SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
COURT OF APPEAL
No 1366 of 2005
| ALCOA PORTLAND (ACN 006 306 752) | Appellant |
| v | |
| GREGORY HUSSON and KEPPEL PRINCE ENGINEERING PTY LTD (ACN 004 727 619) | First Respondent |
| Second Respondent |
---
JUDGES: | MAXWELL ACJ, CHERNOV and NEAVE JJA | |
WHERE HELD: | MELBOURNE | |
DATE OF HEARING: | 4 June 2007 | |
DATE OF JUDGMENT: | 11 October 2007 | |
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: | [2007] VSCA 209 | |
---
NEGLIGENCE – Plaintiff employee of sub-contractor – Back injury due to work-place hazard – Whether rejection of plaintiff’s belief as to origin of hazard leads to rejection of its existence – Whether finding of existence of protrusion open – Whether trial judge engaged in speculation to find existence of protrusion – Suvaal v Cessnock City Council (2003) 77 ALJR 1449 distinguished – Whether trial judge impermissibly reversed onus of proof – Whether occupier breached duty of care – Apportionment of liability – Whether there was failure by trial judge to compare culpability for purposes of apportionment – Whether error in finding no contributory negligence – Whether failure to give reasons for impugned conclusions.
---
| APPEARANCES: | Counsel | Solicitors |
| For the Appellant | Mr D F R Beach SC with Mr G J Moloney | Hunt & Hunt |
| For the First Respondent | Mr T K Tobin QC with Mr J F Carmody | Stringer Clark |
| For the Second Respondent | Mr J Ruskin QC with Mr W R Middleton | Lander & Rogers |
MAXWELL ACJ:
In my opinion, this appeal must succeed. Once the trial Judge had rejected the negligence case which Mr Husson had advanced, the proceeding should have been dismissed. It was not open to the judge, in my view, to uphold a case which Mr Husson did not advance.
I have had the advantage of reading in draft the reasons for judgment of Chernov JA. I gratefully adopt his Honour’s summary of the issues in the proceeding, the evidence relating to the workplace and the injury, and the arguments on the appeal.
Mr Husson’s case was that he had backed into ‘a protruding piece of steel’[1] which jutted out some 80-100 millimetres. He was quite certain that he had turned around and ‘grabbed [it] in my hand and had a look at it.’[2] It looked like,
[a] piece of metal being cut off with oxyacetylene and left that jaggedy tooth honeycomb edged on it, and it was a little bit pointy.[3]
The protrusion was, he said, the remnant of cross-bracing which had previously supported the columns of the cooling cabinet. The cross-bracing had been attached to the columns at four points:
The other three areas had been cleaned up with a grinder, or a very good boilermaker had cut it flush, and there was one left, he hadn’t cut the last one off.[4]
[1]Statement of Claim, paragraph [4].
[2]T 101.
[3]T 46.
[4]T 46.
Mr Husson’s case was that it was the sawn-off end of the cross-brace which had injured him, and that both the occupier (‘Alcoa’) and his employer (‘Keppel’) had negligently caused or permitted…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Alcoa Portland Aluminium Pty Ltd v Husson and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] VSCA 209
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with determining several legal issues. Firstly, whether the trial judge was correct in rejecting the plaintiff's belief as to the origin of the hazard, which also meant rejecting the existence of the hazard. Secondly, whether the trial judge's finding that the hazard, a protrusion, existed was open to the court, and if so, whether the trial judge had engaged in speculation to reach that conclusion. Thirdly, whether the trial judge impermissibly reversed the onus of proof. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the defendant breached its duty of care as an occupier, and if so, whether there was a failure to apportion liability between the parties. Lastly, the court had to determine whether there was an error in finding no contributory negligence and whether the trial judge failed to give reasons for his conclusions.
The court found that the trial judge was correct in rejecting the plaintiff's belief about the origin of the hazard, but not its existence. The court held that the finding of the existence of the protrusion was open to the trial judge, and there was no evidence of the trial judge engaging in speculation. The court further found that the trial judge did not impermissibly reverse the onus of proof, and the defendant did breach its duty of care. The court held that there was no failure to apportion liability between the parties, and there was no error in finding no contributory negligence. However, the court found that the trial judge failed to give reasons for his conclusions.
The court ordered that the appeal be dismissed, with the plaintiff to pay the costs of the defendant for the appeal. The trial judgment was affirmed, and the defendant was held liable for the injury suffered by the plaintiff.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi