Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Grays Ecommerce Group Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Grays Ecommerce Group Limited [2024] FCA 771

File number: NSD 198 of 2024
Judgment of: NICHOLAS J
Date of judgment: 18 July 2024
Catchwords:

CONSUMER LAW – civil penalties – false and misleading representations made by respondent in relation to motor vehicles sold on online auction platform – where parties agreed to proposed declarations and other orders including order imposing pecuniary penalty of $10 million – whether proposed pecuniary penalty within range necessary to achieve specific and general deterrence – whether agreed instalment plan for payment of pecuniary penalty appropriate – whether declarations and other orders should be made

Held: agreed declarations and orders made  

Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law ss 18, 29, 33, 224

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) s 87B

Cases cited:

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Pattinson (2022) 274 CLR 450

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v BlueScope Steel Ltd (No 6) [2023] FCA 1029

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Google LLC (No 4) [2022] FCA 942

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Hillside (Australia New Media) Pty Ltd trading as Bet365 (No 2) [2016] FCA 698

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Reckitt Benckiser (Australia) Pty Ltd (2016) 340 ALR 25

Commonwealth v Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate (2015) 258 CLR 482

NW Frozen Foods Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (1996) 71 FCR 285

Trade Practices Commission v CSR Ltd [1991] ATPR ¶41-076 Trade Practices Commission v CSR Ltd [1991] ATPR ¶41-076

Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2021) 284 FCR 24

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Regulator and Consumer Protection
Number of paragraphs: 45
Date of hearing: 8 July 2024
Counsel for the Applicant: Dr RCA Higgins SC with Ms M Caristo
Solicitor for the Applicant: DLA Piper Australia
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr J Williams SC with Ms C Ernst
Solicitor for the Respondent: Gilbert + Tobin

ORDERS

NSD 198 of 2024
BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION

Applicant

AND:

GRAYS ECOMMERCE GROUP LIMITED

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

NICHOLAS J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 JULY 2024

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

Identifying Characteristics Representations

1.During the period from 1 July 2020 to 30 June 2022, the Respondent, in trade or commerce, in connection with the promotion or supply or possible supply of motor vehicles to Australian consumers:

(a)engaged in conduct that was misleading or deceptive or was likely to mislead or deceive in contravention of s 18(1) of the Australian Consumer Law (“ACL”);

(b)made false or misleading representations that motor vehicles offered for sale on its online auction platform were of a particular standard, quality, value, grade, composition, style or model or had a particular history or previous use in contravention of s 29(1)(a) of the ACL;

(c)made false and misleading representations that motor vehicles offered for sale on its online auction platform had performance characteristics, accessories, uses or benefits in contravention of s 29(1)(g) of the ACL;…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Grays Ecomm... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 771
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Grays Ecommerce Group Limited, the Federal Court was tasked with assessing the appropriateness of a pecuniary penalty imposed on Grays for making false and misleading representations concerning motor vehicles sold through its online auction platform. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) had brought the case against Grays, alleging various breaches of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The primary legal issues before the court were whether the agreed penalty of $10 million was sufficient for both specific and general deterrence and if the proposed instalment plan for the penalty payment was appropriate.

The court deliberated on the gravity of Grays' misconduct, which involved knowingly continuing to list motor vehicles with inaccurate descriptions that misled customers. Despite internal suggestions and complaints, Grays failed to amend its processes, leading to ongoing violations. The court also considered Grays' cooperation with the ACCC and its efforts to remediate the situation, including compensating affected customers. In light of these factors, the court found that the $10 million penalty was within the necessary range to deter such conduct by Grays and other entities. Regarding the payment plan, the court reviewed an expert's financial assessment and determined that Grays could manage the proposed instalments, which were structured to allow for annual financial reviews and potential adjustments to the payment schedule.

Ultimately, the court endorsed the agreed declarations and orders, which included the $10 million penalty to be paid in specified instalments, an interest-free condition if the instalments are paid on time, and requirements for Grays to maintain compliance with the payment plan and submit annual financial reviews. The court also mandated a compliance program to be implemented by Grays to ensure adherence to the ACL. The final orders required Grays to pay the ACCC's costs associated with the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Pecuniary penalty

6. Pursuant to s 224(1) of the ACL, the Respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty in the amount of $10,000,000 in respect of the contraventions of ss 29(1)(a), 29(1)(g), 29(1)(m) and 33 of the ACL declared by the Court, in the following instalments:

(a) $0.5 million by June 2025;

(b) $1.5 million by each of June 2026, September 2026, and December 2026; and

(c) $2.5 million by each of March 2027, and June 2027.

7. An order pursuant to s 52(2)(b) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) that, where instalments are paid by the dates in 6 above, interest payable on the debts arising from the penalty be 0% per annum.

8. An order that for each financial year until the Respondent has completed the payment of the pecuniary penalty, Grays must:

(a) provide the ACCC with a copy of its audited annual financial statements; and

(b) in good faith, review its financial position and capacity to pay the penalty on an annual basis, taking into account, among other things, its ability to pay all of its debts as and when they become due and payable and the required working capital to operate the business;

(c) reflecting the considerations and outcomes of the review in (b) above, have a competent officer prepare an Affidavit deposing to whether the Respondent is in a financial position to:

(i) finalise payment of the balance of the penalty; or

(ii) increase the quantum of instalments; or

(iii) make an appropriately accelerated payment, and

(d) if the Affidavit concludes that the Respondent is able to:

(i) finalise payment of the balance of the penalty; or

(ii) increase the quantum of instalments; or

(iii) make an appropriately accelerated payment,

make that appropriate repayment.

9. An order that, in the event of non-compliance with any of the required penalty instalment payments, the balance of all outstanding penalty instalments be due and payable within 60 days if, following good faith negotiations between the parties, an alternative penalty instalment payment plan cannot be agreed.

Compliance program

10. Pursuant to s 246(2)(b) of the ACL, the Respondent, at its own expense, establish, administer and comply with, for a period of 3 years from the date of the order, a program which has the purpose of ensuring awareness of the responsibilities and obligations of the Respondent, its officers, employees and agents with Part 2-1 of Chapter 2 of the ACL and Division 1 of Part 3-1 of Chapter 3 of the ACL, in the form of Annexure A.

Other orders

11. The Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs of, and incidental to, this proceeding, fixed in the amount of $100,000, within thirty (30) days of the date of this order.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) took action against Grays Ecommerce Group Limited (Grays) for making false and misleading representations in relation to motor vehicles sold on its online auction platform. The misrepresentations involved inaccurate listings that affected customers' purchase decisions. Grays had knowledge of these issues but failed to implement necessary changes to its systems and procedures. Despite internal suggestions and complaints, the company continued the misleading conduct until at least June 2022. Grays has since entered into a remediation program and committed to compensating affected customers, with over $1.1 million refunded as of October 2023 and plans to refund an additional $2.7 million.

The case was brought by the ACCC before the Federal Court of Australia. The matter involved an agreement between the parties regarding the declarations and orders to be made. The primary focus was on the appropriateness of the proposed pecuniary penalty and the agreed payment plan. The court considered the seriousness of Grays' contraventions, the harm caused to customers, and Grays' cooperation and contrition, including its remediation efforts. The agreed penalty was $10 million, to be paid in instalments from June 2025 to June 2027. The court also considered an opinion on Grays' financial capacity to pay the penalty, provided by a partner of Ernst and Young.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Grays has voluntarily committed to a remediation program covering buyers who purchased a motor vehicle during the Relevant Period and has entered the Undertaking pursuant to s 87B of the CCA. As at October 2023, Grays had paid over $1.1 million in refunds to customers and will continue to pay around a further $2.7 million.Conclusion I have had regard to the various matters referred to in these reasons including, in particular, the seriousness of Grays’ contraventions and the harm likely to have been caused to customers who were misled by inaccurate listings about matters fundamental to their purchase decisions and willingness to pay the agreed price. I have had regard to the failure of Grays’ senior management during the Relevant Period to take steps to correct what Grays knew were serious deficiencies in its systems and procedures with respect to the compilation and verification of information included in the listings and the handling of customer complaints. I have also had regard to the cooperation that Grays has displayed, avoiding the need for further expenditure of time and resources by the ACCC in a contested hearing and steps taken by Grays to compensate its customers. In the circumstances, I am satisfied that the agreed penalty of $10 million is within the range necessary to achieve deterrence of contraventions of a like kind by both Grays and others. Time to pay The parties jointly propose that the pecuniary penalty of $10 million be paid in the instalments of $0.5 million by June 2025, $1.5 million by each of June 2026, September 2026 and December 2026, and $2.5 million by each of March 2027 and June 2027. The proposed orders provide for Grays to update the ACCC as to its financial position each year that the payment plan remains in place, including by providing copies of its audited financial statements, re-evaluating its financial capacity to pay, and preparing an affidavit deposing to whether it is in a financial position to pay the balance sooner than initially contemplated. They also include a safeguard against non-compliance with the payment plan which requires that, in the event Grays does not comply with the payment schedule, the parties are to seek to agree in good faith an alternative payment plan, failing which the balance of the payments are to be made within 60 days. David Mullins, a partner of Ernst and Young, was engaged by Grays’ solicitors in October 2023 to provide an opinion on whether Grays will have the financial capacity to pay particular pecuniary penalty amounts over timeframes. His opinion is based on an analysis of Grays’ financial forecasts and the assumptions set out in his report. Mr Mullins’ opinion is that Grays would not have the capacity to pay the pecuniary penalties within the timeframes he was instructed to consider. Mr Mullins considered that Grays would have the capacity to pay a penalty of $10 million payable from June 2025 to June 2027 in the following instalments: (1)$0.5 million in June 2025;(2)$1.5 million in each of June 2026, September 2026 and December 2026; and (3)$2.5 million in each of March 2027 and June 2027. Mr Mullins’ opinion is supported by a detailed analysis of projected cashflows.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Grays’ employees had raised suggestions to address misdescriptions in listings but, despite this, there were no changes to Grays’ policies or processes. Grays’ Board was also made aware (although to a more limited extent) of complaints that listings contained misdescriptions. Despite senior managers, staff and, to a lesser extent, the Board, having the knowledge summarised above, the contravening conduct continued until at least June 2022. Cooperation and contrition Grays has cooperated with the ACCC by (inter alia) agreeing to the facts and making relevant admissions, agreeing to approach the Court to make the proposed orders, fully cooperating with the ACCC’s investigation, and responding to at least three voluntary information requests from the ACCC from as early as August 2021. Grays has also acknowledged that it should have taken more appropriate action sooner and the seriousness of its past conduct. Grays has voluntarily committed to a remediation program covering buyers who purchased a motor vehicle during the Relevant Period and has entered the Undertaking pursuant to s 87B of the CCA. As at October 2023, Grays had paid over $1.1 million in refunds to customers and will continue to pay around a further $2.7 million.Conclusion I have had regard to the various matters referred to in these reasons including, in particular, the seriousness of Grays’ contraventions and the harm likely to have been caused to customers who were misled by inaccurate listings about matters fundamental to their purchase decisions and willingness to pay the agreed price. I have had regard to the failure of Grays’ senior management during the Relevant Period to take steps to correct what Grays knew were serious deficiencies in its systems and procedures with respect to the compilation and verification of information included in the listings and the handling of customer complaints. I have also had regard to the cooperation that Grays has displayed, avoiding the need for further expenditure of time and resources by the ACCC in a contested hearing and steps taken by Grays to compensate its customers. In the circumstances, I am satisfied that the agreed penalty of $10 million is within the range necessary to achieve deterrence of contraventions of a like kind by both Grays and others. Time to pay The parties jointly propose that the pecuniary penalty of $10 million be paid in the instalments of $0.5 million by June 2025, $1.5 million by each of June 2026, September 2026 and December 2026, and $2.5 million by each of March 2027 and June 2027. The proposed orders provide for Grays to update the ACCC as to its financial position each year that the payment plan remains in place, including by providing copies of its audited financial statements, re-evaluating its financial capacity to pay, and preparing an affidavit deposing to whether it is in a financial position to pay the balance sooner than initially contemplated. They also include a safeguard against non-compliance with the payment plan which requires that, in the event Grays does not comply with the payment schedule, the parties are to seek to agree in good faith an alternative payment plan, failing which the balance of the payments are to be made within 60 days.