Abbasi v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Abbasi v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 1274

IMMIGRATION – where Department provided Tribunal with information from files of members of the applicant’s family who were also applying for protection visas – where information provided to the Department in confidence in support of those person’s applications for visas – whether Secretary to the Department was obliged to notify the Tribunal in writing that s 438 of the Act applied to that information – whether failure to notify was a breach of s 476 – where if notice was given, the Tribunal was required to give a direction under s 440 – whether failure to give that direction was a breach of s 476 – whether personal information provided to the Department in support of a visa application is subject to the provisions of the Privacy Act 1988 – whether inference could be drawn that each member of the applicant’s family seeking protection visas consented to the use of information in each other’s application – whether relief would have been refused on discretionary grounds in any event.

Migration Act 1958 (Cth)
Privacy Act 1988 (Cth)

Coco v AN Clark Engineers (1996) RPC 4 cited
Applicant N – 106 of 2000 v MIMA [2000] FCA 866 cited
Hitchcock v TCN Channel Nine Pty Ltd (No. 2) [2000] NSWCA 82 referred to
MIMA v Yusuf [2001] HCA 30 cited
Ragunathan v MIMA [2001] FCA 1142 followed
Smith Kline & French Laboratories (Australia) Ltd v Secretary, Department of Community Services & Health (199) 22 FCR 73 followed
The King v Commonwealth Court of Conciliation & Arbitration;  Ex parte Ozone Theatres (Aust.) Ltd (1949) 78 CLR 389 followed
Qiu v MIMA (1994) 55 FCR 439 followed
Goldie v Commonwealth [2000] FCA 1873 followed

BAHMAN ABBASI v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

NO.  N 394 OF 2001

BEAUMONT J
21 SEPTEMBER 2001
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 394 OF 2001

BETWEEN:

BAHMAN ABBASI
APPLICANT

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

BEAUMONT J

DATE OF ORDER:

21 SEPTEMBER 2001

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The appeal be dismissed, with costs.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

 N 394 OF 2001

BETWEEN:

BAHMAN ABBASI
APPLICANT

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

BEAUMONT J

DATE:

21 SEPTEMBER 2001

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

BEAUMONT J:

INDEX

INTRODUCTION........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ..... 3
THE TRIBUNAL’S REASONS........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ . 3
THE APPLICANT’S CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ .... 3

(a)    The Tribunal’s general description of the material before it........ ........ ........ ........ ........ .... 3
(b)    Statement made by the applicant in interview on arrival........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ . 4
(c)    Statement made by the applicant in the visa application........ ........ ........ ........ ........…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Abbasi v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 1274
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Abbasi v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs involved the applicant, Bahram Abbasi, seeking a protection visa in Australia. The central dispute was whether Abbasi was eligible for refugee status based on his claims of persecution in Iran due to his political activities and his illegal departure from the country. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The legal issues that the court had to decide included whether Abbasi's claims about his persecution and the reasons for leaving Iran were credible, and if his illegal departure and use of a false passport could impact his eligibility for a protection visa. Additionally, the court had to consider the implications of Abbasi's criminal activities in Austria, including drug smuggling and people smuggling, on his character and credibility.

The court examined the evidence provided by Abbasi, including his statements to immigration officers, his statutory declaration, and other supporting documents. The Tribunal initially rejected Abbasi's claim for a protection visa based on his persecution claims but later set aside the decision, focusing on the risk he faced due to his illegal departure and his brother's protection visa. However, the court noted that no independent evidence supported this conclusion. Furthermore, subsequent information revealed that Abbasi had been untruthful in his statements and had a history of criminal activities, which raised questions about his credibility and character.

The court ultimately concluded that Abbasi's claims were not substantiated, and his illegal departure from Iran and criminal history further undermined his eligibility for a protection visa. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed, with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns Mr Bahram Abbasi, an Iranian national who applied for a protection visa in Australia. According to the Tribunal, Mr Abbasi had left Iran using a false Iranian passport in the name of Ali Reza Asghari, organised by his father, due to political problems he had with the Iranian government. These problems began at Tehran University where he attended a student protest about obtaining freedom in Iran. During the protest, soldiers attacked the demonstration, and while he and his brother were able to escape, those at the front were captured and taken away. The authorities subsequently came looking for him and his brother but did not catch him as he had run away from home. Mr Abbasi claimed that he would be in danger if returned to Iran and would have to go into hiding. He had attended the demonstration because he did not like the Iranian government and had been previously detained for minor incidents, including going to a party where he had a can of beer. He was detained for a month and a half, went to court, and was sentenced to eighty lashes. He was also detained numerous times for offences such as having a girl in his car, having long hair, and having a cassette tape in the car. Mr Abbasi came to Australia because his brothers had previously come there. He had to use a passport in a different name to leave Iran because of his involvement in the demonstration.

The matter came before the Tribunal for review of a decision made by the Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs regarding Mr Abbasi's application for a protection visa. The Tribunal reviewed the material before it, including the Department's file, the applicant's oral evidence, and written submissions. The Tribunal also had before it departmental files for protection visa applications made by other members of the applicant's family and Tribunal files relating to applications for review made by the applicant's brothers, Bahram and Peynam. The Tribunal set aside the primary decision refusing Mr Abbasi's application on the basis that the applicant could face persecution because he and his brother Mehran left Iran illegally and because Mehran had been granted a protection visa. The Tribunal did not refer to any independent evidence in support of this conclusion. The case was subsequently appealed, and the appeal was dismissed with costs.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

After explaining the meaning of the Convention as interpreted judicially, the Tribunal turned to describe the applicant’s claims and evidence as follows.THE APPLICANT’S CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE(a) The Tribunal’s general description of the material before it The Tribunal noted that before it were the following:(1)The Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affair’s (“the Department”) file (including a record of interview conducted on the applicant’s arrival in Australia); the applicant’s application for a protection visa; written submissions in support of the application; and a record of interview with a departmental officer.(2)The applicant’s oral evidence to the Tribunal on 7 February 2001.(3)Written submissions to the Tribunal in support of the application for review. The Tribunal also had before it:(1)Departmental files for protection visa applications made by other members of the applicant’s family viz., his parents and four of his six brothers (Mohammed, Bahram, Mehran and Peynam). (The other two brothers, Beynam and Mehrdad, have not been to Australia).(2)Tribunal files relating to applications for review made by the applicant’s brothers, Bahram and Peynam.(b) Statement made by the applicant in interview on arrival The Tribunal noted that the applicant had attempted to enter Australia from Seoul, Korea, by using a photo-substituted Israeli passport (later found to have been reported as lost or stolen) in the name of Ofer Meiseles. When questioned, the applicant initially insisted that he was Israeli and that the passport was his. When informed that he would be returned to Seoul, the applicant stated his real name and said that because he was a refugee from Iran, he could not return to Iran. The Tribunal noted that the applicant then gave the following version of events:·The applicant’s mother and brother were in Australia. He had left Iran one year previously on a false Iranian passport in the name of Ali Reza Asghari. His father had organised this passport for him.·He had left Iran because he had had political problems with the Iranian government. The problem had happened at Teheran University a year and a half previously. He was not a student at the university, but his brother Mehrdad was a student. He had attended a student protest in front of the university about obtaining freedom in Iran. When soldiers attacked the demonstration, he and his brother were able to escape as they were at the back of the crowd. Those at the front of the crowd were captured and taken away. A demonstrator who was arrested gave the Iranian officials the applicant’s name. The next day, the authorities came to look for him and his brother but did not catch him, as he had run away from home. He stayed at a house in Teheran until his father arranged a false passport on which he left Iran.·He would be in danger if he returned to Iran and he would have to go into hiding. He had attended the demonstration because he did not like the Iranian government. He had previously been detained for a minor incident more than two years previously (because he went to a party and had a can of beer). He was detained for a month and a half, went to court and was sentenced to eighty lashes. Also, he had been detained numerous times for offences such as having a girl in his car, having long hair and having a cassette tape in the car. He was usually detained for four to five hours and had been “bashed up”.·He had come to Australia because his brothers had previously come here. He had had to use a passport in a different name to leave Iran because of his involvement in the demonstration.(c) Statement made by the applicant in the visa application

Decision

Reasons for decision

BEAUMONT J
Of this decision, the present Tribunal said:“The Tribunal did not accept Mr [Bahram] Abbasi’s claim that he had been persecuted for a Convention reason in Iran. However, the Tribunal set aside the primary decision refusing Mr Abbasi’s application on the basis that the applicant could face persecution because he and his brother Mehran left Iran illegally and because Mehran had been granted a protection visa. The Tribunal did not refer to any independent evidence in support of this conclusion.”(g) Material placed on Mr Bahram Abbasi’s file after the Tribunal’s decision The present Tribunal said:“Subsequent to the Tribunal’s decision in Mr Bahram Abbasi’s case, information was provided to the Department which was relevant to the issue of his character. This information indicated that Mr Bahram Abbasi had been untruthful in relation to evidence he had given to the Department and the Tribunal. The information indicated, inter alia, that Mr Abbasi:· Had applied for refugee status in Austria. This had originally been refused but was then granted on appeal;· He had obtained an Iranian passport in 1993 which he used to return to Iran on more than one occasion;· He obtained a false Austrian visa which he had placed in his Iranian passport;· His refugee status was revoked following his return to Iran in 1994;· He married an Austrian national and he was granted residency in Austria on that basis;· He was convicted of people smuggling and drug smuggling in Austria;· As a result of the drug smuggling conviction, he was sentenced to two years imprisonment, but came to Australia before he could be taken into custody.In July 1999 the Department wrote to Mr Abbasi putting this information to him and telling him that the Minister might refuse to issue him a visa under section 501(1) of the Act. Mr Abbasi was given an opportunity to comment on this information.On 12 November 1999 Mr Ron Kessels, solicitor, provided written submissions in response to the Department’s letter. In these submissions Mr Kessels submitted, inter alia, that:· Mr Abbasi admitted the matters put to him by the Department and accepted that he could not satisfy the Minister that he passes the character test as defined by section 501(6) of the Act;· The Minister should exercise his discretion not to refuse to grant him a visa as he is a refugee and at risk of persecution if he were returned to Iran;· On 12 August 1994 Mr Abbasi was interviewed by Austrian immigration authorities at which time he effectively renounced his refugee status by advising them that he no longer feared returning to Iran. This was a lie. Since returning from Iran Mr Abbasi had been threatened by the Iranian Embassy and so felt that it would be better to change his status in Iran from that of a refugee to that of the spouse of an Austrian national;· Mr Abbasi realised that his lies to the Department and the Tribunal might amount to offences under the Migration Act 1958. However, his behaviour should be seen in the light of his personal circumstances at the time. He considered these actions were necessary to avoid what he perceived to be the real likelihood that the Austrian government would return him to Iran.At the time of writing this decision, the Department of Immigration had taken no further action in relation to Mr Bahram Abbasi’s case, either to issue a protection visa, to refuse to do so, or to prosecute Mr Abbasi in relation to possible breaches of the Migration Act 1958.”(h) Information in Departmental and Tribunal files relating to other members of the Abbasi family

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BEAUMONT J

The Tribunal further noted that in his accompanying statutory declaration, the applicant gave this version of events:·His family started having problems with the authorities after his brother Bahram was arrested in about 1991. Bahram had escaped from Iran and went to Austria. The authorities had come to their house, looking for Bahram. In about 1992, the authorities came to their house and arrested Mehran. Mehran had bruises and scars on his face when he was released from detention.·In about 1993, his brothers Peyman and Behnam were not living at home, as they were in hiding from the authorities. The authorities came to the house, looking for them, and then arrested Peyman.·In about 1994, his brother Bahram came back to Iran with his wife. His parents told him that Bahram came back to Iran because Peyman would not be released until he came back. They went to the airport to get Bahram and his wife, but Bahram was detained at the airport. Peyman was then released, and his father paid money to get Bahram out of Iran and back to Austria.·Sometimes when he was walking with a girl, or if his hair was too long, he was taken to the police station and hit. The applicant states that, after he finished school, he was with some friends at a party. He drank some beer at the party. The local Hezbollah police raided the party and started to arrest everyone. The applicant was taken to the police station and was held there for three days. He claims that he was told to sign papers but was not told what he was signing. He was handcuffed and taken to court. At the court the papers the applicant signed were read by the Mullah in charge. The applicant tried to explain that he had been forced to sign the papers, but was told to shut up. He was then taken to gaol and was kept there for six weeks. He was mistreated during this period. A guard told him that he was treated worse than other people because his family had a record of being against the government. After six weeks, he was taken back to court. The judge said that he was to be given eighty lashes before he was released. The applicant suffered major injuries to his back from the beating and was bleeding. He was released about five hours later.·The applicant was involved in student demonstrations in mid-1999. He had heard that there was to be a demonstration at the university. He attended the demonstration with his brother Mehrdad (who was a university student) and with a friend of Mehrdad’s. He chanted anti-government slogans. The demonstrators were supporting Khatami. The military attacked the students. Demonstrators were hit with batons and tear gas was used against them. He and his brother lost contact with their friend. The applicant and his brother hid in a small shop until it was safe to take a taxi home. The next day his friend’s mother phoned him to ask about her son. He told her that he did not know, as they had lost him at the university. The applicant believed that his friend had been arrested and would give the applicant’s and the applicant’s brother’s name to the security forces if he were questioned. The applicant and his brother went into hiding in a house in south Teheran. The house was rented in the name of his cousin. The applicant was in hiding for about three months before he left Iran.·The applicant’s father wanted him to leave Iran because of the danger he was in. His father paid a person he knew to arrange for him to leave. A contact of his father gave the applicant his ticket and an Iranian passport in the name “Alireza Asghari”. The passport contained the applicant’s photograph but not his date of birth. He left Iran for Malaysia on 15 September 1999.·The applicant was given a two week visa when he arrived in Malaysia. He met a Pakistani man who had his visa extended. About three months after he arrived in Malaysia, the Pakistani man arranged a British passport for him at a cost of US$4,000. When he tried to use the passport to leave Malaysia, he was told that the passport was false. He was held in the airport. An officer said that he could pay him a bribe, or else he would be sent back to Iran. The applicant paid the officer US$500. He was taken out of the airport and told not to try it again. The applicant then spoke to the Pakistani man who wanted another US$4,000 for another passport and ticket. The applicant did not have the money, so he contacted his family for it. His cousin told him that his father had been arrested. (This was in December 1999.) The applicant then used the Iranian passport to go to Thailand. In Thailand he met another Pakistani, who sold him an Israeli passport (in the name of Meiseles Ofer) and a ticket for US$3,000. The applicant travelled to Australia using this passport.·The applicant was afraid to return to Iran because he feared that he would be persecuted by the authorities who have targeted his family because of his brother Bahram. The applicant also claimed that he will be persecuted because he was involved in protests against the government, left Iran illegally and used an Israeli passport to enter Australia. The applicant stated that if the Iranian authorities learned that he had used an Israeli passport, this would create further problems for him. The applicant stated that he has not done military service and will have a problem because of this.(d) Statement made by Mr Bahram Abbasi in his statutory declaration