Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Hercules Iron Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Hercules Iron Pty Ltd
[2008] FCA 1182

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)

ACCC v INFO4PC.com Pty Ltd (2002) 121 FCR 24
Australian Competition and Consumer Affairs v Hughes (2001) ATPR 41-807
Australian Meat Industry Employees’ Union v Mudginberri Station Pty Ltd (1986) 161 CLR 98
Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd v McAlary-Smith (2008) 165 FCR 560
Colgate Palmolive Co v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 46 FCR 225
Heatons Transport (St Helens) Ltd v Transport and General Workers Union [1973] AC 15
Lade & Co Pty Ltd v Black (2006) 2 Qd R 531
Louis Vuitton Malletier SA v Design Elegance Pty Ltd (2006) 67 IPR 611
Pattison (Trustee), in the matter of Bell (Bankrupt) v Bell [2007] FCA 137
Stancomb v Trowbridge Urban District Council [1910] 2 Ch 190
Universal City Studios LLLP v Hoey (2007) 73 IPR 45

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v HERCULES IRON PTY LTD (ACN 095 382 291) and TOM HATZ

VID 1186 OF 2007

GORDON J
8 AUGUST 2008
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 1186 OF 2007

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

HERCULES IRON PTY LTD (ACN 095 382 291)
First Respondent

TOM HATZ
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

GORDON J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 AUGUST 2008

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.By reason of the first respondent, in breach of paragraph 14 of the Orders of Gordon J of 5 February 2008:

(a)on 22 February 2008, supplying Comet and Asteroid bunk beds not complying with Australian safety standard AS/NZA 4220:1994, cited in Consumer Protection Notice No. 1 of 2003 and published in the Commonwealth of Australia Gazette GN12 (26 March 2003) (“the Prescribed Standard”) to Sydney’s Furniture & Bedding of 256 Settlement Road, Thomastown, Victoria;

(b)on 12 and 22 February 2008, supplying Comet bunk beds not complying with the Prescribed Standard to Thriftway Furniture of 102 Old Geelong Road, Hoppers Crossing, Victoria,

the first respondent is guilty of contempt.

2.By reason of the second respondent, in breach of paragraph 15 of the Orders of Gordon J of 5 February 2008, being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in or party to the conduct described in 1 above, the second respondent is guilty of contempt.

AND THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

3.On or before 4 September 2008, the first respondent shall pay to the District Registrar of the Court a fine in the sum of $10,000 or by such further time and by such instalments as the District Registrar may allow.

4.On or before 4 September 2008, the second respondent shall pay to the District Registrar of the Court a fine in the sum of $10,000 or by such further time and by such instalments as the District Registrar may allow.

5.In the event that there is default in payment of either of the fines, the District Registrar shall apply to the Court for directions…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Hercules Ir... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 1182
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought proceedings against Hercules Iron Pty Ltd and associated individuals for breaches of court orders related to the supply of non-compliant bunk beds. The ACCC alleged that Hercules had supplied bunk beds that did not meet Australian safety standards, in violation of previous court orders. Hercules admitted to the conduct but claimed the beds were either recalled or would be recalled. The court had to determine whether the conduct constituted contempt and, if so, what penalty was appropriate.

The primary legal issues were whether the actions of Hercules constituted a deliberate breach of the court orders and, if so, what penalty should be imposed. The court considered the evidence presented, which included admissions from Hercules’ representatives, invoices, consignment notes, and laboratory test results confirming non-compliance. The court also considered the respondents' failure to dispute the ACCC's evidence. The key issue was whether the deliberate breach of the orders justified an award of indemnity costs.

The court found that the particular circumstances of the case warranted an award of indemnity costs. The court held that Hercules' deliberate breach of the orders, including supplying non-compliant bunk beds despite being aware of the orders and their consequences, constituted contempt. The court granted declarations of contempt against the respondents and ordered fines of $10,000 each, to be paid by specific dates. Additionally, the respondents were ordered to pay the ACCC's costs on an indemnity basis.

The final orders included fines of $10,000 each for the respondents, to be paid by 4 September 2008, with provisions for enforcement in the event of default. The respondents were also ordered to pay the ACCC’s costs on an indemnity basis for the proceedings. This decision underscored the importance of compliance with court orders and the consequences of deliberate non-compliance.

Orders

Orders of the court

3. On or before 4 September 2008, the first respondent shall pay to the District Registrar of the Court a fine in the sum of $10,000 or by such further time and by such instalments as the District Registrar may allow.

4. On or before 4 September 2008, the second respondent shall pay to the District Registrar of the Court a fine in the sum of $10,000 or by such further time and by such instalments as the District Registrar may allow.

5. In the event that there is default in payment of either of the fines, the District Registrar shall apply to the Court for directions concerning enforcement.

6. The respondents pay the applicant’s costs of, and incidental to, the notice of motion dated 6 May 2008 and amended notice of motion dated 27 June 2008, on an indemnity basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

As has been noted, as soon as orders are issued the person bound by that order becomes responsible for taking adequate and continuing steps (Lade & Co Pty Ltd (2006) 2 Qd R 531 at [106]) or all possible steps (Heatons Transport(St Helens) Ltd v Transport and General Workers Union [1973] AC 15 at 113) to comply with the order. If a person bound by an order fails to take such steps to comply with the order, it cannot be said that the conduct was casual, accidental or unintentional. FACTS Against that legal background, I turn now to the facts of the present case. In an affidavit filed on 12 June 2008, Mr Hatz admits that he engaged in the conduct alleged, but states that the non-compliant beds have either already been or will be recalled and collected by Hercules. An ACCC investigator, Mr Colin Pennell, also deposed in an affidavit filed on 6 May 2008 that Mr Hatz admitted to him in a telephone call on 12 March 2008 that Mr Hatz had been involved in Hercules’ supply of possibly non-compliant beds. Further evidence was adduced, by way of invoices, consignment notes, letters of instruction, additional affidavits from ACCC investigators, affidavits from process servers, affidavits from employees of Sydney’s Furniture and Thriftway Furniture, and affidavits and reports from an independent testing laboratory, Australasian Furnishing Research and Development Institute Limited (“Furntech”), to establish that: 1.the beds were supplied by Hercules after the Orders had been entered and served upon the respondents; 2.those beds did not in fact comply with the Prescribed Standard; and 3.the chain of custody was intact (i.e. the beds that were tested for compliance were the same beds that were supplied after entry and service of the Orders and their condition had not been changed from the time of delivery to the time of testing). I will not recite in further detail the ACCC’s evidence supporting the three factual propositions set out above because the respondents failed to dispute that evidence, either by way of cross-examination or positive evidence of their own. In fact, in an affidavit sworn on 30 July 2008 by Mr Hatz (“the July Hatz Affidavit”), he admitted that “a small number of non-complying Bunks that remained in my warehouse … were mixed together with the new complying bunks” and subsequently delivered to Sydney’s Furniture and Thriftway Furniture. Accordingly, it suffices to say that I am satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the facts are as alleged by the ACCC and summarised in [10]. That being the case, there are two remaining issues: first, whether the conduct described amounts to contempt (i.e. whether I am further satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that those facts constitute a deliberate breach of paragraphs 14 and 15 of the Orders by the respondents); and secondly, if it is contempt, what is the appropriate penalty. With respect to the first issue, it is not in dispute, and I am satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt, that the respondents were served with, were aware of and understood the Orders and, in particular, they were aware of the consequences of a deliberate breach of those Orders.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GORDON J
The ACCC sought an order that its costs be paid on an indemnity basis. In order for a court to exercise its discretion to award costs on that basis, there must be some special or unusual feature in the case justifying departure from the ordinary practice. Typical examples of circumstances justifying an award of costs on an indemnity basis include irrelevant or wholly unmeritorious allegations of fraud, frivolous or vexatious claims, wilful time-wasting, abuse of process, and contempt of court: see eg Colgate Palmolive Co v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 46 FCR 225. Here, as in Colgate, the “particular facts and circumstances of the case in question [which I have set out above] warrant the making of an order for payments of costs other than on a party and party basis”: Colgate at 233-234. CONCLUSION Accordingly, I propose to grant declarations that:1.By reason of the first respondent, in breach of paragraph 14 of the Orders of Gordon J of 5 February 2008:(a)on 22 February 2008, supplying Comet and Asteroid bunk beds not complying with Australian safety standard AS/NZA 4220:1994, cited in Consumer Protection Notice No. 1 of 2003 and published in the Commonwealth of Australia Gazette GN12 (26 March 2003) (“the Prescribed Standard”) to Sydney’s Furniture & Bedding of 256 Settlement Road, Thomastown, Victoria; (b)on 12 and 22 February 2008, supplying Comet bunk beds not complying with the Prescribed Standard to Thriftway Furniture of 102 Old Geelong Road, Hoppers Crossing, Victoria,the first respondent is guilty of contempt.2.By reason of the second respondent, in breach of paragraph 15 of the Orders of Gordon J of 5 February 2008, being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in or party to the conduct described in 1 above, the second respondent is guilty of contempt. Consequent upon the granting of those declarations, the appropriate orders are:1.On or before 4 September 2008, the first respondent shall pay to the District Registrar of the Court a fine in the sum of $10,000 or by such further time and by such instalments as the District Registrar may allow.2.On or before 4 September 2008, the second respondent shall pay to the Registrar of the Court a fine in the sum of $10,000 or by such further time and by such instalments as the District Registrar may allow.3.In the event that there is default in payment of either of the fines the District Registrar shall apply to the Court for directions concerning enforcement.4.The respondents pay the applicant’s costs of, and incidental to, the notice of motion dated 6 May 2008 and amended notice of motion dated 27 June 2008, on an indemnity basis.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GORDON J