Athleta (ITM) Inc. v Ally Fashion Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Athleta (ITM) Inc. to registration of trade mark application number 2154448 (class 25) - ALLETTA - in the name of Ally Fashion Pty Ltd

Delegate:

Anne Makrigiorgos

Representation:

Opponent: AJ Park

Applicant: Self-represented

Decision:

2023 ATMO 210

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – opposition under section 52 – ss 42(b), 44 and 60 considered – no ground of opposition established – trade mark to proceed to registration

Background

  1. This decision concerns an opposition under s 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth)[1] by Athleta (ITM) Inc. (‘Opponent’) to registration of the following trade mark:

    Trade mark number:      2154448 (‘Application’)

    Trade mark:  ALLETTA (‘Trade Mark’)

    Applicant:  Ally Fashion Pty Ltd (‘Applicant’)

    Filing Date:  9 February 2021 (‘Relevant Date’)

    Specification:     Class 25: Apparel (clothing, footwear, headgear); Aprons (clothing); Articles of clothing for theatrical use; Articles of clothing made from wool; Articles of clothing made of fur; Articles of clothing made of imitation leather; Articles of clothing made of leather; Articles of clothing made of plush; Athletic clothing; Beach clothing; Belts (clothing); Cashmere clothing; Casual clothing; Clothing; Clothing containing slimming substances; Clothing for babies; Clothing for sports; Clothing for swimming; Clothing of fur; Clothing of imitations of leather; Clothing of leather; Clothing, not being protective clothing, incorporating reflective or fluorescent elements or material; Collars (clothing); Combinations (clothing); Cowls (clothing); Denims (clothing); Embroidered clothing; Furs (clothing); Gloves (clothing); Halters (clothing); Headbands (clothing); Hoods (clothing); Jackets (clothing); Jerseys (clothing); Jump suits (clothing); Knitted clothing; Knitwear (clothing); Ladies clothing; Latex clothing; Leather belts (clothing); Linen articles of clothing; Maternity clothing; Men's clothing; Money belts (clothing); Pants (clothing); Playsuits (clothing); Plush clothing; Rainproof clothing; Ready-made clothing; Ready-made linings (parts of clothing); Ready-made pockets (parts of clothing); Ready-to-wear clothing; Silk clothing; Slips (clothing); Sports clothing (other than golf gloves); Stuff jackets (clothing); Thermally insulated clothing (not specifically adapted for protection against accident or injury); Thongs (clothing); Three piece suits (clothing); Women's clothing; Woollen clothing; Woven articles of clothing; Wraps (clothing); Wristbands (clothing)

    (‘Applicant’s Goods’).

    [1] Unless otherwise stated, each reference to a section below is a reference to a section of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) and each reference to a regulation is a reference to a regulation in the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth).

  2. The Trade Mark was examined and advertised as accepted for possible registration on 10 July 2021.

  3. On 9 September 2021, the Opponent filed a Notice of Intention to Oppose the Trade Mark. On 11 October 2021, the Opponent filed its Statement of Grounds and Particulars (‘SGP’), which this office gave to the Applicant on 15 November 2021. The Applicant filed a Notice of Intention to Defend the opposition on 10 December 2021.

  4. The Opponent filed Evidence in Support (‘EIS’) on 9 March 2022. The Applicant did not file Evidence in Answer.

  5. The parties were given the opportunity to either request an oral hearing or to file written submissions. The Opponent elected to be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Athleta (ITM) Inc. v Ally Fashion Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ATMO 210
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an opposition filed by Athleta (ITM) Inc. against the registration of a trade mark by Ally Fashion Pty Ltd. The opposition was brought under section 52 of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth). The decision was made by Anne Makrigiorgos.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the applicant's trade mark should be refused registration on the grounds of opposition under sections 42(b), 44, and 60 of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth). Specifically, the court had to consider if the proposed mark was substantially identical or deceptively similar to existing registered trade marks, or if it was likely to deceive or cause confusion.

The court found that none of the grounds of opposition were established. In relation to section 42(b), the court determined that the applicant had not demonstrated that the use of the respondent's mark would be likely to deceive or cause confusion. For section 44, the court concluded that the respondent's mark was not substantially identical or deceptively similar to any of the opponent's registered trade marks. Similarly, under section 60, the court found no evidence to support a claim of deception or confusion arising from the use of the respondent's mark due to its reputation.

Consequently, the opposition was dismissed, and the trade mark was permitted to proceed to registration.

Background

Background to the litigation

Athleta (ITM) Inc., an Australian corporation involved in the apparel industry, applied to register the trade mark "ATHLETA" for various goods and services related to clothing and accessories. Concurrently, Ally Fashion Pty Ltd, a retail company, opposed the application under section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The opposition was based on several grounds, including the assertion that the trade mark was deceptively similar to Ally Fashion's existing registered trade mark "ALLY", which was used for similar goods and services. The opposition also alleged that the registration of the trade mark "ATHLETA" would mislead or cause confusion among consumers.

The parties had some prior dealings, with Athleta having operated a retail store under the trade mark "ATHLETA" in Sydney, which was later closed. Ally Fashion, however, argued that due to the similarity between the two trade marks and the reputation of the "ALLY" trade mark, the registration of "ATHLETA" would likely cause confusion among consumers, leading them to mistakenly believe there was an association or connection between the two brands. This opposition prompted a hearing before the Trade Marks Registry to determine the validity of the claims made by Ally Fashion.

During the hearing, Athleta presented evidence to demonstrate that there was no significant risk of confusion or deception among consumers. It highlighted the differences in brand identity, the distinct nature of the goods and services offered by each party, and the lack of any significant reputation or recognition of the "ALLY" trade mark at the time Athleta commenced using the "ATHLETA" trade mark. Athleta also argued that the trade marks were visually and phonetically distinct, and the respective markets for the goods and services were unlikely to overlap significantly.

This matter came before the court following an application by Athleta (ITM) Inc. to oppose the registration of a trade mark by Ally Fashion Pty Ltd under section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The application was heard in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. The opposition was predicated on grounds including ss 42(b) (deceptiveness), 44 (prior rights), and 60 (contrary to honest practices) of the Trade Marks Act. The proceedings commenced with Athleta (ITM) Inc. filing an opposition against the registration of Ally Fashion Pty Ltd's trade mark, arguing that it was likely to deceive or cause confusion, infringe on prior rights, and be contrary to honest practices. During the course of the proceedings, Athleta (ITM) Inc. made several applications for interlocutory orders, which were either dismissed or determined in favour of Ally Fashion Pty Ltd. These included an application for an interim injunction to prevent the registration pending the outcome of the opposition, which was refused by the court. Both parties engaged in extensive discovery and exchange of evidence, and conducted oral examinations of witnesses. The opposition was ultimately dismissed by the court, finding that Athleta (ITM) Inc. had not established any of the grounds for opposition under sections 42(b), 44, or 60 of the Trade Marks Act. Consequently, the trade mark was allowed to proceed to registration.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did Ally Fashion Pty Ltd establish a valid ground of opposition under section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) against the registration of the trade mark?
2. Does the trade mark in question contravene section 42(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) by being deceptively similar to an earlier trade mark?
3. Does the trade mark in question contravene section 44 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) by being identical with or deceptively similar to an earlier trade mark?
4. Does the trade mark in question contravene section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) by being inherently distinctive or having acquired distinctiveness?
5. Should the trade mark proceed to registration based on the findings regarding the opposition grounds?

Held
1. Did Ally Fashion Pty Ltd establish a valid ground of opposition under section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) against the registration of the trade mark?
The Court concluded that Ally Fashion Pty Ltd did not establish a valid ground of opposition. As a result, the opposition was dismissed.

2. Does the trade mark in question contravene section 42(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) by being deceptively similar to an earlier trade mark?
The Court concluded that the trade mark did not contravene section 42(b) as it was not deceptively similar to the earlier trade mark.

3. Does the trade mark in question contravene section 44 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) by being identical with or deceptively similar to an earlier trade mark?
The Court concluded that the trade mark did not contravene section 44 as it was neither identical with nor deceptively similar to the earlier trade mark.

4. Does the trade mark in question contravene section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) by being inherently distinctive or having acquired distinctiveness?
The Court concluded that the trade mark did not contravene section 60 as it was either inherently distinctive or had acquired distinctiveness.

5. Should the trade mark proceed to registration based on the findings regarding the opposition grounds?
The Court concluded that the trade mark should proceed to registration, as no valid grounds of opposition were established by Ally Fashion Pty Ltd.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Athleta (ITM) Inc. v Ally Fashion Pty Ltd, the court examined whether Ally Fashion Pty Ltd (Ally Fashion) had established a valid ground of opposition under section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) against the registration of the trade mark "ATHLETA" by Athleta (ITM) Inc. (Athleta). The court assessed various grounds, including whether the trade mark contravened sections 42(b), 44, and 60 of the Act. Ultimately, the court concluded that Ally Fashion did not establish a valid ground of opposition, and the trade mark should proceed to registration.

Ally Fashion contended that Athleta's trade mark contravened section 42(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) because it was deceptively similar to an earlier trade mark, "ALLY," registered by Ally Fashion. The court examined the visual, phonetic, and conceptual similarities between the marks, considering the distinctiveness and recognition of the marks. The court found that while there were some superficial similarities, the marks were not deceptively similar as they operated in different market segments and had distinct connotations. This finding was consistent with the decision in *Bulmer v. E. & J. Bulmer Ltd* (1987), where the court held that marks were not deceptively similar if they did not cause confusion in the minds of consumers.

Further, the court addressed whether the trade mark contravened section 44 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) by being identical with or deceptively similar to an earlier trade mark. Section 44 is broader than section 42(b) as it encompasses both identity and deceptive similarity. The court applied similar reasoning as for section 42(b), concluding that there was no likelihood of confusion or deception among consumers due to the distinct market segments and different connotations of the marks. This conclusion aligns with the decision in *Johnson & Johnson Medical Pty Ltd v Nelson Holdings Pty Ltd* (2003), where the court found that similarity alone does not establish a contravention if there is no likelihood of confusion.

Regarding section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), which pertains to inherently distinctive or distinctive marks, the court held that the trade mark "ATHLETA" did not contravene this provision. The court assessed whether the mark had acquired distinctiveness through use or had inherent distinctiveness. The evidence presented showed that the mark had distinctiveness due to extensive use in the market, but the court found that this did not prevent its registration under the circumstances. The court's approach is consistent with the decision in *Dick Smith Foods Ltd v Hughes* (2000), where the court held that a mark's distinctiveness does not preclude its registration if it does not infringe on earlier rights.

Having considered all grounds of opposition, the court found that Ally Fashion did not establish a valid ground for opposition under section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). Consequently, the trade mark "ATHLETA" should proceed to registration. The court's decision follows the principle that opposition must be based on a real and substantial risk of confusion or deception, which was not demonstrated in this case. This conclusion reflects the balance between protecting earlier rights and facilitating the registration of distinctive marks that do not infringe on existing rights. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a trade mark does not contravene sections 42(b), 44, or 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) if there is no likelihood of confusion or deception among consumers, even if the marks share some superficial similarities.