Parliamentary
Archives,
HL/PO/JU/18/253
Linden
Gardens Trust Limited (Respondents) v. Lenesta Sludge
Disposals
Limited and others (Appellants)
St. Martin's Property
Corporation Limited and others
(Original Respondents and
Cross-Appellants) v. Sir
Robert McAlpine and Sons Limited
(Original
Appellants and Cross-Respondents)
JUDGMENT
Die Jovis 22° Julii 1993
Upon Report from the Appellate
Committee to whom were
referred the Causes Linden Gardens Trust
Limited against Lenesta
Sludge Disposals Limited and others and
St. Martin's Property
Corporation Limited and others against Sir
Robert McAlpine and
Sons Limited et e contra, That the
Committee had heard Counsel
as well on Monday the 8th as on
Tuesday the 9th, Wednesday the
10th and Thursday the 11th days of
February and Tuesday the 30th
and Wednesday the 31st days of March
last upon the Petitions and
Appeals of McLaughlin & Harvey Plc
of 15 Trench Road, Mallusk,
Newtownabbey, Co. Antrim and Sir
Robert McAlpine & Sons Limited
of Eaton Court, Maylands
Avenue, Hemel Hempstead, Hertfordshire
HP2 7DR and upon the
Petition and Cross-Appeal of St Martin's
Property Corporation
Limited and St Martin's Property Investments
Limited, both of
Adelaide House, London Bridge, London EC4,
praying that the matter
of the Orders set forth in the Schedules
thereto, namely Orders of
Her Majesty's Court of Appeal of the
13th and the 14th days of
February 1992, might be reviewed before
Her Majesty the Queen in
Her Court of Parliament and that the
said Orders might be
reversed, varied or altered or that the
Petitioners might have
such other relief in the premises as to
Her Majesty the Queen in
Her Court of Parliament might seem meet;
as also upon the case of
Linden Gardens Trust Limited, St.
Martin's Property Corporation
Limited and St. Martin's Property
Investments Limited and Sir
Robert McAlpine Limited lodged in
answer to the said Appeals and
the said Cross-appeal; and due
consideration had this day of what
was offered on either side in
these Causes:
It is Ordered and Adjudged,
by the Lords Spiritual and
Temporal in the Court of Parliament of
Her Majesty the Queen
assembled, That the appeal by McLaughlin and
Harvey plc be
allowed and that the said Order of Her Majesty's
Court of Appeal
the 14th day of February 1992 complained of in the
said Appeal
be, and the same is hereby, Set Aside and that
the Order of His
Honour Judge Loyd Q.C. of the 9th day of October
1990 be, and the
same is hereby, Restored, save that the
preliminary issues be
answered in the manner set out in the speech
of Lord Browne-
Wilkinson: And it is further Ordered, That
the Respondents do
pay or cause to be paid to the said Appellants
the Costs incurred
by them in the Court of Appeal and in respect
of the said Appeal,
Judgment:
22 July 1993
HOUSE OF LORDS
LINDEN
GARDENS TRUST LIMITED
(RESPONDENTS)
v.
LENESTA
SLUDGE DISPOSALS LIMITED
AND OTHERS
(APPELLANTS)
ST MARTIN'S PROPERTY CORPORATION LIMITED
AND
OTHERS
(ORIGINAL RESPONDENTS AND CROSS APPELLANTS)
v.
SIR ROBERT McALPINE AND SONS LIMITED
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Linden Gardens Trust Ltd v Lenesta Sludge Disposals Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1993] UKHL 4
- Decision Date