ARJ17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 65 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

ARJ17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

[2018] FCAFC 98

Appeal from: SZSZM v Minister for Immigration & Ors [2017] FCCA 819
File numbers: NSD 223 of 2017
NSD 725 of 2017
Judges: RARES, FLICK AND RANGIAH JJ
Date of judgment: 22 June 2018
Catchwords:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – personal property – where possession of personal property important common law right – whether Secretary had power to approve “blanket policy” authorising officers to search for and seize mobile phones and sim cards of all persons held in immigration detention under Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 252, 273(1) or 5(1), 189 and 196 – whether blanket policy a valid direction to officers by the Secretary under Public Service Act 1999 (Cth) s 13(5)

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 252 – whether s 252(2) authorises search – whether “hidden” things includes objects in plain view or carried in clothing for ordinary use – whether mobile phone or sim card “other thing” “capable of” being used to help detainee escape from immigration detention under s 252(2)(a) – whether officer must give consideration to individual circumstances of detainees when considering whether to search under s 252 – whether blanket policy fetters officer’s discretion to hold mobile phone or sim card for such time as officer “thinks necessary” under s 252(4)

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 273(1) – whether Minister’s power to cause detention centres to be “established and maintained” under s 273(1) authorised blanket policy to take personal property of detainees in all circumstances – whether power to maintain detention centre under s 273 limited by specific powers to search and seize under ss 252-252C

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 5(1), 189 and 196 – whether confiscation of mobile phones and sim cards of all detainees in immigration detention “taking such action and using such force” as “reasonably necessary” to detain under s 5(1)

Legislation:

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 33

Australian Border Force Act 2015 (Cth) ss 23–27

Australian Federal Police Act 1979 (Cth) s 40

Constitution Ch III, s 51(xix)

Defence Force Discipline Act 1982 (Cth) s 27

Legislation Act 2003 (Cth) ss 12, 15G, 15K

Maritime Powers Act 2013 (Cth) ss 72, 74

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) Pt 2, Div 13, ss 5, 189, 196, 197A, 197B, 251, 252, 252AA, 252A, 252C, 252G, 253, 254, 256, 259, 260, 261E, 273, 474, 504

Public Service Act 1999 (Cth) ss 13, 42

Cases cited:

Anthony Hordern & Sons Ltd v Amalgamated Clothing & Allied Trades Union of Australia (1932) 47 CLR 1

ARJ17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 263

Behrooz v Secretary, Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] HCA 36, (2004) 219 CLR 486

Clough v Leahy (1905) 2 CLR 139

Commissioner of Taxation v Futuris Corp Ltd (2009) 237 CLR 146

CPCF v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2015) 255 CLR 514

Entick v Carrington (1765) 2 Wils 275

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ARJ17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCAFC 98
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

ARJ17 and SZSZM, individuals detained in Australian immigration detention facilities, challenged the legality of a policy implemented by the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, which mandated the confiscation of all mobile phones and SIM cards from detainees. The policy was enacted to mitigate risks such as detainee escape, contraband importation, and exposure to inappropriate content. The applicants argued that the policy was not authorised by the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) and was therefore invalid, as well as being an unconstitutional exercise of executive power. The court was required to determine whether the blanket policy for confiscating mobile phones and SIM cards from detainees was authorised by the Migration Act, and whether the blanket policy constituted a valid direction under the Public Service Act 1999 (Cth).

The court found that the blanket policy was not authorised by the Migration Act. The provisions of the Act that might be thought to confer power to confiscate detainees’ mobile phones and SIM cards were examined and found to be insufficient. The court noted that Section 252 of the Act allows for searches of detainees for weapons or items capable of assisting with escape, but does not authorise the confiscation of mobile phones and SIM cards as a blanket policy. The court also found that the power to maintain detention centres under Section 273 of the Act was not intended to authorise the blanket confiscation of detainees’ property. Furthermore, the power to detain under Section 5(1) of the Act was not broad enough to justify the confiscation of mobile phones and SIM cards as part of a blanket policy. The blanket policy, therefore, did not fall within the ambit of the powers conferred by the Act, rendering it invalid.

The court concluded that the blanket policy was invalid as it was not authorised by the Migration Act. The compulsory confiscation of mobile phones and SIM cards from detainees in compliance with the policy would constitute a trespass or conversion of the detainees’ property. As a result, the application was successful, and the appeal was allowed. The parties were directed to provide draft orders to give effect to the court's reasons for judgment. The court also noted that the name of the third respondent should be amended to the Secretary of the Department of Home Affairs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The name of the third respondent be amended to the Secretary of the Department of Home Affairs.

2. On or before 29 June 2018 the parties file agreed orders to give effect the Court’s reasons for judgment.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Before considering the parties’ submissions, it is necessary to describe the factual background and procedural history of each case and the relevant legislative provisions. Rangiah J substantially contributed to preparing this section of these reasons with me.Factual background and procedural history When they commenced their proceedings, ARJ17 and SZSZM were each detained at the Villawood Immigration Detention Centre. The Court has been informed that since the hearing of the appeal, SZSZM has been returned to Pakistan and is therefore no longer in immigration detention. The respondents have not taken any point about the standing of SZSZM to continue his appeal. On 16 November 2017, I ordered that the question reserved for the Full Court be heard and determined on the basis of the evidence before the Federal Circuit Court and the findings of fact made by that Court as if that evidence and those findings were set out in a special case. The following description of the factual background is largely taken from the reasons for judgment of Judge Smith and from the evidence before his Honour. ARJ17 and SZSZM challenge both the blanket policy and decisions proposed to be made under that policy. The blanket policy is described in ARJ17’s originating application as a policy created by a decision of the Secretary of 27 May 2016 and/or a decision of 21 November 2016. While it is apparent that the decision of 27 May 2016 was made by the Secretary, it is not entirely clear who made the decision of 21 November 2016. An internal minute prepared by staff of the Australian Border Force (ABF) in early 2016 noted that a policy was in force prohibiting all illegal maritime arrival detainees from possessing and using mobile phones in detention, but that this policy did not extend to other detainees. It noted that, increasingly, both types of detainees were being co-located, leading to inconsistency in their treatment. The minute stated that serious risks as a result of the use of mobile telephones by detainees within immigration centres had been identified. Those risks included the risk of escape, use of force incidents, importation of illegal substances, abusive/aggressive behaviour, threats, contraband, mobile phones being used as currency, protest coordination and access to inappropriate/abhorrent/radical material. The minute recommended that all detainees in immigration detention centres should be excluded from using or possessing mobile phones. On 27 May 2016, the Secretary decided to adopt a policy reflecting the internal minute. On 1 July 2016, Chapter 8 of the Detention Services Manual (the DSM) maintained by the Secretary was amended to refer to mobile phones and SIM cards. Chapter 8 provides, relevantly:Introduction1 BackgroundThe rationale for preventing some items entering immigration detention facilities (IDF) is a risk mitigation strategy used to manage the good order and security within an IDF and to ensure the health and safety of all persons in any facility. A primary risk mitigation strategy is to place conditions on the entry and use of particular items. Those items may be the property of a detainee, the Facilities and Detention Service Provider (FDSP), departmental officers or visitors. Arrangements for exceptional circumstances are also identified in this instruction. 2 Purpose and scope This instruction provides Department of Immigration and Border Protection (the Department) employees, FDSP personnel and Detention Health Service Provider (DHSP) personnel with guidance on the management of items that may present a risk to the health, security and good order of immigration detention facilities. Discretionary decisions may be made on an individual basis by the Facility Superintendent and/or Commander Detention Operations in relation to issues that have not been anticipated in this policy ...3 PrinciplesThe Department has a duty of care towards all persons in an IDF and must exercise reasonable care to protect them from any reasonably foreseeable harm by providing a safe and healthy environment, which includes excluding specific categories of items from entering the facility …4 Legislative framework This instruction is based on s252G of the Migration Act (the Act), which outlines the legislative framework for conducting searches and screening procedures in immigration detention centres (IDC). Section 252 allows for a detainee, and the detainees’ clothing and property whilst in their immediate control, to be screened and searched without a warrant. The powers under s252G allow screening of a visitor, and their clothing and property, only on entering an IDC. ...5 Screening and searching detainees All detainees are subject to screening by FDSP personnel. Section 252(2) permits an officer to search a detainee, their clothing and any property under their immediate control, without a warrant, for a weapon or item capable of inflicting injury or of assisting with escape. Section 252C(l) allows an authorised officer to take possession of and retain items found in the course of screening or the conduct of a strip search under s252A, if the item found may provide evidence of a commission of an offence against the Act or is forfeited or forfeitable to the Commonwealth. Should a prohibited item be found during a search or a screening procedure of a detainee under s252(l)(a), s252AA(1) or s252A, the item must be dealt with in accordance with established policy and procedures ... …9 Prohibited items Items that are considered illegal by Australian law are not permitted in any IDF. Examples of prohibited items are:Ÿnarcotics/illicit substancesŸweapons and Ÿchild pornography materials.10 Excluded items Items that are not unlawful in the Australian community but have been deemed to present a risk to the health, privacy, safety, security and/or good order of the facility are not permitted in an IDF in any circumstance. Examples of excluded items are:Ÿpornographic books, magazines or related material and Ÿmaterial that incites violence, racism or hatred.11 Controlled items Items that are not unlawful in the Australian community but have been deemed by the Department to present a risk to the health, privacy, safety of individuals within an IDF and/or security and good order of the facility, may be permitted under specific entry approval. …Controlled items that belong to a detainee that are not permitted in the IDF, are, with the exception of perishable food, to be stored as “in-trust” property or otherwise dealt with in accordance with departmental procedures. Refer to DSM – Chapter 3: Entering and leaving detention – Personal property.The FDSP may permit staff, personal and professional visitors to bring certain ‘controlled’ items into the facility and apply conditions of entry and use. Prior approval should be sought by visitors should they wish to bring such items into an IDF …Examples of controlled items are:Ÿall mobile phones …ŸSubscriber Identity Module (SIM) cards for mobile phones and other communication devices …13 Mobile phones For security and safety purposes all mobile phones are classified as controlled items and are not permitted in IDFs, except under conditions specified by the Department. … All detainees within border screening are not permitted to possess a mobile phone … (underlining added)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Constitutional arguments raised by the applicants would become relevant only if it were concluded that the blanket policy is otherwise authorised by the Act. In light of the conclusions described above, it is unnecessary to consider the Constitutional arguments.Conclusion The reserved question is, “Is the blanket policy invalid on the grounds alleged by the applicant?”. The question should be answered as follows:The blanket policy is invalid on the ground that it is not authorised by any provision of the Act. Further, the proposed actions of authorised officers to confiscate mobile phones and SIM cards found in the possession of detainees in immigration detention centres in compliance with the blanket policy will be invalid. The application must succeed and the appeal must be allowed. The parties will be directed to provide draft orders. There are currently two proceedings before the Court, namely: ·SZSZM v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection & Ors – that being an appeal from a decision of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia (SZSZM v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCCA 819, (2017) 321 FLR 162); and·ARJ17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection & Ors – that being an application commenced in the original jurisdiction of this Court by the filing of an Originating Application on 20 February 2017. Both proceedings involve the validity of a change to the Detention Services Manual made on 27 May 2016 by the Secretary of the Department of Immigration and Border Protection (“the “policy”). The policy objective sought to be achieved is the removal of mobile phones and subscriber identity module (“SIM”) cards from the possession of detainees held in immigration detention facilities. It is not necessary to separately set forth at length the terms of the policy, the relevant statutory provisions or the competing arguments advanced by the parties given the great care with which they have already been set forth in the reasons for decision of Rares J. Notwithstanding the comparative length of the Detention Services Manual, the validity of the policy ultimately turns upon two or three lines, namely:·the provision in cl 11 which provides that “[c]ontrolled items that belong to a detainee are not permitted in the [Immigration Detention Facilities and] are … to be stored as ‘in-trust’ property”. Mobile phones and SIM cards were characterised in cl 11 as examples of “controlled items”; and·the provision in cl 13 that “[f]or security and safety purposes all mobile phones are classified as controlled items and are not permitted in [Immigration Detention Facilities], except under conditions specified by the Department”. No conditions have been “specified” in the policy. Those provisions operate and were intended to operate so as to authorise the compulsory taking of possession of detainees’ mobile phones and SIM cards. In the absence of statutory authority of a sufficiently unambiguous character, the compulsory taking of mobile phones and SIM cards would constitute a trespass or conversion of the property of detainees.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 15 November 2016, a plan to implement the policy, known as “Operation Ramentum”, was approved by the Acting Commissioner of the Australian Border Force. On 17 November 2016, the first respondent signed a document noting the implementation plan. On 21 November 2016, an announcement of the policy and the implementation plan was made in writing. The document stated, relevantly:Effective immediately, from 21 November 2016, anyone entering an immigration detention facility or being transferred to another facility is not permitted to have a mobile phone and/or SIM card. If you are not being transferred to another onshore facility you will have a grace period, until midnight 19 February 2017 in which to voluntarily surrender your mobile phones and SIM cards. These items will be held in your ‘in-trust’ property until you leave immigration detention.…From 20 February 2017 you will not be allowed to possess or use mobile phones and SIM cards. You will be provided with additional access to land line phones and you will be able to continue to book time to use the internet…After the grace period, mobile phones and SIM cards will be confiscated as part of routine searches for contraband items in the facility.…Your mobile phones and SIM cards will be kept in your ‘in-trust’ property with your other possessions. They will be returned to you when you leave detention. (emphasis in original) Vanessa Holben, the Commander of the Australian Border Forces’ Detention Operations Branch in the Department gave evidence that prior to 27 May 2016, classes of some persons in immigration detention could possess mobile phones that did not have internet access, camera or recording capabilities, while others could not possess any mobile phones. She said that a “change to policy was approved on 27 May 2016” and that between then and 15 November 2016 work was done preparing an implementation plan for the new policy. She said:On 21 November 2016, an announcement was made regarding a network wide implementation of the Department's policy on mobile phones. From that date, any detainee entering an immigration detention facility or being transferred to another facility would not be permitted to have a mobile telephone. Visitors may be allowed to possess mobile telephones in IDFs. Any person already in detention in an onshore facility and not being transferred to another facility would have the benefit of a grace period until midnight on 19 February 2017 during which they could write down contacts from their phone and could surrender their phone. After that time mobile phones were to be confiscated as part of routine searches for items not permitted in in immigration detention facilities and any phones found as part of that process will be placed in trust for the detainees. On 7 December 2016, SZSZM commenced his application in the Federal Circuit Court. On 16 February 2017, Judge Smith of the Federal Circuit Court granted an interlocutory injunction restraining the confiscation of SZSZM’s mobile phone pursuant to the policy.