B and Ors & B [Limitation of Action]

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

[2005] FamCA 906

FAMILY LAW ACT 1975

IN THE FULL COURT OF

THE FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AT SYDNEY

Appeal No. EA 18 of 2005

File No. SYF 2622 of 1984

IN THE MATTER OF:

B

- and -

C

- and -

C

Appellants/Executors

- and -

B

Respondent/Wife

[Limitation of action]

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

BEFORE:Faulks DCJ, Kay and Boland JJ

HEARD:24 August 2005

JUDGMENT:             26 September 2005

APPEARANCES:     

Dr Birch SC (instructed by HAL Lawyers, Suite 28, 193 Macquarie Street, Sydney NSW 2000) appeared on behalf of the Appellant Executors.

Mr Lloyd of counsel (instructed by Stuart & Mills Solicitors, Level 5, 67 Castlereagh Street, Sydney NSW 2000) appeared on behalf of the Respondent Wife.

APPEAL SUMMARY

MATTER:B and Ors and B [Re limitation of action]

APPEAL NUMBER:  EA 18 of 2005 (SYF 2622 of 1984)

CORAM:Faulks DCJ, Kay and Boland JJ

DATE OF HEARING:  24 August 2005

DATE OF JUDGMENT:  26 September 2005

CATCHWORDS:                

APPEAL – property – orders made under s 79 of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) in 1986 – whether enforcement of orders by the wife against the deceased husband’s executors in 2003 is time barred by Limitation Act 1969 (NSW) s 17 – application of s 79 of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) – meaning of “action on a cause of action on a judgment” in light of Dennehy (a bankrupt) v Reasonable Endeavours Pty Ltd (formerly Asiaciti (Australia) Pty Ltd) [2003] FCAFC 158; (2003) 130 FCR 494 – whether orders for sale of property create an equitable interest in the wife’s favour – whether enforcement of equitable interest also time barred by Limitation Act – meaning of equitable charge – whether subsequent consent orders made in 2003 are null and void – effect of non-compliance with s 105 of the Family Law Act – whether equitable interest must be enforced in the Supreme Court of New South Wales – whether executors entitled to equitable accounting

Mullane v Mullane (1983) 158 CLR 436; (1983) FLC 91-303

Official Trustee in Bankruptcy v Mateo (2003) FLC 93-128

Daniel v Daniel and Jones (Trustee in Bankruptcy) (2004) FLC 93-187

Jones v Daniel; In the matter of Daniel (2004) FLC 93-196

In the Marriage of Michiels (1991) 14 Fam LR 587

Northern Territory of Australia v GPAO and Others (1998-1999) 196 CLR 553; (1999) FLC 92-838

Dennehy (a bankrupt) v Reasonable Endeavours Pty Ltd (formerly Asiaciti (Australia) Pty Ltd) [2003] FCAFC 158; (2003) 130 FCR 494

W T Lamb & Sons v Rider [1948] 2 KB 331

Lowsley v Forbes [1999] 1 AC 329

Gleeson v Gleeson [2002] NSWSC 418

Associated Alloys Pty Ltd v ACN 001 452 106 Pty Ltd (in liq) (2000) 202 CLR 588

Jones v Daniel (2005) 212 ALR 588

Metwally (No 2) v University of Wollongong (1985) 60 ALR 68

Appeal dismissed.

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal by the executors of the estate of a deceased husband against orders made by Le Poer Trench J…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read B and Ors & B [Limitation of Action] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FamCA 906
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned the enforcement of property orders made in 1986 under s 79 of the *Family Law Act 1975* (Cth) by the wife against the executors of her deceased husband's estate. The primary dispute revolved around whether the wife's application in 2003 to enforce these orders was time-barred by s 17 of the *Limitation Act 1969* (NSW). The executors also contended that subsequent consent orders made in 2003 were invalid as they were erroneously based on the original 1986 orders.

The court was required to determine several legal issues. Firstly, it had to consider the applicability of s 17 of the *Limitation Act 1969* (NSW) to the enforcement of the 1986 orders, particularly in light of the decision in *Dennehy (a bankrupt) v Reasonable Endeavours Pty Ltd*. Secondly, the court needed to ascertain the nature of the wife's entitlement arising from the 1986 orders, specifically whether these orders created an equitable interest in her favour, and if so, whether that interest constituted an equitable charge. Finally, the court had to assess the validity of the 2003 consent orders and the effect of any non-compliance with s 105 of the *Family Law Act 1975* (Cth).

The court reasoned that the 1986 orders, which stipulated the sale of the matrimonial home and a 50/50 division of the net proceeds, did not create an equitable interest in the wife's favour that would be subject to the *Limitation Act 1969* (NSW). Instead, the orders created a personal obligation on the husband to pay the wife her share of the proceeds upon sale. The court found that the wife's application in 2003 was an attempt to enforce a judgment debt, and therefore, the *Limitation Act 1969* (NSW) did not apply to such enforcement actions. The court also determined that the 2003 consent orders were validly made and did not suffer from the alleged defects raised by the executors.

The appeal was dismissed, and the orders made by the Judicial Registrar on 2 August 2004 were affirmed. The court ordered that the wife was entitled to her one-half share of the net proceeds of sale of the matrimonial home, amounting to $476,536.96.

Background

Background to the litigation

- Case title: B and Ors & B [Limitation of Action]

This appeal involves the enforcement of property settlement orders made in 1986 by the Family Court of Australia, following the death of the husband in 2001. The husband's executors argue that the wife's enforcement of these orders is barred by the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW) and that the wife's interest under the orders was an equitable charge that was also time barred. The wife asserts that her interest under the orders is an equitable interest in the property itself, not merely a charge, and that her enforcement of the orders is not subject to limitation periods.

The husband and wife made property settlement orders in 1986, providing for the sale of their matrimonial home and division of the proceeds equally between them. The wife sought to enforce these orders in 2003, after the husband's death. The executors of the husband's estate argue that the wife's enforcement is barred by the Limitation Act, as it was an action on a cause of action on a judgment that was not brought within 12 years. They also argue that any interest the wife obtained under the 1986 orders was an equitable charge, which is subject to limitation periods under the Limitation Act. The wife asserts that her interest is an equitable interest in the property itself, not a charge, and that her enforcement of the orders is not subject to limitation periods.

This appeal is from the Family Court of Australia where the executors of the estate of a deceased husband, B, are challenging the orders made by Le Poer Trench J on 27 January 2005. The appeal raises two issues of law concerning the operation of the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW) and the nature of the wife's entitlement as a result of the 1986 orders. The executors submit that the wife is precluded from enforcing the orders made in 1986 by reason of the Limitation Act, which prevents an action on a cause of action on a judgment if brought more than 12 years after the judgment becomes enforceable. They also dispute that the 1986 orders created an equitable interest in the wife's favour and argue that if any equitable interest was created, it was an equitable charge and therefore unenforceable. The wife asserts that the 1986 orders created an equitable interest in her favour such that the husband held one half of the property on trust for her and that the Limitation Act has no effect on her enforcement action. The appeal was heard by Faulks DCJ, Kay, and Boland JJ on 24 August 2005, and the judgment was delivered on 26 September 2005.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW) apply to the enforcement of the 1986 orders by the wife in 2003?
2. If the 1986 orders created an equitable interest in the wife's favour, what is the nature of that interest?
3. Are the 2003 orders null and void due to their reliance on the 1986 orders and non-compliance with s 105 of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)?
4. Is enforcement of the wife's equitable interest available under the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) or should it be pursued in the Supreme Court of New South Wales?
5. If the wife has an equitable interest, is the executor entitled to an equitable accounting for sums paid by the deceased husband after the 1986 orders?

Held
1. The Limitation Act 1969 (NSW) does not apply to the enforcement of the 1986 orders by the wife in 2003, as the action was for enforcement rather than a new action on the cause of action.
2. The 1986 orders created an equitable interest in the wife's favour, which was an absolute interest and not an equitable charge.
3. The 2003 orders are not null and void, as they were based on the 1986 orders and the executors impliedly consented to leave being granted for enforcement proceedings.
4. Enforcement of the wife's equitable interest is available under the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) and the court has exclusive jurisdiction to deal with matrimonial causes, rather than in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.
5. The executor is not entitled to an equitable accounting for sums paid by the deceased husband after the 1986 orders, as the executors confirmed the husband's obligations through the 2003 orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Full Court of the Family Court of Australia considered several key legal issues in this case. Firstly, the court examined whether the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW) applied to the enforcement of the 1986 orders by the wife in 2003. The executors argued that the wife's enforcement of the orders was barred by the Limitation Act, which provides that an action on a cause of action on a judgment is not maintainable if brought after the expiration of a limitation period of twelve years. However, the Full Court found that the wife's application in 2003 was an application for enforcement under s 79(1A) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) and not a new action, and therefore the Limitation Act did not apply. The court relied on the reasoning of the Full Court of the Federal Court in Dennehy (a bankrupt) v Reasonable Endeavours Pty Ltd (formerly Asiaciti (Australia) Pty Ltd) [2003] FCAFC 158; (2003) 130 FCR 494, which held that the limitation statute did not apply to steps taken in the enforcement of a judgment.

Secondly, the court addressed the nature of the wife's equitable interest in the matrimonial home created by the 1986 orders. The executors argued that the wife's interest was merely an equitable charge, which would be subject to the Limitation Act. However, the Full Court found that the wife's interest was not an equitable charge, but rather an absolute interest in the equity of the matrimonial home, which was not subject to the Limitation Act. The court relied on the findings of the Full Court in Official Trustee in Bankruptcy v Mateo (2003) FLC 93-128 and Daniel v Daniel and Jones (Trustee in Bankruptcy) (2004) FLC 93-187, which held that an order under s 79 of the Family Law Act created an equitable interest in the property.

Thirdly, the court considered whether the 2003 orders were null and void due to their reliance on the 1986 orders and non-compliance with s 105 of the Family Law Act. The executors argued that the 2003 orders were void because they were based on the 1986 orders, which were unenforceable, and because the wife had not obtained leave to enforce the orders. However, the Full Court found that the 2003 orders were valid as they provided machinery provisions to effect enforcement of the 1986 orders. The court also found that the executors had impliedly consented to the enforcement proceedings by entering into the 2003 orders.

Fourthly, the court considered whether enforcement of the wife's equitable interest was available under the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) or should be pursued in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The executors argued that the wife's equitable interest should be enforced in the Supreme Court, as it was not within the jurisdiction of the Family Court. However, the Full Court found that the Family Court had exclusive jurisdiction to deal with matrimonial causes, including enforcement of orders made under s 79 of the Family Law Act. The court relied on the provisions of ss 79(1A), 105 and 106B of the Act, which provide that orders made under s 79 are final and binding unless set aside under s 79A, and that enforcement applications are a matrimonial cause.

Lastly, the court considered whether the executors were entitled to an equitable accounting for sums paid by the deceased husband after the 1986 orders. The executors argued that they were entitled to an accounting for the mortgage payments made by the husband after the 1986 orders. However, the Full Court found that the executors had not made a valid claim for an accounting, and that the trial Judge had not been asked to determine the application for a division of the proceeds of sale in proportions different to those in the 1986 orders. The court held that the executors had confirmed the husband's obligations by entering into the 2003 orders, and that the trial Judge had provided an opportunity for the executors to file an amended application if they chose to do so.

In conclusion, the Full Court dismissed the executors' appeal and held that the wife's enforcement of the 1986 orders was not barred by the Limitation Act, that the wife's interest was an absolute interest in the equity of the matrimonial home, that the 2003 orders were valid, that enforcement of the wife's equitable interest was available under the Family Law Act, and that the executors were not entitled to an equitable accounting. The court ordered the executors to pay the wife's costs in the sum of $4,500.