ACN 068 691 092 Pty Ltd v Plan 4 Insurance Services Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court: Civil)

ACN 068 691 092 PTY LTD & ANOR v PLAN 4 INSURANCE SERVICES PTY LTD & ORS

[2012] SASCFC 25

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Anderson, The Honourable Justice Kelly and The Honourable Justice Stanley)

22 March 2012

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INTERFERENCE WITH JUDGE'S FINDINGS OF FACT - FUNCTIONS OF APPELLATE COURT - FINDINGS ON ISSUE OF NEGLIGENCE

TRADE AND COMMERCE - TRADE PRACTICES AND RELATED MATTERS - CONSUMER PROTECTION - MISLEADING, DECEPTIVE OR UNCONSCIONABLE CONDUCT

INSURANCE - GENERAL - POLICIES OF INSURANCE - RENEWAL, AFFIRMATION, RECTIFICATION OR NOVATION OF POLICY

Appeal against decision of trial Judge dismissing appellants’ claim against the respondents for alleged misleading, deceptive and negligent conduct – policy of insurance issued by respondents over shop premises owned by appellant companies – all properties destroyed by fire – Director of appellant companies reduced insurance cover over the properties prior to the fire – allegations of misleading and deceptive conduct against second respondent as a result of discussions with Director of appellant companies when reduction in insurance cover requested – allegations of negligence arising out of format of policy documents issued by the respondents from mid 2004 to July 2006 – appellants claimed policy documentation issued by respondents inaccurate and misleading and thereby induced Director to make an erroneous assumption which was never corrected by the respondents – allegations that loss to appellant companies caused by respondents’ conduct as a whole.

Held:  appeal dismissed – the evidence did not establish any misleading and deceptive conduct on the part of the respondents – any erroneous assumption held by the Director of the appellant companies was not caused or induced by any conduct of the respondents – in any event by the date of the fire the Director of the appellant companies was aware of the underinsurance over the properties and did nothing about it – conduct of respondents in issuing of policy documents between 2004 to 2006 not deceptive or misleading – trial Judge’s decision was based on adverse findings of credit in relation to Director’s evidence – no basis to disturb findings of credit – in any event even if Director’s evidence had been accepted, appellants did not establish any misleading, negligent or deceptive conduct on the part of the respondents.

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INTERFERENCE WITH DISCRETION OF COURT BELOW - PARTICULAR CASES - OTHER MATTERS - COSTS

Appeal against costs awarded in favour of third and fourth respondents respectively and costs awarded to each of the respondents in respect of the cross-actions.

Held: no error in exercise of the discretion to award costs – trial Judge took into account relevant considerations – no proper basis established to disturb trial Judge’s orders.

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) s 12DA; Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 1041H(1), referred to.
Miller & Associates Insurance Broking Pty Ltd v BMW Australia Finance Ltd (2010)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ACN 068 691 092 Pty Ltd v Plan 4 Insurance Services Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SASCFC 25
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned a claim brought by ACN 068 691 092 Pty Ltd and another appellant (the appellants) against Plan 4 Insurance Services Pty Ltd and another respondent (the respondents). The dispute arose after the appellants' shop premises were destroyed by fire. The appellants alleged that the respondents engaged in misleading, deceptive, and negligent conduct in relation to an insurance policy covering the properties. Specifically, the appellants contended that discussions with a director of the second respondent concerning a reduction in insurance cover were misleading, and that the format of policy documents issued between mid-2004 and July 2006 were inaccurate and misleading, inducing an erroneous assumption by the appellants' director which was not corrected. The appeal was heard by Anderson, Kelly, and Stanley JJ.

The central legal issues before the appellate court were whether the trial judge erred in finding that the respondents' conduct did not amount to misleading or deceptive conduct under relevant legislation, and whether the respondents were negligent. The appellants argued that the policy documentation was misleading and that the respondents' conduct, as a whole, caused the loss suffered by the appellant companies. The court was required to consider whether any erroneous assumptions held by the appellants' director were caused or induced by the respondents' actions, and whether the trial judge's findings of fact, particularly regarding the creditworthiness of the appellants' director, were sustainable.

The appellate court dismissed the appeal, upholding the trial judge's decision. The court found that the evidence did not establish any misleading or deceptive conduct by the respondents. It was held that any erroneous assumption made by the appellants' director was not caused or induced by the respondents' conduct. Furthermore, by the time of the fire, the director was aware of the underinsurance and took no action. The court also concluded that the policy documents issued between 2004 and 2006 were neither deceptive nor misleading. The trial judge's adverse findings regarding the credit of the appellants' director were considered a crucial factor, and the appellate court found no basis to disturb these findings. Even if the director's evidence had been accepted, the court determined that the appellants had not established misleading, negligent, or deceptive conduct on the part of the respondents.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellants also contend that the trial Judge erred in law in finding that the first and second respondents’ conduct did not amount to misleading conduct within the meaning of s 12DA of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) (the ASIC Act) and s 1041H(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Corporations Act) and that the respondents were not negligent. Factual Background Before dealing with the legal issues which arise for determination it is necessary to set out the history of the dealings between the relevant parties. Much of the factual background is uncontentious. In 2002 Mr Scragg and Mr Zientara (and their respective interests) purchased the whole of the properties at 87-91 Commercial Road, Port Adelaide for $300,000. There were two titles, one encompassing two shops at 87-89 Commercial Road and the other encompassing one shop at 91 Commercial Road, Port Adelaide. The shop at 87 was a St Vincent De Paul shop selling second hand clothes. The shop next door at 89 was known as the Conti Bar and was a clothing shop. The shop at 91 was vacant at the time of purchase but subsequently became known as the Swop Shop. The agreement between the parties was that the Zientaras would purchase 91 Commercial Road for $140,000. Mr Scragg and his interests would purchase 87-89 Commercial Road for $160,000. Mr Scragg signed the contract for purchase of the properties as nominee. The properties always remained on separate titles. Mr Scragg and Mr Zientara had known each other since about 1980. They met through family connections. Thereafter they had a number of business dealings and were in the habit of meeting regularly for coffee. As a result of a suggestion made by Mr Scragg to Mr Zientara, Mr Zientara contacted Mr Dixon regarding insurance. Mr Dixon later produced a quotation for insurance for the two properties as a whole for $300,000 plus an additional sum of $20,000 for demolition costs. After Mr Dixon met with Mr Zientara at the property the quotation was sent by post to Mr Scragg and the Zientaras. Mr Scragg said he left it entirely to Mr Zientara and Mr Dixon as to how to arrange the insurance on the properties. He was not particularly interested in the mechanism by which that occurred. Payment of the initial premium in respect of the policy was made by Mr Zientara with a Visa credit card. Mr Scragg then reimbursed Mr Zientara in respect of his portion of the premium for 87-89 Commercial Road. The relevant policy of insurance number AP8IL001444 was issued in the name of both Mr Scragg and Mr Zientara. Throughout the whole of the period from 2002 until the date of the fire on 27 July 2006 the policy number remained the same. The Renewal Notice for 2003 was sent with a covering letter to Mr Zientara and Mr Scragg to Mr Zientara’s post box address at Hindmarsh. At that time there were some discussions between Mr Dixon and Mr Zientara about splitting the single premium which later led to the appellants’ property and the Zientaras’ property being separately described on the policy of insurance.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The trial Judge made findings about that conversation:[38][38] ACN 068 691 092 Pty Ltd & Anor v Plan 4 Insurance Services Pty Ltd & Ors [2011] SADC 59 at [47], [140], [145], [147], [156], [158] and [160].[47]The plaintiffs allege that the actions of Mr Dixon at the meeting and following the meeting amounted to misleading conduct and that Mr Dixon was negligent. I will discuss the allegations in more detail later. One thing which is obvious is the lack of specificity in the statements made by both Mr Scragg and Mr Dixon.…[140]The conversation which is said to amount to the misleading conduct took place as part of an overall transaction which involved the reduction of the premium. That transaction culminated in the insurer forwarding to the insured at Mr Scragg's office the Confirmation of Advice. In that document Mr Dixon purported to confirm the discussions whereby Mr Scragg gave instructions to divide the sum insured between the two properties.…[145]Mr Scragg’s evidence was that he asked how much cover or insurance "did I have in relation to Commercial Road". If those words accurately described the question asked by Mr Scragg the question did not make it clear whether Mr Scragg was enquiring as to the plaintiffs’ properties alone or whether his enquiry related to all of the properties at Commercial Road.…[147]Mr Dixon responded to Mr Scragg's question saying "$1.3 million". If the question was directed to all Commercial Road properties that answer would have been correct. That is how Mr Dixon interpreted Mr Scragg's question. His answer to the question is understandable. Mr Scragg could have made the information which he sought clearer. Given the history of the policy and the form of the policy there was no reason why Mr Dixon should have interpreted Mr Scragg’s unspecific question to relate to the plaintiffs properties alone.…[156]If at the time of the meeting with Mr Dixon on 9 March 2005 Mr Scragg was misled as to the extent of the cover over 87-89 Commercial Road and because of that Mr Scragg gave instructions which resulted in the cover over that property being reduced from $800,000 to $400,000 I find that Mr Scragg failed to take reasonable care of his own interests. First, he did not make it clear that the cover that he was enquiring about was restricted to 87-89 Commercial Road. Secondly, he overlooked the fact that he had arranged cover over 87-89 Commercial Road to be increased to $800,000. Thirdly, he overlooked the information which was clearly set out in many documents which the plaintiffs had received from the insurer showing that the cover on 87-89 Commercial Road was $800,000, not $1.3 million, and that the cover on 91 Commercial Rd was $500,000. Mr Scragg should have known that the figure of $1.3 million was the total of the insurance on both 87-89 Commercial Road and 91 Commercial Road.…[158]Mr Scragg's question did not distinguish between the properties. I accept the submission of Mr Jones for the third defendant that any confusion on the part of Mr Scragg resulted from his own question.…[160]Mr Scragg's evidence as to the conversation on 9 March 2005 was confused and there is the possibility that Mr Dixon's answer was a correct answer to the question asked. The evidence does not establish that Mr Scragg's question was directed at the plaintiffs’ Commercial Road property rather than all the Commercial Road properties.[emphasis added]

Decision

Reasons for decision

ANDERSON J KELLY J
I would dismiss the appeal against the costs order made by the Judge.Conclusion The appellant cannot overcome significant findings adverse to Mr Scragg’s credit, which were central to the trial Judge’s conclusion that Mr Dixon’s conduct was not misleading. I do not accept that the trial Judge misunderstood the state of knowledge Mr Scragg had at the relevant time. Even if Mr Scragg’s evidence about the conversation on 9 March 2005 between Mr Scragg and Mr Dixon was accepted, the evidence at trial did not establish that Mr Dixon’s conduct was misleading or negligent. For these reasons I would dismiss this appeal. STANLEY J: I would dismiss the appeal. I agree with the reasons of Kelly J. I have also had the advantage of reading the reasons of Anderson J. I agree also with those reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: ANDERSON J, KELLY J