Catchwords: MIGRATION – Application to review decision of Administrative Appeals Tribunal – whether the Tribunal failed to comply with ss.424A or 425 of the Migration Act 1958.
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Second Respondent:
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File Number:
SYG 536 of 2017
Judgment of:
Judge Barnes
Hearing date:
17 October 2019
Date of Last Submission:
31 October 2019
Delivered at:
Sydney
Delivered on:
15 July 2020
REPRESENTATION
Counsel for the Applicant:
Mr Chia (direct access)
Counsel for the Respondents:
Ms Hooper
Solicitors for the Respondents:
Australian Government Solicitor
ORDERS
The application is dismissed.
FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT SYDNEY
SYG 536 of 2017
ATS17
Applicant
And
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
First Respondent
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
Background
This is an application for review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) dated 18 January 2017 setting aside a decision to refuse to grant the Applicant a Protection (Class XA) visa and substituting a decision to refuse to grant him a Protection (Class XD) visa.
The Applicant, a citizen of Iran, arrived in Australia in April 2013. In his entry interview he claimed he left Iran because he wished to convert to Christianity. He stated that there was no other reason he left Iran.
In August 2013 the Applicant lodged an application for a protection visa. In support of his application he claimed to fear harm due to his Christian beliefs and an imputed political opinion stemming from the arrest and detention of one of his brothers in 2009.
He claimed that one of his brothers was regarded as a supporter of the 2009 protests in relation to the Iranian presidential elections, because his shop was in the square in which the protests started. This brother was arrested and detained for four months. After his brother later failed…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read ATS17 v Minister for Immigration and more:
This matter concerned an application to review a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The applicant, ATS17, sought judicial review of the Tribunal's decision to affirm the Minister for Immigration's decision to refuse to grant a protection visa. The core of the dispute revolved around whether the Tribunal had failed to comply with its obligations under sections 424A or 425 of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth).
The legal issues before the Federal Court were whether the Tribunal had failed to provide the applicant with adequate notice of adverse information that might be the reason for affirming the decision, as required by section 424A(1), and whether the Tribunal had failed to give the applicant a reasonable opportunity to respond to that information, as required by section 425. Specifically, the applicant argued that certain information, including the contents of his passport and supportive material from Pastor Piper, constituted information that the Tribunal should have put to him under section 424A(1).
Justice Barnes, applying the principles from *SZBYR* [2017] FCA 1575, found that the applicant's passport, which indicated he had left India legally, did not in itself contain information that rejected, denied, or undermined his claims for protection. The Court reasoned that such information was not to be found in disbeliefs arising from a process of reasoning applied to the evidence, but rather in the text of the information itself, which was neutral in this instance. Similarly, the Court found that the letters of support from Pastor Piper, which attested to the applicant's sincerity and Christian faith, did not, on their face, contain any rejection or undermining of the applicant's claims. The Court also considered the transcript of the Tribunal hearing, noting that the Tribunal had clearly put the applicant on notice regarding the issues of his motivation for conversion and had provided him with opportunities to explain his reasons. The Tribunal's questions were directed at understanding the applicant's personal motivation for conversion, distinguishing it from criticisms of Islam or comparisons between religions made by Pastor Piper.
The Court concluded that the applicant had not established that the Tribunal failed to comply with its obligations under sections 424A or 425 of the *Migration Act 1958*. Consequently, the application for judicial review was dismissed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
However, in considering information in a passport the Federal Court applied SZBYR in finding (at [26]) that: In the present appeal the alleged s 424A(1) “information” was that the appellant’s passport showed that he left India legally on a passport issued in his own name. That information did not in terms contain a rejection, denial or undermining of the appellant’s claim to be a person to whom Australia owed protection obligation: cf SZBYR 235 ALR at [17]. On that question the passport was quite neutral. … The relevant “information” for s 424A(1) purposes, as SZBYR 235 ALR at [18] indicates, is not to be found in disbeliefs arising from a process of reasoning applied to the evidence. If it is to be found in this matter it must be in the text of the passport itself. It is not.(emphasis added) The Applicant has not pointed to any part of Pastor Piper’s oral evidence, letters of support or in the material cited in footnotes 11 to 13 of the Tribunal’s reasons that contains, in its terms, a rejection, denial or undermining of the Applicant’s claims to be a person to whom Australia owes protection obligations. Indeed, as in SZBYR at [17], one might have thought that had Pastor Piper’s supportive oral evidence and letters of support been believed, this would (were it not for other matters of concern to the Tribunal) have been a relevant step towards accepting the Applicant’s claims about the genuineness of his conversion (and hence departing from the decision under review). The letters of support from Pastor Piper given to the Department and the Tribunal attested to the Applicant’s attendance at, and baptism in, the Liberty Baptist Church and were not expressly referred to in the particulars to this ground. However, if they were intended to be encompassed in the expression “materials he produces”, it has not been established that they constituted or contained information which enlivened the s.424A(1) obligation. In the first letter (addressed to the Department) the pastor stated that his assessment was that the Applicant appeared to be a “sincere, genuine Christian”. Pastor Piper explained how he tested “the genuineness of [the Applicant’s] salvation”. He claimed that many Iranians had come to know that the Applicant was a Christian and that he attended the Liberty Baptist Church. Pastor Piper also expressed his view that the Applicant would face difficulties in Iran as a Christian. In addition, Pastor Piper provided a handwritten document which appeared to show attendances at church services and activities (including that of the Applicant). On its face, this material supported the Applicant’s claims. The Applicant has not pointed to anything in this evidence that in its terms contained a rejection, denial or undermining of his claims to be a refugee. Nor, for that matter, has it been established that this letter reflected the “intense” comparative “focus” of Pastor Piper referred to in paragraph 165 of the Tribunal’s reasons.
Decision
Reasons for decision
The transcript of the Tribunal hearing reveals that it put the Applicant on notice of the issues arising in relation to the decision under review. At the hearing, after the Applicant claimed his life would be in danger as a Christian in Iran, the Tribunal asked: “So what made you decide to take this very momentous step of converting from Islam to Christianity?” (transcript p.42). In response, the Applicant talked about the Koran and the fact you could compare Islam and Christianity. The Tribunal stated (transcript p.43): Tribunal Member: Can I just interrupt you. Umm the things you’re telling me now, are they things that you’ve learnt at Pastor Piper’s church?[the Applicant]: NoTribunal Member: Did you go to the mosque in Iran when you were a child?[the Applicant]: I wasn’t in the mosque but this is what they teach you in Iran, that’s all.Tribunal Member: But you see what you’re saying to me is in the second, the Medina, umm that's when we killed and confiscated, that sounds like a critical comment about Islam. That sounds like it comes from someone who might have Pastor Piper’s approach.[the Applicant]: No this is my research, my understanding. This is comparing, comparison between Islam and Christianity.Tribunal Member: But that’s not what I want you to do. What I want you to tell me is, explain to me why you made the decision to convert to Christianity.[the Applicant]: When I compare it, that’s all related. I don’t quite understand the question.Tribunal Member: Okay you, I mean the country information indicates that umm Iran is a, a majority Shia Islamic country. There are a group of people who are umm strongly religious. There’s also a very large part of the population that either is not very religious or doesn’t believe in religion at all. So wherever you are in that group, to make a decision to convert to a completely different religion requires some motivation, some reason. So what I’m asking you for is what was your reason, what did, what made you decide to do that?[the Applicant]: So firstly I’ve inherited Islam from my father ...(emphasis added) In this way the Tribunal made clear to the Applicant the relevance of his motivation for conversion and the fact that this was not the same as his criticism of Islam or the comparison of Islam and Christianity engaged in by Pastor Piper. The Tribunal alerted the Applicant to the fact that it was enquiring about his personal motivation for conversion, as distinct from what he had learnt from Pastor Piper about Islam and Christianity. This was reinforced in the following exchange (transcript p.44): [the Applicant]: In Iran I was born into a muslim family but I didn't have a right to choose. So by comparing the two religion, Islam and Christianity, has let me to choose Christianity. In my country I had no right to choose.Tribunal Member: But most people who grow up in a particular religion, whether they are strong believers or just inherited, generally just remain in that religion. To change means that you, there’s some reason that you want to change, some motivation for it.[the Applicant]: So I was at discussions, I had with, the discussions with my students and really comparing and understanding the two religions and doing some of my own research lead me to that.Tribunal Member: So you’re saying that the informal discussions you had with your boxing students lead, lead you to make this very very dramatic decision?[the Applicant]: Well that actually made me curious to do some research.Tribunal Member: I, I just finding it difficult to understand or accept the evidence that you're giving me about why you decided to convert.[the Applicant]: How should I be saying it or explaining it that it’s not ...Tribunal Member: Well no, it’s, you can only explain or tell me what is in your own mind but I’m just, to be fair to you, I’m just explaining the concerns that I have. Umm can I umm, is there anything else you want to say about that? Your reasons for conversion.[the Applicant]: Okay. So umm after the discussion, the research ah that I did, I realised that I liked Christianity, very much and it gave me peace, the peace that I never had and but I could of at the same time easily come here you know umm to refuge in this country and still remain someone who’s born into a muslim family and continue. So I must have seen something in Christianity, like as the Pastor said, like it saved me, that’s why I chose it.