R (SC) v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

THE COURT ORDERED that no one shall publish or reveal the names or addresses of the Appellants who are the subject of these proceedings or publish or reveal any information which would be likely to lead to the identification of the Appellants or of any members of their family in connection with these proceedings.

Trinity Term
[2021] UKSC 26

On appeal from: [2019] EWCA Civ 615

Appellants Respondents
Richard Drabble QC Sir James Eadie QC

Tom Royston Ciara Bartlam

Galina Ward

Yaaser Vanderman

(Instructed by Child (Instructed by The
Poverty Action Group) Government Legal

Department)

Intervener
(Equality and Human Rights
Commission)
Helen Mountfield QC
Raj Desai

(Instructed by Equality and Human Rights Commission)

LORD REED: (with whom Lord Hodge, Lady Black, Lord Lloyd-Jones, Lord
Kitchin, Lord Sales and Lord Stephens agree)

1. This appeal concerns the fact that entitlement to one of the components of one of the welfare benefits available in the United Kingdom, namely the individual element of child tax credit, is limited to a maximum amount, calculated as the amount payable in respect of two children. That limitation is challenged in these proceedings as being incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights (“the Convention”, or “the ECHR”), as given effect by the Human Rights Act 1998. The appeal raises a number of important questions in relation to the relevant articles of the Convention, and in relation to the constitutional law of the United Kingdom.

2. In view of the length of this judgment, it may be helpful at the outset to explain how it is laid out, and the conclusions reached.

(1) After summarising the child tax credit scheme (paras 3-10 below), the facts relating to the appellants (paras 11-12 below), the history of the legislation (paras 13-20 below), and the history of these proceedings (paras 21-23 below), I consider arguments that the limitation of entitlement to the individual element of child tax credit to the amount payable in respect of two children is incompatible with the rights of adults and children affected by it, under article 8 of the Convention, and conclude that those arguments should be rejected (paras 24-33 below).

(2) I next consider an argument that the limitation is incompatible with the rights of adults affected by it, under article 12 of the Convention, and conclude that that argument should also be rejected (paras 34-35 below).

(3) After an introductory discussion of article 14 (paras 36-38), I next consider an argument that the limitation constitutes indirect discrimination against women as compared with men, contrary to article 14 taken together with article 8 or with article 1 of the First Protocol to the Convention (“A1P1”). I conclude that the evidence raises a presumption of discrimination on the ground of gender, and that it is therefore for the Government to establish that the limitation has an objective and reasonable justification (paras 39-54 below).

(4) I next consider an argument that the limitation constitutes direct discrimination against children as compared with adults, contrary to article 14…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R (SC) v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] UKSC 26
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal concerned the compatibility of the limitation on entitlement to one component of a welfare benefit, the individual element of child tax credit, with the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). The limitation restricts the maximum amount of the individual element to the amount payable in respect of two children, unless certain exceptions apply. The appellants, represented by the Child Poverty Action Group, argued that the limitation was incompatible with their rights under several articles of the ECHR. The Supreme Court was asked to decide whether the limitation was compatible with the Convention. The court considered the arguments relating to the impact of the limitation on the adult appellants' right to respect for their private and family life under article 8, and their right to found a family under article 12. The court found that the limitation did not interfere with the adults' reproductive choices, nor did it affect their decision-making in relation to the birth of children. The court also considered the argument that the limitation constituted indirect discrimination against women as compared with men, contrary to article 14 taken together with article 8 or with article 1 of the First Protocol to the Convention. The court concluded that the evidence raised a presumption of discrimination on the ground of gender, and that it was for the Government to establish that the limitation had an objective and reasonable justification. The court found that the measure had such a justification, and that the appeal should be dismissed. The court also considered whether the imposition of a limitation on entitlement based on the amount payable in respect of two children constituted direct discrimination against children living in households with more than that number of children, as compared with children living in households with that number of children or fewer. The court concluded that the argument should be rejected. The final issue was whether the measure in question had an objective and reasonable justification, notwithstanding its greater impact on women, and whether the differential treatment of children living in households with more than two children was justifiable. The court concluded that the measure had such a justification, and that the appeal should accordingly be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established