1704840 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

1704840 (Refugee) [2021] AATA 679 (9 February 2021)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

CASE NUMBER:  1704840

COUNTRY OF REFERENCE:                   Malaysia

MEMBER:Sheridan Lee

DATE:9 February 2021

PLACE OF DECISION:  Melbourne

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicant a protection visa.

Statement made on 9 February 2021 at 12:34 pm

CATCHWORDS

REFUGEE – Protection visa – Malaysia – political opinion – involvement in the Bersih political movement – evidence at hearing was entirely different to the claims made on the application form ­– significant debt – loan sharks – particular social group – people with large debts – hardship will not threaten his capacity to subsist or constitute significant harm – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958, ss 5AAA, 5H, 5J, 36, 65

Migration Regulations 1994, Schedule 2

Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 431 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information which does not allow the identification of an applicant, or their relative or other dependant.

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection on 10 March 2017 to refuse to grant the applicant a protection visa under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. The applicant is a [age]-year-old male from Malaysia. He applied for the protection visa on 30 November 2016 on the basis that he would be persecuted by the Malaysian Government for his involvement in the Bersih political movement. The delegate refused to grant the visa on the basis that there was no real risk or chance that the applicant would suffer persecution or significant harm.

  3. The Tribunal viewed a copy of the applicant’s Malaysian passport. I accept that the applicant is a citizen of Malaysia and will assess the applicant’s claims against Malaysia as his country of reference for the purposes of s.5H(1)(a) and receiving country for Complementary Protection purposes.

  4. The applicant appeared before the Tribunal to give evidence and present arguments on 30 January 2020. On 16 November 2020, the Tribunal wrote to advise the applicant that it wished to discuss further issues that had arisen and a second hearing would be required. The Tribunal sought [Mr A]’s consent to hold a combined hearing with each member of his family - who lodged independent claims for protection - in order to discuss common issues. On 1 December 2020, the applicant’s wife, [Ms B], responded on behalf of the family to advise that they would be in attendance.

  5. A second hearing was conducted on 9 December 2020 in conjunction with [Mr A]’s wife, and their two young children. At the hearing, the Tribunal provided an opportunity for [Mr A] and [Ms B] to provide evidence together and separately. Both hearings were conducted with the assistance of an interpreter in the Malay and English languages.

    CRITERIA FOR A PROTECTION VISA

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 1704840 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 679
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Mr A, sought merits review of a decision by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration to refuse his application for a protection visa. The dispute centred on whether Mr A would face persecution or significant harm if returned to Malaysia. Mr A's initial application claimed fear of persecution due to his involvement with the Bersih political movement. However, at the hearing before the Tribunal, his claims shifted to a fear of harm from loan sharks due to significant personal debts.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Mr A was a "refugee" within the meaning of section 5H of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth), based on a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of political opinion or membership of a particular social group, and whether Australia had protection obligations under section 36(2)(aa) of the Act due to a real risk of significant harm. The Tribunal was required to assess the credibility of Mr A's claims and determine if the alleged harm met the threshold of persecution or significant harm as defined by the Act.

The Tribunal found that Mr A's evidence regarding his involvement with the Bersih movement was not substantiated and that his primary concern was the economic hardship arising from his substantial debts. The Tribunal accepted that Mr A might face economic hardship but concluded that this hardship would not threaten his capacity to subsist or constitute significant harm. It reasoned that Mr A was not required to repay his largest debt while unemployed and that there was no evidence to suggest he would be prevented from finding employment in Malaysia due to his debt or potential bankruptcy. Furthermore, the Tribunal found that any harm from money lenders would be motivated by personal debt recovery and not by reasons outlined in section 5J of the Act, such as race, religion, nationality, or political opinion, and therefore did not constitute persecution. Similarly, for complementary protection, the Tribunal determined that the economic hardship and potential actions of money lenders did not amount to significant harm as defined by the Act, particularly lacking the element of intentional infliction required for torture, cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision not to grant Mr A a protection visa, finding that he did not face a real chance of serious harm or significant harm if returned to Malaysia. The Tribunal noted that Mr A's wife had lodged a separate application, which would be considered independently.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In accordance with Ministerial Direction No.84, made under s.499 of the Act, I have taken account of the ‘Refugee Law Guidelines’ and ‘Complementary Protection Guidelines’ prepared by the Department of Home Affairs, and country information assessments prepared by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade expressly for protection status determination purposes, to the extent that they are relevant to the decision under consideration.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCEApplication for protection The applicant first arrived in Australia [in] March 2016 on a Subclass 601 Electronic Travel Authority visa. He applied for protection on 30 November 2016. The application for protection form claimed that:·the applicant joined a group called Bersih because he was dissatisfied with the Malaysian Government.·he participated in a rally, after which the Minister of Home Affairs, Ahmad Zahid Hamidi said action must be taken against all Bersih members. The Minister cited the Peaceful Assembly Act, the Sedition Act, the Penal Code and Police Act.·many Bersih members were imprisoned during the rally and people have searched “every single member of Bersih”.·if he returns to Malaysia the applicant will be jailed or will face legal action.·Bersih members are located across Malaysia and the applicant would face trouble in any Malaysian state. The applicant noted that Malaysia is a small country.·Malaysian authorities would not provide protection because Bersih is an illegal party opposed to the Government.Application for merits review The application for protection was refused by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration on 10 March 2017. [Mr A] applied to the Tribunal for merits review of that decision. No further evidence was submitted at the time of application. [Mr A] appeared before the Tribunal to give evidence and present arguments on 30 January 2020. The applicant gave evidence that he was born in [Sabah], and is one of [number] children. He identifies as a Muslim and a member of the Murut ethnic group from Sabah. The applicant continued to live in Sabah, where he held a [job] until he departed Malaysia to travel to Australia. The applicant has a wife and two children. His family are Malaysian citizens, but his second child was born in Australia. The applicant confirmed hat his family were not included on his application for protection and have not lodged a separate application. The applicant’s wife was employed as a [Occupation 1] in Malaysia. The applicant claimed he was afraid to return to Malaysia because he would be hunted by loan sharks to repay very serious debts. He started working on 15 November 1999 and borrowed money to build a house for his family three years later in 2002. The applicant borrowed money on several occasions from licensed money lenders. The final loan was from [Bank 1] for 180,000 MYR (approximately $61,221 AUD). He has made small repayments on the loan, but still owes 120,000 MYR (approximately $40,414 AUD). The money was used to build a house in the applicant’s [village]. The applicant claimed that houses in the village have no street address and there is no registered title because it was built on village land. The applicant’s brother and his family currently live in the house. The applicant explained that if the house were in his name it would be repossessed, however he then gave evidence that the house was purchased in both he and his wife’s name. Before the applicant departed Malaysia, people from the bank went to the house and took all the property.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In this case, I accept that the applicant may face economic hardship as a result of his significant debts. However, I do not accept that this hardship will threaten his capacity to subsist or constitute serious harm. In particular, I note that the applicant is not required to make repayments on his largest debt while he is not earning an income. In addition, he would not be restricted from finding employment in order to service his debts for any systemic or discriminatory reason. Despite [Mr A]’s claim to have been ‘blacklisted’, there is no evidence to support the assertion that a centralised list of persons holding debt could be accessed by prospective employers. As discussed at the second hearing, the publicly available website of the Malaysian Department of Insolvency[3] reports that:When you are declared a bankrupt, it would not deny you of your right to continue serving with your current organization. Neither would this status prevent you from any future or potential recruitment. However, you must be subjected to your terms of contract with your current employer. For instance, where the contract requires you to inform the employer if you are declared a bankrupt, then you must inform your employer of your status. [3] Accessed at >I do not accept that [Mr A] would be prevented from seeking or securing employment as a result of holding a large debt or being found bankrupt. In respect of the potential harm claimed by the applicant from individual unlicensed money lenders and licensed money loaning institutions, the Tribunal notes that those money lenders seek to recover outstanding debt from the applicant on the basis that he personally borrowed money from them. The money lenders seek to recover money from [Mr A] personally as a result of an agreement reached between them and for no other reason. As such, any harm that the applicant might face as a result of his debt is motivated by the creditors’ personal desire to recover or profit from the debt. There is no evidence before the Tribunal to suggest that the essential and significant reason for any harm the applicant might face at the hands of the money lenders is one of the reasons outlined in s.5J of the Act.I have considered cumulatively what I have accepted of the applicants claim and find that the applicant does not face a real chance of serious harm, now and in the reasonably foreseeable future, for any reason if he were returned to Malaysia. I therefore find that the applicant is not a refugee within the meaning of s.5H and does not fall within Australia’s protection obligations under s.36(2)(a). Complementary protectionFor the same reasons that I found there is no real chance of serious harm as a result of the applicant’s ethnicity or religion, I find that the real risk element of the test in s.36(2)(aa) has not been met in relation to those factors.[4] The applicant gave evidence to the Tribunal that his primary concern is that he would be unable to earn sufficient money in Malaysia to make the repayments on his loans and may face harm from individuals seeking to recover the outstanding amounts.[4] as per the judgment in MIAC vSZQRB [2013] FCAFC 33.As previously outlined, in order to fall within Australia’s complementary protection obligations, there must be substantial grounds for believing that, as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of being removed from Australia to a receiving country, there is a real risk that the applicant will suffer significant harm: s.36(2)(aa). The meaning of significant harm, and the circumstances in which a person will be taken not to face a real risk of significant harm, are set out in ss.36(2A) and (2B).A non citizen will suffer significant harm if:a)the non citizen will be arbitrarily deprived of his or her life; orb)the death penalty will be carried out on the non citizen; orc)the non citizen will be subjected to torture; ord)the non citizen will be subjected to cruel or inhuman treatment or punishment; ore)the non citizen will be subjected to degrading treatment or punishment.As previously outlined, I accept that [Mr A] may face economic hardship as a result of his significant debts. However, I do not accept that this hardship will threaten his capacity to subsist or constitute significant harm. The definitions of torture, cruel or inhuman treatment or punishment and degrading treatment or punishment in s.5(1) of the Act require an element of intent. There must be an act or omission by which severe pain or suffering, or extreme humiliation, ‘is intentionally inflicted on a person’. The general economic situation and the financial impact of loans taken out by the applicant are not circumstances that were intentionally designed by an individual or the state to cause significant harm to the applicant. There is no intent on behalf of Malaysian society or the authorities to prevent the applicant from gaining employment or accessing social services that are available to other citizens. While the applicant may not earn a wage comparable to that he would earn in Australia, he would not face extreme humiliation and he is not in a position of vulnerability vis-à-vis the State. Further, I note that the applicant gave evidence that he is under no obligation to repay his government loan while he is not earning a wage and the Government has appointed a lawyer to assist with the management of the applicant’s debt.In relation to [Mr A]’s money borrowed from loan sharks, he gave evidence that while in Malaysia he did not face any physical harm from unregistered money lenders when he was unable to pay. I note that while he gave evidence that they would become angry if he couldn’t pay, he provided no specific examples to the Tribunal. [Mr A] gave no evidence to indicate that he had been threatened with physical harm or that the money lenders had engaged in any other threatening behaviour, such as extortion. The applicant gave evidence that he would borrow small amounts of money from unlicensed lenders to cover his day to day expenses. Money owed to unlicensed lenders constitutes a small portion of the applicant’s overall debts. [Mr A] gave evidence that he held employment in Malaysia and had been working in Australia. I consider that the applicant would be well-placed to find employment on return to Malaysia and continue making repayments to the unlicensed lenders.The Explanatory Memorandum to the Migration Act provides some guidance on the interpretation of real risk. It outlines that: [a] real risk of significant harm is one where the harm is a necessary and foreseeable consequence of removal. The risk must be assessed on grounds that go beyond mere theory and suspicion but does not have to meet the test of being highly probable. The danger of harm must be personal and present.[5] [5] Explanatory Memorandum to the Migration Amendment (Complementary Protection) Bill 2011 (Cth) at [67]. Similarly, the Second Reading Speech on the introduction of the Bill stated ‘[a] real risk of significant harm has been found in instances where there is a personal or direct risk to the specific person’: Commonwealth of Australia, Parliamentary Debates, House of Representatives, 24 February 2011, 1357 (Chris Bowen, Minister for Immigration and Citizenship). When considering the absence of threats or physical harm in the past when the applicant was unable to pay, the ability of the applicant to gain employment and make repayments, and the provision of assistance with the management of the debt incurred from licensed lenders by the state, I do not consider that there is a real risk that the applicant will suffer significant harm. While I accept that unlicensed lenders in Malaysia have engaged in threatening and sometimes physically harmful activity generally, I do not accept that there is a real risk that this will happen to [Mr A] personally in the circumstances outlined above. In making this finding, I note that the Tribunal is not required to make the applicant’s case for him. Section 5AAA of the Act makes it clear that it is the applicant’s responsibility to specify all particulars of a claim by the person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations and to provide sufficient evidence to establish the claims. For the reasons above, I find that there are no substantial grounds for believing that, as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of the applicant being removed from Australia to Malaysia there is a real risk that he will suffer significant harm: s.36(2)(aa).The applicant originally gave evidence that his family had not applied for protection, however he later gave evidence that his wife had made a separate application. The Tribunal will consider those claims and make separate decisions in those matters. However at this time, the applicant cannot satisfy s.36(2) on the basis of being a member of the same family unit as a person who satisfies s.36(2)(a) or (aa) and who holds a protection visa. Accordingly, the applicant does not satisfy the criterion in s.36(2).DECISIONThe Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicant a protection visa.ATTACHMENT - Extract from Migration Act 19585 (1) Interpretation…cruel or inhuman treatment or punishment means an act or omission by which:(a) severe pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, is intentionally inflicted on a person; or(b) pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, is intentionally inflicted on a person so long as, in all the circumstances, the act or omission could reasonably be regarded as cruel or inhuman in nature;but does not include an act or omission:(c) that is not inconsistent with Article 7 of the Covenant; or(d) arising only from, inherent in or incidental to, lawful sanctions that are not inconsistent with the Articles of the Covenant.…degrading treatment or punishment means an act or omission that causes, and is intended to cause, extreme humiliation which is unreasonable, but does not include an act or omission:(a) that is not inconsistent with Article 7 of the Covenant; or(b) that causes, and is intended to cause, extreme humiliation arising only from, inherent in or incidental to, lawful sanctions that are not inconsistent with the Articles of the Covenant.…torture means an act or omission by which severe pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, is intentionally inflicted on a person:(a) for the purpose of obtaining from the person or from a third person information or a confession; or(b) for the purpose of punishing the person for an act which that person or a third person has committed or is suspected of having committed; or(c) for the purpose of intimidating or coercing the person or a third person; or(d) for a purpose related to a purpose mentioned in paragraph (a), (b) or (c); or(e) for any reason based on discrimination that is inconsistent with the Articles of the Covenant;but does not include an act or omission arising only from, inherent in or incidental to, lawful sanctions that are not inconsistent with the Articles of the Covenant.…receiving country, in relation to a non-citizen, means:(a) a country of which the non-citizen is a national, to be determined solely by reference to the law of the relevant country; or(b) if the non-citizen has no country of nationality—a country of his or her former habitual residence, regardless of whether it would be possible to return the non-citizen to the country.…5H Meaning of refugee(1)For the purposes of the application of this Act and the regulations to a particular person in Australia, the person is a refugee if the person is:(a) in a case where the person has a nationality – is outside the country of his or her nationality and, owing to a well-founded fear of persecution, is unable or unwilling to avail himself or herself of the protection of that country; or(b) in a case where the person does not have a nationality – is outside the country of his or her former habitual residence and owing to a well-founded fear of persecution, is unable or unwilling to return to it.Note: For the meaning of well-founded fear of persecution, see section 5J.…5J Meaning of well-founded fear of persecution(1)For the purposes of the application of this Act and the regulations to a particular person, the person has a well-founded fear of persecution if:(a) the person fears being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion; and(b) there is a real chance that, if the person returned to the receiving country, the person would be persecuted for one or more of the reasons mentioned in paragraph (a); and(c) the real chance of persecution relates to all areas of a receiving country.Note: For membership of a particular social group, see sections 5K and 5L.(2)A person does not have a well-founded fear of persecution if effective protection measures are available to the person in a receiving country.Note: For effective protection measures, see section 5LA.(3)A person does not have a well-founded fear of persecution if the person could take reasonable steps to modify his or her behaviour so as to avoid a real chance of persecution in a receiving country, other than a modification that would:(a) conflict with a characteristic that is fundamental to the person’s identity or conscience; or(b) conceal an innate or immutable characteristic of the person; or(c) without limiting paragraph (a) or (b), require the person to do any of the following:(i)alter his or her religious beliefs, including by renouncing a religious conversion, or conceal his or her true religious beliefs, or cease to be involved in the practice of his or her faith;(ii)conceal his or her true race, ethnicity, nationality or country of origin;(iii)alter his or her political beliefs or conceal his or her true political beliefs;(iv)conceal a physical, psychological or intellectual disability;(v)enter into or remain in a marriage to which that person is opposed, or accept the forced marriage of a child;(vi)alter his or her sexual orientation or gender identity or conceal his or her true sexual orientation, gender identity or intersex status.(4)If a person fears persecution for one or more of the reasons mentioned in paragraph (1)(a):(a) that reason must be the essential and significant reason, or those reasons must be the essential and significant reasons, for the persecution; and(b) the persecution must involve serious harm to the person; and(c) the persecution must involve systematic and discriminatory conduct.(5)Without limiting what is serious harm for the purposes of paragraph (4)(b), the following are instances of serious harm for the purposes of that paragraph:(a) a threat to the person’s life or liberty;(b) significant physical harassment of the person;(c) significant physical ill‑treatment of the person;(d) significant economic hardship that threatens the person’s capacity to subsist;(e) denial of access to basic services, where the denial threatens the person’s capacity to subsist;(f) denial of capacity to earn a livelihood of any kind, where the denial threatens the person’s capacity to subsist.(6)In determining whether the person has a well‑founded fear of persecution for one or more of the reasons mentioned in paragraph (1)(a), any conduct engaged in by the person in Australia is to be disregarded unless the person satisfies the Minister that the person engaged in the conduct otherwise than for the purpose of strengthening the person’s claim to be a refugee.5K Membership of a particular social group consisting of familyFor the purposes of the application of this Act and the regulations to a particular person (the first person), in determining whether the first person has a well‑founded fear of persecution for the reason of membership of a particular social group that consists of the first person’s family:(a) disregard any fear of persecution, or any persecution, that any other member or former member (whether alive or dead) of the family has ever experienced, where the reason for the fear or persecution is not a reason mentioned in paragraph 5J(1)(a); and(b) disregard any fear of persecution, or any persecution, that:(i)the first person has ever experienced; or(ii)any other member or former member (whether alive or dead) of the family has ever experienced;where it is reasonable to conclude that the fear or persecution would not exist if it were assumed that the fear or persecution mentioned in paragraph (a) had never existed.Note: Section 5G may be relevant for determining family relationships for the purposes of this section.5L Membership of a particular social group other than familyFor the purposes of the application of this Act and the regulations to a particular person, the person is to be treated as a member of a particular social group (other than the person’s family) if:(a) a characteristic is shared by each member of the group; and(b) the person shares, or is perceived as sharing, the characteristic; and(c) any of the following apply:(i)the characteristic is an innate or immutable characteristic;(ii)the characteristic is so fundamental to a member’s identity or conscience, the member should not be forced to renounce it;(iii)the characteristic distinguishes the group from society; and(d) the characteristic is not a fear of persecution.5LA Effective protection measures(1)For the purposes of the application of this Act and the regulations to a particular person, effective protection measures are available to the person in a receiving country if:(a) protection against persecution could be provided to the person by:(i)the relevant State; or(ii)a party or organisation, including an international organisation, that controls the relevant State or a substantial part of the territory of the relevant State; and(b) the relevant State, party or organisation mentioned in paragraph (a) is willing and able to offer such protection.(2)A relevant State, party or organisation mentioned in paragraph (1)(a) is taken to be able to offer protection against persecution to a person if:(a) the person can access the protection; and(b) the protection is durable; and(c) in the case of protection provided by the relevant State—the protection consists of an appropriate criminal law, a reasonably effective police force and an impartial judicial system.…36 Protection visas – criteria provided for by this Act…(2)A criterion for a protection visa is that the applicant for the visa is:(a) a non-citizen in Australia in respect of whom the Minister is satisfied Australia has protection obligations because the person is a refugee; or(aa) a non-citizen in Australia (other than a non-citizen mentioned in paragraph (a)) in respect of whom the Minister is satisfied Australia has protection obligations because the Minister has substantial grounds for believing that, as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of the non-citizen being removed from Australia to a receiving country, there is a real risk that the non-citizen will suffer significant harm; or(b) a non-citizen in Australia who is a member of the same family unit as a non-citizen who:(i)is mentioned in paragraph (a); and(ii)holds a protection visa of the same class as that applied for by the applicant; or(c) a non-citizen in Australia who is a member of the same family unit as a non-citizen who:(i)is mentioned in paragraph (aa); and(ii)holds a protection visa of the same class as that applied for by the applicant.(2A)A non‑citizen will suffer significant harm if:(a) the non‑citizen will be arbitrarily deprived of his or her life; or(b) the death penalty will be carried out on the non‑citizen; or(c) the non‑citizen will be subjected to torture; or(d) the non‑citizen will be subjected to cruel or inhuman treatment or punishment; or(e) the non‑citizen will be subjected to degrading treatment or punishment.(2B)However, there is taken not to be a real risk that a non‑citizen will suffer significant harm in a country if the Minister is satisfied that:(a) it would be reasonable for the non‑citizen to relocate to an area of the country where there would not be a real risk that the non‑citizen will suffer significant harm; or(b) the non‑citizen could obtain, from an authority of the country, protection such that there would not be a real risk that the non‑citizen will suffer significant harm; or(c) the real risk is one faced by the population of the country generally and is not faced by the non‑citizen personally.…

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established