Attorney-General's Reference No 1 of 2012

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

[2013] TASCCA 14

COURT:       SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA (COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL)

CITATION:              Attorney-General's Reference No 1 of 2012 [2013] TASCCA 14

PARTIES:  ATTORNEY-GENERAL FOR THE STATE OF TASMANIA
  and
  WRIGHT, James Philip

FILE NO:  1009/2012
DELIVERED ON:                 23 December 2013
DELIVERED AT:                 Hobart
HEARING DATES:             15 May, 20 August 2013
JUDGMENT OF:                  Blow CJ, Porter and Wood JJ

CATCHWORDS:

Criminal Law – Evidence – Judicial discretion to admit or exclude evidence – Illegally obtained evidence – Generally – Police Commissioner to publish Manual containing orders, directions, procedures and instructions – Statutory provision requiring police officers to comply with "all orders in the Manual" and with "any lawful direction or lawful order given by a senior officer" – Whether breach of provision of the Manual other than an order is a contravention of an Australian law.

Police Service Act 2003, ss42(3), 43, 93.

Evidence Act 2001 (Tas), s138.
Tasmania v Woodberry [2012] TASSC 89, considered.
Aust Dig Criminal Law [2685]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
             Attorney-General:  D G Coates SC and S Karpeles
             Respondent:  G A Richardson and C Scott
Solicitors:
             Attorney-General:  Director of Public Prosecutions
             Respondent:  G A Richardson

Judgment Number:  [2013] TASCCA 14
Number of paragraphs:  47

Serial No 14/2013
File No 1009/2012

ATTORNEY-GENERAL'S REFERENCE NO 1 OF 2012

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL

BLOW CJ
PORTER J
WOOD J
23 December 2013

Order of the Court

Question referred for determination:

"Does a breach of the provision of the Tasmania Police Manual but which is not a breach of an order in the Police Manual published under s93 of the Police Service Act 2003, amount to a breach of an Australian law for the purposes of s 138(1)(b) of the Evidence Act 2001?"

Answer:

"No"

Serial No 14/2013
File No 1009/2012

ATTORNEY-GENERAL'S REFERENCE NO 1 OF 2012

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL

BLOW CJ
  23 December 2013

  1. I agree with Porter J.

  2. I confirm that in Tasmania v Woodberry [2012] TASSC 89, I was asked to make a determination as to the admissibility of evidence on the basis of oral evidence as to the contents of the Police Manual, without the production of the manual itself, and without any argument as to "directions, procedures and instructions" not amounting to "orders".

    File No 1009/2012

ATTORNEY-GENERAL'S REFERENCE NO 1 OF 2012

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL

PORTER J
23 December 2013

Introduction

  1. At his trial before Tennent J in November 2011, James Philip Wright was acquitted by a jury of two counts of attempted aggravated robbery. Pursuant to s388AA of the Criminal Code, the Attorney-General referred to this Court for determination a question of law which had arisen at the trial. 

  2. When the reference first came before this Court, the scope and adequacy of the question posed were raised, and the hearing was adjourned.  On resumption, a second question was added to the reference by consent, and was later amended.  During the hearing of the reference however, senior counsel for the Attorney-General said…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Attorney-General's Reference No 1 of 2012 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] TASCCA 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Attorney-General referred a question of law to the Supreme Court of Tasmania concerning the admissibility of evidence obtained in contravention of the Tasmania Police Manual. The dispute arose during pre-trial proceedings where the admissibility of admissions made by an accused was challenged on the grounds that the questioning was not audio-visually recorded, contrary to a provision within the Police Manual. The trial judge had ruled the evidence inadmissible, finding that the breach of the Manual constituted a contravention of Australian law for the purposes of section 138(1)(b) of the Evidence Act 2001 (Tas).

The legal issue before the Full Court was whether a breach of a provision within the Tasmania Police Manual, which was not an express order published under section 93 of the Police Service Act 2003 (Tas), amounted to a contravention of an Australian law for the purposes of section 138(1)(b) of the Evidence Act 2001 (Tas). Section 138 of the Evidence Act provides a discretion to exclude improperly or illegally obtained evidence, defining "Australian law" broadly to include state laws. The court was required to determine if the Police Manual, in its entirety, constituted "Australian law" such that a breach of its provisions, other than explicit orders, would be considered a contravention of Australian law.

The Court reasoned that for a contravention of Australian law to occur under section 138, there must be disobedience of a command expressed in a rule of law. While the Police Service Act 2003 (Tas) requires police officers to comply with "all orders in the Manual" and "any lawful direction or lawful order given by a senior officer," the Court distinguished between "orders" within the Manual and other provisions. It held that a breach of a provision within the Manual that did not constitute an "order" as contemplated by the Act, and was not a lawful direction or order from a senior officer, did not amount to a contravention of an Australian law. Therefore, the question referred was answered in the negative.

Orders

Orders of the court

Question referred for determination:

"Does a breach of the provision of the Tasmania Police Manual but which is not a breach of an order in the Police Manual published under s93 of the Police Service Act 2003, amount to a breach of an Australian law for the purposes of s 138(1)(b) of the Evidence Act 2001?"

Answer:

"No"

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 138 of the Evidence Act is in the following terms:"138 Discretion to exclude evidence improperly or illegally obtained (1) Evidence that was obtained — (a)improperly or in contravention of an Australian law; or(b)in consequence of an impropriety or of a contravention of an Australian law — is not to be admitted unless the desirability of admitting the evidence outweighs the undesirability of admitting evidence that has been obtained in the way in which the evidence was obtained." "Australian law" is defined in the Evidence Act as a law of the Commonwealth or a State or Territory of the Commonwealth, and in a reference to a State law, it includes written and unwritten law: Evidence Act, s3(1), (11). The core meaning of "contravention" in s138 involves disobedience of a command expressed in a rule of law which may be statutory or non-statutory, involving doing that which is forbidden by law or failing to do that which is required by law to be done: Parker v Comptroller General of Customs (2009) 83 ALJR 494 at 501 [30]. Having made the findings of non-compliance with Pt 4.5.5.2(1)(f), the trial judge referred to the decision of Blow J (as he then was) in Tasmania v Woodberry which had, at that time, not been generally published. Counsel had a copy and it was tendered. The trial judge noted that in Woodberry his Honour had considered that a breach of a provision of the Manual amounted to a breach of an Australian law having regard to the provisions of the Police Service Act. The trial judge said that having had the opportunity of reading the reasons in Woodberry, the breaches found to have occurred amounted to breaches of an Australian law. (The reference to "breaches" seems to have been a reference to the two ways in which par(1)(f) had been breached.) Her Honour went on to address the question of whether the desirability of admitting the evidence outweighed the undesirability of admitting it, having regard to the way in which it was obtained. Her Honour held that it did not, and ruled the evidence inadmissible. The judgment in Woodberry was made generally available after the trial of the accused in that case. The medium neutral citation is [2012] TASSC 89. The proceedings were determinations pursuant to s361A of the Criminal Code before the empanelment of a jury. In issue was the admission or exclusion of certain pieces of evidence. The reasons for the determinations were not generally published until after the trial of the accused in that case. One of the issues was the admissibility of evidence of admissions at the accused's place of work when the questions and answers had not been audio-visually recorded. The evidence before his Honour about the Manual was oral evidence of its contents from two witnesses. The evidence from one officer was that the Manual required that when an officer suspected that a person may have committed an indictable offence, and where recording facilities were available, any official questioning of the suspect must be recorded. The second officer gave evidence that there was such a requirement in the Manual, and that it required interviews with suspects on indictable matters to be audio-visually recorded.

Decision

Reasons for decision

BLOW CJ

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BLOW CJ

Full text does not contain this section.