MWB Business Exchange Centres Ltd v Rock Advertising Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

Easter Term

[2018] UKSC 24

On appeal from: [2016] EWCA Civ 553

JUDGMENT

Rock Advertising Limited (Respondent) v MWB Business Exchange Centres Limited (Appellant)

before

Lady Hale, President


Lord Wilson
Lord Sumption
Lord Lloyd-Jones
Lord Briggs

JUDGMENT GIVEN ON

16 May 2018

Heard on 1 February 2018

Appellant Respondent
Clifford Darton Michael Paget
Sally Anne Blackmore Zoë Whittington
(Instructed by Edward (Instructed by DH Law
Harte LLP) Ltd)

LORD SUMPTION: (with whom Lady Hale, Lord Wilson and Lord Lloyd-
Jones agree)

1. Modern litigation rarely raises truly fundamental issues in the law of contract. This appeal is exceptional. It raises two of them. The first is whether a contractual term prescribing that an agreement may not be amended save in writing signed on

behalf of the parties (commonly called a “No Oral Modification” clause) is legally

effective. The second is whether an agreement whose sole effect is to vary a contract to pay money by substituting an obligation to pay less money or the same money later, is supported by consideration.

2. MWB Business Exchange Centres Ltd operates serviced offices in central London. On 12 August 2011, Rock Advertising Ltd entered into a contractual licence with MWB to occupy office space at Marble Arch Tower in Bryanston Street, London W1, for a fixed term of 12 months commencing on 1 November 2011. The licence fee was £3,500 per month for the first three months and £4,333.34 per month for the rest of the term. Clause 7.6 of the agreement provided:

“This Licence sets out all of the terms as agreed between MWB

and Licensee. No other representations or terms shall apply or form part of this Licence. All variations to this Licence must be agreed, set out in writing and signed on behalf of both parties

before they take effect.”

3. On 27 February 2012, Rock Advertising had accumulated arrears of licence fees amounting to more than £12,000. Mr Idehen, the company’s sole director,

proposed a revised schedule of payments to Natasha Evans, a credit controller employed by MWB. The effect of the revised schedule was to defer part of the February and March payments, and to spread the accumulated arrears over the remainder of the licence term. Account being taken of the implicit interest cost of

the deferral, Rock’s covenant to pay would be worth slightly less to MWB under Mr

Idehen’s proposal. There was then a discussion between them on the telephone, in

the course of which Mr Idehen contended that Ms Evans had agreed to vary the licence agreement in accordance with the revised schedule. Ms Evans denied this. She proceeded to treat the revised schedule as a proposal in a continuing negotiation, and took it to her boss. He rejected it. On 30 March 2012, MWB locked Rock Advertising out of the premises on account of its failure to pay the arrears, and terminated the licence with effect from 4 May 2012. They then sued for the arrears. Rock Advertising counterclaimed damages for wrongful exclusion from…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MWB Business Exchange Centres Ltd v Rock Advertising Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] UKSC 24
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom delivered its judgment in the case of Rock Advertising Limited (Respondent) v MWB Business Exchange Centres Limited (Appellant) on 16 May 2018. The case involved a contractual licence agreement between MWB and Rock Advertising for office space in London. The key issue was whether an oral agreement to vary the payment schedule of the licence fee was valid, given the existence of a clause in the written agreement requiring any variations to be in writing and signed by both parties. The Court of Appeal had held that the oral agreement was effective, but the Supreme Court overturned this decision.

The Supreme Court held that a contractual term requiring variations to be in writing is legally effective and should be enforced according to its terms. The court rejected the argument that an oral variation agreement could imply a consent to dispense with the written variation clause. The court found that the oral variation agreement in this case was invalid because it did not comply with the written variation clause. The court also declined to address the issue of consideration, as it was not necessary to do so given the outcome on the written variation clause issue.

The Supreme Court's decision reinforces the importance of contractual certainty and the enforceability of written variation clauses in commercial contracts. The court recognised the commercial benefits of such clauses in preventing informal attempts to undermine written agreements and avoiding disputes about the terms of oral variations. The decision provides clarity for businesses entering into written agreements containing written variation clauses, and confirms that such clauses will be enforced according to their terms.