Australian Olympic Committee Inc v The Big Fights Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 90 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN OLYMPIC COMMITTEE INC v THE BIG FIGHTS INC

[1999] FCA 1042

NG 41 of 1997

NG 481 of 1998

SUMMARY

Introduction

In accordance with the practice of the Federal Court in certain cases of public interest, I have prepared a brief summary to accompany the reasons for judgment that are being delivered today. But the only authoritative pronouncement of my reasons is that contained in the full reasons for judgment.  This summary is necessarily incomplete.

Summary of Judgment

Between 22 November and 8 December 1956, the sixteenth modern Olympic Games were held in Melbourne.  The main issue in this case is the present ownership of the copyright in certain films of those Games.  There is also a dispute over the present ownership of certain copies of those films which are being held in safe storage pending this decision.  In both respects, I decide that the Australian Olympic Committee, or the AOC, succeeds. 

The case has involved facts extending over some forty years and many complex issues – too many to relate here.  What follows is a summary of some of the issues and my conclusions on them.

In 1956, the Australian Olympic Federation, or AOF, was the National Olympic Committee for Australia, recognised by the International Olympic Committee, or IOC.  Organisation of the Games was entrusted to a company formed for the purpose called the “Organising Committee for the Games of the XVIth Olympiad Melbourne 1956”, known as “OCOG”.  OCOG established an “Official Film Unit” and appointed Reginald Peter Whitchurch, known as Peter Whitchurch, as its director.

Cameramen in the Official Film Unit shot a large quantity of footage during the Games.  The rules of the IOC required that certain edited films of the Games be produced.  OCOG engaged Peter Whitchurch to produce those edited films from the unedited ones. 

This case has concerned the unedited films shot by the Official Film Unit, the edited films subsequently produced by Peter Whitchurch, and certain newsreel type films which OCOG permitted two private companies to produce, using their own cameramen.

In 1960, OCOG granted certain rights in respect of the edited films to Peter Whitchurch in return for payment by him of £100.  This was done, not by way of a professionally prepared legal document, but by an exchange of letters between OCOG and Peter Whitchurch.  The letters have given rise to this question in the case: Did OCOG assign the copyright in the edited films to Peter Whitchurch or did it give him only a non-exclusive right to reprint and sell copies of them?

The main protagonists in these proceedings are the AOC on the one hand, and The Big Fights Incorporated on the other.  The AOC is the successor to the AOF.  The business of The Big Fights was the building up and commercial exploitation of extensive libraries of films of sporting events, in particular, boxing films and films of Olympic Games.  Part of its business involved the licensing of others, such as television broadcasters,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Olympic Committee Inc v The Big Fights Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] FCA 1042
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Australian Olympic Committee Inc v The Big Fights Inc, the Federal Court of Australia resolved a complex dispute over the ownership of copyright and physical copies of films from the 1956 Melbourne Olympic Games. The primary issue was the ownership of copyright in the films and certain copies of the films held in storage. The court determined that the Australian Olympic Committee (AOC), successor to the Australian Olympic Federation, was the rightful owner of the copyright and the physical copies of the films. The court ruled that the copyright belonged to the Organising Committee for the Games of the XVIth Olympiad Melbourne 1956 (OCOG) at the time of its dissolution and was subsequently transferred to the AOC. The court also found that the AOC was not estopped from asserting its ownership and that it was not barred by the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW), abandonment, or laches. The court clarified that the rights granted to Peter Whitchurch by OCOG in 1960 were non-exclusive rights to reprint and sell copies of the edited films, not an assignment of the copyright. The court further ruled that the AOC could not terminate the 1960 contract by accepting a wrongful repudiation and that the rights granted to Peter Whitchurch remained valid. The court concluded that the rights of reprinting and selling the edited films passed to the AOC, Benson, and Talbot in equal shares. The court made certain declarations but deferred other relief until further directions were given.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established