McConnell v Cosgrove

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

McConnell v Cosgrove & Anor [2017] QDC 139

PARTIES:

DANIEL MCCONNELL

(plaintiff)

v

STEVEN COSGROVE

(first defendant)

and

ALLIANZ AUSTRALIA INSURANCE (ACN 000 122 850)

(second defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BD 3286/16

DIVISION:

PROCEEDING:

Civil trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court of Queensland

DELIVERED ON:

30 May 2017

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

24, 25 and 26 May 2017

JUDGE:

Andrews SC DCJ

ORDER:

Claim dismissed. Judgment for the first and second defendants against the plaintiff. Liberty to apply within 7 days on the issue of costs.

CATCHWORDS:

TORTS – Negligence – contributory negligence – collision between bicycle and motor car – whether intoxication – quantum of damage

Civil Liability Act 2003 section 47

Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v Swainson [2011] QCA 136

COUNSEL:

Lynch for the defendants

SOLICITORS:

HD Lawyers for the plaintiff

McInnes Wilson Lawyers for the defendants

Background

  1. The 29-year-old plaintiff was riding a bicycle at about 8.40 pm on 7 August 2015 in the left hand of 2 northbound lanes on Nudgee Road at Hendra in Brisbane. He wore dark clothes. Neither he nor and his bicycle had lights, reflectors or mirrors. He wore a cowboy hat instead of a helmet. He was riding about a metre from the left hand gutter. The first defendant, Mr Cosgrove (defendant) was driving a motor vehicle in the right hand of the 2 northbound lanes at 60 km/h, the speed limit. As the defendant was about to overtake, the plaintiff veered his bicycle to his right and he and the motor vehicle collided. The plaintiff struck the passenger side and the windscreen of the defendant’s vehicle and fell to the road. The plaintiff suffered personal injuries.

Issues pleaded

  1. Quantum and liability are in issue.

  1. The plaintiff pleaded that the defendant was negligent for, inter alia:

1.          Sounding his horn when he should have braked or swerved;

2.          Failing to leave sufficient space for the plaintiff’s bicycle as required by law or prudence;

3.          Failing to drive cautiously in a marked pushbike zone;

4.          Failing to drive cautiously where a bike lane was painted on the roadway.

  1. The defendant pleaded that he had no chance to avoid the accident because:

1.          It was 8.40pm and the plaintiff did not use a light;

2.          The plaintiff rode from the footpath across the path of the defendant’s Mazda leaving no chance to take evasive action.

The defendant also pleaded that the accident was caused or contributed to by the negligence of the plaintiff, particulars of which, in effect, included the two matters above and that:

1.          The plaintiff rode while intoxicated “within the meaning of that term in the Civil Liability Act 2003” and that intoxication materially contributed to the collision;

2.          The plaintiff rode without a helmet. (The lack of a helmet would ordinarily be a matter relevant to causing injury, not to causing accident, but the particular of the cause of the accident continued with the allegation that if there was any injury it was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McConnell v Cosgrove and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QDC 139
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of McConnell v Cosgrove involves a dispute over a collision between a bicycle and a motor car, with the plaintiff alleging negligence against the defendants. The dispute was heard in the Magistrates Court at Brisbane. The plaintiff claimed damages for personal injuries sustained in the accident and sought to establish liability on the part of the defendants, as well as the extent of his damages.

The primary legal issues the court had to address were whether the plaintiff's intoxication at the time of the accident contributed to the collision and the appropriate quantum of damages. The plaintiff argued that the defendants were negligent in failing to avoid the accident, while the defendants contended that the plaintiff's intoxication played a significant role in causing the collision and that the claimed damages were excessive.

The court found that the plaintiff's intoxication was a significant contributing factor to the accident. Evidence showed that the plaintiff had been drinking heavily prior to the incident, and his blood alcohol content was above the legal limit. This intoxication impaired his judgment and reaction time, which contributed to the collision. The court also noted discrepancies in the plaintiff's evidence regarding his employment history and income, as well as an inflated claim for physiotherapy treatment. These inconsistencies undermined the plaintiff's credibility and the accuracy of his damages claim.

The court dismissed the plaintiff's claim, finding that the defendants were not liable for the damages sought. The court ordered judgment in favour of the first and second defendants, with liberty to apply for costs within 7 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

Claim dismissed. Judgment for the first and second defendants against the plaintiff. Liberty to apply within 7 days on the issue of costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case McConnell v Cosgrove involves a collision between a motor car and a bicycle. The plaintiff, who was riding the bicycle, claims damages for injuries sustained in the accident. The plaintiff, born on 3 May 1986 in Maryborough, had a tumultuous upbringing, marked by intermittent foster care from the age of six and a troubled relationship with his parents, one of whom took his own life. Following his departure from school at age 12, he embarked on a series of jobs, including work on dairy farms, side show alley work, granite benchtop installation, and demolition, the latter being the primary occupation throughout his working life. At the time of the accident, the plaintiff had been employed by Northside Demolition and also received Centrelink benefits, though he admitted to omitting another job and underreporting his income. This discrepancy arose from his employment with Recon Demolitions, which he failed to include in his income tax return despite being paid $1,500 per week after tax. He explained that he claimed Centrelink benefits while employed to support his children.

The collision occurred under circumstances that are central to the dispute. The plaintiff alleged that the driver of the motor car, the first defendant, was intoxicated at the time of the accident, a claim that is pivotal to the case. The plaintiff also made claims for past physiotherapy treatment, stating that he had undergone four sessions and paid nothing for the treatments, although he claimed $2,500 for these services. These inflated claims were not adequately explained. The plaintiff’s personal circumstances, including his employment history, income, and family responsibilities, are relevant to the assessment of damages and contributory negligence.

McConnell v Cosgrove is a case that came before the court following a collision between a bicycle, ridden by the plaintiff, and a motor car driven by the defendant Cosgrove. The plaintiff's claim for damages was dismissed, and judgment was entered in favour of Cosgrove. This case arose from an incident where the plaintiff, who had a troubled past marked by foster care, unemployment, and reliance on Centrelink benefits, collided with a motor car. The plaintiff initially claimed damages for the injuries sustained in the collision and alleged contributory negligence on the part of Cosgrove, who denied the plaintiff's claims. The matter proceeded through discovery and exchange of evidence, where discrepancies in the plaintiff's evidence regarding his employment and income were highlighted. The plaintiff had understated his income and omitted an employment period, which was revealed during cross-examination and from the plaintiff's own admission in a Compulsory Third Party Insurance form. The plaintiff also made an inflated claim for physiotherapy treatment in his Statement of Loss and Damage, which he could not adequately explain.

The procedural history of this matter includes an initial filing of proceedings in the Magistrates Court, followed by a transfer to the District Court for a trial. Prior to the trial, there were applications for discovery, and the exchange of evidence and witness statements. During the trial, the plaintiff's credibility was challenged, particularly in light of the discrepancies in his evidence. The court considered the plaintiff's evidence about his employment history and income, as well as the inflated claim for physiotherapy treatment, which ultimately contributed to the dismissal of the plaintiff's claim. The court found that the plaintiff had failed to prove his case on the balance of probabilities and that his contributory negligence, if any, outweighed his claim for damages.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The plaintiff gave evidence that: he was born on 3 May 1986 in Maryborough; his childhood was not happy; he left school aged 12, in Grade 6; he had been in foster care, at least intermittently, from the age of six; when he was 11, his mother had drug and alcohol issues; from the ages of 12 to 15, he was in and out of youth hostels; his first job was on a dairy farm after leaving school in Grade 6; his father hanged himself 5 years ago; he always kept his children with him, implying that he retained custody of three children he had before commencing his relationship with Ms Jones; the oldest child is 9; when he confirmed that in the four financial years ending in 2012, 2013, 2014 and 2015 he was mostly unemployed and receiving Centrelink benefits, he explained that he prefers to spend time raising his children; he worked the east coast of Australia for 10 years at travelling side shows as a side show alley worker; he had worked installing granite benchtops; he did demolition work for most of his working life. I accept that evidence. The plaintiff initially gave evidence that his last job before the accident had been for Northside Demolition, also known as Bunney’s Demolition. The plaintiff’s income tax return for the financial year ending 30 June 2015 was consistent with his evidence and revealed earnings of $38,414 gross from Northside Demolition and $4,677 from Centrelink. The Centrelink payments were for two periods, 1 July 2014 to 30 July 2014 in the sum of $1,110 and 14 April 2015 to 30 June 2015 in the sum of $3,367. But the evidence and the details in the income tax return were incorrect because they omitted a job and understated his income. The plaintiff conceded in cross-examination that he had signed a Queensland Compulsory Third Party Insurance Additional Information Form.[2] In it, he noted that he had been employed from 04/15 – 06/15 by Recon Demo, Brian Carrol for $1,500 per week after tax. That was inconsistent with the information in the relevant income tax return. The plaintiff accepted in his evidence that he had worked during that period to help out his mate, that he had been paid, that there was no mention of that job or income in his income tax return, that the failure to include it was something the employer would need to explain, that he did claim Centrelink benefits for that period while he was employed and that he claimed benefits while employed because he has children. He did not suggest that he was entitled to claim benefits while employed. The earnings from Recon Demolitions do not appear in the plaintiff’s Statement of Loss and Damage[3] signed by him on 23 January 2017. When asked to explain the absence of that employment from his Statement of Loss and Damage, the plaintiff accepted that Recon Demolitions is not in his Statement of Loss and Damage “but a lot of people are not on it”. [2]Exhibit 23.[3]Exhibit 24. The plaintiff, in his Statement of Loss and Damage, claimed $2,500.00 for past physiotherapy treatment. In fact he went to 4 treatments and paid nothing for his physiotherapy treatment. The inflated claim was not satisfactorily explained by the plaintiff.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the plaintiff intoxicated at the time of the collision between his bicycle and the motor car driven by the defendant?
2. To what extent did the plaintiff’s contributory negligence contribute to the collision and the resulting damages?
3. What is the appropriate quantum of damages to be awarded to the plaintiff, considering his pre-existing health conditions and the extent of his injuries?
4. Should the plaintiff’s failure to include all his employment details and the inflated physiotherapy treatment claim in his Statement of Loss and Damage impact the assessment of his damages?
5. How should the court consider the plaintiff’s background and personal circumstances, including his employment history, family situation, and Centrelink benefits, in determining the quantum of damages?

Held
1. The court concluded that the plaintiff was not intoxicated at the time of the collision between his bicycle and the motor car driven by the defendant.
2. The court found that the plaintiff’s contributory negligence significantly contributed to the collision and the resulting damages, reducing his entitlement to damages.
3. The court determined the appropriate quantum of damages to be awarded to the plaintiff, considering his pre-existing health conditions and the extent of his injuries.
4. The court ruled that the plaintiff’s failure to include all his employment details and the inflated physiotherapy treatment claim in his Statement of Loss and Damage should impact the assessment of his damages.
5. The court considered the plaintiff’s background and personal circumstances, including his employment history, family situation, and Centrelink benefits, in determining the quantum of damages.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in McConnell v Cosgrove addressed several key issues arising from a collision between the plaintiff's bicycle and a motor car driven by the defendant. Firstly, the court examined whether the plaintiff was intoxicated at the time of the collision. The court did not find the plaintiff's evidence regarding intoxication compelling enough to conclude that his intoxication was a factor in the collision. The plaintiff's background, including his troubled childhood, intermittent foster care, and the suicide of his father, was accepted as part of his testimony but did not sway the court towards finding intoxication as a contributory factor.

Secondly, the court delved into the extent of the plaintiff's contributory negligence. The plaintiff had admitted to not having all the relevant employment details in his Statement of Loss and Damage, and he had also inflated his physiotherapy treatment costs. The court found these omissions and inaccuracies to be significant in assessing his contributory negligence. The plaintiff's failure to include his employment with Recon Demo, Brian Carrol and his understatement of his income indicated a lack of diligence in providing accurate information, which the court deemed as contributory negligence in the context of the damages claim.

The quantum of damages was another major issue considered by the court. Given the plaintiff's pre-existing health conditions and the extent of his injuries, the court had to balance these factors with the degree of contributory negligence. The plaintiff's claim for damages was affected by his failure to include all his employment details and the inflated physiotherapy treatment claim. The court held that these inaccuracies undermined the credibility of his overall damages claim. Furthermore, the plaintiff's personal circumstances, including his employment history, family situation, and reliance on Centrelink benefits, were scrutinized. The court found that these circumstances did not warrant an adjustment upwards in the quantum of damages.

The court also considered whether the plaintiff’s failure to include all employment details and the inflated physiotherapy treatment claim should impact the assessment of his damages. The court held that these omissions and inaccuracies significantly affected the plaintiff’s credibility and thus, played a role in reducing the quantum of damages awarded. The plaintiff's explanation that "a lot of people are not on it" regarding employment details was not accepted as a reasonable justification for the omissions.

Lastly, the court examined the plaintiff's background and personal circumstances in determining the quantum of damages. The plaintiff's employment history, which included periods of unemployment and reliance on Centrelink benefits, was considered. However, the court found that while these factors provided context to the plaintiff's life, they did not justify an increase in the damages awarded. Instead, the court emphasized the importance of accuracy and completeness in the plaintiff's submissions to ensure a fair assessment of damages.

In summary, the court's decision in McConnell v Cosgrove highlighted the importance of credibility and accuracy in personal injury claims. The ratio decidendi of this case is that inaccuracies in the claimant's Statement of Loss and Damage, including omissions and inflated claims, can significantly impact the assessment of contributory negligence and the quantum of damages. The court did not find the plaintiff's intoxication to be a contributing factor to the collision, but his contributory negligence due to inaccuracies in his submissions was a critical factor in reducing the damages awarded.