Australian Skills Quality Authority v Brighton Pacific Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Skills Quality Authority v Brighton Pacific Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 617

Appeal from: Brighton Pacific Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2019] AATA 3645
File number(s): QUD 640 of 2019
Judge(s): COLLIER J
Date of judgment: 11 May 2020
Catchwords: ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – appeal pursuant to s 44(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) – appeal from decision of Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) to set aside decisions of the applicant to cancel the first respondent’s registrations under the National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (Cth) (NVR Act) and the Education Services for Overseas Students Act 2000 (Cth) (ESOS Act) – where the first respondent had not complied with relevant regulatory standards – whether Tribunal made an error of law in respect of its jurisdiction – powers exercisable by Tribunal under s 43(1) AAT Act “for the purpose of reviewing a decision” – whether the Tribunal exceeded its jurisdiction or acted beyond its power – whether Tribunal renewed registrations under relevant legislation – whether Tribunal had power to impose conditions on registration – whether the Tribunal had regard to an irrelevant consideration –where the Tribunal stands in the place of the original decision-maker in reviewing a decision of the original decision-maker – where Tribunal is not confined to exercise the same powers as those exercised by the original decision-maker – where it was open to the Tribunal to set aside decisions of the applicant to cancel the first respondent’s registrations under the NVR Act and the ESOS Act – where it was open to the Tribunal to impose conditions on the first respondent’s registration – where it was open to the Tribunal to align the first respondent’s registrations under the NVR Act and the ESOS Act
Legislation:

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) – ss 25(1), 43(1)

National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (Cth) – ss 20(2), 26, 29, 36(1), 36(2), 37, 39, 203

Education Services for Overseas Students Act 2000 (Cth) – ss 10L, 10L(2), 10D, 10E, 19(1)(c)-(f), 21, 21(2)(a), 46F, 47H, 83(3), 93(4), 108, 119, 169AB, 169AG

National Code of Practice for Providers of Education and Training to Overseas Students 2018

Standards for Registered Training Organisations 2015

ELICOS Standards 2018

Cases cited:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Donald (2003) 136 FCR 7; [2003] FCAFC 318

Collector of Customs v Pozzolanic Enterprises Pty Ltd (1993) 43 FCR 280; [1993] FCA 456

Commissioner of Taxation v Hornibrook (2006) 156 FCR 313; [2006] FCAFC 170

Commissioner of Taxation v Zoffanies Pty Ltd (2003) 132 FCR 523; [2003] FCAFC 236

Commonwealth Bank Officers Superannuation Corporation Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (2005) 148 FCR 427; [2005] FCAFC 244

Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 24 ALR 577; (1979) 46 FLR 409

Fletcher v Commissioner of Taxation (1988) 19 FCR 442

Frugtniet v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2019) 367 ALR 695; [2019] HCA 16

HFM045 v The Republic of Nauru

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Skills Quality Authority v Brighton Pacific Pty L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 617
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved the Australian Skills Quality Authority (ASQA) appealing against a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT), which had set aside decisions made by ASQA to cancel the registrations of Brighton Pacific Pty Ltd under the National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (NVR Act) and the Education Services for Overseas Students Act 2000 (ESOS Act). The primary issue for the court was whether the AAT had made an error of law in its jurisdiction, specifically if it had exceeded its powers in setting aside the decisions to cancel Brighton Pacific's registrations and imposing conditions on its registrations.

The court examined the statutory framework, particularly focusing on the powers of the AAT as outlined in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act). The court concluded that the AAT was not confined to exercising the same powers as ASQA and had the authority to review and set aside the cancellation decisions. It was open to the AAT to impose conditions on Brighton Pacific's registrations and to align the registrations under the NVR Act and the ESOS Act. The court also noted that the AAT did not have regard to any irrelevant considerations in making its decision.

In dismissing the appeal, the court affirmed the AAT's decision, finding that it had correctly exercised its jurisdiction and powers under the AAT Act. The court held that the AAT was entitled to set aside the decisions of ASQA and to impose conditions on Brighton Pacific's registrations. The final orders of the court were that the application be dismissed and that the parties provide joint draft case management orders within seven days concerning costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. The parties provide joint draft case management orders within seven days in respect of further submissions concerning costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The third decision of ASQA, namely to refuse an application by Brighton Pacific to change its CRICOS registration, subsequently affirmed by the Tribunal, was not the subject of the current proceedings before me and I make no further reference to it.BACKGROUND The Tribunal summarised relevant background in its reasons for decision, which summary I gratefully adopt as follows:·Brighton Pacific was registered as a registered training organisation under the NVR Act on 4 May 2015 and traded under the name of Australia Institute of Business & Technology. ·Its Chief Executive Officer at all material times was Ms Fiona Kee.·Brighton Pacific was registered pursuant to the ESOS Act on 29 July 2015. It marketed its offerings via a shared website with its related RTO Australian Institute of Business & Technology — International Pty Ltd (AIBTI), which obtained registration in 2017. ·Brighton Pacific also had a third party agreement with AIBTI for AIBTI to deliver training and assessment for some training products. Its courses were offered across four locations, two in New South Wales (at Blacktown and Ultimo), one in Queensland (in Upper Mount Gravatt) and one in Tasmania (in Hobart).·Brighton Pacific had approximately 2500 students enrolled and undertaking courses, and employed some 160 people. ·As at 11 September 2018, Brighton Pacific offered more than 70 courses within the scope of its VET registration, including two English Language Intensive Courses for Overseas Students (ELICOS) courses and under its CRICOS registration was able to offer 91 courses to nearly 3500 students. ·The courses spanned a range of offerings including business, health, sciences, community services, information technology, technical sciences, hospitality and aviation as well as an English language course.·On 28 May 2018, ASQA issued a compulsory notice pursuant to s 26 of the NVR Act requiring Brighton Pacific to provide information as to whether it was complying or had complied with its obligations under the NVR Act. This information was subsequently provided on 15 June 2018.·On 30 July 2018, ASQA informed Brighton Pacific of its intention to conduct an audit. A site audit was conducted between 7–10 August 2018 across two of Brighton Pacific’s campuses. ·In addition, ASQA undertook a review of Provider Registration and International Student Management Systems (PRISMS) data pertaining to Brighton Pacific and its overseas student enrolments during the period of 25 September 2017 and 4 October 2018.·Brighton Pacific was advised during the site audit and again on 3 September 2018 that ASQA had found non‐compliances, and that Brighton Pacific would have 20 working days to respond once it received a notification letter from ASQA. ·The detailed audit report and annexures was finalised on 12 October 2018. ASQA advised Brighton Pacific on 16 October 2018 that it had made a preliminary decision based on the non‐compliances identified by the audit. ·ASQA invited Brighton Pacific to submit a written response and any additional evidence by 14 November 2018. ·The audit identified that Brighton Pacific was not compliant with a number of regulatory requirements pertaining to its obligations both as an RTO and as a provider of education to overseas students.·The time for a response by Brighton Pacific was extended to 21 November 2018. ·On 22 November 2018 Brighton Pacific submitted its response. ASQA analysed the response and determined that Brighton Pacific had not provided evidence to demonstrate and/or conclusively confirm that it was compliant in a number of areas.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Materially by separate letters dated 19 February 2019 (collectively, the “Decision Letters”), ASQA notified Brighton Pacific of the following decisions:·a decision to cancel Brighton Pacific’s registration under section 39 of NVR Act; and·a decision to cancel Brighton Pacific’s registration for all courses at all locations under section 83(3) and 93(4) of the ESOS Act. The Decision Letter in respect of ASQA’s decision to cancel Brighton Pacific’s NVR Act registration stated as follows:…Dear Ms KeeRe: Brighton Pacific Pty Ltd: Notice of decision to cancel NVR Act registrationOn 16 October 2018, the Australian Skills Quality Authority (ASQA) gave you notice under section 37(1)(a) of the National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (the NVR Act) that it intended to make a decision to cancel your registration under section 39. That notice also, in accordance with section 37(1)(b), invited you to give ASQA a written response no later than 14 November 2018.On 8 November 2018, ASQA received your request for an extension to provide a written response. An extension was approved until the 21 November 2018.On 22 November 2018, ASQA received your response, ASQA has considered your response. In accordance with section 37(2) of the NVR Act, ASQA hereby gives you notice that it has made a decision to cancel your registration under section 39 with effect from 26 March 2019.Reason for the DecisionReview and analysis of Brighton Pacific Pty Ltd's written response to the 'Notice of audit non−compliance and intention to make a decision' sent to the organisation on 16 October 2018 indicates that the provider has taken action to address some aspects of the non−compliance following the compliance monitoring audit of the organisation. However, analysis of the evidence provided also indicates that the provider remains non−compliant with the following requirements.•Standards for Registered Training Organisations 2015 (Standards for RTOs) − Clauses 1.1, 1.3, 1.8, 1.13, 1.14, 1.16, 1.18, 3.1, 4.1, 8.5•National Code of Practice for Providers of Education and Training to Overseas Students 2018 (National Code) − Standards 1. 1, 1.2, 11.2•ELICOS Standards 2018 − P5.1, P6.7.Specifically, the additional information and evidence provided failed to demonstrate and/or conclusively confirm that the provider is compliant in the following areas:•Ensuring that all information disseminated via the RTO’s website about its course offerings (which is also used by its education agents for marketing purposes) is accurate and factual in all cases; and that remedial action has been undertaken to identify and address the impact, the non−compliance identified at audit may have caused to current students enrolled in the training products where non−compliance was identified who received marketing material/information that was not accurate and factual (non−compliance aligns with Clause 4.1 of the Standards for RTOs, and Standards 1.1 and 1.2 of the National Code 2018) •Ensuring that its documented training and assessment strategies for the sampled training products fully and accurately describe the provider's arrangements for the delivery of training and assessment consistent with actual practice, and clearly demonstrate that the RTO’s training and assessment strategies and practice enable each learner to meet the requirements for each unit of competency (non−compliance aligns with Clause 1.1)•Ensuring that the provider has, for the sampled training products, sufficient trainers and assessors (who meet the requirements of the Standards), learning and assessment resources, facilities and equipment, proportionate to the number of students enrolled at any time, the mode of delivery, location of delivery, and the provider's training and assessment strategies (non−compliance aligns to Clause 1.3 of the Standards for RTOs, and Standard 11.2 of the National Code 2018)•Ensuring that the provider's use of educational resources for the purpose of delivering ELICOS courses addresses individual and specific student needs, and reflects new developments in TESOL theory and practice (non−compliance aligns to Standard P5.1 of the ELICOS Standards 2018)•Implementing an assessment system that ensures that the assessment complies with the requirements of the relevant training package and is conducted in accordance with the Principles of Assessment and Rules of Evidence; and completing remedial action to address the impact the non−compliance may have caused to current and former students who were enrolled in the sampled training products who were assessed in a manner that did not meet the requirements of Clause 1.8 (non−compliance aligns to Clause 1.8 of the Standards for RTOs)•Ensuring that all of its nominated trainers and assessors for the sampled training products have or had vocational competencies at least to the level being delivered and assessed; current industry skills directly relevant to the training and assessment they are providing or have provided; and current knowledge and skills in vocational training and learning that informs their training and assessment (non−compliance aligns to Clause 1.13 of the Standards for RTOs) •Ensuring that all of its nominated trainers and assessors delivering the sampled training products hold the training and assessment qualification specified in Item 1 or Item 2 or Item 3 of Schedule 1 to the Standards (non−compliance aligns to Clause 1.14 of the Standards for RTOs)•Ensuring that all of its trainers and assessors delivering or who have delivered the sampled training products have or will undertake professional development in the fields of the knowledge and practice of vocational training, learning and assessment including competency based training and assessment (noncompliance aligns to Clause 1.16 of the Standards for RTOs) •Ensuring that all requirements pertaining to individuals working under supervision of a trainer have been met (non−compliance aligns to Clauses 1.18 of the Standards for RTOs) •Ensuring that it verifies the qualifications of all of its ELICOS teachers (non−compliance aligns to Standard P6.7 of the ELICOS Standards 2018) •Ensuing that its assessment systems meet the requirements of Clause 1.8(a) of the Standards for RTOs with respect to the sampled training products, and thereby guarantees that AQF certification documentation has and will only be issued to a learner who has been assessed as meeting all of the requirements of the relevant training product as specified in the training package (non−compliance aligns to Clause 3.1 of the Standards for RTOs 2015) •Ensuring that the provider complies with all Commonwealth, State and Territory legislation and regulatory requirements relevant to its operations (non−compliance aligns to Clause 8.5 of the Standards for RTOs), in particular, the provider's reporting obligations under the Education Services for Overseas Students Act 2000.…

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Decision Letter in respect of ASQA’s decision to cancel Brighton Pacific’s NVR Act registration stated as follows:…Dear Ms KeeRe: Brighton Pacific Pty Ltd: Notice of decision to cancel NVR Act registrationOn 16 October 2018, the Australian Skills Quality Authority (ASQA) gave you notice under section 37(1)(a) of the National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (the NVR Act) that it intended to make a decision to cancel your registration under section 39. That notice also, in accordance with section 37(1)(b), invited you to give ASQA a written response no later than 14 November 2018.On 8 November 2018, ASQA received your request for an extension to provide a written response. An extension was approved until the 21 November 2018.On 22 November 2018, ASQA received your response, ASQA has considered your response. In accordance with section 37(2) of the NVR Act, ASQA hereby gives you notice that it has made a decision to cancel your registration under section 39 with effect from 26 March 2019.Reason for the DecisionReview and analysis of Brighton Pacific Pty Ltd's written response to the 'Notice of audit non−compliance and intention to make a decision' sent to the organisation on 16 October 2018 indicates that the provider has taken action to address some aspects of the non−compliance following the compliance monitoring audit of the organisation. However, analysis of the evidence provided also indicates that the provider remains non−compliant with the following requirements.•Standards for Registered Training Organisations 2015 (Standards for RTOs) − Clauses 1.1, 1.3, 1.8, 1.13, 1.14, 1.16, 1.18, 3.1, 4.1, 8.5•National Code of Practice for Providers of Education and Training to Overseas Students 2018 (National Code) − Standards 1. 1, 1.2, 11.2•ELICOS Standards 2018 − P5.1, P6.7.Specifically, the additional information and evidence provided failed to demonstrate and/or conclusively confirm that the provider is compliant in the following areas:•Ensuring that all information disseminated via the RTO’s website about its course offerings (which is also used by its education agents for marketing purposes) is accurate and factual in all cases; and that remedial action has been undertaken to identify and address the impact, the non−compliance identified at audit may have caused to current students enrolled in the training products where non−compliance was identified who received marketing material/information that was not accurate and factual (non−compliance aligns with Clause 4.1 of the Standards for RTOs, and Standards 1.1 and 1.2 of the National Code 2018) •Ensuring that its documented training and assessment strategies for the sampled training products fully and accurately describe the provider's arrangements for the delivery of training and assessment consistent with actual practice, and clearly demonstrate that the RTO’s training and assessment strategies and practice enable each learner to meet the requirements for each unit of competency (non−compliance aligns with Clause 1.1)•Ensuring that the provider has, for the sampled training products, sufficient trainers and assessors (who meet the requirements of the Standards), learning and assessment resources, facilities and equipment, proportionate to the number of students enrolled at any time, the mode of delivery, location of delivery, and the provider's training and assessment strategies (non−compliance aligns to Clause 1.3 of the Standards for RTOs, and Standard 11.2 of the National Code 2018)•Ensuring that the provider's use of educational resources for the purpose of delivering ELICOS courses addresses individual and specific student needs, and reflects new developments in TESOL theory and practice (non−compliance aligns to Standard P5.1 of the ELICOS Standards 2018)•Implementing an assessment system that ensures that the assessment complies with the requirements of the relevant training package and is conducted in accordance with the Principles of Assessment and Rules of Evidence; and completing remedial action to address the impact the non−compliance may have caused to current and former students who were enrolled in the sampled training products who were assessed in a manner that did not meet the requirements of Clause 1.8 (non−compliance aligns to Clause 1.8 of the Standards for RTOs)•Ensuring that all of its nominated trainers and assessors for the sampled training products have or had vocational competencies at least to the level being delivered and assessed; current industry skills directly relevant to the training and assessment they are providing or have provided; and current knowledge and skills in vocational training and learning that informs their training and assessment (non−compliance aligns to Clause 1.13 of the Standards for RTOs) •Ensuring that all of its nominated trainers and assessors delivering the sampled training products hold the training and assessment qualification specified in Item 1 or Item 2 or Item 3 of Schedule 1 to the Standards (non−compliance aligns to Clause 1.14 of the Standards for RTOs)•Ensuring that all of its trainers and assessors delivering or who have delivered the sampled training products have or will undertake professional development in the fields of the knowledge and practice of vocational training, learning and assessment including competency based training and assessment (noncompliance aligns to Clause 1.16 of the Standards for RTOs) •Ensuring that all requirements pertaining to individuals working under supervision of a trainer have been met (non−compliance aligns to Clauses 1.18 of the Standards for RTOs) •Ensuring that it verifies the qualifications of all of its ELICOS teachers (non−compliance aligns to Standard P6.7 of the ELICOS Standards 2018) •Ensuing that its assessment systems meet the requirements of Clause 1.8(a) of the Standards for RTOs with respect to the sampled training products, and thereby guarantees that AQF certification documentation has and will only be issued to a learner who has been assessed as meeting all of the requirements of the relevant training product as specified in the training package (non−compliance aligns to Clause 3.1 of the Standards for RTOs 2015) •Ensuring that the provider complies with all Commonwealth, State and Territory legislation and regulatory requirements relevant to its operations (non−compliance aligns to Clause 8.5 of the Standards for RTOs), in particular, the provider's reporting obligations under the Education Services for Overseas Students Act 2000.…