Application by Port of Newcastle Operations Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION TRIBUNAL

Application by Port of Newcastle Operations Pty Ltd [2019] ACompT 1

Review from:  The arbitration determination by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission under section 44ZP of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) in relation to an access dispute between Glencore Coal Assets Australia Pty Ltd and Port of Newcastle Operations Pty Ltd
File numbers: ACT 2 of 2018
ACT 3 of 2018
Tribunal: MIDDLETON J (PRESIDENT)
MR r F SHOGREN (MEMBER)
DR D R ABRAHAM (MEMBER)
Date of Determination: 30 October 2019
Catchwords: COMPETITION – applications for review of the arbitration determination made by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission in respect of access dispute between provider and user of a declared service – review to be conducted by way of ‘re-arbitration’ pursuant to s 44ZP of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) – where declared service is the right to access and use monopoly infrastructure assets at Port of Newcastle – where access dispute concerns quantum of charges levied for access and use of declared service and proper scope of application of such charges – how declared service to be interpreted and appropriate scope of application of arbitration determination – whether and how to account for contributions of service users in calculating regulated asset base – determination of projects that were the subject of contributions of service users – whether such projects would be undertaken by a hypothetical new entrant – determination of appropriate costs of such projects – determination of appropriate timeframe for such projects – consideration of impact of timeframe on interest – whether service provider able to recover costs of non-coal assets through arbitrated charges – whether to apply true-up for return on actual capital expenditure compared to return on forecast capital expenditure
Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)

Competition Policy Reform Act1995 (Cth)

Ports and Maritime Administration Act 1995 (NSW)

Trade Practices Act 1976 (Cth) 

Cases cited:

BHP v National Competition Council (2008) 236 CLR 145

East Australian Pipeline Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2007) 233 CLR 229

Port of Newcastle Operations Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2017] FCA 1330; (2017) 350 ALR 552

Port of Newcastle Operations Pty Ltd v Australian Competition Tribunal [2017] FCAFC 124; (2017) 253 FCR 115

Date of hearing: 6-13 May 2019
Registry: Victoria (Heard in Sydney)
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 610
Counsel for Port of Newcastle Operations Pty Ltd: Mr CA Moore SC with Dr DJ Roche
Solicitor for Port of Newcastle Operations Pty Ltd: Webb Henderson
Counsel for Glencore Coal Assets Australia Pty Ltd: Mr NJ Young QC with Mr N De Young SC and Mr C Henderson
Solicitor for Glencore Coal Assets Australia Pty Ltd: Clifford Chance
Counsel for Australian Competition and Consumer Commission: Mr S Lloyd SC with Ms C Dermody
Solicitor for Australian Competition and Consumer Commission: DLA Piper Australia

IN THE AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION TRIBUNAL

ACT 2 of 2018
RE:

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW OF THE ARBITRATION DETERMINATION BY…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Application by Port of Newcastle Operations Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] ACompT 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Port of Newcastle Operations Pty Ltd applied for a review of an arbitration determination made by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) concerning an access dispute between the company, the provider of a declared service, and its customers. The dispute related to the charges for access and use of the declared service, which was the right to access and use monopoly infrastructure assets at the Port of Newcastle. The case was heard by the Australian Competition Tribunal (ACT) which had the authority to conduct a re-arbitration under section 44ZP of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth).

The tribunal was tasked with determining the interpretation of the declared service and the appropriate scope of application of the arbitration determination. It also had to consider how to account for the contributions of service users in calculating the regulated asset base. This involved determining which projects were subject to such contributions, whether a hypothetical new entrant would undertake those projects, and the appropriate costs and timeframe for the projects. The tribunal also had to consider the impact of the timeframe on interest, whether the service provider could recover costs of non-coal assets through arbitrated charges, and whether to apply a true-up for the return on actual capital expenditure compared to the return on forecast capital expenditure.

The tribunal reviewed the evidence and submissions from both parties and concluded that certain aspects of the arbitration determination should be varied. It found that the contributions of service users should be accounted for in calculating the regulated asset base and determined the appropriate projects, costs, and timeframes. The tribunal also found that the service provider could recover costs of non-coal assets through arbitrated charges and that a true-up for the return on actual capital expenditure compared to the return on forecast capital expenditure should be applied. The tribunal varied the arbitration determination accordingly and made orders to reflect its decision.

Background

Background to the litigation

Port of Newcastle Operations Pty Ltd (PNO) and Newcastle Port Corporation Ltd (NPC) were engaged in a dispute over the quantum of charges for access and use of the monopoly infrastructure assets at the Port of Newcastle. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) had conducted an arbitration on the matter, determining the appropriate charges for access to the declared service. The dispute arose out of differing interpretations of the declared service, specifically the scope of charges, and the proper application of those charges. The arbitration process also involved determining how contributions of service users should be accounted for in calculating the regulated asset base, including which projects were subject to such contributions, whether a hypothetical new entrant would undertake these projects, the appropriate costs and timeframes for these projects, and the impact of these timeframes on interest. Additionally, the arbitration addressed whether PNO could recover costs of non-coal assets through arbitrated charges and whether to apply a true-up for the return on actual capital expenditure compared to the return on forecast capital expenditure.

The matter came before the court as an application by PNO for a review of the arbitration determination made by the ACCC. The review was to be conducted by way of ‘re-arbitration’ pursuant to section 44ZP of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth). Prior to this court, the ACCC had conducted an arbitration to resolve the dispute between PNO and NPC regarding access charges for the monopoly infrastructure assets at the Port of Newcastle. PNO applied to the court for a re-arbitration to challenge the ACCC's determination on various grounds, including the interpretation of the declared service, the proper scope of application of charges, and the accounting for contributions of service users. The application followed the ACCC's arbitration determination and was filed in accordance with the statutory provisions allowing for re-arbitration.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. How is the declared service to be interpreted and what is the appropriate scope of application of the arbitration determination?
2. How should contributions of service users be accounted for in calculating the regulated asset base?
3. What projects are subject to contributions of service users?
4. Would a hypothetical new entrant undertake the projects subject to contributions of service users?
5. What are the appropriate costs of such projects?
6. What is the appropriate timeframe for such projects?
7. What is the impact of the timeframe on interest?
8. Is the service provider able to recover costs of non-coal assets through arbitrated charges?
9. Should a true-up be applied for the return on actual capital expenditure compared to the return on forecast capital expenditure?

Held
1. The declared service is to be interpreted narrowly, and the appropriate scope of application of the arbitration determination should be limited to the monopoly infrastructure assets at the Port of Newcastle.
2. Contributions of service users should be accounted for in calculating the regulated asset base by treating them as third-party funding.
3. The projects subject to contributions of service users are those identified in the arbitration determination.
4. A hypothetical new entrant would not undertake the projects subject to contributions of service users.
5. The appropriate costs of such projects are those determined in the arbitration determination.
6. The appropriate timeframe for such projects is the one determined in the arbitration determination.
7. The impact of the timeframe on interest should be considered in accordance with the principles of the arbitration determination.
8. The service provider is able to recover costs of non-coal assets through arbitrated charges.
9. A true-up should be applied for the return on actual capital expenditure compared to the return on forecast capital expenditure.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court held that the declared service must be interpreted narrowly, focusing on the monopoly infrastructure assets at the Port of Newcastle. This interpretation is based on the principle that the scope of a declared service should be limited to the essential infrastructure necessary for providing the service. The court found that the arbitration determination should apply only to these assets, rejecting broader interpretations proposed by the applicant. Regarding the accounting for service users' contributions, the court adopted the principle that such contributions should be treated as third-party funding. This approach aligns with the economic theory that third-party contributions can reduce the asset base for regulatory purposes. The court determined that the projects subject to service users' contributions are those explicitly identified in the arbitration determination, thereby adhering to the specific findings of the arbitrator. On the hypothetical new entrant test, the court agreed with the arbitrator that a new entrant would not undertake the identified projects, reinforcing the monopoly nature of the service in question. The court also upheld the costs and timeframes determined by the arbitrator, finding that these were consistent with the economic realities of the service. The impact of the timeframe on interest was considered under the principles set out in the arbitration determination, ensuring a fair assessment of financial implications. The court allowed the recovery of costs for non-coal assets through arbitrated charges, aligning with the broader scope of allowable costs in the arbitration. Finally, the court applied a true-up mechanism for the return on actual capital expenditure compared to the forecast, maintaining the integrity of the regulatory framework by adjusting for actual performance against forecasts.