- For the reasons given by Patten J and Collins LJ, as well as those of my noble and learned friends Lord Walker of Gestingthorpe and Lord Neuberger of Abbotsbury, I would allow this appeal.
- This appeal raises a very short point of construction of section 18(2) of the Capital Allowances Act 1990. Since my opinion on the point differs from that of a majority of your Lordships it will suffice for me to explain the reasons for my dissent quite shortly. I am enabled to do so because I have had the advantage of reading in draft the opinions of my noble and learned friends Lord Walker of Gestingthorpe and Lord Neuberger of Abbotsbury, who, with my noble and learned friend Lord Hoffmann, constitute the majority, and can gratefully adopt their description of the facts and relevant statutory background.
- The issue is whether the warehouse in which the respondent, Maco, stores the stock that it purchases from its Austrian parent, Mayer, is an "industrial building or structure" as defined in section 18 of the 1990 Act. Section 18(1) says that an "industrial building or structure" means "a building or structure in use - " for one or other of the purposes specified in the ten following paragraphs, lettered (a) to (j). Only paragraph (f) is of any use to Maco. Paragraph (f) has four sub-paragraphs, numbered (i) to (iv), of which only sub-paragraph (i) is of any use to Maco. Paragraph (f)(i) specifies
- It is common ground that the goods which Maco purchases from Mayer and stores in its warehouse are "goods … which are to be used in the manufacture of other goods or materials". So far, so good. But it is also common ground that Maco does not carry on a "trade which consists in the storage" of goods. Maco's trade consists in the buying of goods and selling them on at a profit. Storage of the goods over the period between purchase and sale is an essential part of that trade but is not a trade on its own account.
- This is where section 18(2) comes into play. The subsection says that
LORD SCOTT OF FOSCOTE
My Lords,
"… the purposes of a trade which consists in the storage -
(i) of goods or materials which are to be used in the manufacture of other goods or materials"
"The provisions of subsection (1) above shall apply in relation to a part of a trade or undertaking as they apply in relation to a trade or undertaking except that where part only of a trade or undertaking complies with the conditions set out in subsection (1), a building or structure shall not by virtue of this subsection be an industrial building or structure unless it is in use for the purposes of that part of that trade or undertaking".
Since storage is "a part of" Maco's trade, subsection (2) requires the provisions of subsection (1)(f)(i) to be applied to that part of Maco's trade. The disagreement between the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Maco Door and Window Hardware (UK) Ltd v Revenue and Customs and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [2008] UKHL 54
- Decision Date