Australasian Performing Right Association Ltd v Metro on George Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australasian Performing Right Association Limited v Metro on George Pty Limited [2004] FCA 1123

COPYRIGHT – infringement – authorisation of infringement – sanction approve or countenance – knowledge of particular work not necessary – nature and extent of control – reasonable steps for the purposes of s 36(1A) – awareness of reasonable grounds for suspecting that the performance is an infringement for purposes of s 39(2) – whether a venue licence is in existence – whether the existence of a clause in the hiring contract requiring the hirer to obtain a licence is sufficient – director’s liability for infringement – joint tortfeasor

CONTRACT – letter of termination of licence citing wrong clause – requirement of written notice – notice by facsimile sufficient – requirement for service of notice on specified address – service on solicitors – course of correspondence – repudiation - termination

Copyright Act 1968 (Cth)

Allen Manufacturing Co Pty Ltd v McCallum & Co Pty Ltd  (2001) 53 IPR 400
ASC v Bank Leumi Le-Israel (Switzerland) (1996) 69 FCR 531
Australasian Performing Right Association Limited v Canterbury-Bankstown League Club Limited [1964-5] NSWR 138
Australasian Performing Right Association Ltd v Jain (1990) 26 FCR 53
Australian Tape Manufacturers Association Ltd v The Commonwealth of Australia (1993) 176 CLR 480
C.B.S. Songs Ltd v Amstrad Consumer Electronics Plc [1988] AC 1013
Golden Editions Pty Ltd v Polygram Pty Ltd (1996) 34 IPR 84
King v Milpurrurru (1996) 34 IPR 11
Mannai Investments Co Pty Ltd v Eagle Star Life Assurance Co Ltd [1997] AC 749
Mentmore Manufacturing Co Ltd v National Merchandising Manufacturing Co Inc (1978) 89 DLR (3d) 195
NM Superannuation Pty Ltd v Hughes (1992) 27 NSWLR 26
Performing Rights Society Ltd v Ciryl Theatrical Syndicate Ltd [1924] 1 KB 1
The Corporation of the City of Adelaide and The Australasian Performing Right Association Limited (1928) 40 CLR 481
The University of New South Wales v Moorhouse (1975) 133 CLR 1
WEA International Inc and Another v Hanimex Corporation Ltd (1987) 17 FCR 274

JW Carter and DJ Harland, Contract Law in Australia (4th ed)(Sydney: Butterworths, 2000)

AUSTRALASIAN PERFORMING RIGHT ASSOCIATION LIMITED
v METRO ON GEORGE PTY LIMITED, PETER WARREN HEARNE and WARWICK WILLIAM DOUGHTY

N1278 OF 2002

BENNETT J
31 AUGUST 2004
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N1278 OF 2002

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALASIAN PERFORMING RIGHT ASSOCIATION LIMITED
(ACN 000 016 099)
APPLICANT

AND:

METRO ON GEORGE PTY LIMITED
(ACN 064 086 693)
FIRST RESPONDENT

PETER WARREN HEARNE
SECOND RESPONDENT

WARWICK WILLIAM DOUGHTY
THIRD RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

BENNETT J

DATE:

31 AUGUST 2004

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. The applicant, Australasian Performing Right Association Limited (‘APRA’), has agreements with at least 57 affiliated bodies carrying on public performance licensing in the United States of America, the United Kingdom, Republic of Ireland, Europe, South America and Asia, pursuant to which APRA obtains its rights with respect to the public performance of the works belonging to the members of these…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australasian Performing Right Association Ltd v Metro on Geo... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 1123
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Australasian Performing Right Association Ltd (APRA) initiated legal proceedings against Metro on George Pty Ltd, a live music venue in Sydney, for copyright infringement. APRA alleged that Metro infringed its copyright by hosting live performances of musical works without the necessary licences. The case centred on whether Metro authorised the infringement of APRA's copyright by permitting performances without the required licences. APRA asserted that Metro, by hosting live performances, permitted the unauthorised use of its copyrighted works, thereby infringing APRA's exclusive rights under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth). The court examined whether Metro had the power to prevent the infringements, the nature of its relationship with the promoters of the performances, and whether Metro took reasonable steps to prevent or avoid the infringements.

The court found that Metro had the power to prevent the unauthorised performances but failed to do so, effectively sanctioning the infringements. It was established that Metro had reasonable grounds to suspect that the performances might infringe APRA's copyright, especially after receiving notification from APRA. The court determined that Metro's inaction and its stance that licensing was the responsibility of APRA and the promoters amounted to authorisation of the infringements. The court held that Metro permitted the venue to be used for performances that constituted copyright infringement, as it had the power to prevent such performances but chose not to act. The court rejected the defence that Metro was unaware of the need for a venue licence, as it had been notified by APRA well before the performances took place.

The court concluded that Metro authorised the infringement of APRA's copyright by permitting the unauthorised performances and failed to take reasonable steps to prevent them. Consequently, the court found Metro liable for copyright infringement under the Copyright Act. The court also held that Mr. Doughty, a director of Metro, was personally liable for the infringements due to his knowledge and involvement in the decision-making process that led to the infringements. The court ordered Metro to pay damages to APRA for the infringements and held Mr. Doughty personally liable for contributing to the infringements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The following sections of the Act are relevant:Section 31(1):‘For the purposes of this Act, unless the contrary intention appears, copyright, in relation to a work, is the exclusive right:(a)in the case of a literary, dramatic or musical work, to do all or any of the following acts:…(iii)to perform the work in public’Section 13:‘(1) A reference in this Act to an act comprised in the copyright in a work or other subject-matter shall be read as a reference to any act that, under this Act, the owner of the copyright has the exclusive right to do.(2) For the purposes of this Act, the exclusive right to do an act in relation to a work, an adaptation of a work or any other subject-matter includes the exclusive right to authorize a person to do that act in relation to that work, adaptation or other subject-matter.’Section 36:‘(1) Subject to this Act, the copyright in a literary, dramatic, musical or artistic work is infringed by a person who, not being the owner of the copyright, and without the licence of the owner of the copyright, does in Australia, or authorizes the doing in Australia of, any act comprised in the copyright.’Section 36(1A):‘In determining, for the purposes of subsection (1), whether or not a person has authorised the doing in Australia of any act comprised in the copyright in a work, without the licence of the owner of the copyright, the matters that must be taken into account include the following:(a)the extent (if any) of the person’s power to prevent the doing of the act concerned;(b)the nature of any relationship existing between the person and the person who did the act concerned;(c)whether the person took any reasonable steps to prevent or avoid the doing of the act, including whether the person complied with any relevant industry codes of practice.’Section 39:‘(1) The copyright in a literary, dramatic or musical work is infringed by a person who permits a place of public entertainment to be used for the performance in public of the work, where the performance constitutes an infringement of the copyright in the work.(2) This section does not apply where the person permitting the place to be so used establishes:(a)that he or she was not aware, and had no reasonable grounds for suspecting, that the performance would be an infringement of the copyright; or…(3) In this section, “place of public entertainment” includes any premises that are occupied principally for purposes other than public entertainment but are from time to time made available for hire for purposes of public entertainment.’THE EVIDENCE The following facts were not in dispute:(a)Metro on George holds regular live performances of music. It is a prominent venue for live music in Sydney.(b)Metro on George sells alcohol from a bar within the theatre during performances, operates a box office, advertises as a venue suitable for the performance of live music and has established and maintained a reputation as a live-music venue.(c)Metro advertise the concerts to take place at Metro on George.(d)Other theatres, such as the Enmore Theatre, operate in the same manner as Metro on George with respect to, for example, tickets and the bar but are not required by APRA to take a Live Performance licence. It is not agreed that the theatres are of a similar nature.(e)Metro on George is used for a variety of activities, including “in standing mode”, “cabaret mode” for performances, award nights and dinners, and “theatre mode”. It is hired out for live music performances approximately 150 nights per year.(f)Until it was terminated in 2002, Metro held a Live Performance licence (‘venue licence’). That is not relied upon by APRA as an admission of the obligation on the part of Metro to hold such a licence.(g)Metro has also held a number of other APRA licences.(h)APRA usually grants licences with respect to the whole of its repertoire on a “blanket” basis. (i)APRA grants different kinds of licences, for example, a venue licence (which it claims is the licence appropriate for Metro), a Promoter’s licence (granted to certain “national promoters” (approximately 33) who deal directly with APRA), a Halls and Function Centre licence and a licence for Recorded Music for Dancing.(j)If a concert were to be held at a place for which there was no venue licence and the promoter approached APRA, APRA would put a licence in place with the promoter. If a national promoter wished to add Metro on George to his or her schedule, APRA would accept that addition and issue a licence. That occurred on a number of occasions. On at least one occasion, a national promoter added Metro on George to his schedule and in fact paid for the performance there but APRA returned the money preferring, apparently, to rely on the venue licence.(k)Many promoters, who are not national promoters, obtain licences from APRA in respect of individual performances at venues, including Metro on George, which do not have a venue licence. The Concert Promoter’s licence is a scheme administered by APRA which applies to promoters who are not national promoters.(l)APRA recognises that, in relation to any given performance, it may directly licence the promoter or licence the venue and has developed different schemes to accommodate these situations. (m)A venue licence is a blanket licence that covers all performances of music in APRA’s repertoire by live performers at the venue.(n)Since 31 May 2002, Metro has not entered into any venue licence with APRA.(o)Metro has taken promoter’s licences for performances where Metro was itself the promoter.(p)Subsistence and ownership of copyright by APRA in the musical works performed at Metro on George on dates between 26 June 2002 and 12 September 2002, as specified in the schedule to the statement of claim (‘the eleven performances’).(q)In the eleven performances various artists performed works the subject of APRA’s copyright.(r)The eleven performances were performances in public.(s)The eleven performances required an APRA licence.(t)No applications for promoter’s licences were received by APRA in respect of the eleven performances and APRA did not grant promoter’s licences for those performances.(u)Four promoters, not national promoters, did approach APRA for licences for other performances to be held at Metro on George. APRA issued a licence in each case.(v)On 3 October 2002, Metro offered to advise APRA of all details of events held at Metro on George where they were promoted by others. Other licences required for events held at Metro on George, such as events where Metro was itself the promoter or where a Recorded Music for Dancing licence was appropriate, were obtained and payment made. (w)There is no evidence of any relevant industry code of practice as referred to in s 36(1A)(c) of the Act.

Decision

Reasons for decision

BENNETT J
Metro cannot, after the notification in the letter of 15 July 2002, avail itself of the defence afforded by s 39(2). The correspondence concerning the need for a venue licence, pre-dated the first of the eleven performances. This correspondence establishes that Metro was indeed aware, or at least had reasonable ground for suspecting, that unlicensed performances of work subject to APRA’s copyright might occur. Accordingly, I am not satisfied that Metro has established that s 39(2) applies to the pre-15 July 2002 performances.Conclusion There can be no doubt that Metro was aware after 15 July 2002 that APRA asserted that performances at Metro on George were unlicensed. That put Metro on notice that some promoters had not obtained licenses. Metro was aware of the possibility that unlicensed performances might occur even before 15 July 2002. BHF asserted that Metro needed a venue licence well before this date. Metro knew at the relevant times that the bands which performed at Metro were likely to perform songs in their own repertoire and that APRA asserted that it owned the performing rights in practically all such works. Metro still made no enquiries of the promoters because it held the firm view that it was not Metro’s problem. That does not derogate from the position that since 15 July 2002 Metro was on notice that unlicensed performances had taken place. Metro took no action, believing it was for APRA and the promoter to arrange the licensing of performances. Neither of those parties took any action, a matter which Metro ignored. Metro thereby effectively waived the express requirement in the Metro contract and permitted the unlicensed situation to continue for any promoter. In this way, Metro permitted or countenanced the unlicensed performances. Metro has not established the application of s 39(2) of the Act. The facts establish infringement under s 36(1) of the Act and negate reliance by Metro on s 36(1A)(c). Metro did not take reasonable steps to prevent any of the eleven infringing performances. Accordingly, I find that Metro authorised infringement of APRA’s copyright in 29 original musical and literary works in the eleven performances under s 36(1) of the Act. In my view, the same evidence establishes that Metro permitted Metro on George, a place of public entertainment, to be used for the eleven performances, where the public performance constituted infringement of copyright within s 39(1) of the Act. The evidence does not establish that Mr Hearne was personally involved in, or that he authorised the infringements. Mr Hearne denied knowing the time or content of the performances and claimed that he believed that hirers would comply with their warranties and obligations under the Contract. Mr Doughty, on the other hand, was put on notice of the infringing performances by the May letter. He was aware of APRA’s assertions that some of the promoters were unlicensed and knew that the performances were likely to infringe APRA’s copyright unless someone was licensed. Acting on his belief that Metro should not be required to pay for a venue licence, Mr Doughty directed the company on a course which led directly to it infringing APRA’s copyright. His conduct satisfies the tests for liability of directors in intellectual property cases, as expressed by the Court in Allen.Nature of relief

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BENNETT J

In Australasian Performing Right Association Ltd v Jain (1990) 26 FCR 53 (‘Jain’) the Full Court of this Court revisited the authorities on authorisation of infringement in an action against a company and its directors in respect of music played at a tavern both through a jukebox and by live bands. With respect to the bands, the evidence was that the respondents took no part in the selection of the bands or of the music performed. APRA had notified one of the respondents of the unlicensed performance of works at the premises. From the Court’s consideration, the following conclusions relevant to this case are:·A reference to the act comprised in the copyright is a reference to any act that, under the Act, the owner of the copyright has the exclusive right to do.·The right to authorise is a separate and distinct right so that infringement of that right is a distinct tort.·Authorisation has its own independent operation which does not exclude the general law principles relating to joint tortfeasors operating on primary infringement.·Authorise means ‘sanction, approve, countenance’ and also ‘permit’.·Authorisation has a wide meaning and applies to both express and implied permission or invitation. ·A person cannot be said to authorise an infringement of copyright unless he or she has some power to prevent it.·Express or formal permission or sanction or active conduct is not essential to constitute authorisation but mere inactivity is not sufficient if there was no knowledge or reason to suspect that the act might be done.·In Moorhouse it was not necessary that all of the books which might be copied were subject to copyright or that all copying would constitute infringement. The library had been given enough information to raise the suspicion that some infringing copies were likely to be made.·Where a general permission or invitation may be implied it is unnecessary that the authorising party have knowledge that a particular act comprised in the copyright will be done.·The acts and omissions of the alleged authorising party must be looked at in the circumstances in which the act comprised in the copyright is done, including the likelihood that such an act will be done.·Acts which fall short of being direct and positive such as indifference, exhibited by acts of commission or omission, may reach a degree from which authorisation or permission may be inferred. It is a question of fact in each case.CONSIDERATIONDate of termination of Metro’s APRA licence In 1994, Metro obtained a Recorded Music for Dancing licence and the venue licence from APRA for the live performance of works in APRA’s repertoire. Since June 1999, Metro has refused to pay licence fees. On 22 September 1999 Metro notified APRA that it believed that it had been wrongly classified by APRA and requested a reassessment of licence fees for the period 1 August 1994 to 30 June 1998. Metro asserted that it did not require a venue licence. APRA did not agree. From that time, the parties have been in correspondence but have not resolved the dispute.