A J Lucas Drilling Pty Ltd v McConnell Dowell Constructors (Aust) Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

No  3852 of 2008
No 3853 of 2008

A J LUCAS DRILLING PTY LTD

(ACN 087 777 455)

Appellant/Plaintiff

v.

McCONNELL DOWELL CONSTRUCTORS (AUST) PTY LTD (ACN 002 929 017) (NO 2)

Respondent/Defendant/Cross-Appellant

---

JUDGES:

REDLICH JA and BEACH AJA

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING:

2 June 2010

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

2 June 2010

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2010] VSCA 128

---

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Offer of compromise – Uncertainty of offer – Uncertain GST clause in offer of compromise – Whether judgment on the claim not more favourable to the Plaintiff than the terms of the offer – Uncertainty of issues – Whether Court should otherwise order – Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2005, r 26.08(3).

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Applicant Ms JJ Batrouney SC with
Mr MH Whitten
Corrs Chambers Westgarth
For the Respondent Mr DS Levin QC with
Mr JR Gurr
Norton Rose Australia

REDLICH JA:

  1. I will ask Beach AJA to deliver the judgment of the Court.

BEACH AJA:

Introduction

  1. On 29 August 2008, Byrne J gave judgment for the plaintiff, A.J. Lucas Drilling Pty Ltd (“Lucas”) in the sum of $1,900,194.45.  In addition to giving judgment for that amount, his Honour ordered the defendant, McConnell Dowell Constructors (Aust) Pty Ltd (“McDow”) to pay Lucas’ costs of the proceeding.[1]

    [1]Save that Lucas was not entitled to:

    (a) the costs of and incidental to the preparation of the first Court Book for use at the hearing commencing on 30 June 2008; or

    (b) the costs of the first half day of the hearing on 30 June 2008.

  1. On 18 December 2009, this Court (constituted by Redlich JA, Dodds-Streeton JA and Beach AJA) dismissed Lucas’ appeal and allowed McDow’s cross-appeal.  As a result of allowing McDow’s cross-appeal, the order made by Byrne J on 29 August 2008 was varied by substituting for the sum $1,900,194.45, the sum of $472,440.29.

  1. Upon the pronouncement of the Court’s orders in relation to the appeal and the cross-appeal, counsel for McDow indicated that there had been an offer of compromise made on 4 September 2007 (“the offer of compromise”), and that as a result of the offer of compromise, McDow would seek to have the order for costs made by Byrne J varied.

  1. Neither side was prepared to argue the question of costs on 18 December 2009.  Both sides wished to file written submissions and supporting material before being given the opportunity to advance oral argument on the question of costs.  Upon the parties’ being advised of the then imminent resignation of Dodds-Streeton JA from this Court, both sides consented to the issues of costs which were then outstanding being determined by a Court constituted by the remaining members of the Court as presently constituted.

  1. Subsequently, written submissions and supporting material were filed by the parties and the matter came on for hearing today.

The outlines of submissions

  1. Before dealing with the offer of compromise and the arguments, it is necessary…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read A J Lucas Drilling Pty Ltd v McConnell Dowell Constructors (... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] VSCA 128
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of A J Lucas Drilling Pty Ltd v McConnell Dowell Constructors (Aust) Pty Ltd (No 2), the dispute involved an offer of compromise made by McConnell Dowell Constructors (Aust) Pty Ltd to A J Lucas Drilling Pty Ltd. The offer was made in accordance with the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2005. The central issue before the court was whether the offer of compromise was valid and whether the plaintiff had obtained a judgment more favourable than the terms of the offer. The plaintiff sought to have the costs order made on 29 August 2008 varied, while the defendant sought to have the costs paid on a solicitor/client basis. Additionally, the court had to consider the impact of an uncertain Goods and Services Tax (GST) clause in the offer of compromise.

The court had to determine whether the judgment sum obtained by the plaintiff was more favourable than the terms of the defendant's offer of compromise. The defendant relied on Rule 26.08(3) of the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2005, which provides that if the judgment sum is not more favourable than the terms of the offer, the court may order the costs of the proceeding to be paid by the plaintiff from the date of the offer. The court also had to consider whether the GST clause in the offer of compromise created uncertainty, and if so, whether this uncertainty affected the validity of the offer. Furthermore, the court needed to decide whether the plaintiff's conduct during the trial warranted the defendant to be reimbursed for its costs on a solicitor/client basis.

The court found that the judgment sum obtained by the plaintiff was not more favourable than the terms of the defendant's offer of compromise. The court also held that the uncertain GST clause in the offer of compromise did not render the offer invalid. The court ordered that the costs of the proceeding be paid by the plaintiff from the date of the offer. The court further held that the plaintiff's conduct during the trial warranted the defendant to be reimbursed for its costs on a solicitor/client basis. The court found that the plaintiff's conduct, particularly after 7 December 2007, was in obdurate disregard of the trial judge's reasons, which justified the defendant's claim for costs on a solicitor/client basis.

In light of the above, the court ordered that the costs of the proceeding be paid by the plaintiff from the date of the offer, and that the defendant's costs subsequent to 7 December 2007 be paid on a solicitor/client basis. The court also ordered that the parties bear their own costs of the proceeding from 5 September 2007.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The offer of compromise was in the following terms:McConnell Dowell Constructors (Aust) Pty Ltd offers to compromise the claims made against it by the Plaintiff and its counterclaims against the Plaintiff in these proceedings (“the claims”) on the basis that:1.McConnell Dowell Constructors (Aust) Pty Ltd pay to the Plaintiff the sum of $4,000,000 (four million dollars) (exclusive of Goods and Services Tax) within 30 days of acceptance of this offer in full and final settlement of the claims.2.This offer of compromise is exclusive of any Goods and Services Tax. To the extent that any supply made upon or in connection with acceptance of this offer is a taxable supply, the GST-exclusive consideration otherwise to be paid or provided for that taxable supply is increased by the amount of any GST payable in respect of that taxable supply and that amount must be paid at the same time and in the same manner as the GST-exclusive consideration is otherwise to be paid or provided. A party’s right to payment under this clause is subject to a valid tax invoice being delivered to the recipient of the taxable supply.3.This offer of compromise is served in accordance with Order 26.02 of the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2005 and is open to be accepted by the Plaintiff for a period of fourteen days after service.The judgment sum below The judgment sum below was calculated as follows: The sum of $1,900,194.45 was varied on appeal to $472,440.29 because, in our judgment, interest was only payable from 5 February 2007, rather than from 23 September 2003 as allowed by the trial judge. McDow submits that the trial judge ordered it to pay the amount of $3,697,925 exclusive of GST. The dismissal of Lucas’ appeal means that there was no alteration to this figure. McDow then submits that interest at the rate prescribed under s 2(1) of the Penalty Interest Rates Act 1983 for the 212 days from 5 February 2007 until the service of the offer of compromise produces the figure of $257,740.31. When $3,697,925 is added to $257,740.31, the figure of $3,955,665.31 is produced. McDow submits that this figure, being less than $4 million, means that the plaintiff obtained a judgment that was not more favourable than the terms of the offer of compromise. McDow then relies upon Rule 26.08(3) of the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2005. Rule 26.08(3) provides: As a result of the operation of r 26.08(3), McDow seeks to have the costs order made on 29 August 2008 varied as follows: However, in addition to relying upon r 26.08(3), McDow seeks to have its costs subsequent to 7 December 2007 paid on a solicitor/client (or indemnity) basis. The foundation for this submission is Lucas’ conduct of the trial following 7 December 2007. McDow categorises Lucas’ conduct of the trial from that time as being “in obdurate disregard of the trial judge’s reasons [earlier delivered]”. Lucas submits that the trial judge’s order that McDow pay Lucas’ costs of the proceeding should be upheld. Alternatively, Lucas contends that the costs order below should be varied so that McDow pay Lucas’ costs of Lucas’ claims up to and including 5 September 2007 and the cost of McDow’s counterclaim, to be taxed on a party and party basis; and the parties bear their own costs of Lucas’ claims after 5 September 2007.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.