Background
Background to the litigation
I consider the IAA’s decision is attended by jurisdictional error. My reasons follow.BACKGROUND The applicant is an Iranian national who arrived in Australia in April 2013 as an unauthorised maritime arrival. Upon arrival, the applicant was interviewed twice by officers from the Australian Border Force, first on 16 May 2013, and again on 27 May 2013. On 25 May 2016, the (then) Department of Immigration and Border Protection invited the applicant to apply for a Temporary Protection visa or a Safe Haven Enterprise visa, advising him that the Minister had exercised power under s 46A(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth)[1] (Act) to remove the prohibition on the applicant lodging a valid visa application, which had to that point prevented the applicant from so applying because he was an unauthorised maritime arrival.[1] Unless otherwise specified or the context otherwise requires, any reference to the Act is a reference to the Act as it was then in force. On 7 June 2017, the applicant applied for a Safe Haven Enterprise (class XE) (subclass 790) visa (SHEV) with the assistance of a legal practitioner. That application was accompanied by, inter alia, a statutory declaration setting out the applicant’s circumstances and his claims for protection. The applicant claimed (and continues to claim) that he feared harm from the Iranian government resulting from his activities as a photographer in Iran and his related political activities and associations. By letter dated 20 July 2017, the Department acknowledged receipt of the visa application. In October 2019, the applicant was invited to attend an interview with the Department scheduled for 31 October 2019, to give further information in relation to his application, which he attended as scheduled (SHEV interview). On 15 November 2019, the Minister’s delegate refused to grant the applicant a SHEV on the basis that the delegate was not persuaded the applicant satisfied s 36(2) of the Act. The notification letter: advised the applicant the matter had been referred to the IAA for review under the Act; set out information relevant to the IAA’s review process; and enclosed a copy of the delegate’s protection visa decision record. That decision record records the delegate’s engagement with and analysis of the applicant’s claims and evidence, and the findings in relation thereto. In short, the delegate found the applicant’s account and evidence in relation to his nationality, departure from Iran, political activities, and the potential for his activities to become subject of investigation by Iranian political groups, all to be credible and plausible. The delegate did not accept, however, that the applicant was being investigated due to his political opinion “demonstrated in his photographs”. The delegate assessed the applicant’s claims against Australia’s protection obligations and the criteria relevant for the grant of a SHEV, and was not satisfied that the applicant would face a real chance of persecution should he be returned to Iran. On that basis, the applicant failed to satisfy the criteria in ss 5H(1) and 36(2) of the Act, and could not be granted a SHEV. The delegate similarly considered whether, nonetheless, the applicant was a person in respect of whom Australia owed protection obligations under s 36(2)(aa), finding there was no real chance that the applicant would suffer significant harm if returned to Iran. On the same day as the delegate’s decision, the applicant was notified the passport which he had provided to the delegate had been seized under s 487ZJ(1) of the Act as a ‘bogus document’ obtained by fraud.IAA PROCEEDING
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
The transcript earlier reproduced, appearing as the second extracted passages, suggests that the applicant was challenging the proposition that he had earlier stated in the arrival interview that he had been excused from military service. The applicant says, through the interpreter, that “Maybe it’s the translation. I haven’t done the military service, maybe in translation they have misinterpreted”. As part of its concerns about the applicant’s credibility about how the applicant had obtained a passport the IAA reasoned: Decision at [21]The applicant claims he was unable to obtain a passport in his own name because it was too risky and he had not completed military service. However, the applicant’s evidence as to why he had not completed military service, and how he had managed to avoid it was unconvincing. When asked about it in his Entry interview, the applicant stated he had “supported my mum and was excused” but he resiled from this in the SHEV interview, insisting he had not received an exemption (for any reason); he just hadn’t done it.(emphasis added) The extracted transcript does not disclose the applicant resiling from what he said earlier during the entry interview. Instead, the applicant disputed the delegate’s recounting of what was said, and posited that in translation, what he said was misinterpreted. There was no resiling. The applicant was not abandoning something that he had earlier said. Instead, he was maintaining that he never said it and if that is what is recorded in his answers, those answers may have been wrongly translated. The SHEV interview was not the first occasion on which the applicant had complained about the quality of the interpreter assigned during the entry interview. In a statutory declaration made by the applicant on 30 May 2017 the applicant said:3.As I have previously raised with the Department of Immigration, there were a number of issues with the interpreter I was assigned for my entry interview, including the fact that he spoke an Afghani dialect of Farsi, was impatient and angry, and cut me off when I was trying to give answers. I have provided additional information in this statement and am happy to provide more at the interview. I would be grateful if I could be assigned an interpreter who speaks the Iranian dialect of Farsi for my protection visa interview.. . .42.I have never had a passport. In Iran, you cannot apply for a passport unless you have completed military service. Because I have not completed military service, I cannot apply for a passport unless I pay a bribe. But this can take a lot of time. It is evident from paragraph [3] of the applicant’s declaration that the provision of additional information was in part motivated by his concern about the adequacy of the translation given by the interpreter at the entry interview, a complaint he says he had previously raised. Paragraph [42] of the statutory declaration sets out that the applicant had not completed military service and therefore could not obtain a passport. He does not say he was excused from service. This is consistent with the information he provided to the delegate during the SHEV interview where he also reiterated his concern about the adequacy of the interpreting service he was provided at the entry interview. It is also consistent with what the applicant said during the 16 May 2013 entry interview where he is recorded as saying (through an interpreter): I never went to start my military service because I had to maintain the living for the family financially. I had to support them. I didn’t go to military service.
Decision
Reasons for decision
The applicant set out the basis on which he alleged the delegate had made incorrect findings and why, as a result, the decision ought be overturned. The applicant contended first that the delegate erred in finding that his political associations and ties with two named individuals, Hoda Saber and Rooin Otoofat, were not investigated or taken into account in assessing whether he faced a risk of harm, and contended that it should have been clear that his participation in political activities with those people was enough to make him a target of the Iranian authorities. The applicant argued second that the delegate had erred in rejecting that he had used photography to convey his political opinion. The applicant said that it was clear from his photography that he was portraying political opinion/s, being entrusted to take photographs for Mr Saber and Mr Otoofat in connection with their political activities, and that the delegate’s finding in that regard demonstrated a lack of understanding and knowledge of the political dynamics in Iran. The applicant said the fact he was not arrested is not evidence that he was not being targeted by the authorities, rather it is in accordance with the Iranian regime’s strategies for combatting political dissent. Finally, the applicant contended that the delegate accepted the Basij went to the applicant’s residence and confiscated his possessions, and that he was under surveillance by that organisation, but then failed to accept that the applicant had used photography as an outlet for his political opinion, notwithstanding that the applicant had been questioned and his equipment confiscated, in connection with his attendance at a meeting of political dissidents. The applicant also contended that the delegate placed disproportionate weight on the fact that he was not arrested following the last incident prior to him fleeing Iran, and that the delegate failed to consider the likelihood of the applicant being arrested following the incident prior to his departure, again notwithstanding the fact that the delegate accepted the applicant was under surveillance and had his possessions confiscated.STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS On 20 January 2020, the IAA affirmed the delegate’s decision not to grant the applicant a SHEV, notifying the applicant of its decision by letter on the same day and enclosing a copy of its Statement of Decision and Reasons (Decision). In its Decision, the IAA set out the application for review, recounted the information before it at [4]–[10], set out the applicant’s claims for protection at [11], before turning to make findings of fact in relation to the applicant’s evidence at [12]–[26]. The IAA concluded at [46] that the applicant did not meet the requirements of the definition of a refugee in s 5H(1) of the Act and failed to satisfy s 36(2)(a), further finding at [51] the applicant did not satisfy s 36(2)(aa). The IAA summarised the applicant’s claims as follows: Decision at [11]:·the applicant was born in Tehran in 1983; in about June 2009 he supported the ‘Green Movement’, a political party opposed to the Iranian regime, and its associated candidate Mir-Hossein Mousavi, and took photographs in support of the movement; his family were also involved in raising awareness for the movement and assisting its activities in the lead up to the 2009 Presidential elections;·Mousavi’s father lived near the applicant, and Mousavi would visit his father on Fridays. The applicant would sometimes visit Mousavi at his father’s house, and on one occasion in the lead-up to the election, Mousavi told the applicant that he and his supporters were being watched and that the applicant should not speak with him; ·on 27 December 2009, the applicant was photographing the Ashura ceremony in Tehran, when some Basij or Sepah (Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps) officers questioned him about his camera, and detained him in a basement for two nights without food. During his detention he was physically assaulted, threatened and coerced into signing a false statement admitting to working for foreign agencies and that he intended to give his photos to the BBC or CNN. He was told that he was going to be transferred to a prison, but a friend of his family got involved and secured his release; ·due to that incident, the applicant lost his government funded clients, and he began to notice people acting suspiciously on his street. In April 2010 he confronted a man who was following him, and an hour later a local Basij leader rammed his front door with a motorbike, rode inside and through the house, and shouted threats at the applicant, saying that the man knew the applicant was active in the election;·the applicant stated that he was not a member of any political organisation, but that he supported certain leaders from 2008, and that he had been mentored by prominent anti-government intellectuals including Hoda Saber and Rooin Otoofat. The applicant said that he had attended their meetings and published photographs of them, including in the magazine ‘Iran Farda’;·in 2013 he was present at one of Otoofat’s meetings at Otoofat’s home, when the house was raided by Iranian authorities. The authorities took the phones and wallets of those present and many items from the house, then made each person present complete forms with their contact details and sign a declaration stating that they had left unharmed. The following day, the authorities contacted the applicant asking him to come and collect his items, whereupon he was questioned about his political activities and opinions, and his connection with Otoofat and Saber. He was questioned at that time about his detention in 2009 and the identity of the person who had helped to secure his release, which the applicant was surprised to learn had been noted on his official record. He was required to sign a statement naming his mentor and connections, and recording details about the meetings he attended. The applicant was threatened by an officer during this questioning on the basis of his association with his mentors;·upon his return from questioning in 2013, he discovered his home had been raided, his photography equipment broken, and many electronic items missing including his computer, CDs and an external storage drive which contained videos relating to vote-tampering and fabrication of votes in 2009;·after this raid, he believed that the authorities had sufficient information to put him in jail, and he arranged to leave the country. He went to stay at his brother’s house while planning to leave, during which time the Iranian authorities attended his house looking for him; the authorities continued visiting the applicant’s house looking for him even after he had left Iran, and the authorities blocked his bank account for a period of six months;·the applicant had not completed his compulsory military service, so was unable to obtain a passport. In order to leave Iran, a friend of the applicant arranged for the applicant’s brother’s passport to be renewed using a photograph of the applicant, and for the passport to be backdated to pre-February 2013, so that his departure just after renewing the passport would not seem suspicious; the applicant therefore departed Iran with a passport bearing his photograph, but his brother’s details: at [13];·the applicant believes that if he returns to Iran, he will face a term of imprisonment of at least 10 years in isolation and will be tortured.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
For those reasons, the delegate’s decision was affirmed. CONSIDERATION By his amended application lodged on 17 June 2025, the applicant alleges under cover of three grounds that the IAA’s decision is affected by jurisdictional error, as follows:(1) The Second Respondent acted outside its jurisdiction in considering the credibility of the Applicant, in particular at [16]-[26] and [33]-[35].ParticularsIn assessing the Applicant’s credibility, the Second Respondent:(a) Went on a “quest to disbelieve”, failing to comply with the principles regarding assessment of credibility espoused in AVQ15 (at [16]-[26] and [33]-[35]).(b) Ignored or overlooked relevant material and failed to consider the evidence as a whole (at [16], [21], [25]-[26] and [33]-[35]).(c) Made findings that were erroneous or otherwise unreasonable (at [17], [19], [25]), and or(d) In making plausibility findings on matters falling outside everyday or ordinary human experience, failed to rely on objective evidence, and erroneously used its own assumptions and views about human behaviour as a universal yardstick (at [17], [18], [20], [21]).(2) The Second Respondent acted unreasonably in exercising (or failing to exercise) its discretion under section 473DC at [8].Particulars(a) An “information” gap arose as the Second Respondent had seen the demeanour of the Applicant and also apparently been shown a photo at interview. Both were relevant to the issue of credibility, a central issue in the case. (b) The Second Respondent acted unreasonably in its consideration and failure to exercise its discretion to invite the Applicant to provide new information in circumstances where there was this “information gap”.(3) The Second Respondent failed to consider all relevant information before it, thus failing to constructively exercise its jurisdiction.Particulars(a) The Second Respondent failed to consider the Applicant’s first entry interview (dated 16 May 2013), which contained relevant information, including to the issue of consistency of evidence. During the hearing the applicant addressed these grounds beginning with ground 2, then ground 3, and concluding with ground 1. It is convenient to deal with the grounds in the same order. Ground 2 By ground 2, the applicant contends the IAA acted unreasonably in exercising or failing to exercise its discretion under s 473DC of the Act. This is because there was said to be an evidence gap in assessing the applicant’s claims about his passport in circumstances where the passport was central to the issue of credibility. The applicant advances two bases which underpin his contention. First, he says that unlike the delegate, the IAA did not have the benefit of assessing his credibility by observing him in person. Second, the applicant says that the IAA did not have the benefit of viewing a photograph of the applicant’s brother apparently shown to the delegate, which purported to corroborate the applicant’s claims regarding the passport.