SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v Swainson [2011] QCA 136
PARTIES:
ALLIANZ AUSTRALIA INSURANCE LTD
ACN 000 122 850
(appellant)
v
GLENN SWAINSON
(respondent)FILE NO/S:
Appeal No 11840 of 2010
DC No 199 of 2009DIVISION:
Court of Appeal
PROCEEDING:
General Civil Appeal
ORIGINATING COURT:
District Court at Southport
DELIVERED ON:
21 June 2011
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
9 March 2011
JUDGES:
Fraser JA, Ann Lyons and Martin JJ
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, each concurring as to the orders madeORDERS:
1. The appeal is allowed;
2. The parties are directed to lodge written submissions within 14 days as to the consequential orders that should be made to give effect to the Court’s reasons for allowing the appeal.
CATCHWORDS:
APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES – INTERFERENCE WITH JUDGE’S FINDINGS OF FACT – FUNCTIONS OF APPELLATE COURT – WHERE INFERENCES OF FACT INVOLVED – WHERE FACTS NOT IN DISPUTE – where the plaintiff was walking home at night when the first defendant’s vehicle collided with him – where the trial judge held that the first defendant was negligent in failing to keep a proper lookout and failing to slow down and steer clear of the plaintiff –where the insurer argued that the trial judge drew inferences which were not open on the evidence and engaged in unwarranted and unsupported speculation – whether the trial judge erred in finding that the first defendant was negligent
TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – ROAD ACCIDENT CASES – LIABILITY OF DRIVERS OF VEHICLES – FAILURE TO LOOK OUT – PEDESTRIAN ACCIDENTS – where the plaintiff was intoxicated at the time of the collision – where the plaintiff chose to walk on the left hand side of the road rather than on the concrete footpath provided – where the plaintiff was hitchhiking and took a small step onto the road – where the first defendant had limited opportunity to avoid the collision – where the insurer argued that the plaintiff’s culpability was greater – whether the trial judge erred in apportioning responsibility for the incident
Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld), s 47
Edwards v Nominal Defendant[2006] QCA 475, distinguished
Hawthorne v Hillcoat (2008) 51 MVR 523; [2008] NSWCA 340, cited
Manley v Alexander (2005) 223 ALR 228; [2005] HCA 79, cited
Pennington v Norris (1956) 96 CLR 10; [1956] HCA 26, distinguished
Podrebersek v Australian Iron & Steel Pty Ltd (1985) 59 ALJR 492; [1985] HCA 34, considered
Swainson v Carruthers & Anor (unreported, DC(Qld), McGinness DCJ, No 199/09, 5 October 2010), considered
Teubner v Humble (1963) 108 CLR 491; [1963] HCA 11, distinguishedCOUNSEL:
S C Williams QC, with P L Feely, for the appellant
M Grant-Taylor SC, with R Trotter, for the respondentSOLICITORS:
McInnes Wilson for the appellant
Shine Lawyers for the respondent
[1] FRASER JA: The plaintiff in proceedings in the District Court claimed damages arising out…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v Swainson and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] QCA 136
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the principles governing appellate interference with factual findings, noting that an appellate court should not lightly interfere with a trial judge's findings, particularly when those findings are based on an assessment of witness credibility and the weight of the evidence. The court examined whether the trial judge's conclusions were open on the evidence presented, including the plaintiff's intoxication, his decision to walk on the left-hand side of the road rather than on the footpath, and the limited opportunity the first defendant had to avoid the collision. The court concluded that the trial judge had indeed drawn inferences that were not supported by the evidence and had engaged in unwarranted speculation. The trial judge had failed to adequately consider the relative contributions to the accident by both the plaintiff and the first defendant.
The appeal was allowed, and the case was remitted to the trial court to re-evaluate the facts in light of the court's findings. The court ordered the parties to submit written submissions within 14 days regarding the consequential orders necessary to implement the court's reasons for allowing the appeal. This decision underscores the importance of the appellate court's limited role in assessing factual findings, particularly where those findings are based on the trial judge's assessment of evidence and witness credibility.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal is allowed;
2. The parties are directed to lodge written submissions within 14 days as to the consequential orders that should be made to give effect to the Court’s reasons for allowing the appeal.
Background
Background to the litigation
This matter is an appeal from a decision of the trial court, where the plaintiff had originally succeeded in a claim for damages against the first defendant for injuries sustained in the collision. The insurer of the first defendant, Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd, appealed the decision on the basis that the trial judge drew inferences which were not open on the evidence and engaged in unwarranted and unsupported speculation regarding the first defendant's negligence. The appeal was heard in the higher court, which reviewed the evidence and the trial judge's findings of fact.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the trial judge erred in finding that the first defendant was negligent in failing to keep a proper lookout and failing to slow down and steer clear of the plaintiff.
2. Whether the trial judge erred in apportioning responsibility for the incident, considering the plaintiff's intoxication, decision to walk on the left-hand side of the road, and the first defendant's limited opportunity to avoid the collision.
Held
1. The court held that the trial judge erred in finding that the first defendant was negligent in failing to keep a proper lookout and failing to slow down and steer clear of the plaintiff. The appeal was allowed on this ground.
2. The court also held that the trial judge erred in apportioning responsibility for the incident, considering the plaintiff's intoxication, decision to walk on the left-hand side of the road, and the first defendant's limited opportunity to avoid the collision. The appeal was allowed on this ground.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the issue of whether the trial judge erred in finding that the first defendant was negligent. The insurer argued that the trial judge drew inferences which were not open on the evidence and engaged in unwarranted and unsupported speculation. The court acknowledged that it is not the function of the appellate court to interfere with the trial judge's findings of fact, particularly where the inferences involved are questions of primary fact and the facts are not in dispute. However, the court found that the trial judge had erred in making certain inferences and speculating in a way that was not supported by the evidence.
The court then examined the issue of whether the trial judge erred in apportioning responsibility for the incident. The court noted that the plaintiff was intoxicated at the time of the collision, chose to walk on the left-hand side of the road rather than on the concrete footpath provided, and took a small step onto the road while hitchhiking. The court found that these factors significantly contributed to the plaintiff's culpability. Additionally, the court considered that the first defendant had limited opportunity to avoid the collision, given the circumstances. The court concluded that the trial judge had erred in apportioning responsibility between the parties, placing undue weight on the first defendant's negligence and insufficient weight on the plaintiff's contributory negligence.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that appellate courts should exercise caution when interfering with trial judges' findings of fact, particularly in cases involving primary facts and undisputed evidence. However, where a trial judge makes inferences that are not supported by the evidence or engages in unwarranted speculation, appellate courts may find error. In apportioning responsibility for incidents involving both drivers and pedestrians, courts must carefully consider the contributory negligence of all parties involved. The court's decision in this case highlights the importance of balancing the negligence of drivers with the contributory negligence of pedestrians, particularly where the pedestrian's actions significantly increase the risk of harm.