Sugar (Appellant) v British Broadcasting Corporation and another (Respondents)

Link copied
Case Copied 65 min read
HOUSE OF LORDS SESSION 2008–09
[2009] UKHL 9

on appeal from:[2008]EWCA Civ 191

OPINIONS

OF THE LORDS OF APPEAL

FOR JUDGMENT IN THE CAUSE

Sugar (Appellant) v British Broadcasting Corporation and another (Respondents)

Appellate Committee

Lord Phillips of Worth Matravers


Lord Hoffmann
Lord Hope of Craighead
Baroness Hale of Richmond
Lord Neuberger of Abbotsbury

Counsel

Appellant:  Respondents:
Tim Eicke  Monica Carss-Frisk QC
David Craig  Kate Gallafent
Siddharth Dhar (Instructed by BBC Litigation Department )

(Instructed by Forsters LLP )

Hearing dates :

3 and 4 DECEMBER 2008

ON
WEDNESDAY 11 FEBRUARY 2009

HOUSE OF LORDS

OPINIONS OF THE LORDS OF APPEAL FOR JUDGMENT

IN THE CAUSE

Sugar (Appellant) v British Broadcasting Corporation and another

(Respondents) [2009] UKHL 9

LORD PHILLIPS OF WORTH MATRAVERS

My Lords,

Introduction

1. The Freedom of Information Act 2000 (“the Act”) provides for a general right of access to information held by public authorities. That right is subject to exceptions. The Act makes provision for its enforcement by the Information Commissioner (“the Commissioner”) and for a right of appeal from a decision of the Commissioner to the Information Tribunal (“the Tribunal”). Schedule 1 to the Act lists the public authorities to which the Act applies. A small number of these are listed in respect only of certain specified information. One of these is the first respondent (“the BBC”), which is listed as “The British Broadcasting Corporation in respect of information held for purposes other than those of journalism, art or literature”.

2. The BBC holds a report that it commissioned in respect of its coverage of the Middle East (“the Balen Report”). The appellant, Mr Sugar asked the BBC to provide him with a copy of this report. He contended that the report was held by the BBC for purposes other than journalism, art or literature and that, in consequence, the BBC held it as a public authority and was bound by the Act to communicate its contents to him. The BBC disagreed. It contended that it held the report for the purposes of journalism and not as a public authority and that, in consequence, the Act had no application. I shall call the issue of whether or not the BBC held the report for journalistic purposes “the journalism issue”. Mr Sugar challenged the BBC’s response before the Commissioner. The Commissioner upheld the BBC’s contention. Mr Sugar appealed to the Tribunal. The BBC and the Commissioner argued that the Tribunal had no jurisdiction. The Tribunal held that it had jurisdiction and purported to exercise this by reversing the Commissioner’s decision on the journalism issue. The BBC then brought, simultaneously, an appeal under the provisions of the Act and a claim for judicial review. The claim succeeded [2007] EWHC 905 (Admin); [2007] 1 WLR 2583. Davis J held that the Commissioner had determined that he had no jurisdiction. He had made no decision that was susceptible to an appeal to the Tribunal under the Act. The Tribunal had acted without jurisdiction and its decision…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sugar (Appellant) v British Broadcasting Corporation and ano... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] UKHL 9
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Sugar (Appellant) v British Broadcasting Corporation and another (Respondents), the House of Lords considered the issue of whether the Information Commissioner and the Information Tribunal had jurisdiction to entertain an appeal from a request for information made to the BBC under the Freedom of Information Act 2000. The BBC argued that it was not a public authority in respect of the information requested, and therefore the Commissioner and the Tribunal had no jurisdiction. The court held that the Commissioner did have jurisdiction to decide whether the BBC was a public authority for the purposes of the Act and whether the information requested was subject to the Act. The court found that the BBC remained a public authority for the purposes of the Act, even if the information requested was excluded, and the Commissioner had jurisdiction to decide whether the information was excluded. The court also held that the Tribunal had jurisdiction to hear the appeal on the point of law. The appeal was allowed, and the case was remitted to the Administrative Court for determination of the journalism issue on the point of law.