185L6 Pty Ltd v Strata Corporation 07176 Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeal from a Master)

185L6 PTY LTD v STRATA CORPORATION 07176 INC

[2011] SASC 164

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Blue

4 October 2011

CORPORATIONS - WINDING UP - WINDING UP IN INSOLVENCY - STATUTORY DEMAND - SUPPORTING AFFIDAVIT - REQUIREMENTS FOR

CORPORATIONS - WINDING UP - WINDING UP IN INSOLVENCY - STATUTORY DEMAND - APPLICATION TO SET ASIDE DEMAND - GENUINE DISPUTE AS TO INDEBTEDNESS - OFFSETTING AND OTHER LIKE CLAIMS - GENERALLY

CORPORATIONS - WINDING UP - WINDING UP IN INSOLVENCY - STATUTORY DEMAND - APPLICATION TO SET ASIDE DEMAND - GENUINE DISPUTE AS TO INDEBTEDNESS - ASSESSING GENUINENESS - GENERALLY

CORPORATIONS - WINDING UP - WINDING UP IN INSOLVENCY - STATUTORY DEMAND - APPLICATION TO SET ASIDE DEMAND - FOR DEFECT OR SOME OTHER REASON - SOME OTHER REASON

Appeal from a decision of a Master. The Master refused to set aside the demand but reduced the amount of the demand by $1.

Whether the Court can receive a second affidavit filed outside the 21 day time period - whether the company has an off-setting claim exceeding the amount of the demand - whether the company has established loss - whether the Master erred in fixing the off-setting claim at a nominal amount - whether there is a genuine dispute as to the existence of the debt - whether there is some other reason to set aside the demand - whether there was a valid application pursuant to s 459G.

Held: The Master erred in ruling the second affidavit could not be received and in setting a nominal amount ($1) for the offsetting claim as the cause of action for breach of duty necessarily requires actual loss. Appeal otherwise dismissed: no question of the offsetting claim demonstrated; no genuine dispute demonstrated or any other reason to set aside the demand.

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 459G, s 459J, s 759G; Strata Titles Act 1986 (SA) s 40, s 41, s 41A, referred to.
Bentham Management Pty Ltd v Union Finance Pty Ltd (2007) 247 LSJS 103; Broke Hills Estate Pty Ltd v Oakvale Wines Pty Ltd (2005) 23 ACLC 1,266; Endeavour Film Management Pty Ltd v Fox Studios Australia Pty Ltd [2003] NSWSC 1056; John Shearer Ltd v GEHL Company (1995) 60 FCR 136; Zenaust Imports Pty Ltd v Alembic Chemicals Works Co Ltd (1998) 28 ACSR 465, applied.
Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O'Neill (2006) 227 CLR 57; Australian Securities Commission v Marlborough Gold Mines Ltd (1993) 177 CLR 485; Beecham Group Ltd v Bristol Laboratories Pty Ltd (1968) 118 CLR 618; Chippendale Printing Co Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (1995) 55 FCR 562; D & S Group of Companies Pty Ltd v O'Connor Investments Pty Ltd (1997) 15 ACLC 1794; David Grant & Co Pty Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation (1995) 184 CLR 265; Energy Equity Corporation v Sinedie Pty Ltd (2001) 166 FLR 179; Eyota Pty Ltd v Hanave Pty…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 185L6 Pty Ltd v Strata Corporation 07176 Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] SASC 164
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of 185L6 Pty Ltd v Strata Corporation 07176 Inc, the respondent, Level 6 Co, sought to set aside a statutory demand made by the appellant, Strata Co, which required Level 6 Co to pay certain strata fees within 21 days. The dispute involved various legal issues, including the validity of the statutory demand, the existence of a genuine dispute over the debt, and the requirements for an offsetting claim. The primary focus of the case was on whether Level 6 Co had established a genuine dispute regarding the debt, including claims for offset and counterclaims, and whether the statutory demand should be set aside.

The court examined the affidavits provided by Level 6 Co and the arguments presented regarding the alleged breaches by Strata Co, specifically concerning the maintenance and installation of the building's air conditioning system. The court determined that Level 6 Co had not established a genuine offsetting claim, as the evidence did not support the claimed damages. Additionally, the court assessed the genuineness of the dispute over the debt, considering the lack of evidence supporting the claimed losses and the procedural errors in the application to set aside the statutory demand. The court held that none of the issues raised by Level 6 Co provided sufficient grounds to set aside the demand.

The court concluded that Level 6 Co had failed to demonstrate a genuine dispute as to the existence or amount of the debt. It rejected the argument that the Master's order reducing the offsetting claim to a nominal amount of $1 was appropriate given the nature of the breach of duty of care claim, which requires actual loss. The court also dismissed the argument that the statutory demand should be set aside based on procedural errors or the alleged invalidity of the application under section 459G of the Corporations Act. The appeal was ultimately dismissed, with the exception of setting aside the order regarding the offsetting claim amount.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Level 6 Co appeals against that decision.The Facts On 16 February 2011, Strata Co served on Level 6 Co a statutory demand (“the Demand”) and supporting affidavit. The Demand required payment within 21 days of $147,649.91 being strata fees and expenses/outgoings in respect of the calendar years 2008 to 2011 inclusive (“the Debt”). On 7 March 2011, Level 6 Co filed and served an application to set aside the Demand and an affidavit by its director Mr Hilton (“the first affidavit”). On 19 May 2011, Level 6 Co filed and served a further affidavit by Mr Hilton (“the second affidavit”). The Master rejected the tender of that affidavit, principally on the basis that Level 6 Co was precluded by s 459G (because it was served outside the 21 day period) from relying upon it. That rejection is one of the grounds of appeal. The first affidavit, which verifies the statement of claim in the District Court action exhibited thereto, deposes to the following relevant matters.1.Strata Co is the strata corporation in relation to a multi-level office building at 185 Victoria Square, Adelaide.2.In mid-2002, Level 6 Co purchased a portion (“Level 6”) of level 6 of the building and thereby became unit holder number 6 in Strata Co (holding 8.5% of the units). Level 6 comprised professional serviced offices, which were occupied by various tenants.3.Since mid-2002, there has been an integrated air conditioning system in the building which is common property (“the old system”).4.In 2005, Strata Co proposed to Level 6 Co (and I infer all other unit holders) that the old system be replaced by a semi-independent air conditioning system for Level 6 (and I infer all other units) connected to new common property air conditioning plant (“the new system”).5.Strata Co has not installed the new system needed to support the semi‑independent air conditioning system which has been installed by Level 6 Co.6.Strata Co has not properly maintained the old system.7.The conduct of Strata Co in not installing the new system and not properly maintaining the old system was in breach of a duty of care owed by Strata Co to Level 6 Co.8.Level 6 Co has lost tenants and rental income and suffered a reduction in the capital value of Level 6.9.On 7 March 2011, Level 6 Co issued an action in the District Court against Strata Co seeking (among other things) damages for loss of rental income, and damages for loss of capital value to be assessed.10.In the District Court action, Level 6 Co also sought particulars of, and an accounting for, expenditure incurred and charges rendered by Strata Co pursuant to s 40 and s 41 of the Strata Titles Act 1988 (SA).11.Level 6 Co has a set-off and counterclaim for damages against Strata Co equal to or greater than $147,649.91.Rejection of the second affidavit The first issue is whether the Master erred in rejecting the second affidavit.General legal principles Section 459G, and Division 3 of Part 5, were introduced into the Act with effect from 23 June 1993.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

BLUE J
Moreover, the statement of claim itself does not plead that the alleged breaches, other than those relating to air conditioning, caused any loss of rental income, loss of capital value or loss, and in any event, there is no evidence of any such loss.Conclusion Accordingly, Level 6 Co has failed to establish a genuine off-setting claim, either in the sum of $529,500 or at all.Reduction by $1 The third issue involves the order made by the Master in connection with the off-setting claim. The Master at [17] of his Reasons set the offsetting claim at a nominal amount of $1. Level 6 Co argues that, if (contrary to its principal contention) no quantum of the off-setting claim were established, the Master erred in so doing and ought not to have fixed any amount. I accept that submission. In Jesseron Holdings Pty Ltd v Middle East Trading Consultants Pty Ltd (No 2),[25] the company established (on the requisite test) that it had an offsetting claim for damages for trespass arising from the allegedly invalid appointment of a receiver, but did not establish any quantum of loss. Young J said at 462:The company would receive only nominal damages for trespass because no other damages have been hinted at in the evidence. Accordingly, I value the amount of the cross-claim at $1.[25] (1994) 13 ACSR 455. In so doing, Young J was recognising that the tort of trespass (unlike breach of duty of care) does not require actual damage as an essential element of the cause of action, and, in the absence of proof of actual damage, nominal damages of $1 would be awarded. In Torrens Aloha Pty Ltd v Sand Modern Painting Pty Ltd,[26] the company established an offsetting claim for breach of contract, but did not establish any actual damage. Santow J at [35]-[36] followed the approach in Jesseron Holdings, and fixed the quantum of the offsetting claim at a nominal $1. Again, the cause of action for breach of contract does not require actual damage, and nominal damages of $1 would be awarded in the absence of proof of actual damage.[26] (2001 19 ACLC 755; [2001] NSWSC 227. The Master cited Torrens Aloha as authority for the approach which he adopted. However, as the cause of action for breach of duty of care requires actual loss as an essential element, that authority was not applicable and the Master erred.Genuine Dispute as to Debt The fourth set of issues is whether Level 6 Co demonstrated a genuine dispute as to the existence (or amount) of the Debt.Set-off The originating process and the original affidavit relied upon a set-off of the claim for loss of rent and capital value to give rise to a genuine dispute as to the existence of the debt as an alternative to its being an offsetting claim. This was not specifically argued by Level 6 Co on appeal. Assuming that the claim is capable at law of being subject to equitable setoff, this ground of setting aside suffers from the same problems as the offsetting claim ground addressed above.Interest The statement of claim in the District Court action pleaded that Strata Co had charged interest, but had not provided particulars relating to the interest rate charged, the basis for charging interest or how the interest was calculated. The relief sought included an order that Strata Co provide particulars and an accounting in respect of (amongst other things) interest pursuant to s 41 of the Strata Titles Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BLUE J

I agree with the Master that none of the five matters identified by Level 6 Co, either alone or in conjunction, constitute a reason to set aside the demand.Declaration that No Valid Application Made By the notice of appeal, Level 6 Co seeks, in the alternative to the statutory demand being set aside, a declaration that there was no valid application pursuant to s 459G of the Corporation Act. Level 6 Co refers to the decision of the New South Wales Court of Appeal in TQM Design & Construct Pty Ltd v KCL Developments Pty Ltd.[28] In that case, a purported application under s 459G had been made by two companies jointly to set aside two separate statutory demands, and the application had been held in previous proceedings to be invalid for that reason.[28] (2001) BFRA 179; [2011] NSWCA 7. In the meantime, the statutory time limit under s 459C for the creditor to institute winding up proceedings (three months after 21 days after service of the statutory demand) had expired. The companies sought and obtained an injunction to restrain the creditor from instituting winding up proceedings in reliance upon the statutory demands. The Court of Appeal upheld that injunction, on the basis that time had commenced to run under s 459C 21 days after service of the demand because the purported application to set aside made within the 21 day period had been invalid. Level 6 Co argues that the same reasoning applies in the present case. However, I have held that the application in this case did validly invoke the jurisdiction of the court, and hence the necessary sub-stratum for Level 6 Co’s contention does not exist. In any event, it is not appropriate to grant a declaration of the type sought on an application to set aside a statutory demand under s 459G. If the contention by Level 6 Co had been sustainable, that would have been a matter to be decided in subsequent proceedings and not the s 459G proceedings.Conclusion For the above reasons, I would set aside paragraph 1 of the order dated 23 June 2011, but otherwise dismiss the appeal.