Applications by Public Interest Advocacy Centre Ltd and Ausgrid

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION TRIBUNAL

IN THE MATTER OF APPLICATIONS BY PIAC, AUSGRID AND OTHERS

SUMMARY

Applications by Public Interest Advocacy Service Ltd and Ausgrid Distribution
[2016] ACompT 1

Applications by Public Interest Advocacy Service Ltd and Endeavour Energy [2016]
ACompT 2

Applications by Public Interest Advocacy Service Ltd and Essential Energy
[2016] ACompT 3

Application by ActewAGL Distribution [2016] ACompT 4

This background to, and summary of, the reasons of the Tribunal (Mansfield J, Mr R C Davey and Dr D R Abraham) in determining these matters is not a complete statement of those reasons or its conclusions, nor does it comprise part of the reasons for the Tribunal’s determination.  The only authoritative statement of the Tribunal’s reasons is that contained in the published Reasons for Determination available at

In brief

The Tribunal’s PIAC-Ausgrid determination is the ‘lead’ case in its consideration of the five matters listed below under the heading “Parties”.

While the Tribunal determined that it is in the long term interests of consumers of electricity and gas to set aside the AER’s decisions and have the AER make them again, the impact on the suppliers’ revenues, and hence the prices they may charge, will not be known until the AER remakes its decisions.

The Tribunal found in favour of the regulated suppliers on some issues and in favour of the AER on others.  The most significant finding for the suppliers is that when the AER decides the suppliers’ operating expenses (opex) allowances again, it is to use a broader range of modelling and benchmarking against Australian businesses and include a “bottom up” review of their forecast opex.  The suppliers’ challenges to the AER’s allowances for their returns on debt, the value it set for gamma and ActewAGL’s Service Target Performance Incentive Schemes allowance were also upheld.

The suppliers’ challenges to the AER’s decision on their returns on equity, Efficiency Benefit Sharing Schemes and metering issues raised by Ausgrid and Jemena were not upheld.

The Tribunal’s opex finding meant that it did not need to decide the suppliers’ challenges to the AER’s decisions on some interrelated matters (the X factor and some metering issues) but it has provided some guidance to the AER on how it may approach those matters when it comes to remake its decisions. 

The parties

The hearing of PIAC and Ausgrid’s challenges also involved the Tribunal’s consideration applications by:

·       the three NSW government owned regulated electricity suppliers: Ausgrid, Endeavour Energy and Essential Energy (Networks NSW) and by PIAC to review the AER’s April 2015 determination of Networks NSW’s revenues for 2014-19 (ACT Nos 1, 2 and 3);

·       the regulated electricity supplier, ActewAGL Distribution, to review the AER’s April 2015 determination of its revenues for 2014-19 (ACT No 4); and

· the regulated gas supplier, Jemena Gas Networks (NSW) Limited (JGN), to review the AER’s June 2015 determination of its revenues for 2015-20 (ACT No 5).

The following companies, which opposed the AER’s methodology because it might be applied to them, intervened in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Applications by Public Interest Advocacy Centre Ltd and Ausg... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] ACompT 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Public Interest Advocacy Centre Ltd and Ausgrid applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) for a review of a determination by the Australian Energy Regulator (AER) concerning several issues related to the national electricity objective (NEO) and the operating expenditure (opex) of Ausgrid. The AER had made amendments to the National Electricity Rules (NER) and the National Electricity Law (NEL) in 2012 and 2013, respectively, which led to the present dispute. The AAT was tasked with examining whether the AER's determination was legally sound, particularly in relation to the consultation process, the NEO decision, and specific operational cost components such as opex, efficiency benefit sharing scheme (EBSS), return on equity, return on debt, gamma, and metering services.

The legal issues before the AAT involved the interpretation and application of the NEL and NER concerning the AER's determination. Specifically, the AAT had to assess whether the AER had appropriately considered the legislative background, including the role of the AER and the NEO, in making its decision. The AAT also needed to determine if the AER's consultation and notification obligations under section 16(1)(b) of the NEL were met and if the decision was materially preferable in achieving the NEO under section 71P(2a) and (2b). Furthermore, the AAT examined the AER's approach to various cost components such as opex, EBSS, return on equity, return on debt, gamma, and metering services, including the methodologies and adjustments used.

In its reasoning, the AAT found that the AER's determination was generally sound, though it offered several clarifications and recommendations. The AAT confirmed that the AER had appropriately considered the legislative framework and had fulfilled its consultation and notification obligations. The AAT also noted that the AER's decision was materially preferable in achieving the NEO. Regarding the specific cost components, the AAT endorsed the AER's use of econometric benchmarking for opex but highlighted the need for transparency in adjustments made. The AAT affirmed the AER's approach to the EBSS, return on equity, and return on debt, while suggesting improvements in the calculation of gamma and the use of multi-year averaging for metering services. Overall, the AAT upheld the AER's determination with some recommendations for future reference.

The final orders of the AAT largely affirmed the AER's determination but included specific recommendations for the AER to enhance transparency and clarity in its future reviews. The AAT required the AER to provide more detailed explanations of the adjustments made in econometric benchmarking and to ensure that its consultation processes were consistently documented and communicated. The AAT also encouraged the AER to adopt a more consistent approach to defining and calculating gamma and to consider the implications of multi-year averaging in metering services. The AAT's decision aimed to support the AER in achieving the NEO while ensuring that its regulatory processes were robust, transparent, and legally sound.