AJ Lucas Operations Pty Ltd v Gladstone Area Water Board

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

AJ Lucas Operations Pty Ltd v Gladstone Area Water Board & Anor [2015] QCA 287

PARTIES:

AJ LUCAS OPERATIONS PTY LTD
ACN 087 777 633
(appellant)
v
GLADSTONE AREA WATER BOARD
(first respondent)
GLADSTONE REGIONAL COUNCIL
(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 674 of 2015
SC No 9296 of 2013

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:


Supreme Court at Brisbane – [2014] QSC 311

DELIVERED ON:

18 December 2015

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

4 August 2015

JUDGES:

Morrison and Philippides JJA and Ann Lyons J
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, each concurring as to the order made

ORDER:

Appeal dismissed with costs.

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – FORMATION OF CONTRACTUAL RELATIONS – AGREEMENTS CONTEMPLATING EXECUTION OF FORMAL DOCUMENT – WHETHER CONCLUDED CONTRACT – where the appellant and the respondents were negotiating to try and settle a dispute between them about the termination of a joint project for the construction of water and sewerage pipelines between Gladstone and Curtis Island – where the primary judge made a declaration that the parties had entered into a binding contract – where the appellant argues that the parties did not intend to be bound before the formal execution of the deed of settlement – where the appellant argues that no offer capable of acceptance was made by the respondents – where the appellant argues that the acceptance of the final offer by the CEO of the appellant was not on the precise terms of any earlier offer – where the appellant argues that the representatives of the respondents did not have authority to bind the respondents and could not have made an offer capable of acceptance by the appellant – whether there was an intention to be bound by the parties – whether an offer capable of acceptance was made by the respondents – whether there was a difference between the terms of the final offer and the earlier oral agreement – whether the parties entered into a concluded agreement

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 127

Barrier Wharfs Ltd v W Scott Fell & Co Ltd (1908) 5 CLR 647; [1908] HCA 88, considered
Cannon Street Pty Ltd v Karedis
[2004] QSC 104, followed
GR Securities Pty Ltd v Baulkham Hills Private Hospital Pty Ltd
(1986) 40 NSWLR 631, followed
Hopcroft & Edwards v Edmunds & Ors
(2013) 116 SASR 191; [2013] SASCFC 38, considered
Masters v Cameron (1954) 91 CLR 353; [1954] HCA 72, followed
Parker v Alessi [2011] NSWSC 947, considered
RT & YE Falls Investments Pty Ltd v New South Wales [2001] NSWSC 1027, considered
VDMT Pty Ltd v Francher Pty Ltd [2009] QSC 351, considered

COUNSEL:

B O’Donnell QC, with D Macfarlane, for the appellant
J McKenna QC, with S Webster, for the respondents

SOLICITORS:

Vincent Young for the appellant
Minter Ellison for the respondents

  1. MORRISON JA:  I have had the considerable…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AJ Lucas Operations Pty Ltd v Gladstone Area Water Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] QCA 287
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of AJ Lucas Operations Pty Ltd v Gladstone Area Water Board concerns a dispute between AJ Lucas Operations Pty Ltd (the appellant) and the Gladstone Area Water Board and the Gladstone Regional Council (the respondents) regarding the settlement of a joint project for the construction of water and sewerage pipelines. The primary judge had ruled that the parties had entered into a binding contract. The appellant argued that the parties did not intend to be bound before the formal execution of the deed of settlement, that no offer capable of acceptance was made by the respondents, that the acceptance by the CEO of the appellant was not on the precise terms of any earlier offer, and that the representatives of the respondents did not have authority to bind the respondents. The legal issues before the court were whether the parties had the intention to be bound, whether an offer capable of acceptance was made by the respondents, and whether there was a difference between the terms of the final offer and the earlier oral agreement. The court's reasoning was that the parties had the intention to be bound, an offer capable of acceptance was made by the respondents, and there was no material difference between the terms of the final offer and the earlier oral agreement. The court dismissed the appeal with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Gladstone Area Water Board and the Gladstone Regional Council (collectively referred to as the Gladstone parties) entered into a contract with AJ Lucas Operations Pty Ltd on 12 September 2011 for a joint project to provide water and sewerage pipeline infrastructure and access roads between Gladstone and Curtis Island. On 7 or 8 June 2012, the parties executed a Deed of Termination which ended the construction contract but preserved AJ Lucas' claims under Schedule 2 of the Deed of Termination. The Deed of Termination included a negotiation process for settling disputes between the parties, with a fallback to an expert panel if negotiations failed. After the negotiation process failed, the parties engaged an expert panel on 22 October 2012. On 5 November 2012, Jim Grayson from the Gladstone parties sent an email to Allan Campbell from AJ Lucas, proposing a settlement offer of $25,074,918.62 for all of AJ Lucas’ claims under the Deed of Termination, excluding certain identified items. An attachment to the email, a draft Deed of Settlement No 1, outlined the settlement terms and the items not to be resolved by the Deed. AJ Lucas responded with a counteroffer on 12 November 2012, and after several iterations, the final draft Deed of Settlement was agreed upon on 26 November 2012. The Gladstone parties sought a declaration that a binding contract had been formed, which the primary judge granted. AJ Lucas appealed this decision.

The case came before the court as an appeal against the decision of the primary judge who had made a declaration that the Gladstone parties and AJ Lucas had entered into a binding contract. The appeal was heard based on the legal consequences of the primary judge's findings. The primary judge's factual findings were not fundamentally challenged by AJ Lucas. The appeal focused solely on the legal issues surrounding the formation of the contract. Prior to the appeal, the parties had engaged in negotiations and mediations, and an expert panel was engaged to determine the disputes but was not utilised due to the settlement reached through the drafts of the Deed of Settlement.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The other declarations made on 19 December 2014 are not the subject of this appeal.The primary judge’s decision The trial before the primary judge was a claim for declaratory relief by the Gladstone parties that they had entered into a contract with AJ Lucas to settle part of a dispute as outlined in the Deed. None of the factual findings of the primary judge are fundamentally challenged on this appeal and the appeal relates only to legal consequences of the findings made by the learned primary judge. A short history of the dealings between the parties can be conveniently summarised as follows. The Gladstone Area Water Board is a water authority under the Water Act 2000 (Qld) and its CEO is Jim Grayson. The Gladstone Regional Council is a local government under the Local Government Act 2009 (Qld).AJ Lucas is a building company and its CEO is Allan Campbell. On 12 September 2011, the Gladstone parties entered into a contract with AJ Lucas pursuant to a formal instrument of agreement in relation to a joint project to provide water and sewerage pipeline infrastructure and access roads between Gladstone and Curtis Island. On 7 or 8 June 2012, the parties entered into a Deed of Termination[2] which brought the construction contract to an end on 8 June 2012. The Deed of Termination provided that AJ Lucas’ claims, as set out in Schedule 2 of that Deed, survived the termination and were to be dealt with in accordance with the Deed of Termination. That Deed then provided a regime by which the parties could attempt to settle their dispute by negotiations and, if the negotiations failed, there would be a reference to an expert panel for determination.[2]For purposes of clarity, the Deed of Settlement is referred to as “the Deed” and the Deed of Termination as “the Deed of Termination”. On 8 June 2012, payment claim No 12 and the final payment claim No 13 had not been submitted. On 14 June 2012, AJ Lucas submitted claim Nos 11 and 12 for work up to 25 May 2012. On 15 June 2012, claim No 13 was submitted. The Deed of Termination provided that the representatives of the parties would meet and negotiate in order to settle those claims. The parties met on 12 July 2012 and a mediation was held between 27 and 29 August 2012 with a further meeting on 19 September 2012. No agreement was reached. On 22 October 2012, the parties engaged an expert panel to provide an expert determination of the disputes between the parties. On 5 November 2012, Mr Grayson from the Gladstone parties sent an email to Mr Campbell from AJ Lucas indicating that it would be costly for the full scope of all the claims to be included in the expert determination process and set out a settlement offer of $25,074,918.62 for all of AJ Lucas’ claims under the Deed except for identified exclusions. The letter noted that there was a preliminary conference of the experts on 19 November 2012 and he requested a formal response by Thursday, 15 November 2012. A draft Deed of Settlement No 1 was attached to the email. That draft Deed set out in a table what items were not to be resolved by the Deed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the appeal, focusing on the legal consequences of the primary judge's findings. Firstly, regarding the intention to be bound, the court examined the conduct of the parties and the context of their negotiations. The court found that the negotiations were not preliminary but were undertaken with a view to reaching a final settlement, which evidenced an intention to be bound. Secondly, the court looked at whether an offer capable of acceptance was made by the respondents. The court considered the offer made by the Gladstone parties via email to AJ Lucas, noting that it was clear, specific, and left nothing open for negotiation. This satisfied the requirements for an offer capable of acceptance. Thirdly, the court analysed whether there was a difference between the terms of the final offer and the earlier oral agreement. The court found that the terms were substantially the same, with only minor variations that did not affect the overall agreement. Finally, the court concluded that a binding contract was formed when the CEO of AJ Lucas accepted the terms of the offer, as evidenced by his conduct and correspondence. The court held that the acceptance by the CEO, who had the authority to bind the company, completed the contract formation process. The ratio decidendi of the case is that where parties engage in detailed negotiations with a view to settling a dispute and one party makes a clear and specific offer, followed by acceptance of those terms by the other party's authorised representative, a binding contract is formed, even in the absence of a formal written agreement.