Australian Olive Holdings Pty Ltd v Huntley Management Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Olive Holdings Pty Ltd v Huntley Management Limited

[2010] FCAFC 76

Citation: Australian Olive Holdings Pty Ltd v Huntley Management Limited [2010] FCAFC 76
Appeal from: Australian Olive Holdings Pty Limited v Huntley Management Limited, in the matter of Huntley Management Limited [2009] FCA 1479
Parties: AUSTRALIAN OLIVE HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 078 862 085) v HUNTLEY MANAGEMENT LIMITED (ACN 089 240 513)
File number: NSD 1479 of 2009
Judges: JACOBSON, GILMOUR and FOSTER JJ
Date of judgment: 29 June 2010
Catchwords:

CONTRACTS – construction of commercial contract for the supply of water for the purpose of irrigating olive tree plantations which constitute the physical subject matter of six managed investment schemes – whether clauses which provide for the termination of the water contract when the original manager is removed as responsible entity of the schemes or retires from that position are triggered only when the schemes are terminated – clauses construed in accordance with the natural and ordinary meaning of the language used – whether clauses void as against public policy because they operate to circumvent the purpose, policy and intent of s 601FS(1) and s 601FT(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Corporations Act) – whether, upon the true construction of the water contract, the obligation imposed upon the responsible entity (manager) which was party to that contract was an obligation to pay a single indivisible sum with the consequence that the payment required cannot be apportioned as between some of the projects and others and cannot be apportioned by reference to only part of a particular financial year

CORPORATIONS – whether, in the circumstances of the present case, s 601FS(1) and s 601FT(1) of the Corporations Act were engaged after the responsible entity of the relevant schemes was changed – whether, upon the true construction of the constitution of the relevant managed investment schemes, the liability of the outgoing responsible entity to pay an annual base fee under the water contract was a liability for which it could have been indemnified out of the scheme property of those schemes so that, pursuant to s 601FS(2)(d) and s 601FT(2), the provisions of s 601FS(1) and s 601FT(1) do not apply to the water contract and to the incoming responsible entity in respect of the water contract

Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), Ch 5C, Pt 5C.2 (s 601FA to s 601FT)
Cases cited: Australian Olive Holdings Pty Ltd v Huntley Management Ltd (2009) 76 ACSR 256 affirmed
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Baxter Healthcare Pty Ltd (2007) 232 CLR 1 cited
Re Investa Properties Ltd (2001) 187 ALR 462 followed
Syncap Management (Rural) Australia Ltd v Lyford (2004) 51 ACSR 223 followed
Date of hearing: 3 May 2010
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 146
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr JC Giles, Mr JS McLeod
Solicitor for the Appellant: Harris & Harris
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr SR Donaldson SC, Mr BL Jones
Solicitor for the…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Olive Holdings Pty Ltd v Huntley Management Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCAFC 76
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of Australian Olive Holdings Pty Ltd v Huntley Management Ltd was before the court to determine issues surrounding a commercial water supply agreement (CWSA) for the irrigation of olive tree plantations. The CWSA was executed between Australian Olive Holdings Pty Ltd (AOHL) and Huntley Management Ltd (Huntley), and involved the supply of water for six managed investment schemes. The primary dispute centered around the interpretation of certain clauses in the CWSA and their implications under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Huntley argued that the clauses allowing termination of the water contract upon the removal or retirement of the original manager were intended to apply only if the schemes themselves were terminated. AOHL, on the other hand, contended that these clauses were to be triggered by any event leading to the manager's removal or retirement, irrespective of the scheme's continuity.

The court was required to decide whether the clauses in the CWSA were void as against public policy and whether they circumvented the provisions of sections 601FS(1) and 601FT(1) of the Corporations Act. Additionally, the court needed to determine if the obligation under the CWSA imposed on the responsible entity was a single indivisible sum that could not be apportioned between projects or financial years. The court also had to consider whether sections 601FS(1) and 601FT(1) of the Corporations Act were engaged after the change in the responsible entity of the schemes and if the outgoing entity's liability for an annual base fee under the CWSA could have been indemnified out of the scheme property.

The court found that the CWSA applied only to Projects 1 to 4, and not to Projects 5 and 6, because of geographical and infrastructural limitations. The court concluded that the clauses in the CWSA were not void as against public policy and that the obligation under the CWSA was a single indivisible sum. The court further held that sections 601FS(1) and 601FT(1) of the Corporations Act did not apply to the water contract and the incoming responsible entity in respect of the water contract. Consequently, Huntley was not liable for damages as it did not repudiate the CWSA.

The appeal by Huntley was dismissed, and it was ordered that Huntley pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In those circumstances, Huntley did not repudiate the CWSA and cannot be liable for damages assessed upon the basis that it did repudiate that agreement.Conclusion Huntley has succeeded on all issues. Accordingly, the appeal must be dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Only approximately 18% of Project 5 and none of Project 6 can be irrigated with water supplied from Yallamundi Lagoon. All of Project 6 and approximately 82% of Project 5 are located on the southern side of Speers Creek and there is no infrastructure enabling the pumping of water from Yallamundi Lagoon across Speers Creek. The only water resource (apart from rain water) which is available for the irrigation of those groves which are on the south side of Speers Creek is the Project 5 dam. The Project 5 dam is filled by overland flow water, not with water from Yallamundi Lagoon. Therefore, the CWSA never applied to Project 6. Although that part of Project 5 located north of Speers Creek was potentially able to be brought under the umbrella of the CWSA, that was never done. For present purposes, therefore, of the three projects with which this appeal is concerned (Projects 4, 5 and 6), the CWSA applied only to Project 4. Therefore, under the CWSA, AOHL was obliged to supply water to irrigate only Projects 1 to 4. AOL’s payment obligations under cl 5 of the CWSA related only to the supply of water to those four projects. For this reason alone, Huntley could never have been made liable in respect of the supply of water to Projects 5 and 6. Consideration It was submitted on behalf of Huntley that cl 7.1 of the CWSA is unambiguously clear in its terms. The parties to the CWSA, according to the submissions made on behalf of Huntley, fully intended to trigger the consequences and actions embodied in subcl 7.1(b) and subcl 7.1(c) of the CWSA as soon as the original manager under the CWSA (AOL) was removed or retired as manager (responsible entity) of any one or more of the projects covered by the CWSA as at the date of its execution (viz Projects 1 to 4). It was submitted on behalf of Huntley that it was open to the parties to the CWSA to make an agreement which, in effect, denied to any incoming responsible entity control over the water supply for irrigating the groves in the projects supported by the CWSA and which compelled the ultimate transfer to COGL of all relevant pumping and reticulation equipment. AOHL submitted that such a construction of cl 7.1 did not make good commercial sense. Counsel for AOHL submitted that:(a)Upon the true construction of cl 7.1, the essential common feature of each of the events described in subcll 7.1(a)(i) to (iii) is the termination of the projects. The consequences described in subcll 7.1(b) and (c), does not sit comfortably with a state of affairs whereby the projects continued beyond the termination of the CWSA;(b)The event covered by subcl 7.1(a)(i) is the termination of the projects themselves. The event described in subcl 7.1(a)(ii) (being the termination of the Lease) is an event which has the necessary consequence of terminating the projects because, upon termination of the Lease, the responsible entity and the investors in the projects cease to have access to the Water Resource. Accordingly, subcl 7.1(a)(iii) should be similarly construed as applying only if there is an event which effectively terminates the projects. Having regard to the various matters of context to which reference has been made at [48]–[58] above, subcl 7.1(a)(iii) should be read as if the following words appeared at the very end of that subclause, namely “… without a replacement being appointed”; and (c)AOHL advanced the following reasons in support of these submissions, namely: (i)Such a construction would give effect to the objective commercial purpose of the CWSA. The identity of the responsible entity under the CWSA and related agreements, at any given point in time, is irrelevant as long as that responsible entity is suitably qualified and appointed in accordance with the Act and the relevant contracts;(ii)Any attempt to entrench the position of any particular responsible entity offended the obvious purpose of Ch 5C of the Act;(iii)Clause 6.1 of the CWSA provides that the manager may assign its rights and interests under that Agreement. AOHL’s construction avoids any conflict between cl 6.1 and cl 6.3;(iv)The CWSA contemplates AOL having a successor or substitute which (in light of s 601FS and s 601FT) is apt to include a new responsible entity; and(v)Under the Constitutions for Projects 4, 5 and 6, the parties contemplated the possibility that a responsible entity could retire or be removed without replacement and that the consequence of that event was winding up (see cl 6.1 of the Constitution).