A1 Granny Flats v Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (icare)

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY A MEMBER

CITATION:

A1 Granny Flats v Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (icare) [2023] NSWPICPD 69

APPELLANT:

A1 Granny Flats

FIRST RESPONDENT:

Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (icare)

SECOND RESPONDENT:

Todd Martin

FILE NUMBER:

A1-W2524/22

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:

President Judge Phillips

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:

6 November 2023

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:

1.   The Certificate of Determination dated 9 December 2022 is confirmed.

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION – proceedings concerning the Commission’s determination of an uninsured employer’s liability for reimbursement pursuant to section 145 of the Workers Compensation Act1987 – employer bears the onus of proof in challenging a section 145 notice – Raniere Nominees Pty Limited v Daley [2005] NSWCA 121 applied – nature of s 145 proceedings is not “inquisitorial”– South Western Sydney Area Health Service v Edmonds [2007] NSWCA 16 applied – deemed date of injury affixed by s 15(1)(a) of Workers Compensation Act 1987 –Inghams Enterprises Pty Ltd v Thoroughgood [2014] NSWCA 166 – previously unnotified matters to be considered in context of guiding principle, s 42 of the Personal Injury Commission Act 2020 – elements of section 11A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 to be broadly approached – provision of employment benefits – Northern New South Wales Local Health Network v Heggie [2013] NSWCA 255 and Canterbury Bankstown Council v Gazi [2019] NSWWCCPD 14 applied – practitioner’s obligation to clearly identify error in grounds of appeal – Kowalski v Repatriation Commission [2011] FCAFC 43 and Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Quirk [2023] FCAFC 163 considered

HEARING:

On the papers

REPRESENTATION:

Appellant:

Mr P Macken, solicitor

Leigh Virtue & Associates

First Respondent:

Mr S Grant, counsel

Hall & Wilcox

Second Respondent:

Mr J McEnaney, counsel

Turner Freeman Lawyers

DECISION UNDER APPEAL

SENIOR MEMBER:

Ms K Haddock

DATE OF SENIOR MEMBER’S DECISION:

9 December 2022

INTRODUCTION

  1. A1 Granny Flats, the appellant, employed Mr Todd Martin (the second respondent) as a salesman. Mr Martin claimed to sustain a psychological injury during the course of this employment, with a deemed date of injury of 13 August 2020. The claim for workers compensation was made on 2 September 2020. At the relevant time for the purposes of this application, the appellant did not hold a policy of workers compensation insurance. Accordingly, icare NSW, on behalf of the Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (the first respondent, hereafter referred to as the Nominal Insurer) responded to Mr Martin’s claim and made payments to him for weekly compensation and medical treatment relating to his psychological injury.

  2. The Nominal Insurer subsequently sought reimbursement from the appellant of these payments made to Mr Martin, totalling $110,766.81, by way of a notice issued pursuant to s 145(1) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (the 1987 Act), on the basis the appellant was the employer liable at the time to pay Mr Martin workers compensation.[1] The appellant disputed its liability to pay this reimbursement in the Personal Injury Commission (Commission) by way of a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read A1 Granny Flats v Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (icar... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPICPD 69
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of A1 Granny Flats v Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (icare), the applicant, A1 Granny Flats, sought reimbursement from the Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (icare) under section 145 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The dispute arose from the insurer’s refusal to reimburse the applicant for compensation payments made to two former employees who had suffered psychological injuries. The case was heard by the Industrial Division of the NSW Supreme Court, which had to determine whether the insurer's liability for reimbursement was valid and if the applicant had satisfied the onus of proof required to challenge the notice under section 145. The court also needed to assess whether the injury of the former employees was wholly or predominantly caused by the applicant's actions regarding employment benefits, as stipulated in section 11A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the applicant had successfully discharged the onus of proof in challenging the section 145 notice. The court had to determine if the proceedings were inquisitorial in nature, as argued by the respondents, and whether the applicant had clearly identified the error in the grounds of appeal concerning the interpretation of the medical evidence and the broader context of the injury causation. The court needed to consider the principles set out in Raniere Nominees Pty Limited v Daley [2005] NSWCA 121, which established that the applicant bears the onus of proof in challenging a section 145 notice. Additionally, the court had to interpret section 11A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987, which requires the injury to be wholly or predominantly caused by the employer's actions regarding employment benefits.

The court found that the applicant had not discharged the onus of proof in challenging the section 145 notice. It determined that the nature of section 145 proceedings is not inquisitorial, following the decision in South Western Sydney Area Health Service v Edmonds [2007] NSWCA 16. The court also held that the deemed date of injury, as affixed by section 15(1)(a) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987, was applicable in this case, in line with the decision in Inghams Enterprises Pty Ltd v Thoroughgood [2014] NSWCA 166. The court further noted that the medical evidence, including the reports of Dr Khan and Dr George, did not support the applicant’s claim that the injury was wholly or predominantly caused by its actions regarding employment benefits. The Senior Member’s findings at reasons [393] to [399] highlighted the unchallenged evidence that the injury was also caused by other factors. The court rejected the applicant's argument that the Senior Member had erred in construing the medical evidence and found that the applicant had not clearly identified the alleged error in the grounds of appeal, as required by Kowalski v Repatriation Commission [2011] FCAFC 43 and Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Quirk [2023] FCAFC 163.

The court dismissed the appeal and affirmed the decision of the Senior Member, finding that the applicant had not satisfied the onus of proof in challenging the section 145 notice. The court concluded that the applicant had not demonstrated that the injury was wholly or predominantly caused by its actions regarding employment benefits, and thus the insurer's liability for reimbursement remained valid.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Senior Member’s reasoning on the s 11A question appears in a discrete number of paragraphs entitled “Section 11A(1)” commencing at reasons [388] and concluding at [400]. It seems to me that the critical finding made by the Senior Member is to be found at reasons [393] where the following is recorded: “The difficulty the [appellant] has in establishing that the second respondent’s injury was wholly or predominantly caused by its action with respect to provision of employment benefits is the evidence, much of it unchallenged, that the injury was also caused by matters other than the late payment of his commissions …”. (emphasis added) Having made this finding, the Senior Member then reviewed the medical evidence before consolidating this view at reasons [399] in the following terms: “Taking into account the other medical evidence, including that of Dr [Abdal] Khan, who has in my view provided a detailed and balanced report, I am not satisfied that the second respondent’s injury was wholly or predominantly caused by the [appellant’s] actions with respect to provision of employment benefits”. Both respondents rely on the Senior Member’s approach to deciding the s 11A question of “wholly and predominantly” as a complete answer to this ground. Tellingly, the second respondent notes, with some justification, that this finding has not been challenged on appeal by the appellant. Notwithstanding these submissions from each respondent, it seems that the appellant’s challenge to this finding rests on the challenge as to how the medical evidence was construed, which only deals with one of the two elements of the Senior Member’s reasoning on this question. It is clear from reasons [393] that the Senior Member was referring to evidence more broadly than the construction of the medical evidence. The Senior Member refers to such evidence at reasons [394] to [396]. In terms of the construction of the medical evidence, the appellant states that the second report of Dr George[105] needs to be read in conjunction with the earlier history taken in Dr George’s first report dated 11 November 2020. The final three paragraphs of this report (in the first respondent’s Reply, page 175) deal with the second respondent’s problems with being paid. Pausing here, I have examined Dr George’s report closely and in particular, the history appearing at page 175 of the first respondent’s Reply. Whilst it is true that on this page a history of the second respondent’s problems with being paid salary and commissions is recorded, these are not the only problems that the doctor has set out in that section of his report. Beneath the heading “Presenting Complaints” is a recount of other complaints, not related to employment conditions. The doctor recorded the second respondent as feeling “both intimidated and bullied by the owner of the company.” Later in the same report of 11 November 2020 Dr George says: “Given the history he presented on the day of assessment, it does appear that his employment has been the main contributing factor to the development of his condition.”[106] Much emphasis is placed by the appellant on the opinion in Dr George’s second report of 9 December 2020. Dr George says: “It does appear that the predominant cause of injury to Mr Martin has related to the actions of his employer in relation to provision of employment benefits.”[107] The Senior Member was not satisfied or persuaded by Dr George’s opinion.[108][105] First respondent’s Reply, p 180.[106] First respondent’s Reply, p 178.[107] First respondent’s Reply, p 180.[108] Reasons, [397]–[398].

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.