FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v First Class Slate Roofing Pty Limited [2022] FCA 1093
File number: NSD 1118 of 2021 Judgment of: YATES J Date of judgment: 14 September 2022 Catchwords: COMPETITION LAW – cartel conduct – bid-rigging - admitted contraventions of s 45AJ and s 45AK of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) – application for pecuniary penalties and other relief – agreed orders Legislation: Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) ss 45AD(3)(c)(ii), 45AD(3)(c)(iv), 45AD(3)(c)(v), 45AD(4)(a), 45AD(4)(b), 45AD(4)(j), 45AJ, 45AK, 76(1), 80, 86C(2)(b), 86C(2)(c), 88
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 191
Cases cited: Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2017] FCAFC 113; 254 FCR 68
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v MLC Nominees Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 1306; 147 ACSR 266
Division: General Division Registry: New South Wales National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations Sub-area: Economic Regulator, Competition and Access Number of paragraphs: 18 Date of hearing: 14 September 2022 Counsel for the Applicant: Ms K Morgan SC Solicitor for the Applicant: Johnson Winter & Slattery Counsel for the First and Second Respondents: Mr R Yezerski Solicitor for the First and Second Respondents: Ashurst Australia Counsel for the Third and Fourth Respondents: Mr C Bannan Solicitor for the Third and Fourth Respondents: MistryFallahi Lawyers & Business Advisors ORDERS
NSD 1118 of 2021 BETWEEN: AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Applicant
AND: FIRST CLASS SLATE ROOFING PTY LIMITED ACN 162 450 437
First Respondent
SCOTT BARTON
Second Respondent
RAD ROOFING SPECIALISTS PTY LIMITED T/A MR SHINGLES ACN 050 877 462 (and another named in the Schedule)
Third Respondent
ORDER MADE BY:
YATES J
DATE OF ORDER:
14 SEPTEMBER 2022
THE COURT DECLARES THAT:
Wesley College Project
1.Between 23 August and 16 September 2019:
(a)the First Respondent made an arrangement or arrived at an understanding with MLR Slate Roofing Pty Limited (MLR Slate Roofing) and the Third Respondent that contained a cartel provision that had the purpose of ensuring that in the event of a request for bids in relation to the re-roofing of the Main Roof at Wesley College located within the grounds of the University of Sydney (Wesley College Project), each of the First Respondent, MLR Slate Roofing and the Third Respondent would bid but on the basis that the First Respondent’s bid was more likely to be successful than both MLR Slate roofing’s and the Third Respondent’s bids within the meaning of s 45AD(3)(c)(ii) or (iv) of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (CCA) and/or on the basis that a material component of each of MLR Slate Roofing’s and the Third Respondent’s bids was worked out in accordance with the arrangement or understanding within the meaning of s 45AD(3)(c)(v) of the CCA;
(b)the First Respondent, MLR Slate Roofing and the Third Respondent were or were likely to be, or but for the arrangement or understanding referred to in paragraph 1(a) above would have been or would be likely…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v First Class... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] FCA 1093
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the severity of the breaches, the culpability of the respondents, and the need to deter future conduct of a similar nature. The admitted bid-rigging conduct was found to be egregious, affecting multiple projects and involving significant financial payments. The court emphasised the importance of upholding the law to maintain fair competition and protect consumers. In determining the penalties, the court took into account the respondents' early admissions, cooperation with the ACCC, and the financial constraints of the businesses involved. The court found that the penalties should reflect the seriousness of the conduct while also considering the respondents' ability to pay.
The court ordered pecuniary penalties for each respondent, to be paid in instalments over a period of up to six years. Additionally, the court imposed injunctive relief to prevent future bid-rigging conduct and compliance orders requiring two of the respondents to undertake compliance training. The court also mandated disclosure orders requiring the respondents to publish notices within their industry to educate others about the consequences of cartel conduct. These orders aim to promote compliance and deter similar anti-competitive behaviour in the future.
Orders
Orders of the court
Pecuniary Penalties
11. Pursuant to section 76(1) of the CCA, the First Respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty in the amount of $280,000, in instalments as follows:
(a) $23,333.33 within 6 calendar months of the date of this order;
(b) $23,333.33 within 12 calendar months of the date of this order;
(c) $23,333.33 within 18 calendar months of the date of this order;
(d) $23,333.33 within 24 calendar months of the date of this order;
(e) $23,333.33 within 30 calendar months of the date of this order;
(f) $23,333.33 within 36 calendar months of the date of this order;
(g) $23,333.33 within 42 calendar months of the date of this order;
(h) $23,333.33 within 48 calendar months of the date of this order;
(i) $23,333.33 within 54 calendar months of the date of this order;
(j) $23,333.33 within 60 calendar months of the date of this order;
(k) $23,333.33 within 66 calendar months of the date of this order; and
(l) $23,333.37 within 72 calendar months of the date of this order,
provided that if the First Respondent fails to pay any of the instalment amounts by the due date, and fails to remedy that default by paying the instalment amount within 30 days of the due date, then the full amount of the remaining penalty then outstanding shall become immediately due and payable.
12. Pursuant to section 76(1) of the CCA, the Second Respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty in the amount of $60,000, in instalments as follows:
(a) $5,000 within 6 calendar months of the date of this order;
(b) $5,000 within 12 calendar months of the date of this order;
(c) $5,000 within 18 calendar months of the date of this order;
(d) $5,000 within 24 calendar months of the date of this order;
(e) $5,000 within 30 calendar months of the date of this order;
(f) $5,000 within 36 calendar months of the date of this order;
(g) $5,000 within 42 calendar months of the date of this order;
(h) $5,000 within 48 calendar months of the date of this order;
(i) $5,000 within 54 calendar months of the date of this order;
(j) $5,000 within 60 calendar months of the date of this order;
(k) $5,000 within 66 calendar months of the date of this order; and
(l) $5,000 within 72 calendar months of the date of this order,
provided that if the Second Respondent fails to pay any of the instalment amounts by the due date, and fails to remedy that default by paying the instalment amount within 30 days of the due date, then the full amount of the remaining penalty then outstanding shall become immediately due and payable.
13. Pursuant to section 76(1) of the CCA, the Third Respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty in the amount of $65,000, in instalments as follows:
(a) $3,611.11 within 1 calendar month of the date of this order;
(b) $3,611.11 within 2 calendar months of the date of this order;
(c) $3,611.11 within 3 calendar months of the date of this order;
(d) $3,611.11 within 4 calendar months of the date of this order;
(e) $3,611.11 within 5 calendar months of the date of this order;
(f) $3,611.11 within 6 calendar months of the date of this order;
(g) $3,611.11 within 7 calendar months of the date of this order;
(h) $3,611.11 within 8 calendar months of the date of this order;
(i) $3,611.11 within 9 calendar months of the date of this order;
(j) $3,611.11 within 10 calendar months of the date of this order;
(k) $3,611.11 within 11 calendar months of the date of this order;
(l) $3,611.11 within 12 calendar months of the date of this order;
(m) $3,611.11 within 13 calendar months of the date of this order;
(n) $3,611.11 within 14 calendar months of the date of this order;
(o) $3,611.11 within 15 calendar months of the date of this order;
(p) $3,611.11 within 16 calendar months of the date of this order;
(q) $3,611.11 within 17 calendar months of the date of this order; and
(r) $3,611.13 within 18 calendar months of the date of this order,
provided that if the Third Respondent fails to pay any of the instalment amounts by the due date, and fails to remedy that default by paying the instalment amount within 30 days of the due date, then the full amount of the remaining penalty then outstanding shall become immediately due and payable.
14. Pursuant to section 76(1) of the CCA, the Fourth Respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty in the amount of $15,000, in instalments as follows:
(a) $833.33 within 1 calendar month of the date of this order;
(b) $833.33 within 2 calendar months of the date of this order;
(c) $833.33 within 3 calendar months of the date of this order;
(d) $833.33 within 4 calendar months of the date of this order;
(e) $833.33 within 5 calendar months of the date of this order;
(f) $833.33 within 6 calendar months of the date of this order;
(g) $833.33 within 7 calendar months of the date of this order;
(h) $833.33 within 8 calendar months of the date of this order;
(i) $833.33 within 9 calendar months of the date of this order;
(j) $833.33 within 10 calendar months of the date of this order;
(k) $833.33 within 11 calendar months of the date of this order;
(l) $833.33 within 12 calendar months of the date of this order;
(m) $833.33 within 13 calendar months of the date of this order;
(n) $833.33 within 14 calendar months of the date of this order;
(o) $833.33 within 15 calendar months of the date of this order;
(p) $833.33 within 16 calendar months of the date of this order;
(q) $833.33 within 17 calendar months of the date of this order; and
(r) $833.39 within 18 calendar months of the date of this order,
provided that if the Fourth Respondent fails to pay any of the instalment amounts by the due date, and fails to remedy that default by paying the instalment amount within 30 days of the due date, then the full amount of the remaining penalty then outstanding shall become immediately due and payable.
Injunctions
15. Pursuant to section 80 of the CCA, each of the Respondents be restrained for a period of 3 years from the date of this order from making, arriving at, or giving effect to, or being in any way, directly or indirectly, knowingly concerned in, or party to, any contract, arrangement or understanding involving suppliers of roofing for the supply, installation, maintenance or repair of roofing, containing a provision which has the purpose of ensuring that in the event of a request for bids in relation to the supply, installation, maintenance or repair of roofing that one bid is more likely to be successful than the others or that a material component of at least one of those bids is worked out in accordance with the contract, arrangement or understanding, unless such conduct is authorised under section 88 of the CCA.
Compliance Orders
16. Pursuant to section 86C(2)(b) of the CCA, the Second Respondent, at his own expense:
(a) within 90 days of the date of this order is to attend and undertake compliance training with particular emphasis on Part IV of the CCA; and
(b) is to ensure the training referred to in Order 16(a) is administered by a qualified compliance professional or legal practitioner with expertise in the Part IV of the CCA.
17. Pursuant to section 86C(2)(b) of the CCA, the Fourth Respondent, at his own expense:
(a) within 90 days of the date of this order is to attend and undertake compliance training with particular emphasis on Part IV of the CCA; and
(b) is to ensure the training referred to in Order 17(a) is administered by a qualified compliance professional or legal practitioner with expertise in the Part IV of the CCA.
Disclosure Orders
18. Pursuant to section 86C(2)(c) of the CCA, within 21 days of the date of this order the Second Respondent and the Fourth Respondent, at their own expense, are to publish, or cause to be published, by email (or, if email is not reasonably practicable, by post) to the current members of the Roofing Industry Association of NSW Incorporated an educative notice in the form and with the content of Annexure A to these orders.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Annexure A
Don’t do what we did – rigging bids for roofing projects is illegal!
This message is published by Scott Barton of First Class Slate Roofing Pty Limited and Damian Hand of RAD Roofing Specialists Pty Limited (trading as Mr Shingles) by order of the Federal Court of Australia, in proceedings brought by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC).
Our businesses both install and maintain slate roofing in Sydney.
We have both recently admitted to bid-rigging in relation to two slate roofing projects, and have been ordered by the Federal Court to pay penalties totalling $420,000, including individual penalties imposed on each of us personally. We also have to pay our own significant legal costs.
Our businesses have suffered reputational damage as a result of publicity about the case, and our illegal conduct will be permanently on the record.
This message is being circulated to all members of the Master Roof Tilers & Slaters Association of NSW, so that you can learn from our mistakes, and the very serious consequences which followed.
What we did
In 2019, we were each asked to tender for the re-roofing of the main roof at Wesley College. MLR Slate Roofing was also asked to tender.
Through text messages and phone calls, First Class (via Scott) agreed with MLR and separately with Mr Shingles (via Damian) that MLR and Mr Shingles would submit tender prices provided to them by First Class. These would be higher than First Class’s tender prices.
In exchange, First Class would pay them each $10,000.
This was then put into effect by the bids submitted by MLR and Mr Shingles, and First Class was awarded the Wesley College project.
Around the same time, Mr Shingles and First Class were approached to tender for the supply and installation of slate at a house in Bellevue Hill. Damian and Scott agreed by text message that for this project Mr Shingles would provide prices to First Class on the understanding that First Class would submit a quote with prices that were substantially higher than those submitted by Mr Shingles.
In exchange, Mr Shingles would pay First Class $2,000 by way of an offset against the earlier agreed $10,000. This was then put into effect and Mr Shingles was awarded the job.
MLR and Mr Shingles submitted invoices to First Class for the agreed payments, and these payments were made.
What we did is called bid-rigging. It is a form of illegal cartel conduct. There are very serious consequences for this sort of conduct, as we discovered.
What happened next
The ACCC found out what had taken place and began an investigation.
The ACCC issued notices requiring us to produce information and documents, including texts and emails. They also required us each to attend an examination to give evidence on oath about our conduct.
The ACCC then issued civil proceedings in the Federal Court against both our companies and us personally.
Federal Court case
We each agreed at the earliest stage of the proceedings to admit that we had breached the law and to pay substantial penalties to be imposed by the Court.
Although these penalties took into account the size of our businesses and our financial circumstances, they will take us up to 6 years to pay. We also incurred significant legal costs for our lawyers acting in the ACCC investigation and Federal Court proceedings, which occurred over a total period of 19 months.
And it turns out that we were fortunate. This sort of conduct can be prosecuted criminally, including potential imprisonment. The ACCC can refer serious cartel conduct for prosecution by the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions. We could have ended up with a criminal record.
Lessons to learn from our mistakes
We made very serious mistakes by engaging in illegal bid-rigging, and this has had serious consequences for us, our families and our businesses.
Do not do what we did. Learn from our mistakes and make sure you don’t engage in cartel conduct.
Cartel Conduct Generally
It’s pretty simple - here is what you need to know about cartel conduct:
· Avoid speaking to your competitors about customers and pricing, including bids for projects.
· Never agree or even try to agree with a competing business on the prices you or they will charge or what discounts will be offered including in tenders or quotes for jobs.
· Never limit the goods or services you or they supply or allocate customers or geographic areas.
· If you are approached by another competing business to discuss arrangements about pricing, customers or bidding, don’t get involved and report it to the ACCC.
Some more detail about the law on cartel conduct
Cartel conduct is illegal and is strictly prohibited. The laws about cartel conduct are in the Competition and Consumer Act 2010, which applies to all corporations in Australia, as well as individuals involved in the conduct.
Cartel conduct is when 2 or more competitors agree to:
· fix prices, when competitors agree on pricing instead of competing against each other
· market share, when competitors agree to divide a market between themselves so they don’t have to compete
· control output, when competitors agree to limit the amount or type of goods and services available
· rig bids, when suppliers discuss and agree among themselves who should win a tender, and at what price.
Individuals found to have been involved in cartel conduct in cases brought by the ACCC can face a penalty of up to $500,000 for each breach of the law.
Cartel conduct can also be a criminal offence, and individuals prosecuted by the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions can face imprisonment for up to 10 years and/or fines of up to $440,000 per offence.
For corporations, the maximum penalty or fine for each contravention or offence is the greater of $10 million, 3 times the benefit obtained, or (if the value of the benefit cannot be determined) 10% of the annual turnover of the company for the year.
Further information
For questions about this notice, to make an enquiry, or report an issue, please contact the ACCC on 1300 302 021 or visit our website at https://www.accc.gov.au/contact-us/contact-the-accc/make-an-enquiry.
Anyone with information about cartel conduct is urged to call the ACCC Cartel Hotline on (02) 9230 3894. You can provide a tip-off or report cartel conduct anonymously at https://accc-cartels.whispli.com/cartels.
You can also seek immunity from prosecution and ACCC proceedings in exchange for helping the ACCC with its investigations. Remember that if you don’t report suspicious activity, others may choose to report your involvement to the ACCC.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi