SPI Electricity Pty Ltd v Australian Competition Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SPI Electricity Pty Ltd v Australian Competition Tribunal [2012] FCAFC 186

Citation: SPI Electricity Pty Ltd v Australian Competition Tribunal [2012] FCAFC 186
Appeal from: Application by United Energy Distribution Pty Ltd [2012] ACompT 1
Application by United Energy Distribution Pty Ltd (No 2) [2012] ACompT 8
Parties: SPI ELECTRICITY PTY LTD v AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION TRIBUNAL and AUSTRALIAN ENERGY REGULATOR
File number: VID 338 of 2012
Judges: MANSFIELD, BESANKO AND MCKERRACHER JJ
Date of judgment: 20 December 2012
Catchwords:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – judicial review of a decision of the Australian Competition Tribunal (Tribunal) – construction of Part 6, Division 3A, Subdivision 2 of the National Electricity Law – where multiple service providers sought review by the Tribunal of distribution determinations of the Australian Energy Regulator (AER) – where the Tribunal found reviewable error in distribution determination of another service provider – where error common to both that service provider and the applicant’s distribution determinations – whether s 71O(2) of the National Electricity Law prevented the applicant from raising the issue in its review before the Tribunal – where applicant had raised the matter before the AER but subsequently not pursued the contention – Tribunal found that s 71O(2), inter alia, prevented applicant from agitating matter before the Tribunal – s 71O(2) did not prevent applicant from raising the matter before the Tribunal – error of law committed by the Tribunal when reviewing a distribution determination of the Australian Energy Regulator.

Legislation:

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1974 (Cth)
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth)
National Electricity (South Australia) Act 1996 (SA)
National Electricity (Victoria) Act 2005 (Vic)
Energy Legislation Amendment Act 2012 (Vic)
Energy Legislation Amendment Bill 2012 (Vic)
National Electricity (Victoria) Law
National Electricity Rules

Cases cited:

Hope v Bathurst City Council (1980) 144 CLR 1
Application by Ergon Energy Corporation Limited (Street Lighting Services) (No 6) [2010] ACompT 14
Application by United Energy Distribution Pty Ltd [2012] ACompT 1
Application by Envestra Ltd (No 2) [2012] ACompT 3
Application by United Energy Distribution Pty Ltd (No 2) [2012] ACompT 8

Dates of hearing: 5, 6 September 2012
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 71
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr P. Bick QC and Mr D. Farrands
Solicitor for the Applicant: Ms S Taylor of SP AusNet
Counsel for the Second Respondent: Mr P.R.D. Gray SC and Mr T. Clarke
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Counsel for the Minister for Energy and Resources (intervening): Mr G.R. McCormick
Solicitor for the Minister for Energy and Resources (intervening): Minter Ellison

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 338 of 2012

BETWEEN:

SPI ELECTRICITY PTY LTD
Applicant

AND:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION TRIBUNAL
First Respondent

AUSTRALIAN ENERGY REGULATOR
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

MANSFIELD, BESANKO AND MCKERRACHER J

DATE OF ORDER:

20 DECEMBER 2012

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The parties within 28 days confer and submit to the Court the agreed form of orders to give effect to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SPI Electricity Pty Ltd v Australian Competition Tribunal and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCAFC 186
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of SPI Electricity Pty Ltd v Australian Competition Tribunal concerns a judicial review of a decision by the Australian Competition Tribunal (Tribunal) regarding the construction of a specific section of the National Electricity Law. The Tribunal had found that SPI was prevented from raising a particular issue in its review, which was related to the distribution determinations made by the Australian Energy Regulator (AER). The Tribunal's decision was based on the interpretation that SPI had not raised the issue in its submissions to the AER before the reviewable regulatory decision was made. SPI challenged this decision, arguing that it had indeed raised the issue before the AER, and that the Tribunal had erred in its interpretation of the law.

The legal issues that the court had to decide included whether section 71O(2) of the National Electricity Law prevented SPI from raising the issue in its review before the Tribunal, and if the Tribunal's interpretation of the law was correct. The court had to examine the submissions made by SPI to the AER and determine whether the issue was indeed raised as required by the law. The court also had to consider whether SPI's acceptance of the AER's approach after the Draft Decision meant that it had effectively waived its right to raise the matter before the Tribunal.

The court found that the Tribunal had erred in its construction of section 71O(2) of the National Electricity Law. The court held that SPI had raised the matter before the AER in its initial regulatory proposal and that the subsequent acceptance of the AER's approach did not mean that the matter was not raised as required by the law. The court emphasised that section 71O(2) does not require a party to maintain an issue throughout the regulatory process until the reviewable regulatory decision is made. Therefore, the Tribunal's decision that SPI was barred from raising the issue was incorrect.

The final orders of the court required the parties to confer and submit to the court the agreed form of orders to give effect to the reasons for judgment, or if the form of orders was not agreed, each party separately make submissions in writing as to the appropriate orders. The parties were also required to submit to the court their agreed form of orders as to costs of the application, or if there was no agreement, each party make brief submissions in writing as to the appropriate order for costs to be made on the application. The court's decision effectively overturned the Tribunal's finding and allowed SPI to raise the issue in its review, thereby granting it the opportunity to challenge the AER's decision on the matter.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties within 28 days confer and submit to the Court the agreed form of orders to give effect to the reasons for judgment, or if the form of orders is not agreed each party separately make submissions in writing as to the appropriate orders to give effect to the reasons for judgment.

2. The parties within 28 days submit to the Court their agreed form of orders as to costs of this application, or alternatively if there is no such agreement each party make brief submissions in writing as to the appropriate order for costs to be made on the application.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

One final preliminary matter needs to be mentioned. The application to the Court was made on 2 May 2012, obviously more than 28 days after the January Decision. The January Decision gave reasons for the S Factor Scheme determination of the Tribunal. However, it is clear that the Tribunal contemplated that SPI (and other DNSPs) should be able to seek judicial review of that element of the January Decision after the April Decision: see the January Decision at [238]. If it had been necessary, the Court would have extended the time within which SPI could seek review of the Tribunal decision concerning the S Factor Scheme issue to 2 May 2012, under s 11(1)(c) of the ADJR Act. The AER did not oppose that course. However, for obvious reasons it is not necessary to do so.THE DECISIONS OF THE AER AND THE TRIBUNAL The process of regulatory decision making for SPI took the following, standard, course. On 30 November 2009, pursuant to rule 6.8.2(a) of the NER, SPI submitted its regulatory proposal for the period 2011 to 2015 (the initial regulatory proposal). On 4 June 2010, under rule 6.10.2 of the NER, the AER published a draft determination as well as its reasons for that determination, the Victorian distribution draft decision 2011-2015 (the Draft Decision). Following the Draft Decision SPI, along with the other DNSPs and other interested parties made further submissions to the AER. On 29 October 2010, under rule 6.11.1 of the NER, the AER made a distribution determination for SPI entitled Final: SPI Electricity Pty Ltd Distribution determination 2011-2015 (the Final Determination). Relevantly to this application, the Final Determination reflected the AER’s decision to adjust SPI’s RAB for six years’ inflation. The reasons for that decision, along with the other bases for the Final Determination, are set out by the AER in its Final decision: Victorian electricity distribution network service prodders Distribution determination 2011-2015 (the Final Decision). The Final Determination constituted the first electricity determination made by the AER on the price control regime to apply to the DNSPs. The previous determination (i.e. that which applied for the regulatory period 2006 – 2010) had been made by the ESCV. The AER, in closing out the ESCV S Factor Scheme, purported to be exercising the power granted by rules 6.4.3(a)(6) and 6.4.3(b)(6) of the NER. Those rules relevantly provide:6.4.3 Building block approach(a) Building blocks generallyThe annual revenue requirement for a Distribution Network Service Provider for each regulatory year of a regulatory control period must be determined using a building block approach, under which the building blocks are: …(6)the other revenue increments or decrements (if any) for that year arising from the application of a control mechanism in the previous regulatory control period – see paragraph (b)(6); and …(b) Details of the building blocksFor the purposes of paragraph (a):… (6) the other revenue increments or decrements referred to in paragraph (a)(6) are those that are to be carried forward to the current regulatory control period as a result of the application of a control mechanism in the previous regulatory control period and are apportioned to the relevant year under the distribution determination for the current regulatory control period; and …

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As noted, following the passage of the Energy Legislation Amendment Bill 2012 (Vic) and the Bill receiving Royal Assent, SPI, by letter to the Court dated 3 October 2012, no longer pursued its application insofar as it related to the S Factor Scheme issue. It has been desirable to set out the detail of the Tribunal’s decisions on that issue so as to properly inform its decision on the RAB Indexation issue.CONSIDERATION In summary, in this application SPI submits that it was not prevented by s 71O(2) of the NEL from raising the RAB Indexation issue before the Tribunal. It supports this submission by reference to its initial regulatory proposal, in which it sought indexation for six and a half years of inflation. This, SPI says, constitutes raising the matter “before the reviewable regulatory decision was made” and its subsequent acceptance of the AER’s modelling does not render it otherwise. Section 71O(2), in SPI’s submission, does not require a DNSP to maintain an issue throughout the course of the regulatory process until the reviewable regulatory decision was made. The AER submits that this application raises the question of whether, by expressly accepting the AER’s proposed indexation methodology, SPI should be held to have effectively waived its right to raise the matter before the Tribunal. The AER submits that this question should be answered in the affirmative and suggests that the concept of ‘raising a matter’ should not be read as including a case where a DNSP has done so but has later expressly abandoned it and accepted the AER’s proposed decision. Section 71O of the NEL operates to limit the matters that parties may raise in a review. It provides:71O—Matters that parties to a review may and may not raise in a review(1)The AER, in a review under this Subdivision, may raise—(a)a matter not raised by the applicant or an intervener that relates to a ground for review, or a matter raised in support of a ground for review, raised by the applicant or an intervener;(b)a possible outcome or effect on the reviewable regulatory decision being reviewed that the AER considers may occur as a consequence of the Tribunal making a determination setting aside or varying the reviewable regulatory decision.(2)A party (other than the AER) to a review under this Subdivision may not raise any matter that was not raised in submissions to the AER before the reviewable regulatory decision was made. As already mentioned, the Tribunal determined that SPI was barred from raising the RAB Indexation issue because SPI had accepted the AER’s approach following the Draft Decision. This raises a constructional point about s 71O(2), namely whether a matter can be regarded as not raised for the purposes of the section if it is not pursued by the DNSP beyond its initial regulatory proposal and the Draft Decision of the AER. There is no dispute before the Court that SPI had raised the RAB Indexation issue in submissions to the AER before the Draft Decision. In the “roll-forward” model accompanying its initial regulatory proposal SPI proposed that six and a half years of inflation should be applied. As noted above, at [20], SPI accepted the AER’s approach following the Draft Decision to allow only six years of inflation and JEN was the only DNSP to maintain its contention for six and a half years of inflation in both its initial and revised regulatory proposals.