Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cosic Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cosic Holdings Pty Ltd (ACN 121 788 985) [2009] FCA 1579

TRADE PRACTICES - breach of section 65AAC of Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) - illegal pyramid selling scheme –– whether proposed consent orders should be made – public interest consideration - appropriate for Court to make declarations and injunction sought

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 21
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s 6A, s 65AAC, s 65AAC(1), s 64AAD(1), s 65AAD(1)(a), s 65AAD(1)(b), s 65AAE s 80, s 80(4), s 80(5)

Australian Communications Network v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2005) 146 FCR 413
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Allergy Pathway Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 960
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Communications Network Pty Ltd (2005) 143 FCR 23
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Dimmeys Stores Pty Ltd (2001) ATPR 41 – 811
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v 4WD Systems Pty Ltd (2003) 200 ALR 491
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Goldy Motors Pty Ltd [2000] FCA 1885
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v On Clinic Australia Pty Ltd (1996) ATPR 41 – 517
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Real Estate Institute of Western Australia Inc (1999) 161 ALR 79
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Target Ltd [2001] FCA 1326
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Wordplay Services Pty Ltd (2004) 210 ALR 562
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Z-Tek Computer Pty Ltd (1987) 148 ALR 339
BMI v Federated Clerks Union of Australia (1983) 51 ALR 401
Forster v Jododex Australia Pty Ltd (1972) 127 CLR 421
ICI Australia Operations Pty Ltd v Trade Practices Commission (1992) 38 FCR 248

Trade Practices Commission v Mobile Oil Australia (1984) 4 FCR 296

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION & CONSUMER COMMISSION v COSIC HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 121 788 985) and JOHN COSIC

WAD 70 of 2009

BARKER J
8 DECEMBER 2009
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

general division

WAD 70 of 2009

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION & CONSUMER COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

COSIC HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 121 788 985)
First Respondent

JOHN COSIC
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

BARKER J

DATE:

8 DECEMBER 2009

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

CONSENT ORDERS

  1. On 8 December 2009 at the hearing of the application in this proceeding, I made the following orders by consent of the parties:

    1.Between 18 September 2006 and November 2007, the first respondent participated in a pyramid selling Scheme within the meaning of section 65AAD of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (Act), in contravention of section 65AAC(1) of the Act, by:

    (a)participating in the Emerald Passport Scheme (Scheme) described in Schedule A to these Orders:

    (b)establishing, controlling, operating and contributing to or being otherwise involved with the following Internet websites that referred to, linked to or otherwise related to the Scheme:

    (i)      and

    (iv)    (Paramount Partners website);

    (c)printing promotional material, including pamphlets about the Scheme;

    (d)arranging live and recorded telephone conference calls for prospective participants…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cosic Holdi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 1579
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought proceedings against Cosic Holdings Pty Ltd and its director, Mr Cosic, alleging breaches of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) related to pyramid selling schemes. The respondents consented to the making of orders by the Federal Court, and the court considered the statement of agreed facts submitted by the parties. The primary legal issue for the court was whether the consent orders proposed by the parties were appropriate and should be made, considering the public interest in enforcing the Trade Practices Act provisions governing pyramid selling schemes.

The court accepted the statement of agreed facts and found that the proposed consent orders properly reflected the public interest in enforcing the relevant provisions of the Trade Practices Act. The court also considered that the orders would bring an efficient and cost-effective conclusion to the civil enforcement proceedings commenced by the ACCC. The Emerald Passport Scheme, which was the subject of the proceedings, involved the sale of self-help products and income-earning opportunities for participants who qualified as directors. The court found that the consent orders would effectively address the respondents' breaches of the Trade Practices Act and protect consumers from similar conduct in the future.

The court was satisfied that the proposed consent orders were appropriate and should be made, considering the agreed facts and the public interest in enforcing the Trade Practices Act provisions governing pyramid selling schemes. The orders would bring an efficient and cost-effective conclusion to the civil enforcement proceedings and protect consumers from similar conduct in the future. The court made the orders by consent of the parties, effectively addressing the respondents' breaches of the Trade Practices Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

What follows are the reasons for the making of these orders by consent.Agreed facts The parties together submit that the Court should make the orders sought as set out in a minute of proposed consent orders, having regard to the conduct of the first respondent and the second respondent. In that regard, the parties through their solicitors signed a statement of agreed facts dated 4 December 2009. The Court received this statement of agreed facts at the hearing of the application. As explained further below it appears to the Court that it is appropriate to regard the statement of agreed facts in determining whether or not to make orders in the proceeding by consent of the parties. The statement of agreed facts provides as follows. The applicant (Australian Competition & Consumer Commission (ACCC)) is, and was at all material times, a body corporate established by s 6A of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (Act). The first respondent, Cosic Holdings Pty Ltd (Cosic Holdings) is and was at all material times:(a)a company duly incorporated and carrying on business in Australia; and(b)a corporation within the meaning of the Act. The second respondent (Mr Cosic) is and was at all material times a director of Cosic Holdings. Emerald Passport Inc is and was at all material times:(a)a company duly incorporated in the Republic of Panama; and(b)the publisher of the Internet websites and (Emerald Passport website). Attached to the statement of agreed facts at Sch B and C (but not reproduced in this judgment) are a Compensation Plan Diagram and Terms and Conditions from the Emerald Passport website. The parties agree that the Compensation Plan Diagram accurately represents the structure of the Scheme that is, and was at all material times, operated by Emerald Passport and described further below (Emerald Passport Scheme). Attached to the statement of agreed facts at Sch D1 to F (but not reproduced in this judgment) are screen shots from websites established by the Respondents. Those screen shots are referred to and derived from the process described in the Affidavit of Duane Andrew Collinson (sworn 18 August 2009) and are printed from the DVD that is annexure SLK01 to the affidavit of Stephen Leigh Kinnersly (sworn 18 August 2009). The parties agree that the screen shots accurately represent the content of the relevant websites. The Emerald Passport website contains information on the Emerald Passport Scheme, which has the following elements:(a)The Emerald Passport website promotes self-help products which are only sold through the internet as part of the Emerald Passport Scheme. The products are described on the Emerald Passport website as:(i)The ‘Passport to Prosperity’ product suite which is sold to consumers for US$1,295 (Phase 1 Product). The Phase 1 Product consists of eight Internet based, multi-module audio visual presentations entitled ‘Real Estate’, ‘Negotiating’, ‘Forex’, ‘Anatomy of Success’, ‘Mastering Money’, ‘Success Fundamentals’, ‘Entrepreneur’ and ‘Wealth Fundamentals’.(ii)The ‘Wealth & Self’ conference which is sold to consumers for US$5,995 (Phase 2 Product). The Phase 2 Product consists of:(A) an invitation to attend a four day conference in Panama; and(B) presentations from guest speakers and lecturers on subjects including money, investing, banking, corporate and income tax, the psychology of money, trusts, real estate, currencies, trading, global investment strategies and international financial affairs.(iii)The ‘Millionaires Club’ conference which is sold to consumers for US$14,995 (Phase 3 Product). The Phase 3 Product consists of:(A) an invitation to attend a four day seminar held at premier resorts; and(B) presentations from speakers in the fields of finance, leadership and personal development.(collectively, the Products). (b)To purchase a Product, a person must pay the respective Product price to a participant in the Emerald Passport Scheme who has qualified as a Director for a particular product phase. The manner in which a Director becomes qualified in a particular product phase is explained below in [12(i)], [12(k)] and [12(m)].(c)The Emerald Passport website promotes income earning opportunities for participants who have qualified as Directors. (d)To participate in the Emerald Passport Scheme, a participant must:(i)register online at the Emerald Passport website as an “Independent Distributor” (Distributor); (ii)agree to the terms and conditions on the Emerald Passport website; and(iii)pay an annual US$99 (Annual Fee) to Emerald Passport Inc (see Sch C (cl 17), and Sch D5).(e)A Distributor is provided with:(i)maintenance of a personal website; (ii)website hosting; (iii)access to live distributor support staff; (iv)back office training; (v)a business platform which allows Distributors to operate their distributorship and promote the Products to others; and(vi)the opportunity to earn commissions.(f)Once a participant has registered as a Distributor, they can only earn commissions by becoming a “Director” (see Sch C (cl 14)). (g)There are three levels of directorship which are available to participants and aligned with each phase of the Products. Distributors must first become a Phase 1 Director, after which they may then qualify to become a Phase 2 Director, and then a Phase 3 Director. (h)Participants who have qualified as Directors are entitled to retain commissions on each of the Products as follows: (see Sch B)(i)Phase 1 Directors retain US$1,000 for selling each Phase 1 Product with the remaining US$295 paid to Emerald Passport Inc;(ii)Phase 2 Directors retain US$4,500 for selling each Phase 2 Product with the remaining US$1,495 paid to Emerald Passport Inc; and (iii)Phase 3 Directors retain US$10,000 for selling each Phase 3 Product with the remaining US$4,995 paid to Emerald Passport Inc. (i)For a Distributor to qualify as a Phase 1 Director, a Distributor must:(i)be mentored by another participant who has already achieved the status of Phase 1 Director; and (ii)purchase a Phase 1 Product, unless the Product was purchased when joining as a Distributor, and refer two other participants that then register as Distributors and purchase the Phase 1 Product from the mentoring Director; or(iii)refer four other participants that register as Distributors and purchase the Phase 1 Product from the mentoring Director. (j)In relation to commissions in Phase 1:(i)the commissions for the purchases referred to in [12(i)] above are not retained by the Distributor;(ii)the commissions for the purchases referred to in [12(i)] above are retained by a Phase 1 Director;(iii)once a Distributor has qualified as a Phase 1 Director, they are entitled to retain the US$1,000 commission for each further sale of the Phase 1 Product which they make as a Phase 1 Director; (iv)a newly qualified Phase 1 Director may mentor further new Distributors who wish to qualify as Phase 1 Directors and in doing so retain the commissions on the sales referred to the newly qualified Phase 1 Director by those further new Distributors as set out in [12(i)] above.(k)To qualify as a Phase 2 Director:(i)a Phase 1 Director must be mentored by another participant who has already achieved the status of Phase 2 Director; and(ii)purchase a Phase 2 Product and refer two other participants that then purchase the Phase 2 Product from that mentoring Director; or(iii)refer four other participants that purchase the Phase 2 Product from that mentoring Director. (l)In relation to the commissions in Phase 2:(i)the commissions for the purchases referred to in [12(k)] above are not retained by the Phase 1 Director;(ii)the commissions for the purchases referred to in [12(k)] above are retained by a Phase 2 Director;(iii)once a Phase 1 Director has qualified as a Phase 2 Director, they are entitled to retain the US$4,500 commission for each further sale of the Phase 2 Product which they make as a Phase 2 Director; (iv)a newly-qualified Phase 2 Director may mentor other Phase 1 Directors who wish to qualify as Phase 2 Directors and in doing so retain the commissions on the sales referred to the newly qualified Phase 2 Director by those other Phase 1 Directors as set out in [12(k)] above.(m)To qualify as a Phase 3 Director:(i)a Phase 2 Director must be mentored by another participant who has already achieved the status of Phase 3 Director; and(ii)purchase a Phase 3 Product and refer two other participants that then purchase the Phase 3 Product from that mentoring Director; or(iii)refer four other participants that purchase the Phase 3 Product from that mentoring Director. (n)In relation to the commissions in Phase 3:(i)the commissions for the purchases referred to in [12(m)] above are not retained by the Phase 2 Director;(ii)the commissions for the purchases referred to in [12(m)] above are retained by a Phase 3 Director;(iii)once a Phase 2 Director has qualified as a Phase 3 Director, they are entitled to retain the US$10,000 commission for each further sale of the Phase 3 Product which they make as a Phase 3 Director; (iv)a newly qualified Phase 3 Director may mentor other Phase 2 Directors who wish to qualify as Phase 3 Directors and in doing so retain the commissions on the sales referred to the newly qualified Phase 3 Director by those other Phase 2 Directors as set out in [12(m)] above.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

BARKER J
I was further informed by counsel for the ACCC that this is not a case the ACCC considered should require any orders for compensation to be paid by the respondents to any other person. In cases such as this, the ACCC has discovered by experience that it is difficult to obtain any information concerning any loss suffered by persons who may have dealt with promoters such as the respondents of pyramid selling Schemes. I accept that regulatory experience and proceed on that basis in this case.conclusion and orders For these reasons, I am satisfied that the consent orders proposed by the parties are appropriate and should be made. They properly reflect the public interest in the enforcement of the Trade Practices Act provisions governing pyramid selling Schemes. They also bring to an end, in an efficient and cost effective manner, these civil enforcement proceedings commenced by the ACCC.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BARKER J