SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil)
ANZ BANKING GROUP LTD v WILLIAMS & ANOR; ANZ BANKING GROUP LTD v WILLSMORE & ANOR
[2012] SASC 2
Reasons for the Order of Judge Lunn a Master of the Supreme Court
16 January 2012
REAL PROPERTY
Application under Part 17 of Real Property Act 1886 by mortgagee against mortgagors for order for possession of premises - tenant of mortgagors in occupation of premises - whether Residential Tenancies Tribunal has exclusive jurisdiction to deal with such a claim for possession - held where claimant for possession is a mortgagee, and not a landlord, Supreme Court has jurisdiction - order for possession made.
ANZ BANKING GROUP LTD v WILLIAMS & ANOR; ANZ BANKING GROUP LTD v WILLSMORE & ANOR
[2012] SASC 2JUDGE LUNN:
Reasons on mortgagees’ applications for possession
In Action SCCIV-11-1572 in this Court the plaintiff seeks an order for the possession of premises at 19 Acacia Road, Morphett Vale, under Part 17 of the Real Property Act 1886 (“the RPA”) and 6R 204. The named defendants are the registered proprietors of that property. They have mortgaged it to the plaintiff and are in default in their obligations under the mortgage. When served with the Summons and supporting documents on 26 October 2011 the defendants informed the process server that a woman and her children were in occupation of the premises under a Residential Tenancy Agreement.
In Action SCCIV-11-1582 in this Court the plaintiff seeks similar orders in respect to a property at Normanville.[1] The defendants in this action have also mortgaged that property to the plaintiff and are in default in their obligations under that mortgage. Upon service of the Summons on 29 October 2011 the defendants informed the process server that a sister of the second defendant was in occupation of the Normanville property.
[1] The order is also sought in respect of another property, but there is no suggestion that that property is tenanted.
In both actions there is no cogent evidence before me about whether there is currently a tenant in occupation of the subject properties pursuant to a tenancy agreement to which the Residential Tenancies Act 1995 (“the RTA”) applies. However, for the purpose of the argument, the plaintiff’s counsel conceded that I should proceed on the basis that there were tenants in occupation under Residential Tenancy Agreements to which the RTA applied.
In neither action has any defendant, tenant or occupant of the properties responded to the Court as required by the Summonses and notices served upon them. Hence, there has been no contradictor to oppose the orders sought by the plaintiff.
By virtue of 6RR 203 and 204(1) both actions seek orders in rem for possession of the subject properties. This means that subject to any further orders made by the Court, if a warrant of possession is executed by the Sheriff over a property pursuant to any order for possession made by the Court, the Sheriff will evict from that property any persons…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read ANZ Banking Group Ltd v WILLIAMS; ANZ Banking Group Ltd v Wi... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] SASC 2
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the jurisdiction of both the Supreme Court and the Tribunal, concluding that the Tribunal's jurisdiction was not exclusive when the claimant to possession was a mortgagee, rather than a landlord. The court held that the Tribunal could only hear possession applications from landlords, not from mortgagees, and that the Residential Tenancies Act did not grant the Tribunal the right to make possession orders on behalf of non-landlords. Furthermore, the court found that the Tribunal's exclusive jurisdiction, as provided by section 24(1)(a) of the Act, did not extend to all claims for possession of residential premises, as the Act itself referred to both court and Tribunal orders for possession. The court also rejected the argument that the Real Property Act took precedence over the Residential Tenancies Act, as it was not necessary to determine this point. Consequently, the court ruled that the existence of a residential tenancy did not affect the Supreme Court's jurisdiction to make an order for possession in favour of the mortgagee.
The court made orders for possession of the properties in favour of ANZ Banking Group Ltd on 9 January 2012, allowing the bank to enforce its rights under the mortgage and obtain possession of the properties from the defendants and their tenants.
Background
Background to the litigation
The key facts are that the Williams and Willsmores mortgaged properties to ANZ and defaulted on the mortgages, there were tenants in occupation of the properties under residential tenancy agreements, and ANZ sought orders for possession of the properties under the Real Property Act. The central issue was whether the court or the Residential Tenancies Tribunal had jurisdiction to make possession orders when a mortgagee, not the landlord, was the claimant. The court ultimately found in favour of ANZ's jurisdiction to seek possession orders.
The matter before the Supreme Court of South Australia was an application by ANZ Banking Group Ltd (the plaintiff) seeking an order for possession of two residential properties, both mortgaged to the plaintiff by the respective defendants who were in default of their obligations. The properties were located at 19 Acacia Road, Morphett Vale, and at Normanville. In both actions, the plaintiff sought orders under Part 17 of the Real Property Act 1886 and rr 203 and 204 of the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006. Upon service of the Summons, the defendants informed the process server that tenants were in occupation of the properties under Residential Tenancy Agreements governed by the Residential Tenancies Act 1995. The plaintiff’s counsel conceded for the purpose of argument that there were tenants in occupation of the properties.
No contradictor responded to the Court, hence there was no opposition to the orders sought by the plaintiff. The plaintiff had made out its entitlement to possession of the subject properties on the affidavits filed. However, the matter raised a jurisdictional issue concerning whether the Supreme Court or the Residential Tenancies Tribunal had exclusive jurisdiction to deal with such claims for possession. The plaintiff argued that the Tribunal did not have exclusive jurisdiction, especially when the claimant for possession was a mortgagee, not a landlord, and the Supreme Court had jurisdiction. The court examined the Residential Tenancies Tribunal’s order in Lea v Perpetual Trustees Victoria Ltd and concluded that the Tribunal's exclusive jurisdiction did not extend to claims by a mortgagee for possession of residential premises. Therefore, the Supreme Court had jurisdiction to make the orders for possession in favour of the mortgagee.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the Residential Tenancies Tribunal have exclusive jurisdiction to deal with a claim for possession of premises by a mortgagee, or does the Supreme Court have concurrent jurisdiction under the Real Property Act 1886?
2. Does the Residential Tenancies Act 1995 limit the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court to make an order in rem for the possession of a property in favour of a mortgagee, even where a tenant is in occupation under a Residential Tenancy Agreement?
3. If the Supreme Court does have jurisdiction in such a case, can it make an order for possession of the premises, and if so, what are the implications for the tenant under the Residential Tenancies Agreement?
4. Are the provisions of the Residential Tenancies Act 1995, specifically sections 79(d), 95(b), and 96, consistent with the Residential Tenancies Tribunal having exclusive jurisdiction over all claims by anyone who claims the right to possession of residential premises from a tenant?
Held
1. The Supreme Court has jurisdiction to deal with a claim for possession of premises by a mortgagee, and it does not have exclusive jurisdiction; the Residential Tenancies Tribunal does not have exclusive jurisdiction over such claims.
2. The Residential Tenancies Act 1995 does not limit the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court to make an order in rem for the possession of a property in favour of a mortgagee, even where a tenant is in occupation under a Residential Tenancy Agreement.
3. If the Supreme Court has jurisdiction in such a case, it can make an order for possession of the premises. The implications for the tenant under the Residential Tenancies Agreement are that the tenant must vacate the premises if a warrant of possession is executed by the Sheriff.
4. The provisions of the Residential Tenancies Act 1995, specifically sections 79(d), 95(b), and 96, are not consistent with the Residential Tenancies Tribunal having exclusive jurisdiction over all claims by anyone who claims the right to possession of residential premises from a tenant.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered whether the Residential Tenancies Tribunal (Tribunal) has exclusive jurisdiction over a claim for possession of premises by a mortgagee or if the Supreme Court has concurrent jurisdiction under the Real Property Act 1886 (RPA). The court distinguished between the jurisdiction of the Tribunal and the Supreme Court, holding that the Tribunal's exclusive jurisdiction applies only when the claimant is a landlord seeking to evict a tenant under a Residential Tenancy Agreement (RTA). In this case, the plaintiff, ANZ Banking Group Ltd, was a mortgagee, not a landlord. The court relied on the reasoning in Croome v State of Tasmania, which clarified that a "matter" in s 24(1)(a) of the RTA refers to the subject of the controversy rather than the action itself. The court also noted that the RTA does not grant the Tribunal the right to make an order for possession on the application of a party who is not a landlord but claims to be entitled to possession.
Further, the court addressed whether the RTA limits the Supreme Court's jurisdiction to make an order in rem for the possession of a property in favour of a mortgagee, even where a tenant is in occupation under a Residential Tenancy Agreement. The court held that the RTA does not exclude the Supreme Court's jurisdiction in such cases. Sections 79(d), 95(b), and 96 of the RTA, which refer to orders for possession made by either a Court or the Tribunal, support this interpretation. If the Tribunal had exclusive jurisdiction, the references to "Court" in these sections would be redundant. The court concluded that the existence of a residential tenancy does not affect the Supreme Court's jurisdiction to make an order in rem for the possession of the property in favour of a mortgagee.
Moreover, the court examined whether, if it has jurisdiction, the Supreme Court can make an order for possession of the premises and what the implications are for the tenant under the Residential Tenancies Agreement. The court found that the Supreme Court can indeed make such an order. The court highlighted that if the Supreme Court's order for possession terminates the residential tenancy, the rights of any tenant under the RTA are significantly diminished. However, the court did not base its decision on this point and noted that it was not necessary to explore the argument that Part 17 of the RPA takes precedence over any inconsistent provision of the RTA.
Lastly, the court considered whether the provisions of the RTA, specifically sections 79(d), 95(b), and 96, are consistent with the Tribunal having exclusive jurisdiction over all claims by anyone who claims the right to possession of residential premises from a tenant. The court found that these provisions indicate the RTA as a whole is inconsistent with the Tribunal having exclusive jurisdiction. The references to "Court" in these sections imply that both the Supreme Court and the Tribunal have the authority to make orders for possession, supporting the court's jurisdiction in such matters. The court's decision was influenced by the argument that the Tribunal's exclusive jurisdiction applies only when the claimant is a landlord, not a mortgagee.
In conclusion, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the Supreme Court has concurrent jurisdiction with the Residential Tenancies Tribunal to make an order for the possession of premises in favour of a mortgagee, even where a tenant is in occupation under a Residential Tenancy Agreement. The court departed from the Tribunal's exclusive jurisdiction interpretation in Lea v Perpetual Trustees Victoria Ltd, clarifying that the Tribunal's jurisdiction is limited to claims by landlords, not mortgagees.