying him in lieu of providing him notice. The relevant issue is whether a belief or suspicion that the applicant had made such a disclosure formed any part of the reasons for the respondent causing detriment to the applicant. The respondent has the burden of proof with respect to this issue.

The documents requested, which relate to the steps taken in response to one of the allegations in the applicant's disclosure of 9 July 2024, are not relevant to that issue.

In any event, even if they were relevant, the request is so broad as to be disproportionate to the case, having regard to the expedited program, and would impose an unreasonable burden on the respondent.

No.

Document(s) / Specific Category of Documents Sought

Basis of Request

Response

Ruling

Reason why Documents are relevant and material to the outcome of the case

Reason why Documents are assumed to be in possession, custody and control of Respondent

6.

All emails, memoranda, correspondence, investigations undertaken or other documentation including the respondent's Time in Lieu Policy relating to all of the applicant's claims for Time in Lieu, all assessments of the applicant's claims for Time in Lieu, all notes and other documentation of decisions made by the respondent in relation to claims for Time in Lieu by the applicant.

The documents are material and relevant as the applicant alleges due to his whistleblowing disclosures. his latest Time in Lieu claim was rejected.

The respondent should have possession, custody or control of these documents as they were created by representatives of the respondent.

Such documents are not in the applicant's possession, custody or control.

The respondent objects to this request on the basis that the documents sought are wholly irrelevant to the issues in dispute between the parties (see Orders, para. 5(b)(i)).

First, while the respondent bears the onus of proving that the applicant's victimisation claim is not made out, the applicant bears the onus of establishing that he made a valid TIL claim. These matters are within the applicant's knowledge, since it is he who alleges that he worked excessive overtime and was entitled to TIL. Contrary to the applicant's assertion, many of the documents requested are already in the applicant's possession: the applicant has attached the TIL policy, his application (including supporting documents) and the respondent's initial and only rejection of the claim.

Second, the respondent will deny that the applicant was entitled to the TIL claimed and therefore any rejection of

The respondent is to give discovery of documents directly relevant to the issues raised in para 68 of his concise statement.

No.

Document(s) / Specific Category of Documents Sought

Basis of Request

Response

Ruling

Reason why Documents are relevant and material to the outcome of the case

Reason why Documents are assumed to be in possession, custody and control of Respondent

the claim did not constitute a detriment for the purposes of section 1317ADA of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). This is a question of law, based on the applicant's contract of employment, the TIL policy, the application and the rejection, the documents in relation to which are already attached to the applicant's affidavit.

Finally, the relevant issue is whether a belief or suspicion that the applicant had made such a disclosure formed any part of the reasons for the respondent causing detriment to the applicant. The respondent has the burden of proof with respect to this issue. The applicant's affidavit already attaches the rejection in the system.

Based on its current searches of its records, the respondent has identified and will provide one other email relating to the reasons for the rejection. The respondent otherwise submits that any other documents sought are irrelevant to the facts in issue for this trial.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established