SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil)
ACN 068 691 092 PTY LTD & ANOR v PLAN 4 INSURANCE SERVICES PTY LTD & ORS
[2014] SASC 39
Reasons of Judge Withers a Master of the Supreme Court
20 March 2014
PROCEDURE - COSTS
INDEMNITY PRINCIPLE
Seal & Seal v Malaugh Holdings (No 2) Pty Ltd & Ors (No 2) [2008] SASC 223; Amendola & Anor v Olma (unreported, Master Rice, District Court Judgment No 176 of 2005), applied.
Trevorrow v State of South Australia (No 7) [2008] SASC 5; Wentworth v Rogers (2006) 66 NSWLR 474; Legal Costs South Australia Norman; Law of Costs Dal Pont, 3rd ed, considered.
ACN 068 691 092 PTY LTD & ANOR v PLAN 4 INSURANCE SERVICES PTY LTD & ORS
[2014] SASC 39
JUDGE WITHERS. This matter was an unsuccessful appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court against a judgment of a District Court Judge. The Court dismissed the appeal on 22 March 2012 – see ACN 068 691 092 Pty Ltd & Anor v Plan 4 Insurance Services Pty Ltd & Ors [2012] SASCFC 25.
The four respondents to the appeal obtained an order that the appellants pay them their costs of and incidental to the appeal. Since that time the respondents have submitted short form claims for costs to which the appellants have responded. The claim by the third respondent has been resolved. The claim by the fourth respondent has led to an application by the appellants filed on 18 October 2013 that the respondents provide to the appellants a copy of the accounts that they have rendered to their clients and a copy of their respective fee agreements. What was intended was an order that the respondents disclose to the appellants copies of accounts received by them from their solicitors in respect of their appeal costs. Various other relief was also sought – see interlocutory application FDN 25. In making that application the appellants rely on the indemnity principle.
The solicitor for the fourth respondent has filed a responding affidavit to which she has exhibited a copy of the fee agreements for both an interstate firm that acted for the fourth respondent, and the fee arrangements for her own firm. Both sets of solicitors were involved in defending the appellants’ appeal. In the third exhibit to her affidavit, or Court document FDN 30C, the Adelaide solicitor for the fourth respondent provides a copy of a letter forwarded by her to the solicitor for the appellants in which she provided to the appellants a copy of the fee accounts rendered to the fourth respondent both by the interstate solicitors and by her firm, but declined to provide a copy of the schedule of attendances appended to the original of each of those accounts. In that letter the solicitor for the fourth respondent noted that “such schedules would include various attendances which are not the subject of a claim for costs by way of the fourth respondent’s…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read ACN 068 691 092 Pty Ltd v Plan 4 Insurance Services Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] SASC 39
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether the indemnity principle should be applied globally or whether it could be applied on an item-by-item basis, and whether the detailed accounts of the work performed by the solicitors should be disclosed. The court examined the principles of the indemnity rule, which is designed to compensate the successful party for the legal costs incurred, but not to provide a punitive measure against the unsuccessful party. The court noted that the indemnity principle is a flexible principle, capable of accommodating conditional fee agreements and allowing for a just and fair result. The court found that there was a prospect of duplication of work by the interstate solicitor and the local solicitor, and of the accounts containing items of work not relevant to this action. The purpose of disclosing the detailed accounts was to identify any issues of duplication and any work external to the action that should not be included in fixing the cap.
The court concluded that the interests of justice mandated disclosure of those fee schedules annexed to the accounts in this action. Any confidential items could be redacted if necessary. The consequence of this ruling might be, or might not be, a reduction in the global cap, which may then have an impact on the amount allowed on an adjudication of the fourth respondent's costs on the Court schedule. However, it would not provide a fertile ground for the appellants to compare costs charged for each item of work and argue for a reduction if the amount charged was less than the scheduled fee for that particular item. The limited purpose of the disclosure was to identify whether or not the cap set by the addition of those various accounts should, for proper reason, be reduced.
The court ordered the fourth respondent to provide the appellants with a full copy of the accounts rendered by each of their solicitors to them within 14 days. The court noted that it would hear the parties as to costs if necessary, but its preliminary view was that costs should follow the event and that the appellants should have the costs of and incidental to the interlocutory application so far as this issue was concerned. The court certified fit for counsel.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi