JSC BTA Bank (Respondent) v Khrapunov (Appellant)

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

Hilary Term

[2018] UKSC 19

On appeal from: [2017] EWCA Civ 40

JUDGMENT

JSC BTA Bank (Respondent) v Khrapunov (Appellant)

before

Lord Mance, Deputy President


Lord Sumption
Lord Hodge
Lord Lloyd-Jones
Lord Briggs

JUDGMENT GIVEN ON

21 March 2018

Heard on 24 and 25 January 2018

Appellant Respondent
Charles Samek QC Stephen Smith QC
Marc Delehanty Tim Akkouh
(Instructed by Hughmans (Instructed by Hogan
Solicitors) Lovells International LLP)

LORD SUMPTION AND LORD LLOYD-JONES: (with whom Lord Mance,

Lord Hodge and Lord Briggs agree)

Introduction

1. This is litigation on a large scale. Between May 2005 and February 2009, Mr Mukhtar Ablyazov was the chairman and controlling shareholder of the claimant, a bank incorporated in Kazakhstan. It is alleged that during this period, he embezzled

some US$6 billion of the Bank’s funds. In February 2009, the Bank was nationalised

and Mr Ablyazov was removed from office. He fled to England, where he ultimately obtained asylum. In August 2009, the Bank began proceedings against him in the Commercial Court, alleging misappropriation of its funds. Other proceedings followed, in the Commercial Court and the Chancery Division. Mr Ablyazov was ultimately the defendant in eleven actions brought by the Bank against him, either alone or in conjunction with alleged associates.

2. At the outset of the litigation, the Bank obtained a disclosure order requiring Mr Ablyazov to identify and disclose the whereabouts of his assets and a worldwide freezing order preventing him from dealing with them. Subsequently, in August

2010, the High Court appointed receivers over all of Mr Ablyazov’s assets. Later

that year, the Bank obtained a number of search and disclosure orders. These yielded a haul of documents revealing a large number of undisclosed assets and a network of undisclosed companies through which Mr Ablyazov had sought to put them out of the reach of the Bank.

3. In 2011, the Bank applied for an order committing Mr Ablyazov for contempt of court. Teare J gave judgment on that application on 16 February 2012. He held that Mr Ablyazov had failed to disclose his assets in breach of the disclosure order, that he had disposed of certain of them in breach of the freezing order and the receivership order, and that he had given false evidence and forged documents in an attempt to cover his tracks. Teare J sentenced him to 22 months imprisonment. However, by the time that the judgment was handed down, the bird had flown. Mr

Ablyazov fled the country on receipt of the judge’s draft judgment. He spent some

time in prison in France pending the resolution of an application by Russia for his extradition, which ultimately failed. His present whereabouts are unknown. On 29

February 2012, Teare J ordered that Mr Ablyazov’s defences in the Commercial

Court actions should be struck out unless he gave full disclosure of his assets and surrendered himself to the tipstaff. He did neither of these things, and default judgments were subsequently obtained against him in four of the actions for sums…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JSC BTA Bank (Respondent) v Khrapunov (Appellant) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] UKSC 19
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

JSC BTA Bank (Respondent) v Khrapunov (Appellant) involved a large scale litigation stemming from allegations that Mr Mukhtar Ablyazov, the former chairman and controlling shareholder of the claimant bank, embezzled approximately US$6 billion of the Bank’s funds between May 2005 and February 2009. The Bank was nationalised in February 2009, and Mr Ablyazov fled to England, where he obtained asylum. The Bank initiated proceedings against Mr Ablyazov in August 2009, and subsequently obtained several court orders, including a worldwide freezing order and receivership order. Mr Ablyazov was found in contempt of court for failing to disclose his assets and was sentenced to 22 months imprisonment. The Bank obtained default judgments against Mr Ablyazov for sums exceeding US$4.6 billion. The present proceedings were commenced in July 2015 against Mr Ablyazov and his son-in-law, Mr Khrapunov, who is domiciled in Switzerland. Mr Khrapunov contested the jurisdiction of the English court, arguing that there is no such tort as the Bank asserts, and that the claim falls outside the special jurisdiction conferred by article 5(3) of the Lugano Convention. The Supreme Court held that the Bank's pleaded allegations disclose a good cause of action for conspiracy to injure it by unlawful means, and that the English court has jurisdiction over Mr Khrapunov.

The Supreme Court began by examining the nature of the alleged tort of conspiracy, distinguishing between lawful means and unlawful means conspiracies. It held that the unlawful means relied upon in this case, namely criminal contempt of court, necessarily constituted unlawful means for the purposes of the tort of conspiracy. The Court rejected the argument that there is a principle of public policy precluding a claim for civil damages for contempt of court, stating that breach of an order of the court is actionable where it gives effect to an underlying private law obligation which is itself actionable.

Turning to the issue of jurisdiction, the Supreme Court considered the relevant provisions of the Lugano Convention and the decisions of the Court of Justice on the interpretation of article 5(3). It held that the event giving rise to the damage was the conspiratorial agreement in England, and that the English court has jurisdiction over Mr Khrapunov under article 5(3) of the Lugano Convention.

In conclusion, the Supreme Court dismissed Mr Khrapunov’s appeal, holding that the Bank’s pleaded allegations disclose a good cause of action for conspiracy to injure it by unlawful means, and that the English court has jurisdiction over Mr Khrapunov.