AWX24 v Australian National University (Separate Question)

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AWX24 v Australian National University (Separate Question) [2024] FCA 1075    

File number: ACD 36 of 2023
Judgment of: KENNETT J
Date of judgment: 17 September 2024
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – separate question stated for resolution prior to final hearing – whether hearing should proceed in the light of concessions made by respondent as to jurisdictional error

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – statutory disciplinary process of university – where legislation governing disciplinary process provides for appeal – where jurisdictional error in appellate decision conceded by respondent – where court has discretion whether to grant relief – where the Federal Court has issued decision in McGary v Australian National University [2024] FCA 800 (McGary) on the proper task of the appellate decision maker under the relevant statutory scheme – where respondent appealing that decision to Full Court – where respondent does not concede McGary-style jurisdictional error in present proceeding, but concedes it is open to court to find a McGary-style jurisdictional error in present proceeding – whether court should proceed to review initial disciplinary decision – whether statutory appeal process sufficient remedy for error at first instance – whether matter should be referred back to statutory appeal process – whether respondent can maintain submission that statutory appeal process sufficient while contesting the content of that appeal process before the Court in other proceedings

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – where respondent concedes one jurisdictional error in decision under review and consents to relief in the form of certiorari – where applicant wishes to press claim for certiorari on other grounds of judicial review – whether court should proceed to hear claim for certiorari on other grounds   

Legislation:

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) ss 5, 10, 16

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 39B

Appeals Rule 2018 (Cth)

Appeals Rule 2021 (Cth) s 23

Appeals Rule 2023 (Cth) ss 11, 14, 15, 17, 19, 20, 23, 32, 33

Australian National University (Legislation) Statute 2023 (Cth) s 26

Discipline Rule 2021 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Gondarra v Minister for Families, Housing, Community Services and Indigenous Affairs [2014] FCA 25; 220 FCR 202

Irwin v Military Rehabilitation & Compensation Commission [2009] FCAFC 33; 174 FCR 574

Kamha v Australian Prudential Regulation Authority [2005] FCAFC 248; 147 FCR 516

Kovalev v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 557; 100 FCR 323

Makowski v Legal Profession Admission Board [2020] NSWCA 305

McGary v Australian National University [2024] FCA 800

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Bhardwaj [2002] HCA 11; 209 CLR 597

VNPC v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services & Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCA 921

Division: General Division
Registry: Australian Capital Territory
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 45
Date of hearing: 30 August 2024
Counsel for the applicant: P Walker SC with J Bird
Solicitor for the applicant: David Healey Solicitors
Counsel for the respondent: R Graycar with K Morris
Solicitor for the respondent: HWL Ebsworth
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AWX24 v Australian National University (Separate Question) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 1075
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case of AWX24 v Australian National University (Separate Question) involved a student, AWX24, challenging a series of disciplinary decisions made by the Australian National University. The student sought judicial review of multiple decisions, including an exclusion decision by Professor Venville and an appeal decision by an Appeals Committee. The University conceded a jurisdictional error in the appeal decision but contested other aspects of the student's claims. The court was tasked with determining whether to set aside the appeal decision, dismiss certain claims, and schedule a hearing for the remaining issues.

The key legal issues before the court were whether the court should proceed with reviewing the initial disciplinary decisions in light of the University's concession of a jurisdictional error in the appeal decision, whether the statutory appeal process provided sufficient remedy for the error, and whether the court should consider other grounds for certiorari despite the concession. Additionally, the court needed to decide whether to dismiss specific claims and whether the University could maintain that the statutory appeal process was sufficient while contesting its content in other proceedings.

The court held that it should set aside the appeal decision due to the conceded jurisdictional error. However, the court was not satisfied that the concession of procedural unfairness was valid, as the disclosed information was not required to be shared under principles of procedural fairness. Consequently, the court dismissed the claim for relief based on this concession. The remaining claims for relief were set down for hearing, and the case was listed for case management to schedule the hearing on the remaining issues. The court also ordered that the costs of the hearing on the separate question be reserved.

The court's final orders were to set aside the appeal decision, dismiss the claim for relief based on the conceded procedural unfairness, and schedule a case management hearing to timetable evidence and submissions for the remaining issues. The costs of the hearing on the separate question were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The question stated for separate decision on 7 August 2024 be answered as follows:

(a) The decision of the Appeals Committee of the respondent communicated to the applicant on 12 January 2023 (the Appeal decision) should be set aside.

(b) Prayer 1(f) in the amended originating application should be dismissed.

(c) The remaining prayers for relief should be set down for hearing.

2. In accordance with the answers stated in order 1:

(a) the Appeal decision be set aside; and

(b) the originating application be dismissed in so far as it seeks the relief set out in prayer 1(f).

3. The proceeding be listed for case management on a date to be advised.

4. The parties provide short minutes of order to Justice Kennett’s Chambers 24 hours prior to the case management hearing referred to in order 3 providing for the timetabling of evidence and submissions for a hearing on the remaining issues in the proceeding.

5. The costs of the hearing on the separate question stated on 7 August 2024 be reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 20 September 2022, Professor Venville informed the applicant of the outcome of her inquiry into allegations made by another student, ATT24. Professor Venville accepted ATT24's allegations and decided to exclude the applicant from the Australian National University (ANU) immediately. This decision was subject to an appeal process under the Appeals Rule 2021 (Cth). The applicant appealed the exclusion decision, arguing that the findings were manifestly wrong and the penalty excessive. An Appeals Committee heard the applicant's appeal on 24 November 2022 and confirmed the exclusion decision in a letter dated 12 January 2023. The applicant subsequently filed an originating application for judicial review on 20 June 2023, seeking various orders, including the quashing of multiple decisions made by Professor Venville and the Appeals Committee, as well as a declaration and an order for the university to pay costs.

The applicant filed an originating application for judicial review on 20 June 2023, which was followed by a series of interlocutory applications and amendments. The case involved protracted discussions about confidentiality orders and proposed further amendments to the statement of claim. On 11 April 2024, the applicant filed another originating application, effectively reconstituting the case as an ordinary judicial review application under the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth). Leave to file an amended originating application was granted on 6 August 2024. The court heard arguments on a separate question stated for resolution on 30 August 2024.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 20 September 2022, Professor Venville wrote to the applicant informing him of the outcome of her inquiry. In short, she accepted the allegations of ATT24 as set out in her complaint. She decided to exclude the applicant from the University (the exclusion decision). The exclusion was effective immediately. Decisions of this kind are subject to an appeal process under delegated legislation (at the time, the Appeals Rule 2021 (Cth) (Appeals Rule) of the University). The applicant retained a local firm of solicitors and appealed against the exclusion decision. His grounds of appeal were that the findings of Professor Venville were manifestly wrong and the penalty imposed was manifestly excessive. An Appeals Committee was constituted, consisting of three staff members of the University and a student representative. The Appeals Committee heard from the applicant in person on 24 November 2022 between 10:46am and 11:14am. It also did not speak to ATT24 or the other witnesses. The Appeals Committee communicated its decision to the applicant by a letter dated 12 January 2023, signed by the University’s Senior Appeals and Integrity Officer “on behalf of the Appeals Committee” but naming only three of the members of that committee. Pursuant to s 23(1)(a) of the Appeals Rule, it confirmed the decision of Professor Venville.This proceeding The applicant filed an originating application for judicial review, together with a statement of claim, on 20 June 2023. These documents had a number of deficiencies which do not need to be detailed here, but which have contributed to the matter taking an undesirably long time to reach the point that it has reached. Following a series of interlocutory applications, an amended statement of claim, a protracted process leading to the making of confidentiality orders and disagreement concerning a proposed further amended statement of claim, the applicant (having changed counsel) filed an originating application on 11 April 2024. By this stage, a claim in tort had been abandoned and the case was effectively reconstituted as an ordinary judicial review application under s 39B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth). The applicant later sought to amend his originating application so as to seek substantially the same relief under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) (for which an extension of time was needed) and clarify some aspects of his case. This was not consented to, although the prejudice it occasioned to the University was unclear. Leave to file the amended originating application (the amended application) was granted on 6 August 2024. The amended application does not appear to have been filed. However, in the light of the grant of leave, I proceed on the basis that it states the relief which the applicant seeks and the grounds on which it is sought. The relief sought by the amended application is as follows (the decisions mentioned in prayers 1(a) to (d) being those made by Professor Venville).1. The Applicant seeks orders to the following effect:a. An order quashing the Inquiry Decision. b. An order quashing the Interim Denial of Access Decision. c. An order quashing the Misconduct Decision. d. An order quashing the Permanent Denial of Access Decision. e. An order quashing the Appeal Committee Decision. f. A declaration that, on the evidence before it, the Appeals Committee could not reasonably decide other than the appeal had to be upheld. g. A declaration that the Applicant is entitled to resume his studies at the Australian National University. h. An order that the Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs of and incidental to the Application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The parties filed written submissions on this question and I heard argument on 30 August 2024.ConsiderationThe process and decision of the Appeals CommitteeThe concessions by the University As noted earlier, the University originally proposed to resolve the matter on the basis of a concession that the applicant was denied procedural fairness. In the proposed form of orders submitted by the University’s solicitors, this was described as a failure to invite the applicant to comment on “potentially adverse information”, although the information was not identified. At the hearing of the separate question I was taken to an email chain in the court book which, I was informed, was the material the subject of the concession. The applicant had been in possession of this material (albeit in a redacted form) for some time, thanks to a freedom of information request, and had not sought to make any point about failure to disclose it during the Appeals Committee process. The version in the Court Book is also redacted (and the basis of the redaction is not explained). So far as can be seen, it is an exchange of emails in which one of the Committee members asks whether the alleged sexual assault had been reported to police or otherwise become the subject of a criminal investigation and a staff member replies that (so far as the administration is aware) it has not. Nothing in the exchange constitutes information that was referred to adversely with respect to the applicant in the Committee’s reasons or could rationally have been taken into account adversely to him. The fact that the complainant had made no report to police was something that the applicant had very likely worked out for himself and that he might conceivably have deployed in his favour. It was not “adverse” and on this basis was not required to be disclosed by ordinary principles of procedural fairness (see eg Gondarra v Minister for Families, Housing, Community Services and Indigenous Affairs [2014] FCA 25; 220 FCR 202 at [145]-[149] (Kenny J)). Before making consent orders the Court must be satisfied that they are within power and appropriate. Where the proposed orders would set aside a purported exercise of statutory power, this means that the Court must be satisfied that the exercise of power is vitiated by the conceded error: the consent of the parties is not itself sufficient to empower the making of the order: Irwin v Military Rehabilitation & Compensation Commission [2009] FCAFC 33; 174 FCR 574 at [13]-[15] (Downes, Greenwood and Tracey JJ); see also Kovalev v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 557; 100 FCR 323 at [11] (French J); VNPC v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services & Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCA 921 at [2]-[5] (Colvin J). I am not satisfied that the Appeals Committee denied the applicant procedural fairness in the manner sought to be conceded. Senior counsel for the applicant described this concession as a “confection” and suggested that it was an attempt to prevent his client’s complaints being fully ventilated. While the concession is surprising and suggests a strategic withdrawal, it would be inappropriate for me to speculate as to the University’s motives. It is sufficient to record that I do not accept that there was a denial of procedural fairness of the kind suggested.