Aitchison v Director of Public Prosecutions (ACT)

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
COURT OF APPEAL

Case Title:

Aitchison v Director of Public Prosecutions (ACT)  

Citation:

[2021] ACTCA 21

Hearing Date:

2 June 2021

DecisionDate:

27 August 2021

Before:

Mossop J

Decision:

The application for an extension of time within which to appeal out of time from the conviction recorded on 27 April 2018 and the sentence imposed on 13 August 2018 is dismissed.

Catchwords:

APPEAL – CRIMINAL LAW – Application for leave to appeal out of time – appeal against conviction and sentence – sexual intercourse with a young person – act of indecency with a young person – appeal commenced then discontinued – lengthy period of delay – inadequate explanation for delay – whether counsel at trial was incompetent – poor prospects of appeal – application dismissed

Legislation Cited:

Court Procedure Rules 2006 (ACT), rr 5471, 5510

Supreme Court Act 1933 (ACT), ss 37J(1)(b), 37O(2)(a)(i)

Cases Cited:

Alkhair v The Queen [2016] NSWCCA 4; 255 A Crim R 419

Bridges v The Queen (1998) 20 WAR 59
Burnett v FitzGerald and Browne [2015] TASSC 51; 25 Tas R 42
Burridge v Chief Magistrate of the Magistrates Court of the Australian Capital Territory [2017] ACTCA 24
Grierson v The King (1938) 60 CLR 431
M v The Queen (1994) 181 CLR 487
MFA v The Queen [2002] HCA 53; 213 CLR 606
Nudd v The Queen [2006] HCA 9; 35 SASR 356
Outram v R [2013] NSWCCA 329
Pell v The Queen [2020] HCA 12; 268 CLR 123
R v Aitchison (No 3) [2018] ACTSC 214
R v Clark [2003] NSWCCA 308
R v Marriner [2006] QCA 32; 1 Qd R 179
R v McNamara (No 2) [1997] 1 VR 257
RA v R [2020] NSWCCA 356
Tognolini v The Queen (No 2) [2012] VSCA 311

Vojneski v The Queen [2015] ACTCA 44; 262 A Crim R 370

Parties:

John Aitchison ( Applicant)

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions ( Respondent)

Representation:

Counsel

K Clowry ( Applicant)

K McCann ( Respondent)

Solicitors

Cruz Clowry Law Group (Applicant)

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions ( Respondent)

File Number:

ACTCA 14 of 2021

Decision under appeal: 

Court/Tribunal:             ACT Supreme Court

Before:  Elkaim J

Date of Decision:          13 August 2018 

Case Title:  R v Aitchison (No 3)

Citation: [2018] ACTSC 214

MOSSOP J:

Introduction

  1. The applicant was convicted of 12 offences after a trial before a judge and jury which occurred between 18 April 2018 and 27 April 2018. The charges on which he was convicted were seven counts of an act of indecency with a young person and five counts of sexual intercourse with a young person. The complainant was the same in relation to each offence. The counts related to offending between 27 July 1987 and 6 October 1989.

  1. On 18 May 2018 the applicant appealed from the jury’s decision to the Court of Appeal.

  1. On 13 August 2018 he was sentenced to a total sentence of imprisonment of nine…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Aitchison v Director of Public Prosecutions (ACT) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] ACTCA 21
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory heard an application by John Aitchison for an extension of time to appeal his conviction for sexual intercourse with a young person and acts of indecency with a young person, and the sentence imposed. The convictions arose from offences alleged to have occurred between 1987 and 1989. Aitchison had initially appealed his conviction, but this appeal was later discontinued. He subsequently applied for leave to appeal out of time, which was refused by the Registrar, leading to this application to the Court of Appeal.

The Court was required to determine whether to grant an extension of time for Aitchison to appeal his conviction and sentence. This involved considering the length of the delay, the adequacy of the explanation provided for the delay, the interests of the community and the victim, and the prospects of success of the proposed appeal. The applicant sought to argue that his representation at trial was incompetent, that the trial had miscarried due to the failure to tender evidence inconsistent with his guilt, and that the jury's verdict was unreasonable given the evidence.

In dismissing the application, the Court noted that time limits for appeals are significant and that the longer the delay, the greater the community's expectation that the criminal process has concluded. While courts may exercise latitude in granting extensions, the reasons for the delay must be acceptable. Here, the explanation for the significant delay was found to be inadequate. Furthermore, the Court considered the grounds of appeal, including allegations of incompetent legal representation and a miscarriage of justice, and found that the prospects of success were poor. The Court also had regard to the interests of the victim and the community in finality.

Background

Background to the litigation

John Aitchison was convicted in the ACT Supreme Court on 27 April 2018 on 12 charges related to sexual offences against a young person between 27 July 1987 and 6 October 1989. The victim, a talented violinist, came into contact with Aitchison when she was about 13 or 14 years old, during the time he was working at the All Saints’ Anglican Church in Ainslie. The charges included counts of acts of indecency and sexual intercourse with the young person. The Crown's case relied heavily on the victim's testimony, which was supported by expert evidence regarding delayed complaints by children and tendency evidence from two men who had been abused by Aitchison. Aitchison filed an appeal on 18 May 2018 but discontinued it on 14 September 2018 following advice that the appeal had almost zero chance of success. He then applied for leave to appeal out of time on 2 March 2021, citing mental health issues and the High Court decision in Pell v The Queen as reasons for the delay and potential merit in the appeal. The Court of Appeal considered the application on 2 June 2021 and examined the evidence and arguments supporting the grounds of appeal, which included claims of incompetent counsel and an unreasonable verdict. The Court found the explanations for the delay to be inadequate, the grounds of appeal to be weak, and the prospects of a successful appeal to be poor, ultimately dismissing the application for leave to appeal out of time.

The applicant, John Aitchison, was convicted by a jury in the ACT Supreme Court on 27 April 2018 of 12 offences, comprising seven counts of an act of indecency with a young person and five counts of sexual intercourse with a young person. He was sentenced to nine years' imprisonment with a non-parole period of five years on 13 August 2018. Aitchison appealed from the conviction and sentence to the ACT Court of Appeal on 18 May 2018, which appeal was subsequently discontinued on 14 September 2018. On 2 March 2021, Aitchison applied to the Registrar of the ACT Supreme Court for leave to appeal out of time from the conviction and sentence. That application was refused on 15 April 2021. On 29 April 2021, Aitchison applied to the ACT Court of Appeal to determine his application for leave to appeal out of time. The application was heard on 2 June 2021, and the Court dismissed the application on 27 August 2021. The Court found that the application was filed more than three years after the sentence was imposed and that Aitchison had failed to provide an acceptable explanation for the delay in bringing the application. The Court also found that the proposed grounds of appeal were weak and that the prospects of success of an appeal were poor.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Court of Appeal have jurisdiction to grant an extension of time for a further appeal in circumstances where an earlier appeal has been discontinued?
2. Was the delay in bringing the application for an extension of time adequately explained?
3. Did the applicant's counsel act incompetently in failing to introduce certain evidence at trial?
4. Does the decision in Pell v The Queen (2020) HCA 12 provide a basis for the applicant's appeal?
5. Is the appeal based on the assertion that the jury's verdict was unreasonable or cannot be supported, given the evidence and the whole of the available material in the trial, likely to succeed?

Held
1. The Court of Appeal does not have jurisdiction to grant an extension of time for a further appeal in circumstances where an earlier appeal has been discontinued. The application for leave to appeal out of time is dismissed.
2. The delay in bringing the application for an extension of time was not adequately explained. The applicant's mental health issues were not enough to justify the significant delay in pursuing the appeal.
3. The applicant's counsel did not act incompetently in failing to introduce certain evidence at trial. The evidence that the applicant contends should have been presented was either not relevant or not admissible in the circumstances of the case.
4. The decision in Pell v The Queen (2020) HCA 12 does not provide a basis for the applicant's appeal. The decision did not change the law, and a mere factual similarity between the cases is not enough to establish the merit of an appeal.
5. The appeal based on the assertion that the jury's verdict was unreasonable or cannot be supported, given the evidence and the whole of the available material in the trial, is unlikely to succeed. The identified grounds of appeal are weak, and the application for an extension of time is dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal, in dismissing the application for an extension of time, considered several key issues. The court began by addressing whether it had the jurisdiction to grant such an extension in the context of a discontinued appeal. Although the respondent argued that the discontinuance of the earlier appeal precluded the granting of leave to appeal out of time, the court did not deem it necessary to resolve this question given the other issues before it. Instead, it focused on the merits of the application, the explanation for the delay, the alleged incompetence of counsel, and the basis for the appeal itself.

The court was not persuaded by the applicant's explanation for the delay in bringing the application for an extension of time. The applicant's affidavit mentioned a history of mental health difficulties, but this did not substantiate a claim that he was unfit to provide instructions to his counsel during the trial or the period when his earlier appeal was active. The court found that the applicant's mental health history, as evidenced by expert reports, did not support the contention that he was unable to participate in the appeal process.

The court examined the grounds of appeal alleging incompetence of counsel and found them to be inadequately supported. The applicant pointed to several pieces of evidence that should have been introduced or called at trial, including evidence of the applicant's sexual orientation, psychological or medical evidence regarding sexual dysfunctionality, and evidence of the applicant's tenure at All Saints' church. However, the court found that these grounds were weak because they did not explain how the proposed evidence could have been introduced without prejudice to the applicant's case. Additionally, the applicant's failure to cross-examine effectively and in accordance with instructions was considered, but the court found the submissions to be lacking in specificity and unlikely to establish a miscarriage of justice.

The court also dismissed the suggestion that the decision in Pell v The Queen (2020) HCA 12 provided a basis for the applicant's appeal. The court clarified that the Pell decision did not change the law and that factual similarities alone were insufficient to establish the merit of an appeal. The court found that the applicant's assertion that the jury's verdict was unreasonable or unsupported by the evidence did not demonstrate the merit of this ground of appeal.

Finally, the court assessed the overall prospects of the appeal and concluded that they were poor. Given the lengthy delay for which there was only a poor explanation, and the weak grounds of appeal, the court determined that there was not a sufficiently arguable case of a miscarriage of justice warranting an extension of time. Therefore, the application for an extension of time was dismissed. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that an application for an extension of time to appeal out of time must be supported by a strong explanation for the delay and compelling grounds of appeal, particularly in the context of a lengthy delay and a previously discontinued appeal.