Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Apple Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Apple Pty Ltd (No 3) [2018] FCA 617

File number: VID 339 of 2017
Judge: LEE  J
Date of judgment: 8 May 2018
Catchwords: EVIDENCE – Advance ruling under s 192A of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) as to the admissibility of admissions – finding that the admissions were obtained by improper conduct – application of s 138 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) – officer of regulator engaging in a fiction of posing as a consumer needing repair to a mobile telephone and making false statements with knowledge that they were likely to cause the person who was being questioned to make an admission – whether evidence obtained improperly should be the subject of discretionary exclusion – evidence not excluded in the exercise of discretion
Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law, Pts 3-2, ss 54, 55

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), ss 155(1)(a), 155(1)(b)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), Pts 3.4, 3.6, 3.11, ss 5(a), 26, 29, 38, 55, 56, 85, 85, 97, 135, 136, 138, 138(1), 138(2)(b), 139, 139(2), 192A

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), Pt VB

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), s 64

Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), ss 138(2), 139, 139(2)

Surveillance Devices Act 1999 (Vic), s 5(a)

Evidence Act 2001 (Tas), s 139(2)

Cases cited:

Application by Peter James Holland pursuant to s 78 Crimes (Appeal and Review) Act 2001 (NSW) [2017] NSWSC 462

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Hellicar [2012] HCA 17; (2012) 247 CLR 345

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Sigalla (No 2) [2010] NSWSC 792; (2010) 240 FLR 327

Bedford v Bedford (unreported, Supreme Court of New South Wales, Windeyer J, 20 October 1998)

Commercial Union Assurance Company of Australia Ltd v Ferrcom Pty Ltd (1991) 22 NSWLR 389

Commonwealth of Australia v Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate [2015] HCA 46; (2015) 258 CLR 482

Director of Consumer Affairs Victoria v The Good Guys Discount Warehouses (Australia) Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 22; (2016) 245 FCR 529

Fleming v The Queen [2009] NSWCCA 233; (2009) 197 A Crim R 282

Gedeon v The Queen [2013] NSWCCA 257; (2013) 237 A Crim R 326

Gilmour v Environment Protection Authority [2002] NSWCCA 399; (2002) 55 NSWLR 593

Jager v Lynch [2003] TASSC 114; (2003) 12 Tas R 195

Kelly v The Queen [2004] HCA 12; (2004) 218 CLR 216

Melbourne Steamship Company Limited v Moorehead (1912) 15 CLR 333

Parker v Comptroller-General of Customs [2007] NSWCA 348; (2007) 243 ALR 574

Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority [1998] HCA 28; (1998) 194 CLR 355

R v Camilleri [2007] NSWCCA 36; (2007) 68 NSWLR 720

R v Coulstock (1998) 99 A Crim R 143

R v Gallagher [2015] NSWCCA 228

R v Naa [2009] NSWSC 851; (2009) 76 NSWLR 271

R v Reitberger [2014] NSWDC 154

Ridgeway v The Queen (1995) 184 CLR 19

Robinson v Woolworths Ltd [2005]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Apple Pty L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 617
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought an action against Apple Pty Ltd in relation to alleged misleading or deceptive conduct by Apple under the Australian Consumer Law. The case, Apple Pty Ltd (No 3), reached the Federal Court where the primary legal issue was the admissibility of evidence obtained by the ACCC through undercover investigations. Specifically, the ACCC had used a technique known as "Jo Consumer enquiries," where officers posed as consumers to gather information about Apple's repair practices. Apple contested the admissibility of the evidence, arguing it was obtained improperly and should be excluded under the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth).

The court examined whether the ACCC's undercover investigator, Laughlin Nicholls, had engaged in improper conduct by knowingly making false statements during his interactions with Apple employees. Apple argued that such conduct rendered the evidence inadmissible under section 138 of the Evidence Act. Additionally, Apple contended that the probative value of the evidence was substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice, warranting exclusion under section 135(a) of the Evidence Act. The ACCC, on the other hand, maintained that the evidence was relevant and obtained through legitimate investigative techniques. The court considered the evidence presented during a voir dire, including affidavits, recordings, and witness testimonies, to determine the admissibility of the contested evidence.

The Federal Court found that although the ACCC investigator had made false statements, this did not render the evidence inadmissible under section 138 of the Evidence Act. The court held that the investigator's conduct, while improper, did not prejudice Apple to such an extent that the evidence should be excluded. Furthermore, the court determined that the probative value of the evidence was not substantially outweighed by the risk of unfair prejudice, as the ACCC intended to use the evidence solely to prove a specific case and not for broader implications. Consequently, the court ruled that the contested evidence could be admitted, subject to the conditions of the Evidence Act. The court also noted that it would hear submissions on the costs of the voir dire proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 192A of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), the affidavit of Laughlin Nicholls affirmed on 11 August 2017 is able to be adduced as evidence at the hearing.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As noted above, Apple objects to the evidence contained in the First Nicholls Affidavit. This is on three bases (the first two of which constituted the primary thrust of Apple’s submissions):(a)first, the admissions obtained and referred to in the First Nicholls Affidavit were obtained improperly because, to the extent the affidavit records representations that are admissions, they were made during questioning in circumstances where Mr Nicholls knowingly made false statements and knew (or ought reasonably to have known) that making those false statements was likely to cause the person being questioned to make an admission: see s 138(2)(b) of the EA;(b)secondly, that “more broadly” the evidence was obtained improperly or in consequence of an impropriety: see s 138(1) of the EA; and(c)thirdly, the evidence ought be the subject of discretionary exclusion because the probative value of the evidence is substantially outweighed by the danger that it might be unfairly prejudicial to Apple: see s 135(a) of the EA.D THE VOIR DIRE – RELEVANT EVIDENCE & FINDINGS In order to make the advance ruling, evidence was adduced on the voir dire and, apart from the First Nicholls Affidavit, the ACCC relied upon a further affidavit of Mr Nicholls affirmed 15 December 2017 (Second Nicholls Affidavit), two ‘chain of custody’ affidavits by solicitors, and an affidavit of Mr Scott Peter Gregson affirmed on 16 February 2018 (Gregson Affidavit). The balance of the ACCC’s evidence was a CD-ROM, correspondence and, importantly: (a) audio recordings of further calls made in June 2016 to an additional nine Apple Stores (which, together with the Relevant Calls, I will describe compendiously as the June Calls); and (b) a bundle of file notes made by Mr Nicholls of telephone calls made to Apple Stores in April 2016 (April Calls). Mr Nicholls and Mr Gregson were cross-examined. For Apple, the only tender was a letter from its solicitor, Clayton Utz, to the ACCC dated 29 July 2013. It is unnecessary to make reference to some of this material, but from the evidence adduced on the voir dire, I make the following relevant findings: (a)in undertaking its enforcement role under the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (CCA), the ACCC uses a number of investigative tools including, on occasion, what it describes internally as “Jo Consumer enquiries” (Jo Consumer enquiries); Jo Consumer enquiries involve ACCC investigators making enquiries of traders, and occasionally purchasing goods or services from traders, without disclosing that they are ACCC officers; (b)types of Jo Consumer enquiries may differ, including in-store, online or phone enquiries, or attending seminars or forums; the information gleaned from Jo Consumer enquiries is used for three main purposes: (i) compliance assessments, as part of reviewing particular representations or conduct across an industry; (ii) investigations, to gather evidence about alleged contraventions; and (iii) enforcement action, including obtaining evidence as to alleged contraventions; (c)guidance is provided by the ACCC to investigators as to how investigations may be undertaken and there has been “some material available on Jo Consumer investigations at different points in time” (T 12) and, according to Mr Nicholls, there were (at least at some time) guidelines as to how to conduct such operations, setting out the circumstances in which covert calls are to be made (T 28); (d)as a general proposition, ACCC investigators endeavour to make Jo Consumer enquiries closely resemble the interaction of consumers with businesses; dissembling the fact that the officer making the enquiry is an ACCC investigator enables the relevant officer “to gather highly relevant information about how a business interacts with consumers” (see Gregson Affidavit at [12]);(e)again, as general propositions: (i) there are advantages to conducting Jo Consumer enquiries, including where the investigation involves oral representations and there is a need to obtain evidence of what statements are being made, and consumers may be unwilling or unable to assist in providing evidence; and (ii) “Jo Consumer enquiries are an important investigative tool for the ACCC to carry out its enforcement activities” (see Gregson Affidavit at [14]); (f)Mr Gregson, as the head of the Enforcement Division of the ACCC, “would certainly want [a Jo Consumer enquiry] to be done within the framework that [the ACCC] set[s] our investigators” and the use of Jo Consumer enquiries would be inappropriate if it went beyond what was necessary for the purposes of investigation as a matter of principle (T 8); (g)although Mr Gregson was aware of the relevant Apple investigation and that it involved Jo Consumer enquiries, he had no recollection of knowing who was involved or the specific set up of the April Calls or June Calls, nor was he involved in the process of approving use of the technique in the present case;(h)in April 2016, in making the April Calls, Mr Nicholls engaged in what was, in effect, “a trial run, to try out some investigative techniques”; the records of the April Calls were not intended or envisaged to form part of the evidence in any case brought by the ACCC, but constituted Mr Nicholls “just testing the waters with some investigative techniques to see how it might play out” (T 15); (i)there were two outcomes in the April Calls: either a communication from an Apple employee that the fictional consumer had no rights under the ACL to a free repair; or, alternatively, there was no indication either way as to ACL rights, but rather a request was made by the Apple employee that the fictional iPhone be brought into an Apple Store with the intention that it be looked at by Apple technicians (T 16);(j)after the making of the April Calls, Mr Nicholls thought about how he could hone his technique and obtain the most effective evidence in conjunction with his colleagues; before Mr Nicholls decided to make the June Calls, he added an important additional element to the fictional consumer’s scenario he was to portray: this was, that whatever Apple Store he called, he was to represent to his interlocutor that the fictional consumer lived an inconvenient distance away, thereby suggesting it was impracticable for the fictional consumer to come into the Apple Store (T 20); this was a detail deployed quite deliberately (T 21); importantly, this investigative technique (of identifying a consumer at an apparently inconvenient location) was adopted by Mr Nicholls in the June Calls to try to push the conversation along with the Apple employee to make it more likely that there would be an answer given by that employee relevant to the question as to whether ACL rights existed (T 21); put another way, the adoption by Mr Nicholls of this technique reflected a general strategy in the June Calls to attempt to direct the conversation to the point of the Apple employee expressing a view about whether the fictional consumer had a right to free repair under the ACL (T 23);(k)as to the June Calls, again Mr Nicholls only obtained two outcomes to his enquiries: one was a request by the Apple employee for the fictional consumer to bring the defective iPhone into the Apple Store; the other was for the Apple employee to make a statement to the effect that the fictional consumer did not have a right to free repair under the provisions of the ACL; it follows, that in none of the June Calls was there a conversation during which an Apple employee said that there was a right to free repair under the ACL (T 24); this outcome was obtained in circumstances (given Mr Nicholls’ previous communications) where he considered, at the time of the making of the June Calls, that this was the most likely response, that is, that there was no right to a free repair, and when he obtained such a response he made certain to get the Apple employee to repeat it (T 24); Mr Nicholls adopted this course of conduct because he was conscious of trying to make sure that the evidence, being the admissions made by Apple employees, was as clear and definite as possible as to what the Apple employee was saying concerning the ACL (T 26);(l)although the June Calls comprised 22 calls, in the First Nicholls Affidavit, reference was only made to 13 telephone calls (being the Relevant Calls), and no reference whatever was made in that affidavit to the April Calls (or, obviously enough, those of the June Calls which were not the Relevant Calls).

Decision

Reasons for decision

During the course of oral argument, however, it became plain that the ACCC eschews use of the evidence other than to prove the ACCC Representation case. Consistently with this, as noted above, no tendency notice has been served and it follows that the issue of alleged unfair prejudice falls away.J CONCLUSION & ORDERS It follows from the above that neither of the discretionary exclusions contained in Part 3.11 of the EA are engaged. Given that it is common ground that the evidence is relevant within the meaning of ss 55 and 56 of the EA, I will make an advance ruling pursuant to s 192A of the EA. This ruling can be stated simply as allowing the affidavit to be read. For completeness, I note that I did give consideration as to whether a limitation should be made pursuant to s 136 of the EA to limit the use of the relevant admissions to the ACCC Representation case, but in the light of the submissions made by the ACCC, and in the absence of a tendency notice, I do not consider that such a limitation is necessary. I will hear the parties as to the costs of the voir dire.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.