Scott (Appellant) v Southern Pacific Mortgages Limited (Respondents)

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

Michaelmas Term

[2014] UKSC 52

On appeal from [2012] EWCA Civ 17

JUDGMENT

Rosemary Scott (Appellant/Second Defendant) and Southern Pacific Mortgages Limited (Claimant/First Respondent) and Mortgage Express (Second Respondent) and Amee Lydia Wilkinson (First Defendant) and The Mortgage Business Plc (Intervener)

before

Lady Hale


Lord Wilson
Lord Sumption
Lord Reed
Lord Collins

JUDGMENT GIVEN ON

22 October 2014

Heard on 3 and 4 March 2014

Appellant First Respondent
Bryan McGuire QC Justin Fenwick QC
James Stark Nicole Sandells

Nicholas Broomfield

(Instructed by Paula (Instructed by Paul
Harris, David Gray Heeley, TLT LLP)

Solicitors LLP)

Second Respondent

Justin Fenwick QC

Nicole Sandells

Nicholas Broomfield

(Instructed by Ian Drew,

Walker Morris LLP)

Intervener

Lesley Anderson QC

Daniel Gatty

(Instructed by Richard Pitt,

Eversheds LLP)

LORD COLLINS (with whom Lord Sumption agrees)

1.         The transactions with which this appeal is concerned arose during a period when sale and rent back transactions were common. They were what was described by the Office of Fair Trading in 2008 (Sale and rent back: An OFT market study) as a relatively new type of property transaction whereby firms bought homes from individuals, usually at a discount, and allowed the former home owners to stay on in the property as tenants. The deals were often sold to home owners in financial difficulties and the firms selling them often told the home owners that they would be able to stay in their homes for years, when in fact the tenancies were rarely granted for more than six or twelve months. Many firms financed the purchase of the properties through secured borrowing, and former owners were being evicted following proceedings for possession by mortgage lenders after the purchasers defaulted on their loans.

The home owners did not fully understand the risks involved, and the OFT’s

research found that solicitors provided by the sale and rent back companies to provide advice to the seller were sometimes suspected to be acting for the companies as well. By the time of the study the OFT estimated that there were 1,000 firms involved in selling the schemes and about 50,000 transactions.

2.         In 2009 the Financial Services Authority recommended that consumer detriment occurring in this market warranted a fast regulatory response, and in the same year sale and rent back transactions became a regulated activity under section 19 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000. As a result, in February 2012 the FSA reported that most sale and rent back transactions were unaffordable or unsuitable and should never have been sold, but that in practice the entire market had shut down. They are now very rare.

3.         This is an appeal in one of what were originally ten test cases in which the defendant home owners were persuaded to sell their properties to purchasers who promised the vendors the right to remain in their homes after the sale. The purchasers bought the homes with the assistance of mortgages from lenders, who were not given notice of the promises to the home…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scott (Appellant) v Southern Pacific Mortgages Limited (Resp... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] UKSC 52
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Scott v Southern Pacific Mortgages Limited and others involved an appeal against the decision of the Court of Appeal in which the Court held that the vendors had no proprietary interest in the property which could take priority over the lenders' charge. The appeal raised two main questions: (1) whether the purchasers were in a position at the date of exchange of contracts to confer equitable proprietary rights on the vendors, as opposed to personal rights only; and (2) whether, even if the equitable rights of the vendors were more than merely personal rights, the rationale of the decision of the House of Lords in Abbey National Building Society v Cann applied in this case. The Supreme Court held that the appeal should be dismissed. The purchasers were not in a position at the date of exchange of contracts to confer equitable proprietary rights on the vendors, as opposed to personal rights only. Even if the equitable rights of the vendors were more than merely personal rights, the rationale of the decision in Abbey National Building Society v Cann applied in this case. The purchasers, conveyance, and mortgage were indivisible and the vendors could not assert against the lenders their interests arising only on completion. The court also held that the contract of sale, conveyance, and mortgage were not indivisible for the purposes of this appeal. The reasoning of the court was based on the law of proprietary estoppel and the effect of the contract of sale on the parties involved. The court held that the vendors acquired no more than personal rights against the purchasers when they agreed to sell their properties on the basis of the purchasers’ promises that they would be entitled to remain in occupation. Those rights would only become proprietary and capable of taking priority over a mortgage when they were fed by the purchasers’ acquisition of the legal estate on completion. The court also held that the decision in Abbey National Building Society v Cann applied to the facts of this case and that the contract of sale, conveyance, and mortgage were indivisible for the purposes of this appeal. The final orders of the court were that the appeal should be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established