Alben Hyland by next friend Ajay Singh v Mitchell

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

CITATION:   ALBEN HYLAND by next friend AJAY SINGH -v- MITCHELL [2022] WASC 300

CORAM:   FORRESTER J

HEARD:   ON THE PAPERS

DELIVERED          :   6 SEPTEMBER 2022

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1576 of 2022

BETWEEN:   ALBEN HYLAND by next friend AJAY SINGH

Plaintiff

AND

JAMIE MITCHELL

First Respondent

ADAM WIRINGI

Second Respondent

DEREK CANNING

Third Respondent

ROSS CUNNINGHAME

Fourth Respondent

STEPHEN SLISKOVIC

Fifth Respondent

LEANNA GREEN

Sixth Respondent

LARA TURNER

Seventh Respondent

TRACY AVELING

Eighth Respondent

MARK NELL

Ninth Respondent

LUKE KIRKHAM

Tenth Respondent

HAI DIN TAN

Eleventh Respondent

IAN MCCUTCHEON

Twelfth Respondent

HIS HONOUR MAGISTRATE STEVEN MALLEY

Thirteenth Respondent


Catchwords:

Administrative law - Review order pursuant to s 36 of the Magistrates Court Act 2004 (WA) - Jurisdictional error - Criminal Law (Mentally Impaired Accused) Act 1996 (WA) - Whether magistrate had the power to make a custody order

Legislation:

Criminal Code
Criminal Law (Mentally Impaired Accused) Act 1996 (WA)
Magistrates Court Act 2004 (WA)
Sentencing Act 1995 (WA)

Result:

Custody orders set aside
Applicant remanded in custody to appear in Magistrates Court for matters to be dealt with according to law

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff : No appearance
First Respondent : No appearance
Second Respondent : No appearance
Third Respondent : No appearance
Fourth Respondent : No appearance
Fifth Respondent : No appearance
Sixth Respondent : No appearance
Seventh Respondent : No appearance
Eighth Respondent : No appearance
Ninth Respondent : No appearance
Tenth Respondent : No appearance
Eleventh Respondent : No appearance
Twelfth Respondent : No appearance
Thirteenth Respondent : No appearance

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : Legal Aid - Perth - Criminal Law Division
First Respondent : State Solicitor's Office
Second Respondent : State Solicitor's Office
Third Respondent : State Solicitor's Office
Fourth Respondent : State Solicitor's Office
Fifth Respondent : State Solicitor's Office
Sixth Respondent : State Solicitor's Office
Seventh Respondent : State Solicitor's Office
Eighth Respondent : State Solicitor's Office
Ninth Respondent : State Solicitor's Office
Tenth Respondent : State Solicitor's Office
Eleventh Respondent : State Solicitor's Office
Twelfth Respondent : State Solicitor's Office
Thirteenth Respondent : State Solicitor's Office

Cases referred to in decision:

A v Corruption and Crime Commissioner [2013] WASCA 288

Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd [1986 HCA 40; (1986) 162 CLR 24

Pickett v The State of Western Australia [2004] WASCA 291

Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority [1998] HCA 28; (1998) 194 CLR 355

Rayney v AW [2009] WASCA 203

Re an application under the Magistrates Court Act 2004; Ex parte Brecker [2007] WASC 151

Re Magistrate R Bromfield; Ex parte Caratti [2016] WASC 147

Rundle v Innerd [2015] WASC 340

FORRESTER J:

Introduction

  1. The applicant has applied for a review order pursuant to s 36(1)(c) of the Magistrates Court Act 2004 (WA) (the Magistrates Court Act) on the basis that he is aggrieved by:

    (c) an act, order or direction done or made by a Court Officer –

    (i) on the ground that it was done or made without…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alben Hyland by next friend Ajay Singh v Mitchell and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] WASC 300
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Alben Hyland, represented by his next friend Ajay Singh, applied for a review order pursuant to s 36(1)(c) of the Magistrates Court Act 2004 (WA) in relation to two custody orders made by Magistrate Malley on 17 September 2020. The applicant had been found to be mentally unfit to stand trial in relation to 19 charges and was detained indefinitely in an authorised hospital or prison. The applicant sought to set aside the custody orders on the basis that they were made without jurisdiction or power. The legal issues were whether the magistrate had the power to make custody orders in relation to the applicant and, if so, whether the magistrate had considered the relevant factors required by s 16(6) of the Criminal Law (Mentally Impaired Accused) Act 1996 (WA). The court found that there was jurisdictional error in respect of each of the custody orders. The errors fell into four categories: the applicant was not liable to a custody order in respect of the charge because he had pleaded guilty to the charge prior to a finding that he was mentally unfit to stand trial; the statutory penalty for the offence to which the custody order related was not, and did not include, imprisonment and thus a custody order was not open to the magistrate; the charge did not disclose an offence known to the law; and there was a jurisdictional error on the basis that the court failed to take into account a relevant consideration which the statute required be taken into account as a precondition of the exercise of authority to make the decision. The court determined that the orders of the magistrate should be set aside. The applicant was remanded in custody to appear in Magistrates Court for matters to be dealt with according to law.

Background

Background to the litigation

Alben Hyland, by next friend Ajay Singh, was charged with various offences between 2016 and 2020. Hyland had a history of offences including aggravated burglary, theft, unlawful wounding, assault on public officers, and breaching intensive supervision orders (ISO) and bail undertakings. On 14 May 2019, Hyland pleaded guilty to certain charges and was found unfit to stand trial on 17 September 2020. Consequently, two custody orders were made, directing his indefinite detention in an authorised hospital or prison.

On 24 August 2017, Hyland was committed for sentence on charges of aggravated burglary, stealing, and stealing a motor vehicle. On 11 December 2017, he was sentenced to an ISO of 8 months for aggravated burglary and stealing a motor vehicle, with no penalty for the theft of car keys. On 27 June 2018, he was sentenced for aggravated burglary in the Karratha Magistrates Court. On 27 August 2018, he was sentenced for reoffending while subject to an ISO, receiving another ISO of 12 months. On 19 February 2019, Hyland pleaded guilty to two charges of assaulting a public officer and two charges of breaching a bail undertaking. On 14 May 2019, he pleaded guilty to unlawful wounding and two charges of breaching an ISO. He was also charged with further offences of assaulting a public officer.

On 17 September 2020, Hyland appeared before Magistrate Malley on various charges, where two custody orders were made due to his unfitness to stand trial. These orders were challenged on the grounds that they were made without jurisdiction or power.

The applicant, Alben Hyland, applied for a review order under s 36(1)(c) of the Magistrates Court Act 2004 (WA). The application was heard on the papers, with written submissions from both the applicant and the respondents. The court found that the custody orders were made without jurisdiction or power and set them aside. The application was filed more than 20 months after the custody orders were made, but the delay was not considered a bar to relief given the potential for indefinite imprisonment without proper jurisdiction.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the magistrate have the power to make a custody order in respect of the charges to which the applicant had pleaded guilty prior to being found mentally unfit to stand trial?
2. Was the statutory penalty for the offence to which the custody order related imprisonment, making a custody order permissible under s 16(6) of the Criminal Law (Mentally Impaired Accused) Act 1996 (WA)?
3. Did the charge that served as the basis for one of the custody orders disclose an offence known to the law?
4. Did the court fail to take into account relevant considerations which the statute required be taken into account as a precondition of the exercise of authority to make the decision?

Held
1. The court held that the magistrate did not have the power to make a custody order in respect of the charges to which the applicant had pleaded guilty prior to being found mentally unfit to stand trial.
2. The court held that the statutory penalty for the offence to which the custody order related was not imprisonment, making a custody order impermissible under s 16(6) of the Criminal Law (Mentally Impaired Accused) Act 1996 (WA).
3. The court held that the charge that served as the basis for one of the custody orders did not disclose an offence known to the law.
4. The court held that the court failed to take into account relevant considerations required by the statute as a precondition of the exercise of authority to make the decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In this case, the court was asked to review custody orders made by a magistrate in relation to a mentally unfit accused. The applicant sought relief under s 36 of the Magistrates Court Act 2004 (WA), arguing that the custody orders were made without jurisdiction or power. The court found jurisdictional error in each of the custody orders for various reasons.

First, the court found that the magistrate did not have the power to make a custody order in respect of charges to which the applicant had already pleaded guilty. The Criminal Law (Mentally Impaired Accused) Act 1996 (WA) did not apply to these charges as they were sentencing proceedings. Thus, the magistrate did not have the jurisdiction to make a custody order.

Second, the court found that the magistrate did not have the power to make a custody order in relation to charges that did not have imprisonment as a statutory penalty. The relevant charges were breaches of a community order by non-compliance, which carried a maximum penalty of a fine of not more than $1,000. As such, a custody order was not permissible under s 16(6) of the CL(MIA) Act.

Third, the court found that the charge that served as the basis for one of the custody orders did not disclose an offence known to the law. The charge in question was a fictitious charge created solely for the purpose of committing the matter to the District Court and alleging reoffending while subject to a community order. This charge was not an offence known to law and could not have been the subject of a custody order.

Fourth, the court found that the magistrate failed to take into account relevant considerations required by the statute as a precondition of the exercise of authority to make the decision. Section 16(6) of the CL(MIA) Act requires a magistrate to consider several factors before imposing a custody order, including the strength of the evidence, the nature of the alleged offence, the accused's character, antecedents, age, health, and mental condition, and the public interest. The magistrate did not consider these factors, resulting in the custody order being made without jurisdiction or power.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a magistrate must consider all relevant statutory factors before imposing a custody order on a mentally unfit accused, and failure to do so results in the order being made without jurisdiction or power. Additionally, the CL(MIA) Act does not apply to sentencing proceedings, and a custody order cannot be made for an offence that does not have imprisonment as a statutory penalty.