Agar and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 1074

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No N1998/1741

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION          )      
           Re      NEERA AGAR         
  Applicant

And    AUSTRALIAN POSTAL CORPORATION        
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       The Hon Mr R N J Purvis, QC, Deputy President         

Date7 December 2000

PlaceSydney

Decision      Leave is granted to the Applicant to lodge an application for review of the Respondent's decision of 20 November 1995, the same to be so lodged within 28 days of the publication of this decision.  No order as to costs.      

……………………..
  R N J Purvis
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
COMPENSATION – extension of time – approximately two years out of time – whether acceptable explanation of delay – whether fair and equitable in the circumstances to extend time – whether action taken by applicant which makes the decision-maker aware that applicant contests the finality of the decision is relevant – whether prejudice to the respondent – whether unsettling of established practices – merits of the substantial application – consideration of fairness between applicant and other persons in a like position – evidence – state of mind and belief of the applicant – intent to seek review

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975

Hunter Valley Developments v Cohen (1984) 3 FCR 344
Re Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation and Barbara (1987) 6 AAR 300
Agar v Australian Postal Corporation (1998) 56 ALD 361
Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor (1996) 186 CLR 541
Comcare v A'Hearn (1993) 45 FCR 441
Mulheron and Australian Telecommunications Corporation (1991) 14 AAR 42

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Application:

  1. This is an application by Mrs Neera Agar ("the Applicant") by which she seeks leave pursuant to section 29(7) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 for extension of time to bring a substantive application before the Tribunal. By the latter application she would ask that a review be had of a decision of a delegate of the Australian Postal Corporation ("the Respondent") terminating compensation payments to her in relation to injuries sustained while employed by the Respondent. The extension of time application came before the Tribunal in 1998 when on 7 May 1998 the application was refused. On appeal to the Federal Court the then decision of the Tribunal was set aside, the matter being remitted for further consideration according to law.
    The injury and termination of compensation payments:

  2. As succinctly put by the Federal Court in its reasons for decision on the appeal:

    "The Applicant is 51 years of age and commenced work with [the Respondent] as a postal services officer in April 1992. While performing a task at the North Sydney post office on 7 September 1993, the Applicant caught her right foot between two milk crates causing her to fall on her back and injure her right ankle. The [Respondent] accepted the Applicant's claim for compensation arising from the injury and compensation payments were made for the following two years. On 20 June 1995 the [Respondent] wrote to the Applicant notifying her that her entitlement to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Agar and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] AATA 1074
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Agar v Australian Postal Corporation involves the Applicant, who is seeking compensation for an injury sustained during her employment with the Respondent, Australian Postal Corporation. The dispute pertains to the Respondent's refusal to pay compensation, which led the Applicant to file an application for an extension of time to seek review of the decision. The matter was heard in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Tribunal should accept the Applicant's explanation for the delay in seeking review, if it was fair and equitable to extend the time limit, and whether the Respondent was sufficiently aware of the Applicant's contestation of the decision.

The court examined the Applicant's explanation for the delay, which spanned approximately two years, and found it reasonable. The Applicant had consistently communicated her ongoing medical condition and her disagreement with the Respondent's decision through medical reports, certificates, and correspondence. The Tribunal acknowledged that the Respondent was made aware of the Applicant's contention that her condition was linked to the 1993 accident, thereby fulfilling the requirement that the decision-maker be aware of the finality of the decision being contested. The court also highlighted the need to consider the fairness between the Applicant and others in similar positions and whether the merits of the Applicant's claim warranted an extension of time.

Ultimately, the Tribunal decided that it was fair and equitable to extend the time limit for the Applicant to seek review. The court found that the Applicant had provided a credible explanation for the delay and had kept the Respondent informed about her condition and her disagreement with the decision. The Tribunal concluded that the Respondent was aware of the Applicant's contestation, and there was no significant prejudice to the Respondent or disruption to established practices. The court's decision was based on the Applicant's ongoing medical condition, the continuous communication of her situation to the Respondent, and the lack of any substantial negative impact on the Respondent.

The final orders of the Tribunal were to grant the Applicant's application for an extension of time to seek review of the Respondent's decision. This ruling allowed the Applicant to proceed with her claim, ensuring that her rights to contest the decision were upheld despite the delay.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The explanation of delay provided by the Applicant is one that the Tribunal considers it should accept. It was not put to the Applicant in the course of her cross examination that there was a lack of sincerity in requests made by her of the Respondent or that the condition of which she complained was other than real. The Tribunal accepts the reasonableness of the explanation of the delay even be it over a relatively long period of time.Applicant making the decision maker and any other party to the decision aware that the finality of the decision was contested: The Federal Court in it's decision in Agar v Australian Postal Corporation (1998) 56 ALD 361 at page 370 observed: It was submitted on behalf of the Applicant that the Respondent was well aware that she contested the finality of its decision. Throughout the period February 1996 to March 1998 it received medical reports from the Applicant's doctors all of which referred to an ongoing problem with her right leg. From February 1996 to March 1997 the Respondent received medical certificates which referred to the injury and certified her as unfit for work because of a diagnosis which related to that injury and her ongoing medical condition. During the period February 1996 to March 1997 the Respondent sought permission from the Applicant to confer with and if necessary obtain medical information from her treating medical experts in relation to the ongoing problems with her right ankle. The Applicant lodged applications for leave in 1995 and 1996 seeking "compensation leave" consequent on problems with her right ankle. In October 1997 she wrote to the Respondent referring to her accident, the subject decision and evidence provided by the Respondent's own medical advisers and entreating the Respondent to reconsider it's position. "It is only because of my liking for the job and the family support that I have lasted so far". It was submitted on behalf of the Respondent that the Applicant failed to tell "anyone at all" in the Respondent's employ "that she disputed the decision". The provision of the medical reports as earlier detailed in these reasons provides ample evidence as to the employer being put on notice and kept on notice as to the Applicant not accepting the Respondent's contention that "there was anything wrong with her." The relevant decision was to the latter effect, whereas the Applicant, per medium of the material furnished to her employer, maintained otherwise. The Tribunal is of the opinion that the Respondent was well aware over the whole of the relevant period that the finality of its decision was contested. The acceptance by it of the reports, requests made for further information and for the Applicant herself to be examined by its medical experts is further evidence of this prerequisite being satisfied.The merits of a substantive application: As has already been indicated it is not necessary for the Tribunal to make a definitive assessment as to the merits of a substantive application if made by the Applicant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On the basis of the above reports and the affirmation on reconsideration of the original decision the Applicant says she believed the then condition was to be accepted and she could continue with her work in the environment as it then existed.The period following the reconsideration to the time when notice was given to the Respondent of intent to seek review: It is not a part of the task presently before the Tribunal for it to reach a definitive decision on the nexus between the 1993 accident and the current medical condition of the Applicant. It is germane however for it to consider the continuing medical condition, why the Applicant did not make application to the Tribunal at an earlier date and the extent to which the Respondent was kept on notice as to such medical condition and the contended nexus with the original accident. The Tribunal has earlier set forth in these reasons the factual situation and the progression of the relevant pain, discomfort and disabilities. Exhibit E in the proceedings was said to comprise all relevant reports and certificates extending from the expiration of the statutory time limit to the time when the application for extension of time was made. The significant aspect of the material is the continuing pain and suffering being experienced by the Applicant, the fact that she was continually seeking medical advice and that she constantly kept the Respondent informed by provision of copies of reports of her progress, of the various opinions and the likelihood of her claim for compensation being maintained and her non-acceptance of the subject decision. It is also apparent that the Respondent called upon the Applicant and her medical advisers for copies of relevant reports and sought to have the Applicant examined by its medical advisers. It is sufficient to this end to note that relevant medical information was constantly provided to the Respondent. Originals of the following reports or copies of the reports were forwarded to it. The Respondent, as also noted, caused its own examinations to be conducted:(a)Dr Crichton provided reports in February and April 1996, April and September 1997 and February 1998 generally recommending that the Applicant be allowed to remain sedentary in the hope that the pain would resolve. Nexus with the accident in 1993 is implicit.(b)Dr Steel, a general practitioner, in March 1996 reported the Applicant's unfitness for work and need for physiotherapy treatment.(c)Dr C Chen, consultant in occupational medicine, in March 1996 sought earlier medical information before conducting an examination.(d)Medical certificates under workcover signed by Dr Delaney, his reports and reports of other medical officers of April, June, July and October 1996, February and April 1997, January and March 1998.(e)Various of the medical practitioners made claim for payment on the Respondent.(f)In October 1996 and January 1998 the Applicant authorised a medical services adviser retained by the Respondent to exchange medical information.(g)Medical certificates under workcover and reports of Dr Henschke of October and November 1996, where mention was made of the continuing contentions of the Applicant and Respondent, and of the position "of the two parties" being "now deeply ingrained".(h)Reports of Dr Lane of November 1996, July 1997 and February 1998 associating the Applicant's adverse condition with the 1993 accident.(i)Request from the Respondent in November and December 1996 for the Applicant to be seen by a Commonwealth medical officer.(j)Report of Dr Connor of November 1996 speaking inter alia of a "long and drawn out problem".(k)A leave application letter from the Applicant to the Respondent in December 1996 together with a report from Dr Henschke seeking one years leave without pay stating in support:"As you are aware since sustaining a fall whilst working in the North Sydney post office on 7 September 1993, I have suffered continuing and significant pain and swelling in my right ankle. There is now overwhelming evidence to indicate that:Prolonged standing aggravates the condition and only long rest – ranging from weeks to months – partially relieves it."I have been continuing with treatment for this problem while working, however with minimal success for I am neither able to do my work effectively and regularly - due to significant leg pain – nor effectively treat the condition – because of a lack of sufficient rest. As a result I have suffered physically, psychologically and financially.In such circumstances and supported by medical advice I am thus forced to the conclusion that unless I fully concentrate on my illness (ie total rest, physiotherapy and other therapies) my injury may become irreparable. Indeed it has already worsened since it's onset three years ago.In order to aim for such a recovery a significant period off work is necessitated.…"(l) Workplace assessments on behalf of the Respondent in January 1997 and a report for fitness for duty, canvassing the various issues between the parties compiled by a Commonwealth medical officer. A letter from the Respondent to the Applicant of 31 January 1997 stated:"I refer to your claim for compensation in respect of sprained right ankle and strained left neck muscle and the enclosed account.As previously advised by this office liability to pay compensation in relation to your claim was ceased on and from 16 May 1995 [settlement of the account is therefore your responsibility/the receipt is there for return for your records]. Please advise your doctor and other service providers that Australia Post will nor be paying for any treatment of your condition provided after 16 May 1995.…"(m) Dr R Garrick October 1997, detailing the history of the injury and disabilities in contemplation of operative procedure.