Parliamentary
Archives,
HL/PO/JU/4/3/114 7
HOUSE OF LORDS
VANDERVELL
Lord Reid
Lord Pearce
Lord Upjohn
Lord
Donovan
Lord
Wilberforce
V.
COMMISSIONERS OF INLAND REVENUE
Lord Reid
MY LORDS,
This case
provides yet another illustration of the folly of entering into
an
important transaction of an unusual character without first
obtaining expert
advice regarding tax liabilities which it may
create. In 1958 the Appellant
decided to give £150,000 to
the Royal College of Surgeons to found a
chair of Pharmacology.
But by reason of the method by which this gift
was made additional
assessments to surtax amounting to £250,000 have
been made
on the Appellant for the years 1958/9 and 1959/60, and
if this
appeal fails there is a possibility of further additional
assessments.
The
Appellant is chairman, managing director, and principal
shareholder
of a very successful engineering company. The capital
structure of the
company is unusual. Besides certain preference
shares there were three
classes of ordinary shares: first there
were 500,000 ordinary shares sub-
stantially all of which were
owned by the Appellant; secondly there were
100,000 'A' ordinary
shares held by a bank as trustee for the Appellant
when this gift
was made; and thirdly there were 2,600,000 ' B ' ordinary
shares
of which over two million were held by the Vandervell Trustees
Ltd.,
as trustees of a family settlement. Only the first of these
three classes of
shares carried any voting rights but the Articles
permitted the company
(which was controlled by the Appellant) to
resolve that the whole of the
proiit to be distributed in any year
might be paid as dividends on any one
of these three classes of
shares to the exclusion of the other two.
The
Appellant decided to make this gift to the Royal College of
Surgeons
by causing the Bank to transfer to them the 100,000 A
ordinary shares
and then causing the company to declare dividends
on these shares amounting
to £150,000. But then it occurred
to his financial adviser, Mr. Robins, that
if the Appellant's
company were to be floated as a public company there
might be
difficulties if these shares remained registered in the name of
the
College so he advised that there should be an option to
acquire these
shares from the College after they had received the
£150,000 in dividends.
The Appellant agreed to this and gave
Mr. Robins carte blanche to make
whatever arrangements he thought
fit. The Appellant did not want to
have these A ordinary shares
because of possible Estate Duty questions on
his death, and he
wished to make the gift by causing the company to pay
it in
dividends because of the possibility of surtax directions if the
company
did not distribute enough of its profits. It is clear that
both he and Mr.
Robins intended that he should have no further
rights to or in respect of
the shares or the dividends.
Many of
the arrangements were made orally. The only relevant docu-
ments
are (1)a letter of 14th November 1958…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Vandervell v Inland Revenue Commissioners and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1966] UKHL 3
- Decision Date