AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION TRIBUNAL
Applications by Public Interest Advocacy Centre Ltd and Essential Energy [2016] ACompT 3
Citation: Applications by Public Interest Advocacy Centre Ltd and Essential Energy [2016] ACompT 3 Review from: Australian Energy Regulator Applicants: PUBLIC INTEREST ADVOCACY CENTRE LTD and ESSENTIAL ENERGY File number: ACT 3 of 2015
ACT 7 of 2015Tribunal: MANSFIELD J, PRESIDENT
MR R DAVEY, MEMBER
DR D ABRAHAM, MEMBERInterveners in
ACT 3 of 2015
ACT 7 of 2015:AusNet Services (Distribution) Pty Ltd
AusNet Services (Transmission) Ltd
Australian Gas Networks Ltd
Citipower Pty Ltd
Powercor Australia Ltd
SA Power Networks
United Energy Distribution Pty Ltd
Ergon Energy Corporation Ltd
Minister for Resources, Energy and Northern AustraliaInterveners in
ACT 3 of 2015:Essential Interveners in ACT 7 of 2015: Public Interest Advocacy Centre Ltd Date of Determination: 26 February 2016 Dates of hearing: 21-25 September 2015; 28-30 September 2015;
1-2 October 2015; 6-9 October 2015Place: Darwin (via video link to Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane and Adelaide) Category: No Catchwords Number of paragraphs: 57 Counsel for the Public Interest Advocacy Centre Ltd: S Horgan QC and T Clarke Solicitor for the Public Interest Advocacy Centre Ltd: Public Interest Advocacy Centre Ltd Counsel for Endeavour Energy: C Moore SC and K Morgan with A Hochroth and C Dermody Solicitor for Essential Energy: Herbert Smith Freehills Counsel for the Australian Energy Regulator: S Lloyd SC and M O’Bryan QC with S Balafoutis, A Mitchelmore, J Arnott, T Phillips, D Tucker and F St John Solicitor for the Australian Energy Regulator: Corrs Chambers Westgarth Counsel for the Commonwealth Minister for Resources, Energy and Northern Australia: T Howe QC with B Lim Solicitor for the Commonwealth Minister for Resources, Energy and Northern Australia: Australian Government Solicitor Counsel for AusNet Services (Distribution) Pty Ltd; AusNet Services (Transmission) Ltd; Australian Gas Networks Ltd, Citipower Pty Ltd, Powercor Australia Ltd, SA Power Networks and United Energy Distribution Pty Ltd: P Brereton SC with R Higgins Solicitor for AusNet Services (Distribution) Pty Ltd; AusNet Services (Transmission) Ltd; Australian Gas Networks Ltd, Citipower Pty Ltd, Powercor Australia Ltd, SA Power Networks and United Energy Distribution Pty Ltd: Jones Day Counsel for Ergon Energy Corporation Ltd: T Bradley QC with A Coulthard and E Hoiberg
IN THE AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION TRIBUNAL
ACT 7 of 2015
RE:
BY:
APPLICATION UNDER SECTION 71B OF THE NATIONAL ELECTRICITY LAW FOR A REVIEW OF DISTRIBUTION DETERMINATION MADE BY THE AUSTRALIAN ENERGY REGULATOR IN RELATION TO ESSENTIAL ENERGY PURSUANT TO RULE 6.11.1 OF CHAPTER 6 OF THE NATIONAL ELECTRICITY RULES
ESSENTIAL ENERGY
Applicant
TRIBUNAL:
MANSFIELD J, PRESIDENT
MR R DAVEY, MEMBER
DR D ABRAHAM, MEMBERDATE OF DETERMINATION:
26 FEBRUARY 2016
WHERE MADE:
DARWIN (VIA VIDEO LINK TO SYDNEY, MELBOURNE, BRISBANE AND ADELAIDE)
THE TRIBUNAL DETERMINES THAT:
1.Pursuant to s 71P(2)(c) of the National Electricity Law, the Final Decision Essential Energy distribution determination 2015-16 to 2018-19, April 2015, including attachments (the Final Decision) is set aside and remitted to the Australian Energy Regulator (AER) to make the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Applications by Public Interest Advocacy Centre Ltd and Esse... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] ACompT 3
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues that the court had to address centred around the interpretation and application of the National Electricity Law and the National Electricity Rules. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the AER had appropriately assessed the operating expenditure proposed by Essential Energy, whether the decision on the return on debt, and the estimated cost of corporate income tax were made in accordance with the applicable rules and whether any errors required the decision to be set aside and remitted. The applicants argued that the AER had failed to properly consider the operating expenditure criteria and had not adequately justified its decisions on return on debt and the estimated cost of corporate income tax.
The court found that the AER had indeed erred in its decisions regarding the operating expenditure, return on debt, and estimated cost of corporate income tax. The court held that the AER should reassess these components using a broader range of modelling, benchmarking against other Australian businesses, and conducting a “bottom up” review. The court also directed the AER to consider and adjust the Final Decision in other respects as it deemed appropriate. Consequently, the court set aside the Final Decision and remitted it to the AER for reconsideration in line with these directives.
The court’s final orders mandated that the Final Decision be set aside and returned to the AER for re-evaluation. The AER was directed to make new decisions on operating expenditure, return on debt, and the estimated cost of corporate income tax in accordance with the court’s reasons. Additionally, the AER was instructed to consider and potentially modify the Final Decision in other respects as it deemed necessary, ensuring alignment with the court’s guidance.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Pursuant to s 71P(2)(c) of the National Electricity Law, the Final Decision Essential Energy distribution determination 2015-16 to 2018-19, April 2015, including attachments (the Final Decision) is set aside and remitted to the Australian Energy Regulator (AER) to make the decision again in accordance with the following directions:
(a) the AER is to make the constituent decision on opex under r 6.12.1(4) of the National Electricity Rules in accordance with these reasons for decision including assessing whether the forecast opex proposed by the applicant reasonably reflects each of the operating expenditure criteria in r 6.5.6(c) of the National Electricity Rules including using a broader range of modelling, and benchmarking against Australian businesses, and including a “bottom up” review of Essential’s forecast operating expenditure;
(b) the AER is to make the constituent decision on return on debt in relation to the introduction of the trailing average approach in accordance with these reasons for decision;
(c) the AER is to make the constituent decision on estimated cost of corporate income tax (gamma) in accordance with these reasons for decision, including by reference to an estimated cost of corporate income tax based on a gamma of 0.25; and
(d) the AER is to consider, and to the extent to which it considers appropriate to vary the Final Decision in such other respects as the AER considers appropriate having regard to s 16(1)(d) of the National Electricity Law in the light of such variations as are made to the Final Decision by reason of (a)-(c) hereof.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi