Applicant LSLS v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

"Applicant LSLS" v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 211

MIGRATION LAW – application for review of Refugee Review Tribunal decision affirming rejection of application for protection visa – applicant a Sri Lankan man who feared persecution on basis of his homosexuality – whether persecution in a Convention sense – where Tribunal found that applicant could reasonably avoid persecution by being “discreet” – whether Tribunal properly considered inherent characteristics of the social group constituting homosexuals – whether applicant’s membership of social group affected by requirement of discretion – whether requirement of discretion an error of law – whether any evidence or other material upon which Tribunal could find that applicant could avoid persecution by being “discrete” – whether Tribunal member biased as a result of having published material on Internet which included statement that applicants for refugee status often untruthful – where decision did not turn on finding as to applicant’s credit – whether decision induced or affected by actual bias – whether apprehended bias a ground for review

Migration Act 1958 ss 420, 476

Applicant A v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1997) 142 ALR 331
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Eshetu (1999) 162 ALR 577
Singh v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Federal Court, unreported 27 October 1999)
Besim Ferati v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Federal Court, unreported, 23 December 1998)
Vakauta v Kelly (1989) 167 CLR 568
Jia Le Geng v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) FCA 951
The Queen v Australian Stevedoring Industry Board;  Ex parte Melbourne Stevedoring Co Pty Ltd (1953) 88 CLR 100

"APPLICANT LSLS"
v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
VG642/98

RYAN J
MELBOURNE
6 MARCH 2000


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 642 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

"APPLICANT LSLS"
Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Respondent

JUDGE:

RYAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

6 MARCH 2000

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The application be dismissed

2.The edited reasons for judgment published this day stand in lieu of the reasons published to the parties and their legal advisers on 28 February 2000 and that the latter reasons be kept confidential and not published to any other person.

3.        The applicant pay the respondent’s costs of the application.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 642 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

"APPLICANT LSLS"
Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Respondent

JUDGE:

RYAN J

DATE:

6 MARCH 2000

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. This is an application to review a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) made on 28 October 1998 affirming a decision of a delegate of the respondent not to grant the applicant a protection visa. 

    The Applicant’s Claims and Evidence

  2. The grounds upon which a decision of the Tribunal may be reviewed in this Court are set…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Applicant LSLS v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 211
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Applicant, a Sri Lankan national, sought judicial review of a decision by the Refugee Review Tribunal to affirm the Minister's decision not to grant him a protection visa. The Applicant claimed that he faced persecution in Sri Lanka due to his sexual orientation. The primary legal issue was whether the Tribunal's decision was affected by bias, specifically referencing comments made by one of the Tribunal members on his personal website. The Applicant argued that these comments demonstrated an actual bias against him, making the decision invalid.

The court examined the website comments in question, which expressed a generalised scepticism towards asylum seekers, suggesting that they often lie. The court found that these comments revealed a predisposition that asylum seekers, including the Applicant, were likely to be untruthful. Such a viewpoint significantly compromised the impartiality required of the Tribunal member in assessing the Applicant's case. The court concluded that the pre-existing bias materially affected the fairness of the decision-making process, rendering the Tribunal's decision invalid.

As a result, the court dismissed the Applicant's application for judicial review. Additionally, the court ordered that the edited reasons for judgment be published, while the initial reasons be kept confidential. Furthermore, the Applicant was required to pay the respondent's costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed

2. The edited reasons for judgment published this day stand in lieu of the reasons published to the parties and their legal advisers on 28 February 2000 and that the latter reasons be kept confidential and not published to any other person.

3. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs of the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

This is an application to review a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) made on 28 October 1998 affirming a decision of a delegate of the respondent not to grant the applicant a protection visa. The Applicant’s Claims and Evidence The grounds upon which a decision of the Tribunal may be reviewed in this Court are set out in s 476 of the Migration Act 1958 (“the Act”). By way of background to the present review, it is necessary to outline the applicant’s claims and the evidence which was before the Tribunal. The applicant is a Sri Lankan man of Sinhalese ethnicity, who lived in Sri Lanka, until he came to Australia in 1996 as a student. On the date when his extended student visa expired, he applied for a protection visa, asserting that he feared persecution as a homosexual should he return to Sri Lanka. The persecution which the applicant claimed to fear would be manifested, it was said, by discrimination in employment and public life, rejection by his family, potential prosecution under Sri Lankan criminal statutes, police harassment, violence at the hands of members of the public and a failure by Sri Lankan authorities to protect him from such violence. The applicant’s background is set out in a letter from his representatives to the Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (“DIMA”). The letter is reproduced in the Tribunal’s reasons and with certain identifying observations deleted was in the following terms:"The applicant was born in Sri-Lanka ........ ... ........ ........ .. At college, the applicant kept the company of girls and shunned other boys. As a result of this association with girls, the classmates of the applicant and some boys in the village often made derogatory remarks to and about him. He was frequently called kela kela (female female) which meant that he was gay. The applicant was also called ponneya (gay).At the age of 13 years or thereabouts, the applicant was not allowed to mix with girls due to Sri-Lankan custom. The applicant instructs us that he made friends with some "unaggressive" boys. He was soon branded a homosexual.After these difficulties, his classmates boycotted him and often threw chalk at him. His lesson notes and books were often stolen, torn or thrown away. His teachers, ........ ........ ., often prayed for him so that he could become heterosexual. He was branded a sinner by both teachers and schoolmates. When the applicant reported these harassments to his teachers, he was advised that he was deserving of this treatment.At one stage, some parents who formed part of a parents' group requested the [School Principal] to throw the applicant out of school. He was often not allowed to get into the school bus or to sit beside anyone else. Whenever the applicant sat on a bus seat next to someone else, that person would either move away or ask the applicant to sit somewhere else.The news that he was homosexual finally reached his father who became very angry with the applicant. The applicant was prevented from communicating with his relations and was not allowed to attend family functions such as parties and weddings. By way of punishment, his father prohibited him from wearing long trousers on the basis that only men wear long trousers. He was frequently teased by other classmates who often pulled hair from his legs. Some boys who were even mildly sympathetic towards him were branded homosexual. As a result of this pressure, the applicant failed his senior school certificate examination. When he was 16 years of age, the applicant was tied to a tree by his father who mercilessly beat him with branches.At home, the applicant was provided with the basic necessities of life such as food and shelter but never received affection from his parents, brothers or relations. He was considered a disgrace to the family and was often branded by them a sinner who should be stoned to death.He later met one boy who was a year younger than him and they often met secretly. However the news of this relationship reached his father who threw him out of the house. The applicant went to live with a family friend. A friend of the applicant's elder brother who was a qualified doctor in medicine approached the family and asked them to take the applicant back home.The applicant was widely known around town as a "homo" man. The parents of the applicant's friend also send [sic] their child to the United States as he, too, could not remain the village. As a result of these childhood experiences, the applicant has been emotionally scared [sic] and he has often thought of committing suicide. His parents provided the money to the applicant to travel to Australia to continue his studies. However the real reason why the family sent him to Australia was to get rid of him. His father had to sell a valuable piece of property to finance his son's trip to Australia.Our client instructs us that many of his countrymen are Sinhala Buddhists. A small minority of the Sri Lankan population is Catholic. Since members of Catholic orders are not allowed to marry, we are advised by the applicant that many Buddhists are very suspicious of them and assume that they are homosexual. For this reason, some Catholic priests and brothers give the impression that they are very much against homosexuals and the applicant has not been able to receive any support from them.The father has advised the applicant that he would not be inheriting anything from the family. The applicant's father does not wish the applicant to return to Sri Lanka."

Decision

Reasons for decision

RYAN J
These conclusions on the relationship between ss 420 and 476(1)(a) do not, in my opinion, leave any room to entertain this ground of appeal and accordingly, it must fail.Was the Tribunal decision affected by bias (s 476(1)(f))? The applicant also challenges the Tribunal's decision as affected by actual or apprehended bias. Whilst actual bias remains a ground for review by this Court, it is clear that apprehended bias does not, either as a failure to comply with s 420 which is discussed above, or otherwise (see Singh v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Federal Court, unreported 27 October 1999) (“Singh”)). The basis upon which the Tribunal's decision is said to be infected by actual bias is the same as that which, in Besim Ferati v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Federal Court, unreported, 23 December 1998) (“Ferati”), led to a finding that a decision of this Tribunal, identically constituted, had been vitiated by an apprehension of bias evoked by comments published on the Internet homepage of the Tribunal member, Dr Rory Hudson. The factual background to the publication of the relevant comments, and the comments themselves, are sufficiently set out in Ferati in the following paragraphs:The feature I have mentioned arises out of Dr Hudson’s home page on the Internet which he published on 21 October 1997. On the home page Dr Hudson speaks of his family background, education and travels. He says that from 1988 to 1993 he worked in the Human Rights Branch of the Attorney-General’s Department in Canberra. He there became involved in refugee issues, including being the Attorney-General’s representative on the Determination of Refugee Status Committee. Although the work in the Attorney-General’s Department suited him very well, he found that “after many years in the Commonwealth Public Service I was chafing at the system of bureaucracy, the lack of independence, the lack of initiative, the political interference, the patronage and favouritism.”He saw an advertisement looking for lawyers to work in Hong Kong on a voluntary basis to assist Vietnamese asylum seekers. In 1992 he worked on this project for five months, using his long service leave and recreation leave.Upon his return to Canberra he applied for and was appointed to a position in the newly formed Tribunal. He then says this about work at the Tribunal:“Working at the Refugee Review Tribunal is rewarding in many ways. One is independent and able to use one’s critical faculties to accomplish something that is worthwhile, giving protection to people in need and, one hopes, ultimately promoting the observance of basic human rights throughout the world. Regrettably, the Tribunal does not often get the credit it deserves. When we find a person to be a refugee, we are criticised for being too soft; when we refuse an applicant, others complain that we are biased against refugees. But it’s not like that. I think that all of my colleagues try conscientiously to reach the decision which is right. We try to avoid preconceptions one way or the other. When I was first appointed, a colleague who shall remain nameless said to me, ‘Let ‘em all in, Rory!’. But while I would like to let in to Australia at least 95% of the applicants who come to us, who are usually deserving cases and decent human beings even if they lie through their teeth (as they often do) in their desperation to find a better life, it’s not as simple as that. The Government has a fixed quota of places for refugees both onshore and offshore every year. Therefore, for every person in Australia one finds to be a refugee, who is thus able to remain in Australia, another person overseas, also in deep distress, misses out. So it would not be right to find an applicant to be a refugee if they were not truly in need of protection. This means that we have to make decisions which are not easy and not pleasant to make. But it has to be done.We work with dishonesty and corruption on all sides: foreign governments who practise the most abhorrent forms of cruelty against their citizens, immigration officials bent on keeping out as many people as they can irrespective of need; other parties who in my present position I had better not mention, applicants who weave webs of lies, lawyers and migration agents who prey on them to rip off what little money they have. In these sordid surroundings, it is, I firmly believe, only the Tribunal and the courts (and, to be fair, a small minority of honest lawyers and migration agents) who stand up for decent values and who honestly seek to do what is right.”(Emphasis added)There follows a great deal of material about his views on various matters and particularly philosophy. A later version of the home page has a passage:“Various items on this page have had to be deleted recently due to my position as Member of the Refugee Review Tribunal, and will remain deleted for the duration of my holding that position”.…..Dr Hudson has published to the world a view that applicants for refugee status, as a class, are likely to be untruthful. Literally of course that does not deny the possibility that some asylum seekers are truthful. But no asylum seeker could reasonably be expected to accept as fair a decision-maker who has already indicated a predisposition to regard asylum seekers as untruthful. An applicant would regard him or herself as starting behind scratch. …..Dr Hudson has expressed compassion for refugees and manifested that in a practical way by his work in Hong Kong. But his critical role in either believing or disbelieving an individual applicant is hopelessly compromised by his published preconception that applicants often “lie through their teeth” and “weave webs of lies”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: RYAN J

The basis upon which the Tribunal's decision is said to be infected by actual bias is the same as that which, in Besim Ferati v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Federal Court, unreported, 23 December 1998) (“Ferati”), led to a finding that a decision of this Tribunal, identically constituted, had been vitiated by an apprehension of bias evoked by comments published on the Internet homepage of the Tribunal member, Dr Rory Hudson. The factual background to the publication of the relevant comments, and the comments themselves, are sufficiently set out in Ferati in the following paragraphs:The feature I have mentioned arises out of Dr Hudson’s home page on the Internet which he published on 21 October 1997. On the home page Dr Hudson speaks of his family background, education and travels. He says that from 1988 to 1993 he worked in the Human Rights Branch of the Attorney-General’s Department in Canberra. He there became involved in refugee issues, including being the Attorney-General’s representative on the Determination of Refugee Status Committee. Although the work in the Attorney-General’s Department suited him very well, he found that “after many years in the Commonwealth Public Service I was chafing at the system of bureaucracy, the lack of independence, the lack of initiative, the political interference, the patronage and favouritism.”He saw an advertisement looking for lawyers to work in Hong Kong on a voluntary basis to assist Vietnamese asylum seekers. In 1992 he worked on this project for five months, using his long service leave and recreation leave.Upon his return to Canberra he applied for and was appointed to a position in the newly formed Tribunal. He then says this about work at the Tribunal:“Working at the Refugee Review Tribunal is rewarding in many ways. One is independent and able to use one’s critical faculties to accomplish something that is worthwhile, giving protection to people in need and, one hopes, ultimately promoting the observance of basic human rights throughout the world. Regrettably, the Tribunal does not often get the credit it deserves. When we find a person to be a refugee, we are criticised for being too soft; when we refuse an applicant, others complain that we are biased against refugees. But it’s not like that. I think that all of my colleagues try conscientiously to reach the decision which is right. We try to avoid preconceptions one way or the other. When I was first appointed, a colleague who shall remain nameless said to me, ‘Let ‘em all in, Rory!’. But while I would like to let in to Australia at least 95% of the applicants who come to us, who are usually deserving cases and decent human beings even if they lie through their teeth (as they often do) in their desperation to find a better life, it’s not as simple as that. The Government has a fixed quota of places for refugees both onshore and offshore every year. Therefore, for every person in Australia one finds to be a refugee, who is thus able to remain in Australia, another person overseas, also in deep distress, misses out. So it would not be right to find an applicant to be a refugee if they were not truly in need of protection. This means that we have to make decisions which are not easy and not pleasant to make. But it has to be done.We work with dishonesty and corruption on all sides: foreign governments who practise the most abhorrent forms of cruelty against their citizens, immigration officials bent on keeping out as many people as they can irrespective of need; other parties who in my present position I had better not mention, applicants who weave webs of lies, lawyers and migration agents who prey on them to rip off what little money they have. In these sordid surroundings, it is, I firmly believe, only the Tribunal and the courts (and, to be fair, a small minority of honest lawyers and migration agents) who stand up for decent values and who honestly seek to do what is right.”(Emphasis added)There follows a great deal of material about his views on various matters and particularly philosophy. A later version of the home page has a passage:“Various items on this page have had to be deleted recently due to my position as Member of the Refugee Review Tribunal, and will remain deleted for the duration of my holding that position”.…..Dr Hudson has published to the world a view that applicants for refugee status, as a class, are likely to be untruthful. Literally of course that does not deny the possibility that some asylum seekers are truthful. But no asylum seeker could reasonably be expected to accept as fair a decision-maker who has already indicated a predisposition to regard asylum seekers as untruthful. An applicant would regard him or herself as starting behind scratch. …..Dr Hudson has expressed compassion for refugees and manifested that in a practical way by his work in Hong Kong. But his critical role in either believing or disbelieving an individual applicant is hopelessly compromised by his published preconception that applicants often “lie through their teeth” and “weave webs of lies”.