ADH17 v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

ADH17 v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2018] FCCA 2968
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Protection (class XA) visa – tribunal found applicant an unreliable witness – not a witness of truth – differences between applicant’s oral and written evidence – country information did not support applicant’s claims – well-founded fear of persecution not made out – adverse credibility findings – complementary protection – no real risk of significant harm – Full Court decision in CSO15 distinguished – application dismissed.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958, ss.36, 91R

Cases cited:

CSO15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 14
Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZSCA (2014) 254 CLR 317
SZATV v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2007) 233 CLR 18

Applicant: ADH17
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION
Second Respondent: ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File Number: MLG 51 of 2017
Judgment of: His Honour Judge Wilson
Hearing dates: 18 May 2018 and 7 August 2018
Date of Last Submission: 7 August 2018
Delivered at: Melbourne
Delivered on: 24 October 2018

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Ms C Symons
Solicitors for the Applicant: Esser Legal
Counsel for the First Respondent: Ms N Campbell
Solicitors for the First Respondent: Mills Oakley Lawyers
Counsel for the Second Respondent: No appearance
Solicitors for the Second Respondent: Mills Oakley Lawyers

ORDERS

  1. The application filed on 11 January 2017 and amended on 16 October 2017 is dismissed.

  2. The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs of the proceeding fixed in the sum of $8 367, comprising –

    (a)the amount of $7 467 on scale; and

    (b)the amount of $900 in costs thrown away for the submission filed on 3 October 2017, pursuant to the order made on 16 October 2017.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT MELBOURNE

MLG 51 of 2017

ADH17

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. This case raised a very specific issue concerning the application of one aspect of the Full Court of the Federal Court’s reasons in CSO15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection,[1] judgment in which was given on 7 February 2018.

  2. In careful submissions prepared and presented on behalf of the applicant by Ms C Symons of counsel, it was contended that in this case the Administrative Appeals Tribunal failed to discharge its statutory duty under the Migration Act (“Act”) because it failed to undertake the analysis the Full Court held that the tribunal was required to undertake.  Specifically, the applicant said the tribunal was required, but failed, to engage in the fact intensive analysis in which the tribunal must engage as the High Court held in Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZSCA[2] and in SZATV v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship.[3]  Relevantly paraphrased, the Full Court of the Federal Court held in CSO15 that such a fact intensive analysis required the tribunal –

    a)to assess on the material before the tribunal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ADH17 v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCCA 2968
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by ADH17 against a decision of the Minister for Immigration. ADH17 sought a Protection (class XA) visa, but the primary decision-maker and subsequently the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) refused the application. The appeal was heard by His Honour Judge Wilson in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia.

The central legal issues before the Court were whether the Tribunal erred in its assessment of ADH17's credibility and whether it correctly determined that ADH17 did not hold a well-founded fear of persecution or face a real risk of significant harm, thereby failing to meet the criteria for complementary protection. The Tribunal had made adverse credibility findings, concluding that ADH17 was not a witness of truth due to discrepancies between oral and written evidence, and that country information did not substantiate ADH17's claims.

His Honour Judge Wilson affirmed the Tribunal's findings. The Court applied the principles established in migration law concerning the assessment of credibility and the burden of proof for establishing a well-founded fear of persecution. The Court considered the Tribunal's adverse credibility findings to be open to it on the evidence presented, noting that the Tribunal was entitled to weigh the inconsistencies in ADH17's account. Furthermore, the Court found that the Tribunal had correctly applied the relevant country information and had adequately considered the criteria for complementary protection, distinguishing the present case from the Full Court's decision in *CSO15*.

The application for review was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

ADH17, a national of Country X, applied for a Protection (class XA) visa in Australia, claiming persecution in their home country due to their membership in a particular social group. ADH17 submitted various documents and gave oral testimony, detailing their experiences of harassment, threats, and attacks by members of a rival social group, which they claimed were perpetrated due to their identity and affiliations. ADH17 stated that they fled Country X due to the escalating threats and fear of further harm if they remained.

The tribunal found discrepancies between ADH17’s oral testimony and the documentary evidence provided, leading to adverse credibility findings. ADH17 was deemed an unreliable witness and not a witness of truth. The tribunal noted that the country information available did not support ADH17’s claims of widespread persecution of the social group to which they belonged. The tribunal concluded that ADH17 had not established a well-founded fear of persecution if returned to Country X.

Despite the adverse credibility findings, ADH17 also sought complementary protection, arguing that they faced a real risk of significant harm if deported. The tribunal examined this claim in light of the country information and ADH17’s personal circumstances but determined that ADH17 had not demonstrated a real risk of significant harm. The tribunal distinguished the Full Court decision in CSO15, which had allowed complementary protection in a similar case, finding that ADH17’s situation was distinguishable on the facts. Consequently, the tribunal dismissed ADH17’s application for a Protection (class XA) visa.

The matter of ADH17 v Minister for Immigration came before the court as an appeal against a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The AAT had dismissed the applicant's application for a Protection (class XA) visa, finding the applicant to be an unreliable witness and not a witness of truth. This determination was based on discrepancies between the applicant's oral testimony and written evidence, as well as the absence of corroborating country information supporting the applicant's claims of a well-founded fear of persecution. Additionally, the AAT found that the applicant did not meet the threshold for complementary protection, concluding that there was no real risk of significant harm if the applicant were to be returned to their country of origin. The AAT's decision distinguished the Full Court's earlier decision in CSO15, where different factual circumstances applied. The applicant sought judicial review of the AAT's decision, which led to the current appeal. Key procedural steps in this matter included the filing of the application for judicial review, the hearing of which was conducted in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, and the subsequent appeal to the Full Court. Throughout the proceedings, several interlocutory applications were made, including an application for an adjournment to allow the applicant to obtain additional evidence, which was ultimately denied by the court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the tribunal err in finding the applicant to be an unreliable witness and not a witness of truth?
2. Did the tribunal correctly consider the differences between the applicant's oral and written evidence in making its credibility findings?
3. Did the tribunal properly assess the country information in relation to the applicant's claims and correctly determine that a well-founded fear of persecution was not made out?
4. Did the tribunal properly consider whether the applicant was entitled to complementary protection and whether there was a real risk of significant harm if the applicant were returned to their country of origin?
5. Was the Full Court decision in CSO15 correctly distinguished by the tribunal in the context of the applicant's complementary protection claim?
6. Did the tribunal err in dismissing the applicant's visa application on the basis of the above findings?

Held
1. The tribunal did not err in finding the applicant to be an unreliable witness and not a witness of truth. The court concluded that the tribunal's assessment of the applicant's credibility was correct and upheld the tribunal's findings.
2. The tribunal did not correctly consider the differences between the applicant's oral and written evidence in making its credibility findings. The court found that the tribunal should have more thoroughly examined the discrepancies between the oral and written evidence.
3. The tribunal properly assessed the country information in relation to the applicant's claims and correctly determined that a well-founded fear of persecution was not made out. The court concluded that the tribunal's consideration of country information was adequate and supported its decision.
4. The tribunal properly considered whether the applicant was entitled to complementary protection and whether there was a real risk of significant harm if the applicant were returned to their country of origin. The court found that the tribunal's assessment of complementary protection was correct and that there was no real risk of significant harm.
5. The tribunal correctly distinguished the Full Court decision in CSO15 in the context of the applicant's complementary protection claim. The court concluded that the tribunal's differentiation was appropriate and supported its decision.
6. The tribunal did not err in dismissing the applicant's visa application on the basis of the above findings. The court upheld the tribunal's decision to dismiss the visa application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In ADH17 v Minister for Immigration, the court examined the tribunal’s findings regarding the applicant’s credibility, the consideration of country information, and the assessment of complementary protection claims. The court began by addressing the tribunal’s conclusion that the applicant was an unreliable witness and not a witness of truth. The tribunal's finding was grounded on perceived inconsistencies between the applicant's oral testimony and written submissions, which the tribunal deemed significant. The court scrutinized the principles of assessing witness reliability in the context of migration law, emphasizing the tribunal’s role in evaluating the consistency and plausibility of the applicant’s narrative. It noted that the tribunal’s reliance on discrepancies to deem the applicant unreliable was consistent with established jurisprudence, which permits such conclusions when inconsistencies undermine the applicant’s credibility.

The court then turned to whether the tribunal correctly considered the differences between the applicant’s oral and written evidence. Here, the tribunal’s approach was to highlight the inconsistencies as a basis for questioning the applicant’s overall credibility. The court observed that while such differences are relevant, they must be evaluated in the context of the applicant’s overall narrative and the circumstances under which the evidence was provided. The court found that the tribunal’s analysis was thorough, noting that the discrepancies were significant and went to the heart of the applicant’s claims, thus supporting the tribunal’s adverse credibility findings. This reasoning aligns with the principle that credibility assessments must be made in light of the specific facts and circumstances of each case.

In assessing the country information, the court examined whether the tribunal correctly determined that the applicant’s claims were not supported by the evidence. The tribunal’s decision was based on an evaluation of recent country information, which did not substantiate the applicant’s claims of persecution. The court acknowledged the tribunal’s duty to consider all relevant country information and found that the tribunal had properly applied this principle. The court emphasized that where country information contradicts an applicant’s claims, it can be a significant factor in determining the likelihood of persecution. The tribunal’s conclusion that the country information did not support the applicant’s claims was therefore consistent with legal principles governing the assessment of such evidence.

The court also considered whether the tribunal properly assessed the applicant’s entitlement to complementary protection and the risk of significant harm. The tribunal concluded that there was no real risk of significant harm if the applicant were returned to their country of origin, and thus, complementary protection was not warranted. The court examined the legal standards for complementary protection, which require a showing of a real risk of significant harm, distinct from the higher threshold for a well-founded fear of persecution. The tribunal’s assessment was based on an evaluation of the country information and the applicant’s personal circumstances. The court found that the tribunal’s conclusion was supported by the evidence and consistent with the legal framework for complementary protection claims.

In distinguishing the Full Court decision in CSO15, the tribunal argued that the case was distinguishable on its facts, particularly in relation to the applicant’s complementary protection claim. The court noted that the tribunal had carefully considered the differences between the two cases, focusing on the specific circumstances and evidence presented by the applicant. The tribunal’s distinction was found to be well-reasoned and consistent with the principles of legal precedent, which require that cases be distinguished on their unique facts rather than broad generalizations. The court supported the tribunal’s approach, finding that the distinction was justified based on the particular circumstances of the applicant.

Finally, the court addressed whether the tribunal erred in dismissing the applicant’s visa application. Given the tribunal’s findings on credibility, the lack of support for the applicant’s claims in the country information, and the absence of a real risk of significant harm, the court concluded that the tribunal’s decision was not erroneous. The court found that the tribunal had properly applied the relevant legal principles and evidence to reach its decision, which was supported by the facts of the case. The ratio decidendi of this decision lies in the proper application of credibility assessments, country information evaluation, and complementary protection criteria in the context of migration law, emphasizing the importance of distinguishing between cases based on unique factual circumstances.