Bain v International Capital Markets Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Bain v International Capital Markets Pty Ltd (No 2) [2024] FCA 847

File number(s): VID 1088 of 2023
VID 88 of 2024
Judgment of: O'BRYAN J
Date of judgment: 2 August 2024
Catchwords:

REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – Multiplicity of proceedings – where three “open class” representative proceedings commenced against same defendants raising the same or similar issues – where two of the proceedings brought in the Federal Court of Australia and one of the proceedings brought in the Supreme Court of Victoria – applications for stay or transfer of proceeding made in both the Federal Court and the Supreme Court

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Competing class actions brought in the Federal Court of Australia and the Supreme Court of Victoria – application of Protocol for communication and cooperation between Supreme Court of Victoria and Federal Court of Australia in class action proceedings – concurrent hearing of stay applications brought in the Federal Court and the Supreme Court

Legislation:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth)

Civil Procedure Act 2010 (Vic)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth)

Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 (Cth)

Jurisdiction of the Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 (Vic)

Penalty Interest Rates Act 1983 (Vic)

Supreme Court Act 1986 (Vic)

Cases cited:

BMW Australia Ltd v Brewster (2019) 269 CLR 574

Brewster v BMW Australia Ltd [2019] NSWCA 35

Cargill Australia Ltd v Viterra Malt Pty Ltd (No 30) (2022) 67 VR 1

Edwards v Hyundai Motor Company Australia Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 1134

Elliott-Carde v McDonalds Australia Ltd (2023) 301 FCR 1

Fuller v Allianz (2021) 65 VR 78

Galactic Seven Eleven Litigation Holdings LLC v Davaria [2024] FCAFC 54

Hungerfords v Walker (1989) 171 CLR 125

Jowene Pty Limited v Downer EDI Limited [2023] FCA 924

Klemweb Nominees Pty Ltd v BHP Group Limited [2019] FCAFC 107

Lay v Nuix Ltd [2022] VSC 479

Perera v GetSwift Ltd (2018) 263 FCR 1

Perera v GetSwift Ltd (2018) 263 FCR 92

Stallard v Treasury Wine Estates Limited Ltd [2020] VSC 679

Westpac Banking Corporation v Lenthall (2019) 265 FCR 21

Wigmans v AMP Ltd [2019] NSWSC 603

Wigmans v AMP Ltd (2019) 103 NSWLR 543

Wigmans v AMP Ltd (2021) 270 CLR 632

Wileypark Pty Ltd v AMP Ltd (2018) 265 FCR 1

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 132
Date of hearing: 4 July 2024
Counsel for the Applicant (VID 1088 of 2023): F Forsyth KC with R Clark and E Olivier
Solicitors for the Applicant (VID 1088 of 2023): Echo Law
Counsel for the Applicant (VID 88 of 2024): T Bagley
Solicitors for the Applicant (VID 88 of 2024): Piper Alderman
Counsel for the First Respondent: M Borsky KC with M Gvozdenovic
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan
Counsel for Second Respondent: P Annabell
Solicitor for Second Respondent: Arnold Bloch Leibler
Counsel…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bain v International Capital Markets Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 847
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves three representative proceedings brought against International Capital Markets Pty Ltd (ICM) in relation to alleged breaches of the Corporations Act by ICM. The proceedings were initiated by Nathaniel Bain and Anor (Bain), Robert Wyer (Wyer), and Nathan Vingrys (Vingrys). The Bain and Wyer proceedings were filed in the Federal Court of Australia, while the Vingrys proceeding was filed in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The Bain and Wyer proceedings were subsequently consolidated. The applicants in the Bain and Wyer proceedings applied for a stay or transfer of the Vingrys proceeding to the Federal Court. In response, Vingrys applied for a stay or transfer of the Bain and Wyer proceedings to the Supreme Court. The court had to decide on the appropriate forum for the proceedings, whether to consolidate the proceedings, and the appropriate cost and funding arrangements.

The court found that the Vingrys proceeding should be stayed and dismissed, and the Bain and Wyer proceedings should be consolidated. The court rejected Vingrys's application for transfer to the Supreme Court and the applicants' application for transfer of the Vingrys proceeding to the Federal Court. The court held that the consolidated proceeding was better prepared and had a firm funding proposal, which provided greater certainty of sufficient resources for the proceeding. The court also considered that the consolidation would generate benefits for group members by virtue of the complementary expertise of the legal teams involved. The court ordered the consolidation of the Bain and Wyer proceedings and appointed an independent costs referee to oversee the proceedings.

The court's decision was based on the factors outlined in the Protocol for communication and cooperation between the Supreme Court of Victoria and the Federal Court of Australia in class action proceedings. The court found that the consolidated proceeding was in the best interests of the group members, and the consolidation would facilitate efficient management of the proceedings. The court also considered the proposed funding arrangements and the expertise of the legal teams involved.

The court made several orders, including dismissing Vingrys's applications for stay or transfer of the Bain and Wyer proceedings, consolidating the Bain and Wyer proceedings, and appointing an independent costs referee. The court also ordered that the consolidated proceeding be known as Nathaniel Bain and Anor v International Capital Markets Pty Ltd and Anor and be identified as VID1088/2023. The court further ordered that Echo Law be granted leave to be named as solicitors on the record for the Applicants in the Consolidated Proceeding, and that an independent costs referee be appointed to oversee the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Application to intervene and stay the proceeding

1. Nathan Vingrys be granted leave to intervene in the Bain Proceeding and the Wyer Proceeding for the purpose of the hearing and determination of his interlocutory applications dated 31 May 2024.

2. The interlocutory applications of Nathan Vingrys dated 31 May 2024, seeking orders that the Bain Proceeding and the Wyer Proceeding be transferred to the Supreme Court of Victoria pursuant to s 5(4) of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 (Cth) and/or s 1337H(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), or in the alternative that those proceedings be permanently stayed, be dismissed.

3. Nathan Vingrys bear his own costs of the interlocutory applications dated 31 May 2024 in the Bain Proceeding and the Wyer Proceeding and there be no other costs order against Mr Vingrys in those proceedings.

Consolidation

4. Pursuant to r 30.11 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (the Rules) and s 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act), the Bain Proceeding be consolidated with the Wyer Proceeding and the consolidated proceeding be known as Nathaniel Bain and Anor v International Capital Markets Pty Ltd (ACN 123 289 109) and Anor and be identified as VID1088/2023 (Consolidated Proceeding).

5. The Applicant in each of the Bain Proceeding and the Wyer Proceeding are to be the Applicants in the Consolidated Proceeding.

6. Pursuant to r 1.32 of the Rules and s 33ZF of the Act, Echo Law be granted leave to be named as solicitors on the record for the Applicants in the Consolidated Proceeding on the following bases:

(a) Piper Alderman will act as Echo Law’s agent (together, the Lawyers) for the prosecution of claims the subject of the Consolidated Proceeding as provided for pursuant to the Agency Agreement;

(b) the Lawyers must conduct the Consolidated Proceeding in accordance with:

(i) the Conditional Costs Agreement;

(ii) the Agency Agreement;

(iii) the Litigation Management and Funding Agreement; and

(iv) the Standard Lawyer Terms;

(c) all correspondence sent to the Respondents or the Court on behalf of the Applicants and group members in the Consolidated Proceeding will be sent by Echo Law;

(d) a single counsel team will be engaged to represent the Applicants and the group members in the Consolidated Proceeding;

(e) the Applicants will jointly:

(i) make any interlocutory applications that are necessary in the Consolidated Proceeding save for any application in respect of non-common issues;

(ii) respond to any interlocutory applications filed by the Respondents in the Consolidated Proceeding; and

(iii) retain, brief and instruct expert witnesses in the Consolidated Proceeding.

7. Costs incurred to date in the Wyer Proceeding are to be costs in the Consolidated Proceeding.

8. Costs incurred to date in the Bain Proceeding are to be costs in the Consolidated Proceeding.

9. In the event that the Applicants in the Consolidated Proceeding are required to provide security for costs, the Funder will provide a form of security for costs that shall be acceptable to the Respondents, or as otherwise ordered by the Court.

10. In the event that an adverse costs order is made against the Applicants in the Consolidated Proceeding, the Funder will meet any such order, unless otherwise ordered by the Court.

11. Pursuant to s 33ZF and s 54A of the Act, an independent costs referee (Costs Referee) be appointed for the purpose of:

(a) conducting inquiries every six months (commencing from the date of the making of these orders) as to the question of whether there is unnecessary or excessive work (including any duplication of work) being performed by the Lawyers in the Consolidated Proceeding, having regard to:

(i) the skills and experience of the Lawyers;

(ii) the objective of ensuring that the total legal costs are reasonable and proportionate; and

(iii) the objective of minimising, to the greatest extent possible, the legal costs incurred through overlapping or duplicated work;

(b) providing confidential written reports (of no more than 8 pages) to the Court (Costs Report) and to the Lawyers every six months (commencing after the date of the making of these orders) stating the Costs Referee’s opinion on the question set out in paragraph 11(a) above.

12. Within 14 days of the date of these orders, the Applicants are to identify a suitable candidate to carry out the role of Costs Referee, provide the candidate’s curriculum vitae to the Court and seek orders from the Court for that candidate’s appointment.

13. The Lawyers must provide such information, access to personnel and access to documents as the Costs Referee requires.

14. The reasonable fees of the Costs Referee shall be borne equally by the Applicants in the Consolidated Proceeding and shall not be recoverable against the Respondents in the Consolidated Proceeding.

15. The costs of any work performed in the Consolidated Proceeding on and after the date of these orders that has been identified by the Costs Referee and/or the Court as costs relating to work that has been performed by reason of there being two firms conducting the Consolidated Proceeding, and where such work would not have needed to be performed if there was only one firm conducting the Consolidated Proceeding, are not to be recoverable against the Respondents in the Consolidated Proceeding.

Pleadings

16. The Applicants in the Consolidated Proceeding file and serve a consolidated statement of claim by 23 August 2024.

Costs

17. The costs of the parties in respect of the concurrent hearing on 4 July 2024 and the interlocutory applications heard at the concurrent hearing (including the interlocutory applications filed in proceeding S ECI 2024 01169 in the Supreme Court of Victoria) be taken to be costs in the cause in the Consolidated Proceeding.

Further case management

18. The Consolidated Proceeding be listed for further case management at 9.30 am on 30 August 2024.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is alleged that, from at least 5 October 2021, ICM was obliged to publish a “Target Market Determination” (TMD) pursuant to s 994B of the Corporations Act, and ICM complied with that obligation. It is further alleged that ICM contravened s 994E of the Corporations Act because it failed to take reasonable steps that would result in retail product distribution conduct in relation to CFDs that was consistent with its TMD. It is alleged that Mr Budzinski is liable as an accessory to those breaches of law by ICM.C. PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND TO THE PRESENT APPLICATIONS On 9 February 2024, shortly after the filing of the Wyer proceeding, the Court conducted a joint case management hearing of the Bain and Wyer proceedings. Orders were made on that day requiring the applicants in both proceedings to confer and seek to agree upon any terms for cooperation in the Bain and Wyer proceedings including, if appropriate, consolidation of the proceedings. The orders provided that, if no agreement upon terms for cooperation was reached, the Court would determine whether and in what manner the Bain and/or Wyer proceedings would be permitted to proceed (which is referred to for convenience as the “multiplicity issue”). A timetable for the filing of evidence and submissions in that regard was made. Immediately prior to the hearing, the Court received a communication from the law firm Banton Group that they anticipated receiving instructions to file a further competing class action. The applicants in the Bain and Wyer proceedings informed the Court that they would provide a copy of the 9 February 2024 orders to Banton Group and invite them to participate in the contemplated conferral. A second case management hearing was held on 7 March 2024. At that hearing, the Court was informed that an agreement had been reached between the applicants in each of the Bain and Wyer proceedings to resolve the multiplicity issue by consolidating the proceedings. Timetabling orders were made for the filing of evidence and submissions in support of the consolidation application and the application was listed for hearing on 22 March 2024. On 13 March 2024, the applicants in the Bain and Wyer proceedings filed submissions and evidence in support of the consolidation application. On 14 March 2024, Mr Vingrys filed a competing class action in the Supreme Court of Victoria. A third case management hearing was held on 22 March 2024. Mr Vingrys appeared at that hearing with leave of the Court. At that hearing, the Court determined that, by reason of the commencement of the Vingrys proceeding, it would not be appropriate to hear and determine the consolidation application at that time and that a further case management hearing would be listed to address the multiplicity issue arising from the Bain, Wyer and Vingrys proceedings (as well as the consolidation application). In accordance with the procedure contemplated by the Protocol (described earlier), the parties proposed orders by consent in each of the proceedings to facilitate a concurrent hearing of the multiplicity issue. Timetabling orders were made by consent in each proceeding on 4 June 2024. The timetabling orders contained a list of issues that were to be addressed by the proponents of the competing class actions and, to the extent relevant, the respondents. The issues were stated as follows:(1)Carriage (a)The position adopted by the applicants in respect of carriage, including any proposal to:(i)stay one or more proceedings;(ii)consolidate one or more proceedings (and if so, the proposal for legal representation of the consolidated proceeding); or (iii)leave open more than one proceeding.(2)Practitioners(a)The experience of the practitioners representing the applicants in this proceeding.(b)The resources made available by the firm of solicitors, and their accessibility to clients. (3)Nature and scope of the causes of action advanced (and relevant case theories)(a)Extent of overlap between the proceedings.(b)Material differences and unique features of the proceeding (i.e. identification of areas where the proceeding does not overlap with the competing proceedings). (4)Group Membership (a)Size and composition of the group.(5)Funding and legal costs(a)The proposed funding arrangements, including funding terms and conditions and percentages (including any general costs order arrangements that are intended to be sought).(b)Cost estimates and comparative costs modelling.(c)The sufficiency of the resources of the entity who will fund the proceeding, to fund it in accordance with the proposed funding model and estimated costs.(d)Net hypothetical return to group members.(6)Proposals for security(a)Proposal for security for costs, including who is to provide security for costs (i.e. a litigation funder), the proposed form of security and relevant material particulars of any expected after the event insurance policy.(b)The litigation funder or firm of solicitors’ resources to meet any adverse costs order.(7)The state of preparation of the proceedings(a)Conduct of the representative applicants in this proceeding to date.(b)The degree of expedition with which the applicants have approached the proceedings.(c)Order of filing.(8)Forum(a)The appropriate Court in which to advance group member claims.(9)Any factor that the applicants expect might be material to the resolution of the Multiplicity Issue that is not covered by points 1 – 9 above(10)Relief sought

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At the hearing, Mr Vingrys did not press his application to have the Bain and Wyer proceedings transferred to the Supreme Court (and nor did Messrs Bain and Wyer press their applications before the Supreme Court to have the Vingrys proceeding transferred to this Court). This reflected a recognition by each applicant that a transfer of the proceedings between the courts was not an end in itself and was only a means by which multiplicity could be addressed by a single judge in one of the courts. As multiplicity was able to be addressed in an efficient and practical manner through a concurrent sitting of the courts to hear the stay applications brought in each court, the transfer applications served no useful purpose. Furthermore, and as discussed below, each applicant considered that there were juridical and procedural advantages for group members in their choice of forum. Those matters were better addressed as part of the resolution of the multiplicity issue rather than as a preliminary transfer issue divorced from the multiplicity issue.D. EVIDENCE ADDUCED ON THE APPLICATIONS In advance of the concurrent hearing held on 4 July 2024, and in accordance with the consent orders of 4 June 2024, the parties filed a court book containing the evidence and submissions to be relied upon at the hearing. The evidence was read at the hearing without objection and taken to be evidence in each of the three proceedings. The evidence comprised the following:(a)on behalf of Mr Bain, two affidavits of Mathew Glen Chuk (of Echo Law) affirmed 17 and 24 June 2024 and an affidavit of John Francis Walker (of CASL Funder Pty Ltd as trustee for CASL Portfolio Fund 1 Trust (CASL)) affirmed 17 June 2024;(b)on behalf of Mr Wyer, two affidavits of Katherine Louise Sambrook (of Piper Alderman) affirmed 17 and 24 June 2024 and also the above-mentioned affidavit of Mr Walker; and(c)on behalf of Mr Vingrys, two affidavits of Amanda Kim Banton affirmed 17 and 24 June 2024 and an affidavit of James Searby affirmed 25 June 2024. At the hearing, ICM sought leave to read an affidavit of Elan Sassoon (of Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, solicitors for ICM) affirmed 3 July 2024. The affidavit exhibited correspondence between Quinn Emanuel and the solicitors for the respective applicants on the issue of security for costs. There was no objection to the late service of the affidavit and, for that reason, the Court granted leave for the affidavit to be read and relied upon. Also at the hearing, Mr Vingrys sought leave to read a further affidavit of Ms Banton affirmed 3 July 2024. Messrs Bain and Wyer objected on two bases: first, that the evidence proposed to be given by the affidavit would have the effect of further revising the statement of position of Mr Vingrys that had been filed, contrary to the orders made on 4 June 2024; and second, that Messrs Bain and Wyer did not have a fair opportunity to respond to the evidence. The objection was upheld for reasons given at the hearing. In summary, I concluded that to permit Mr Vingrys to rely on the affidavit would be unfair to the other parties and contrary to the overarching objective in s 37M of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (FCA Act). Under the timetabling orders that had been made on 4 June 2024, each party had been given a reasonable opportunity to respond to the issues in dispute prior to the hearing. The orders provided for an initial statement of position, a revised statement of position, evidence in chief and evidence in reply, all to be completed by 24 June 2024, which allowed a further week for the preparation for the oral hearing. The affidavit of Ms Banton of 3 July 2024 was received only the evening before the hearing. The affidavit sought to adduce evidence which reflected a change in position on the applications before the Court, which was contrary to the express requirements of the timetabling orders. The affidavit traversed matters that had been in issue between the parties from the outset and the evidence could have been adduced earlier. The other applicants would not have had a fair opportunity to respond to the affidavit without an adjournment, which no party sought.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Under this heading, Messrs Bain and Wyer adduced evidence suggesting that Mr Vingrys’s personal circumstances make him an unsuitable lead applicant in the class action. It is unnecessary to describe those circumstances, as I do not consider that it is a factor that carries any material weight. It is usual for an initial trial in a class action to hear the cases of a number of group members who have different personal circumstances to enable the greatest number of common issues to be determined in the initial trial. If it became apparent that Mr Vingrys’s individual claim was unlikely to succeed, he could be replaced as lead applicant.G. CONCLUSION AND ORDERS Having regard to the factors considered above, in my view permitting the consolidated proceeding, rather than the Vingrys proceeding, to go ahead would be in the best interests of the group members. The only factor that favours the Vingrys proceeding is the proposed lower percentage rates for the funding commission to be sought under a group costs order or, if necessary, under a common fund order. In my assessment, all other factors favour the consolidated proceeding or are neutral. As stated above, while the funding commission proposed to be sought by way of common fund order in the consolidated proceeding is at higher percentage rates than the Vingrys proceeding, the differences are not large and the ultimate financial return to group members will be most affected by the amount of any award or settlement achieved. The amount of any award of damages or settlement will be affected by the overall conduct of the proceeding, including the skills, expertise and resources able to be devoted to the conduct of the proceeding. In my view, the proposed consolidated proceeding is better prepared than the Vingrys proceeding and, at this stage, Echo Law and Piper Alderman have undertaken more thorough investigation than Banton Group of the causes of action against the respondents. Further, the consolidated proceeding has a firm funding proposal in place with agreed terms, and a clear and firm approach to security for costs. I consider that the proposed litigation funding available to the legal team to conduct the proposed consolidated proceeding provides greater certainty that sufficient resources will be available to conduct the proceeding, in comparison to Banton Group self-funding the Vingrys proceeding. It follows from the foregoing that I would dismiss the FC stay applications brought by Mr Vingrys. The parties agreed at the hearing that, in that event, the appropriate order as to Mr Vingrys’s costs of the FC stay applications is that Mr Vingrys bear his own costs and there be no other costs order against Mr Vingrys in the proceedings. With respect to the consolidation application, I earlier observed that it would be theoretically open to the Court to form the view that the consolidation of the Bain and Wyer proceedings is not in the best interests of group members and that one or other of those proceedings ought to have sole carriage of the claims. However, neither Mr Bain nor Mr Wyer applied, in the alternative, to be granted sole carriage of the claims within their own proceeding and the evidence and submissions of the parties were addressed to the proposed consolidated proceeding. Further, no party opposed the consolidation of those proceedings. Mr Vingrys advanced submissions about the risk that the consolidated proceeding would result in duplication of work between Echo law and Piper Alderman. In my view, that risk is ameliorated by the terms of the proposed Agency Agreement to be entered into between the two firms, as well as the orders to appoint a costs referee to undertake enquiries to determine whether unnecessary, duplicative or excessive work has been undertaken. I also consider that the consolidation of the two proceedings is likely to generate benefits for group members in the litigation of their claims, by virtue of the complementary expertise and experience of Echo Law and Piper Alderman with respect to the issues arising in the proceeding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 31 May 2024, Mr Vingrys filed interlocutory applications in each of the Bain and Wyer proceedings seeking orders that those proceedings be transferred to the Supreme Court of Victoria pursuant to s 5(4) of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 (Cth) and/or s 1337H(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act), or in the alternative that those proceedings be permanently stayed (FC stay applications). On 31 May 2024, each of Mr Bain and Mr Wyer filed interlocutory applications in the Vingrys proceeding seeking the permanent stay of that proceeding or alternatively that the proceeding be transferred to this Court pursuant to s 5(1)(b) of the Jurisdiction of the Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 (Vic) (SC stay application). Multiplicity issues frequently arise in proceedings issued within a single court. In some cases, multiplicity issues have arisen in proceedings issued in this Court and in the Supreme Court of a State or Territory, but the parties have agreed to the transfer of one of the proceedings to the other court to enable the resolution of the multiplicity issue in a single court (see for example Edwards v Hyundai Motor Company Australia Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 1134 and Jowene Pty Limited v Downer EDI Limited [2023] FCA 924). In the present matter, the multiplicity issue arises in proceedings issued in this Court and in the Supreme Court of Victoria, both exercising federal jurisdiction in respect of the subject matter of the proceedings. Each of the applicants has given reasons for wishing to conduct their proceeding in the court of their choice, and none of the applicants have consented to the transfer of their proceeding to the other court. A protocol was agreed between the Federal Court of Australia and the Supreme Court of Victoria on 5 June 2019 addressing communication and cooperation between the courts in class action proceedings (Protocol). The Protocol states:This Protocol addresses measures by which representative or class action proceedings involving common parties and the same or similar issues that are commenced at or about the same time in the Supreme Court of Victoria and the Federal Court of Australia can be cooperatively managed with a view to facilitating access to justice and the just, quick and cheap resolution of the real issues in dispute.A similar protocol operates between the Supreme Court of New South Wales and the Federal Court of Australia dated 1 November 2018.By this protocol, each court intends to facilitate the cooperative and efficient management of similar or substantially similar class actions on foot in each of the Supreme and Federal Courts at the same time. The Protocol is a reflection of the necessary comity that is required between the Supreme Courts of the States and Territories and the Federal Court of Australia in the concurrent exercise of federal jurisdiction: see Wileypark Pty Ltd v AMP Ltd (2018) 265 FCR 1 (Wileypark) at [11] per Allsop CJ. Under the Protocol, the courts aim to promote the efficient and timely coordination and administration of competing class action proceedings in the most convenient and appropriate jurisdiction having regard to: the issues raised in the respective proceedings; the interests of the parties and group members in the respective proceedings; the minimisation of costs and inconvenience to the parties; the management of the competing class action proceedings in ways that are proportionate to the size and nature of the respective classes, the complexity of the issues, the nature of the proceedings, and the number of jurisdictions involved. The Protocol contemplates the conduct of joint case management hearings, including for the purpose of ascertaining the suitability of the matters for joint or concurrent hearing of a “selection” or carriage hearing to resolve a multiplicity issue across the courts.