Mastercard Incorporated and others (Appellants) v Walter Hugh Merricks CBE (Respondent)

Link copied
Case Copied 85 min read

Michaelmas Term

[2020] UKSC 51

On appeal from: [2019] EWCA Civ 674

JUDGMENT

Mastercard Incorporated and others (Appellants) v Walter Hugh Merricks CBE (Respondent)

before

Lord Kerr


Lord Briggs
Lord Sales
Lord Leggatt
Lord Thomas

JUDGMENT GIVEN ON

11 December 2020

Heard on 13 and 14 May 2020

Appellants Respondent
Mark Hoskins QC Paul Harris QC
Matthew Cook Marie Demetriou QC
Hugo Leith Victoria Wakefield QC

Jon Lawrence

(Instructed by Freshfields (Instructed by Quinn
Bruckhaus Deringer LLP Emanuel Urquhart &
(London)) Sullivan UK LLP)
Intervener (Which?)

Tristan Jones
(Instructed by Hausfeld &

Co LLP)

LORD BRIGGS: (with whom Lord Thomas agrees)

Introduction

1. This appeal concerns the procedure for collective proceedings introduced by amendment to the Competition Act 1998 (“the Act”) for the purpose of enabling small businesses and consumers more easily to bring claims for what may loosely be described as anti-competitive conduct in breach of the provisions of the Act. Where the harmful impact of such conduct affects consumers, it may typically cause damage to very large classes of claimants. Proof of breach, causation and loss is likely to involve very difficult and expensive forensic work, both in terms of the assembly of evidence and the analysis of its economic effect. Viewed from the perspective of an individual consumer, the likely disparity between the cost and effort involved in bringing such a claim and the monetary amount of the consumer’s individual loss, coupled with the much greater litigation resources likely to be available to the alleged wrongdoer, means that it will rarely, if ever, be a wise or proportionate use of limited resources for the consumer to litigate alone.

2. The procedure for collective proceedings introduced by the Act applies to claims by two or more persons for damages, money or an injunction in respect of a breach of specified provisions of statutory competition law: see sections 47A(2) and 47B(1) of the Act. It enables whole classes of consumers to vindicate their rights to compensation and the large cost of the necessary litigation to be funded, before an expert tribunal, the Competition Appeal Tribunal (CAT), which is given exclusive jurisdiction over collective proceedings. The prospect that the rights of consumers can be vindicated in that way also serves to act as a disincentive to unlawful anti- competitive behaviour of a type likely to harm consumers generally. But collective proceedings may not proceed beyond the issue and service of a claim form without the permission of the CAT in the form of certification by a Collective Proceedings Order (“CPO”) under section 47B of the Act. At issue in the appeal are the legal requirements for certification.

3. There are (at least for present purposes) three key features of collective proceedings. The first is that claims by any number of claimants may be pursued on their behalf by a single representative who may, but need not, be a member of the class. The claims need not be identical, and they need not all be against all the defendants, but they…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mastercard Incorporated and others (Appellants) v Walter Hug... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] UKSC 51
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned the procedure for collective proceedings introduced by the Competition Act 1998 for the purpose of enabling small businesses and consumers to bring claims for anti-competitive conduct. The respondents, Mr Walter Merricks, sought to bring a claim on behalf of 46.2 million people against the Mastercard group of companies for damages in respect of a breach of statutory competition law. The CAT refused the CPO on the grounds that the claims were not suitable for an aggregate award of damages and that the proposed method of distribution did not respond to the compensatory principle. The Court of Appeal found the CAT’s decision to be vitiated by error of law. The court allowed the appeal and quashed the Court of Appeal’s decision. The court held that the CAT was entitled to conclude that the claims were not suitable to be brought in collective proceedings because there was no realistic prospect of the applicant being able to apply its proposed economic methodology across the whole width of the proposed class. The court rejected the contention that the CAT was wrong to conclude that the claims were not suitable for an aggregate award of damages. The court also held that the CAT was not wrong to conclude that there was no reasonable and practicable means of estimating the loss suffered by each individual claimant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established