APIR Systems Limited v Donald Financial Enterprises Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

APIR Systems Limited v Donald Financial Enterprises Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 1448

Australian Securities and Investment Commission Act 2001 (Cth), s 12DA, s 12GM
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 1041E, 1041H, 1041I, 1325(1), 1325(5)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), s 82, s 87

Donald Financial Enterprises Pty Ltd v APIR Systems Ltd [2008] FCA 1112 related
Alexander v Cambridge Credit Corp Ltd (1985) 2 NSWLR 685 followed
Kalifair Pty Ltd v Digi-Tech (Australia) Ltd; McLean Tecnic Pty Ltd v Digi-Tech (Aust) Ltd (2002) 55 NSWLR 737 distinguished
Philip Morris (Australia) Ltd v Nixon [1999] FCA 1281 followed

APIR SYSTEMS LIMITED ACN 081 044 957, ANDREW WILLIAM HUTCHINGS BROSO, ANDREW JOSEPH RILEY, MAUREEN CANE, NOEL FRANCIS WICKS and DAVID MCGREGOR v DONALD FINANCIAL ENTERPRISES PTY LTD ACN 083 141 628 AS TRUSTEE FOR THE ELYSUM TRUST

NSD 1306 of 2008

FOSTER J
23 SEPTEMBER 2008
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1306 of 2008

ON APPEAL FROM A SINGLE JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

APIR SYSTEMS LIMITED ACN 081 044 957
First Appellant

ANDREW WILLIAM HUTCHINGS BROSO
Second Appellant

ANDREW JOSEPH RILEY
Third Appellant

MAUREEN CANE
Fourth Appellant

NOEL FRANCIS WICKS
Fifth Appellant

DAVID MCGREGOR
Sixth Appellant

AND:

DONALD FINANCIAL ENTERPRISES PTY LTD ACN 083 141 628 AS TRUSTEE FOR THE ELYSUM TRUST
Respondent

JUDGE:

FOSTER J

DATE OF ORDER:

23 SEPTEMBER 2008

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Notice of Motion filed by the appellants on 21 August 2008 be dismissed.

2.The appellants pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to that Notice of Motion.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1306 of 2008

ON APPEAL FROM A SINGLE JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

APIR SYSTEMS LIMITED ACN 081 044 957
First Appellant

ANDREW WILLIAM HUTCHINGS BROSO
Second Appellant

ANDREW JOSEPH RILEY
Third Appellant

MAUREEN CANE
Fourth Appellant

NOEL FRANCIS WICKS
Fifth Appellant

DAVID MCGREGOR
Sixth Appellant

AND:

DONALD FINANCIAL ENTERPRISES PTY LTD ACN 083 141 628 AS TRUSTEE FOR THE ELYSUM TRUST
Respondent

JUDGE:

FOSTER J

DATE:

23 SEPTEMBER 2008

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

THE PRESENT APPLICATION

  1. The appellants have applied by way of Notice of Motion for a stay of final orders made by Edmonds J on 30 July 2008 pending the hearing of their appeal from those orders. 

  2. The orders which his Honour made on 30 July 2008 were in the following terms:

    THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

    1.The Share Subscription Deed between the first respondent, the applicant and the first cross-respondent dated 23 January 2004 is void ab initio.

    THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

    2.The first respondent forthwith refunds to the applicant the subscription price of the 200,000 shares in the first respondent for which the applicant applied and subscribed.

    3.If the first respondent is unable for any reason beyond its control…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read APIR Systems Limited v Donald Financial Enterprises Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 1448
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In APIR Systems Limited v Donald Financial Enterprises Pty Ltd, the appellants sought to have orders made by the trial judge set aside and the respondent's claim dismissed with costs. Alternatively, they sought to modify the orders regarding interest and costs. The appellants argued that they had attempted to comply with certain orders by tendering cheques to the respondent, but the respondent refused to accept them. The respondent maintained its position that it would only accept the cheques if the appellants abandoned their appeal and agreed to certain conditions regarding the transfer of shares, interest, and costs. The court was tasked with determining whether the appellants' actions were appropriate given their pending appeal and the respondent's refusal to accept the cheques.

The court considered the appellants' prospects on appeal and whether the Amended Notice of Appeal contained sufficient grounds to support their submissions. The court was not convinced that the trial judge's approach to damages and relief was flawed and found the appellants' arguments regarding disclosure and liability to be problematic. The court also found the argument that the offer made by the appellants constituted a satisfactory Calderbank offer to be strained and difficult. The court concluded that the appellants' prospects on appeal were weak and that their actions in tendering the cheques without accepting the respondent's conditions were not appropriate.

The court dismissed the Notice of Motion filed by the appellants and ordered them to pay the respondent's costs of and incidental to that Notice of Motion. The court found that the appellants' actions were not justified given their weak prospects on appeal and the respondent's reasonable position in refusing to accept the cheques without agreement on certain conditions. The court's decision upheld the respondent's position and reinforced the importance of adhering to court orders and engaging in good faith negotiations to resolve disputes.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Notice of Motion filed by the appellants on 21 August 2008 be dismissed.

2. The appellants pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to that Notice of Motion.

Background

Background to the litigation

APIR Systems Limited and Donald Financial Enterprises Pty Ltd were involved in a legal dispute that originated from a transaction involving the purchase and sale of shares. On 30 July 2008, Edmonds J made several orders in favour of Donald Financial Enterprises Pty Ltd, including orders for the transfer of shares and payment of money. APIR Systems Limited, the appellants, sought to appeal these orders, arguing for a stay of execution or alternative orders regarding interest and costs. The appellants tendered two bank cheques to the respondent, Donald Financial Enterprises Pty Ltd, to partially comply with the orders, but the respondent refused to accept them. The dispute also involved post-judgment conduct, where the appellants attempted to transfer shares to a nominee without the respondent's agreement.

The case originated from orders made by Edmonds J on 30 July 2008, which the appellants sought to appeal. The appellants filed a Notice of Appeal and subsequently a Notice of Motion seeking a stay of the orders or alternative orders concerning interest and costs. The appellants tendered two cheques to the respondent to partially comply with the orders, which the respondent refused to accept. The proceedings continued with various applications and correspondence between the parties, including a letter from the respondent's solicitor outlining conditions under which the respondent would agree to a transfer of shares pending the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FOSTER J
In the Amended Notice of Appeal, the appellants seek to have all of the orders made by Edmonds J on 30 July 2008 set aside and the respondent’s claim dismissed with costs. In the alternative, they seek to set aside the orders made by Edmonds J in respect of interest and costs and to substitute for those orders orders in the following terms:4(b). … (i). An order that the Respondent/(Applicant at trial) pay the Appellants’ costs of the Respondent’s claim on:1. An indemnity basis; or alternatively2. A party-party basis: or alternatively3. The basis that each party pay their own costs of the Respondent’s claim; or alternatively4. A reduced, proportional or other basisfrom 27 March 2007 or such other time or basis as this Court considers just;(ii).An order that the First, Second and Third Appellants/(First, Second and Third Respondents at trial) pay the Respondent’s/(Applicant’s at trial) prejudgment interest up to and including 27 March 2007 only.SOME RELEVANT POST JUDGMENT MATTERS Under cover of a letter dated 22 August 2008, the appellants tendered to the respondent two bank cheques – one for $530,000 and the other for $217,045.60. The appellants contend that they have thus attempted to comply with orders 2, 3, 4, and 5 of the final orders made by Edmonds J on 30 July 2008. In the letter, under cover of which those cheques were tendered, the solicitor for the appellants said:Upon receipt of these cheques, kindly complete and return to our client APIR Systems Ltd the properly executed instruments of transfer for 281,904 shares pursuant to orders 4 and 5. APIR directs that all the shares be transferred to Dalton Consultants Pty Limited ABN 86 052 406 309, PO Box 3798 Weston ACT 2611, 15–25 Trenerry Street, Weston ACT 2611. Kindly ensure that this information is correctly transcribed as necessary on the transfer documents you return to APIR for completion.Finally, as you are aware, an appeal has been filed in this matter. This payment now is made without prejudice to our clients’ appeal. The respondent did not accept the tender of those cheques. In a letter dated 25 August 2008 from the solicitor for the respondent to the solicitor for the appellants, the solicitor for the respondent said: Apart from the inherent conflict in your clients’ actions in seeking simultaneously to stay all of the orders made by Justice Edmonds and to selectively enforce such of those orders which appear to suit your clients’ tactical and commercial interests, this approach appears to be one designed to maximise the prejudice to my client's interests whatever the outcome of the appeal.Your clients’ offer involves our client agreeing to the transfer of these shares to your clients' nominee. We assume the nominee is a third party. In the normal course, if your client were to succeed in the appeal, each party would need to make restitution. That restitution would involve:1. my client refunding the $747,045.60 (and also perhaps interest); and2. the shares being returned to my client.Otherwise, the parties are not returned to the position they would have been in had the orders made by the Full Court on appeal (assuming your clients are successful) been made at first instance.We understand that such restitution would not be possible in view of the proposed transfer of these shares being to a third party.Accordingly, there are significant and difficult issues that would need to be resolved if restitution was not possible by the return of these shares to our client.My client does wish to enforce all of the orders of Justice Edmonds without limitation. It is not willing to be in a position where it only receives back what was paid 4½ years ago without any compensation for the loss of the use of that money for that period of time, in return for the shares. Otherwise, if your client were to succeed on the appeal, my client would be arguably in the worst position.Also if my client succeeds in the appeal it would be left chasing the balance of the orders with the prejudice of delay imperilling the recovery of interest and costs. My client does not trust your clients. This is a reasonable position for it to take in view of the findings of Justice Edmonds.My client, however, would be willing to agree to a transfer of the shares pending the appeal upon the following basis:1.your client abandon its application for a stay of the orders of Justice Edmonds or any part thereof;2.my client be paid in full the original purchase price of $747,045.60 plus interest in accordance with the orders of the Court calculated up to the time the money is paid;3.there be an agreement between the parties that in the event of your client succeeding on the appeal:(a)it would not be under any obligation to return the shares to our client;(b)at the same time, your client would not be entitled to any refund of the abovementioned sums (the original purchase price of $747,045.60 plus interest);4.my client agrees and undertakes not to pursue any of the orders with respect to costs until the reasons for judgment on the appeal are published by the Full Court.Alternatively, my client will await the outcome of the Court’s determination of your client's application for a stay.In these circumstances, and consistent with the reasons outlined in this letter, the two bank cheques totalling $747,045.60 which were enclosed with your letter dated 22 August 2008 are returned herewith.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FOSTER J

In my view, the present case can be distinguished from the circumstances before the Court in Kalifair 55 NSWLR 737.CONSIDERATION AND CONCLUSIONS In my view, the appellants’ prospects on appeal are weak. I express this view as a tentative or preliminary view and only for the purpose of giving appropriate weight to those prospects when considering the present application. Further, I am not convinced that the Amended Notice of Appeal contains a ground of appeal which supports Mr Bennett’s submission concerning his Honour’s reasoning in respect of damages and relief generally. Ground 8 seems to raise a different point and no other ground of appeal seems apt to cover the matter. In any event, I think that there is real difficulty with the proposition that his Honour approached his consideration of the appropriate relief to be granted in the present case upon the basis that, were damages to be awarded, those damages would be expectation damages. His Honour’s remarks at [188] of his Reasons (Donald Financial Enterprises Pty Ltd v APIR Systems Ltd [2008] FCA 1112) have to be read in context and in light of the arguments advanced to his Honour by the appellants at trial. It must be remembered that his Honour did not award damages to the respondent but, rather, reversed the transactions. His Honour did so because his Honour also held that any assessment of loss or damage which involved the respondent keeping the shares was “… exceedingly difficult, if not impossible” (see Donald Financial Enterprises Pty Ltd v APIR Systems Ltd [2008] FCA 1112 at [190]). The second ground of appeal developed by Mr Bennett in his oral submissions depends upon the appellants persuading the Full Court of two propositions. First, they will have to demonstrate that, within the bundle of papers offered to Mr Sharp but declined by him, there was material which amounted to appropriate and sufficient disclosure of that which his Honour found had not been disclosed. Second, they will have to persuade the Full Court that Mr Sharp’s decision not to look at the material tendered to him operated in some way to relieve the appellants from liability. Both of these propositions are problematic. The final grounds of appeal developed by Mr Bennett in his oral submissions concerned his Honour’s discretionary orders in respect of interest and costs. Much will turn upon the Full Court’s evaluation of the letter dated 27 March 2007. The offer contained in that letter did not address the payment of interest or the costs of the proceedings. The offer was made on behalf of unidentified persons or entities who were not parties to the litigation. Mr Bennett submitted that the respondent could have accepted the offer and gone back to the Court to argue about interest and costs. In this way, Mr Bennett sought to advance an argument that the offer made constituted, in substance, a satisfactory (albeit informal) Calderbank offer. My present view is that this is an extremely difficult argument, based as it is on a somewhat strained interpretation of the letter.